You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login
Google

Reply #53: here's my question: Why does someone who can afford such an elective surgery [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (1/22-2007 thru 12/14/2010) Donate to DU
ComerPerro Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Wed Mar-28-07 11:13 AM
Response to Original message
53. here's my question: Why does someone who can afford such an elective surgery
need alimony in the first place?
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
  -Man agreed to pay alimony to his ex -- but not to the man she became. Now what? LiberalHeart  Mar-27-07 09:27 PM   #0 
  - Gender of the ex-spouse is irrelavent.  LeftyMom   Mar-27-07 09:30 PM   #1 
  - But, if you can't legally be married to somebody of the same sex,  BuyingThyme   Mar-27-07 09:34 PM   #4 
  - The divorce happened prior to the sex change. n/t  whereismyparty   Mar-27-07 09:39 PM   #6 
  - Sure. They were married legally and then they legally divorced.  LeftyMom   Mar-27-07 09:40 PM   #7 
  - Well, the question is to what the contractual obligations are.  BuyingThyme   Mar-27-07 09:53 PM   #14 
  - If, as the article states, he's on the hook until his ex remarries or dies,  LeftyMom   Mar-27-07 10:00 PM   #17 
     - What if the stipulation had to do with marrying or cohabiting  BuyingThyme   Mar-27-07 10:07 PM   #19 
        - Well, here's my suspicion.  LeftyMom   Mar-27-07 10:15 PM   #21 
        - I was assuming that sex changes were widely recognized,  BuyingThyme   Mar-27-07 10:33 PM   #27 
        - It's in Florida  johnnie   Mar-28-07 11:42 AM   #65 
        - Some states have rules/laws that recognize cohabitation in lieu of marriage as grounds for the  Solo_in_MD   Mar-27-07 11:03 PM   #31 
  - He is still the same person she was  treestar   Mar-27-07 11:02 PM   #29 
  - Palimony recognizes alimony like obligations outside of a formal marriage  Solo_in_MD   Mar-27-07 11:00 PM   #28 
     - Yes, sometimes.  BuyingThyme   Mar-27-07 11:04 PM   #32 
  - Not completely irrelvant  slackmaster   Mar-28-07 03:05 PM   #71 
     - Right. As a transgendered man. Sure.  Zhade   Mar-28-07 10:57 PM   #79 
        - My point is that the gender change does change factors used to compute alimony  slackmaster   Mar-29-07 09:01 AM   #90 
  - He's gotta' pay. He outta' pay.  whereismyparty   Mar-27-07 09:32 PM   #2 
  - I'm with you on this.  LiberalHeart   Mar-27-07 09:34 PM   #3 
  - It's arguable that it's hardly elective.  Zhade   Mar-28-07 10:58 PM   #80 
  - He continues to pay.  Hepburn   Mar-27-07 09:35 PM   #5 
  - The alimony agreement was made with a person, not a gender  BattyDem   Mar-27-07 09:41 PM   #8 
  - Alimony, smalimony...  1monster   Mar-27-07 09:41 PM   #9 
  - You know, if two people enter an agreement  kineta   Mar-27-07 09:55 PM   #15 
     - Okay, there is merit to that argument, however, that should be part of the  1monster   Mar-27-07 10:18 PM   #24 
        - agree with you about the terminology  kineta   Mar-27-07 11:26 PM   #35 
  - I can solve this....  hlthe2b   Mar-27-07 09:50 PM   #10 
  - I tend to dislike alimony in all cases.  Warren Stupidity   Mar-27-07 09:50 PM   #11 
  - the alimony should stop - he/she has changed her side of the deal so the guy gets to change his  msongs   Mar-27-07 09:50 PM   #12 
  - what deal was that? nt.  Warren Stupidity   Mar-27-07 09:53 PM   #13 
  - your implying that they had a divorce DEAL that mentioned her/his gender?  kineta   Mar-27-07 09:56 PM   #16 
  - What deal? Still the same person.  uppityperson   Mar-27-07 10:07 PM   #18 
  - If a person goes through a sex change  Katzenkavalier   Mar-28-07 12:59 AM   #42 
     - dicksteele says it well in post #41  uppityperson   Mar-28-07 10:50 AM   #50 
     - When a person goes through a sex change do they still carry their debt  mondo joe   Mar-28-07 11:17 AM   #57 
  - He's still the ex-wife.  LeftyMom   Mar-27-07 10:08 PM   #20 
  - And if my landlord gets a sex change I can stop paying my rent, too!  dicksteele   Mar-27-07 10:24 PM   #25 
  - LOL  kineta   Mar-27-07 11:27 PM   #36 
  - Your landlord/tenant relationship was not dependent upon your  Laurier   Mar-28-07 12:19 AM   #40 
     - Kinda my point. That alimony agreement is not dependent on gender, either.  dicksteele   Mar-28-07 12:51 AM   #41 
     - I have to disagree with your assertion that the terms of the marriage are irrelevant .  Laurier   Mar-28-07 01:17 AM   #45 
     - once the marriage is ended why the hell should gender matter?  kineta   Mar-28-07 11:07 AM   #51 
     - I disagree.  Laurier   Mar-28-07 10:52 PM   #78 
     - no, the decision about alimony is based on the deal the couple makes -  mondo joe   Mar-28-07 11:26 AM   #61 
     - Duplicate - deleted  Laurier   Mar-28-07 01:19 AM   #46 
        - And we all know that nothing rhymes with "orage".  dicksteele   Mar-28-07 01:41 AM   #47 
           - Because the obligation to one's spouse is not the same as one's  Laurier   Mar-28-07 10:32 PM   #77 
              - Again you show some peculiar difficulties with reading comprehension.  dicksteele   Mar-28-07 11:54 PM   #88 
     - Neither is the divorce relationship.  mondo joe   Mar-28-07 11:10 AM   #52 
     - Neither was the alimony order.  Zhade   Mar-28-07 11:05 PM   #82 
  - it's the same person  shatter   Mar-27-07 11:02 PM   #30 
  - Are you sure you are liberal?  jesus_of_suburbia   Mar-27-07 11:30 PM   #37 
  - Were there terms in the deal referring to genitalia?  mondo joe   Mar-28-07 11:16 AM   #56 
  - You're wrong.  Zhade   Mar-28-07 11:00 PM   #81 
  - Does he now call him a "bloodsucking prick" rather than a...  mitchum   Mar-27-07 10:16 PM   #22 
  - Interesting semantic awkwardness: SHE no longer exists to pay alimony to. LOL!  BlooInBloo   Mar-27-07 10:17 PM   #23 
  - Pay it and like it.  Forkboy   Mar-27-07 10:29 PM   #26 
  - Would a self-respecting man take that alimony? Heh.  WinkyDink   Mar-27-07 11:09 PM   #33 
  - Ouch!  BuyingThyme   Mar-27-07 11:16 PM   #34 
  - What bullshit. *I know you were kidding though*  jesus_of_suburbia   Mar-27-07 11:33 PM   #38 
     - OMG. Like this Democratic flaming Liberal WOMAN doesn't know or think that.  WinkyDink   Mar-28-07 01:11 AM   #44 
  - Interesting.  Laurier   Mar-28-07 12:15 AM   #39 
  - Another reminder why I will probably never get married  RagingInMiami   Mar-28-07 01:09 AM   #43 
  - Is alimony at all based on  spoony   Mar-28-07 03:36 AM   #48 
  - If you think transgendered persons are treated better than women...  Zhade   Mar-28-07 11:09 PM   #83 
     - Lol, LoZoccolo was so dead on about you.  spoony   Mar-29-07 03:41 AM   #89 
  - Why is ANYONE still being awarded "Alimony?" until death or remarriage  alphafemale   Mar-28-07 03:48 AM   #49 
  - I think it depends on what you think marriage is.  mondo joe   Mar-28-07 11:14 AM   #54 
  - here's my question: Why does someone who can afford such an elective surgery  ComerPerro   Mar-28-07 11:13 AM   #53 
  - Alimony isn't welfare. NT  mondo joe   Mar-28-07 11:15 AM   #55 
     - true, but what reason could there be for the husband to have to keep paying  ComerPerro   Mar-28-07 11:21 AM   #59 
        - Because it doesn't have to do with "hurting for finances".  mondo joe   Mar-28-07 11:23 AM   #60 
           - well, whatever. IMO, alimony and child support is all bullshit anyway  ComerPerro   Mar-28-07 11:33 AM   #63 
              - Child support is bullshit? What do you mean?  uppityperson   Mar-28-07 03:03 PM   #70 
              - Child support is bullshit?  Zhade   Mar-28-07 11:13 PM   #84 
  - By this reasoning, if you get a sex change you can abandon all your debt.  mondo joe   Mar-28-07 11:19 AM   #58 
  - What a fat (and ignorant) pig.  BlueIris   Mar-28-07 11:29 AM   #62 
  - Do we know he's fat? Should fat be an insult?  Zhade   Mar-28-07 11:14 PM   #85 
  - I think if she can afford to become a he, ...  CRH   Mar-28-07 11:37 AM   #64 
  - Alimony is not generally a needs based arrangement.  mondo joe   Mar-28-07 01:25 PM   #66 
  - Alimony is an acknowledgment of a spouses contribution to the marriage  Rosemary2205   Mar-28-07 01:34 PM   #67 
  - I don't think people here understand what alimony is  gollygee   Mar-28-07 01:41 PM   #68 
  - He is a he. Deal with it.  Zhade   Mar-28-07 11:15 PM   #86 
  - I don't understand why anyone would think it would make any difference at all  gollygee   Mar-28-07 01:50 PM   #69 
     - Men still earn more money than women  slackmaster   Mar-28-07 03:08 PM   #72 
        - Yeah because transgendered people have a really easy time  gollygee   Mar-28-07 03:11 PM   #73 
           - Only if they disclose that they are transgendered  slackmaster   Mar-28-07 03:23 PM   #74 
           - Do you think it's that easy to keep a secret?  gollygee   Mar-28-07 03:29 PM   #75 
              - I'm not assuming anything about this individual  slackmaster   Mar-28-07 03:41 PM   #76 
           - THANK you. It's like some people are blind to the discrimination Ts get EVERY DAY.  Zhade   Mar-28-07 11:16 PM   #87 
 

Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (1/22-2007 thru 12/14/2010) Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators


Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC