You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login
Google

Reply #23: Was just looking at the Pew Survey and it's got problems... [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (1/22-2007 thru 12/14/2010) Donate to DU
JackRiddler Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Mon Jun-23-08 05:39 PM
Response to Original message
23. Was just looking at the Pew Survey and it's got problems...
Edited on Mon Jun-23-08 05:42 PM by JackRiddler
This survey is always promoted heavily when it comes out. My impression through the years of Pew Research is that it specializes in extreme conventionalism, always reinforcing the status quo.

Both the media and the report writers themselves play with how they're presenting the results, mainly in what and how they highlight, and what they choose as headlines.

Here's the survey.

http://religions.pewforum.org/reports

The question yielding the 92 percent answer is not listed separately there, but from the listing of the results it's clear that it roughly ran, "Do you believe in God or a universal spirit"? Spirit of what? "Universal spirit" is incredibly vague, and I believe many people who are basically atheists but not doctrinaire about it would say they believe in it. On alternate Tuesdays, I also believe in "universal spirit," a concept that doesn't necessarily have anything to do with God. A sociologically valid question would give a choice of multiple answers, and certainly not equate "God" (understood by almost everyone to mean a specific, sentient entity) with "universal spirit" (a variable philosophical concept).

Says the report:

For example, while more than nine-in-ten Americans (92%) believe in the existence of God or a universal spirit, there is considerable variation in the nature and certainty of this belief. Six-in-ten adults believe that God is a person with whom people can have a relationship; but one-in-four including about half of Jews and Hindus see God as an impersonal force. And while roughly seven-in-ten Americans say they are absolutely certain of Gods existence, more than one-in-five (22%) are less certain in their belief.


Other paragraphs give more differentiated views and cast doubt on the 92 percent figure, although they don't seem to generate as many newspaper ledes:

Nearly two-thirds of the public (63%) takes the view that their faiths sacred texts are the word of God. But those who believe Scripture represents the word of God are roughly evenly divided between those who say it should be interpreted literally, word for word (33%), and those who say it should not be taken literally (27%). And more than a quarter of adults including two-thirds of Buddhists (67%) and about half of Jews (53%) say their faiths sacred texts are written by men and are not the word of God.


(Note: I don't even see how Western Buddhists can be considered theists. They're invariably interested in the practice of meditation as a means to overcoming suffering and reaching personal enlightenment, and not the often-flexible doctrines of the religion per se.)

I think the questions concerning "absolutely certain" belief in God and actual practice in the form of attending church services are far closer to the reality of religious adherence and belief in God in the United States:



Then there is the herd effect. In this culture, people are generally reluctant to say they don't believe, or if they are uncertain or their belief is shallow or nominal, they will tend to go with the herd. Starting with the sociologically incompetent mixing of two different concepts in the central question (God vs. "universal spirit"), I see no indication that this survey acknowledged this problem, or attempted to deal with the distortion this would cause. Quite the contrary; the underlying preference seems to be to lump as many of us as possible together in a common identity as "Americans," albeit with a tendency to "tolerance," so that definitive-sounding results can be given.

I'd like to see a survey that acknowledges the herd effect and is clearer about the range of possible answers. Going from these results, it seems to be about one-third of Americans don't really believe in the conventional God but go along with the conventional answer without devoting much thought to it. God isn't a factor in their lives, but they'll express allegiance anyway. Let us recall how atheism in particular has been demonised, and the threats of hellfire from the right. This survey is not taking place in a neutral environment.

Here's another question that's not as clear as the statistics make it seem:



I'm Greek, so to the Orthodox Church I am affiliated even if I don't believe in the religion. On some days I might be inclined -- if a survey called me -- to say I am affiliated, just to see our true numbers reflected against the Anglo-Protestant majority. I'm sure many people, especially nominal Catholics, answered out of this form of team loyalty.

The last question may be closest to the truth, by the way - the 16 percent "unaffiliated" may correlate most closely to the group implicitly telling you they reject religion. You can bet that almost all of the "unaffiliated" grew up in some church or other, or are considered by their own family to be Catholic or Muslim or Protestant, even if they don't think so themselves.

I'd like to see a survey drawn up by atheists and agnostics without a pro-religionist bias, like this one. Hell, I'd like to see one with an anti-religion bias, to see how high our numbers can be pushed when atheists are doing the manipulation!
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
  -Holy Moly! Is America really this religious? RiverStone  Jun-23-08 04:35 PM   #0 
  - Where the Hell did they take THAT poll???  Rick Myers   Jun-23-08 04:36 PM   #1 
  - at churches  SoCalDem   Jun-23-08 05:13 PM   #18 
     - that's gotta be it, then. nt  Spock_is_Skeptical   Jun-23-08 10:51 PM   #41 
  - You don't have to be religious to believe in God or heaven.  Drunken Irishman   Jun-23-08 04:40 PM   #2 
  - Question for you...  RiverStone   Jun-23-08 04:44 PM   #4 
     - I guess it depends.  Drunken Irishman   Jun-23-08 04:51 PM   #6 
     - I value your take...  RiverStone   Jun-23-08 04:54 PM   #7 
     - Yes, most Americans say they believe  ihavenobias   Jun-23-08 05:03 PM   #14 
     - No, absolutely not.  johnaries   Jun-23-08 04:58 PM   #10 
        - Yes! "I'm glad more people are finding god and leaving the church." Lenny Bruce  Echo In Light   Jun-23-08 05:54 PM   #24 
  - The wierdest thing to me  Somawas   Jun-23-08 04:42 PM   #3 
  - There are a lot of people who don't know the difference between atheism and agnosticism  MN Against Bush   Jun-23-08 05:02 PM   #13 
     - I just related what the article said.  Somawas   Jun-23-08 09:33 PM   #32 
  - actually I read something recently.......  tulsakatz   Jun-23-08 04:49 PM   #5 
  - A secret ballot ...  Drifter   Jun-23-08 04:55 PM   #8 
  - I am agnostic, so do I believe in God?  MN Against Bush   Jun-23-08 04:57 PM   #9 
  - I'm an agnostic in that I can't disprove the existence of a God...  ihavenobias   Jun-23-08 05:10 PM   #16 
  - and if one is under-educated, dead-tired from working 3 shit-jobs  SoCalDem   Jun-23-08 05:16 PM   #19 
  - The poll asks whether people believe in 'God' or a 'universal power'  kineta   Jun-23-08 04:59 PM   #11 
  - could be their all like my friend from h.s. who wasn't sure if there's a god but was afraid not to  Iris   Jun-23-08 05:01 PM   #12 
  - Too bad religious doesn't equate with peace and love of fellow human beings..  mmonk   Jun-23-08 05:04 PM   #15 
  - not for nothing, but I think 90% of DU believes in God  mdmc   Jun-23-08 05:11 PM   #17 
  - Probably more like 50%.  ozone_man   Jun-23-08 07:48 PM   #31 
  - Luke 13:22-30; Matthew 7:15-23; Matthew 23:23-28  MrCoffee   Jun-23-08 05:21 PM   #20 
  - I want to know how many people know these Bible verses...  MN Against Bush   Jun-23-08 05:28 PM   #21 
  - They should ask how many people think they're going to heaven  hokies4ever   Jun-23-08 06:29 PM   #28 
  - No.  cornermouse   Jun-23-08 05:32 PM   #22 
  - Was just looking at the Pew Survey and it's got problems...  JackRiddler   Jun-23-08 05:39 PM   #23 
  - Well, It IS a PEW survey after all. (They ask people who are sitting in PEWS!) n/t  Wiley50   Jun-24-08 07:40 PM   #47 
  - No.  fifthgendem   Jun-23-08 06:13 PM   #25 
  - Sometimes I wonder...  Blue Belle   Jun-23-08 06:18 PM   #26 
  - It's called hedging your bets  hokies4ever   Jun-23-08 06:27 PM   #27 
  - difference believing in god, higher power ect... and religious. 90%  seabeyond   Jun-23-08 06:32 PM   #29 
  - Yes, there is such a thing as the religious left.  intheflow   Jun-23-08 06:47 PM   #30 
  - No, the survey misrepresents its own results to maximize the God thing.  JackRiddler   Jun-23-08 09:36 PM   #33 
  - "Religious" does not equal "Believe in God." I think the study is accurate.  faithfulcitizen   Jun-23-08 09:37 PM   #34 
  - I'm always amazed to see liberals who treat those two ideas as equivalent.  BullGooseLoony   Jun-23-08 10:47 PM   #39 
  - It depends on how you define "religious"  Rage for Order   Jun-23-08 10:33 PM   #35 
  - Yes, I believe 90% is correct. Don't confuse "believing in god" with "religious" though  Levgreee   Jun-23-08 10:37 PM   #36 
  - Yes believe it or not there is even a religious left.  Wizard777   Jun-23-08 10:43 PM   #37 
  - It's a mistake not to pander to Christians and believers and I hope Obama does..  cbc5g   Jun-23-08 10:45 PM   #38 
  - what a bullshit poll.  Spock_is_Skeptical   Jun-23-08 10:50 PM   #40 
  - i'll bet 60% think Jeebus looked like Kenny Rodgers on a really good day  bridgit   Jun-23-08 10:54 PM   #42 
  - I don't think they got a good sample..seems skewed.  krabigirl   Jun-23-08 11:17 PM   #43 
  - The Pacific Northwest is the most secular region of the country  Lydia Leftcoast   Jun-23-08 11:56 PM   #44 
  - That is rather pathetic..90%  and-justice-for-all   Jun-24-08 07:15 PM   #45 
  - I saw that on the news  ismnotwasm   Jun-24-08 07:29 PM   #46 
 

Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (1/22-2007 thru 12/14/2010) Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators


Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC