You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login

Reply #39: Let's suppose that the doctrine has no redeeming value. [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (01/01/06 through 01/22/2007) Donate to DU
Boojatta Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Mon Aug-28-06 11:17 AM
Response to Reply #38
39. Let's suppose that the doctrine has no redeeming value.
Edited on Mon Aug-28-06 11:18 AM by Boojatta
Can we conclude that there can be no redeeming value in discussions launched in response to mention of the doctrine?

Suppose that at least 95% of the land in Mecca that is inherited within the next 40 years will be inherited by Arabs. Would you conclude that people who own land in Mecca are racists?
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
  -Fairness and Inheritance Boojatta  Aug-26-06 01:08 PM   #0 
  - How is an American Indian determined? This is now a legal question  John Q. Citizen   Aug-26-06 01:14 PM   #1 
  - Doctrine? According to whom?  acmavm   Aug-26-06 01:16 PM   #2 
  - Are you challenging the use of the word "doctrine" to describe it?  Boojatta   Aug-27-06 09:05 AM   #23 
  - I can tell you what Thomas Paine suggested...  FormerRushFan   Aug-26-06 01:17 PM   #3 
  - Blasphemy! Why do you hate America?  Selatius   Aug-26-06 06:29 PM   #16 
  - Ummm  HereSince1628   Aug-26-06 01:18 PM   #4 
  - It's no problem finding a place for money to go.  Boojatta   Aug-26-06 01:29 PM   #7 
  - Land = food / water / shelter  havocmom   Aug-26-06 09:19 PM   #18 
     - Maybe, but why should land be left as heritable and nothing else??  HereSince1628   Aug-27-06 06:51 AM   #19 
        - "Why should...?" is a challenging kind of question.  Boojatta   Aug-27-06 09:16 AM   #24 
  - Except for me.  niallmac   Aug-26-06 01:20 PM   #5 
  - I think the Kennedys woud disagree n/t  auburnblu   Aug-26-06 01:24 PM   #6 
  - Which tribe(s) gets which area(s)?  genie_weenie   Aug-26-06 01:36 PM   #8 
  - Thats not always applicable  Solo_in_MD   Aug-26-06 08:45 PM   #17 
     - My question was posed to the thread's creator  genie_weenie   Aug-27-06 08:20 AM   #22 
        - Would your acceptance or non-acceptance of the doctrine change  Boojatta   Aug-27-06 10:28 AM   #27 
           - I think your premise is flawed.  genie_weenie   Aug-27-06 12:23 PM   #32 
  - That's a fine idea....NOT.  MADem   Aug-26-06 01:53 PM   #9 
  - We're leaving everything to charity.  Tierra_y_Libertad   Aug-26-06 02:17 PM   #10 
  - What's fair about that?  Totallybushed   Aug-26-06 02:17 PM   #11 
  - Cool! I'm 1/16th Cherokee. Ignore the red hair. nt.  johnaries   Aug-26-06 02:20 PM   #12 
  - I know I'm being idealist,but.  terminal_concept   Aug-26-06 02:25 PM   #13 
  - My attempt to answer  Boojatta   Aug-27-06 10:14 AM   #26 
  - What about the homes on that land?  Nicole   Aug-26-06 02:31 PM   #14 
  - It's cute, but it makes no sense...  TreasonousBastard   Aug-26-06 06:24 PM   #15 
  - how about a doctrine  sweetheart   Aug-27-06 07:03 AM   #20 
  - My comment on that is that it's painfully stupid.  Spider Jerusalem   Aug-27-06 07:24 AM   #21 
  - Can we try to make a few distinctions?  Boojatta   Aug-27-06 10:50 AM   #28 
     - I can't extract any sense out of what you're saying here.  Spider Jerusalem   Aug-27-06 11:11 AM   #29 
        - How much effort are you making to extract sense?  Boojatta   Aug-27-06 11:46 AM   #30 
           - I didn't think I'd NEED to specify what the analogy was;  Spider Jerusalem   Aug-27-06 12:10 PM   #31 
              - Whatever level I'm at now, I'd like to increase  Boojatta   Aug-27-06 01:14 PM   #33 
              - ...  Spider Jerusalem   Aug-27-06 06:32 PM   #36 
                 - Are we discussing the precise meaning of the word "own"?  Boojatta   Aug-28-06 10:13 AM   #37 
                    - Now you're just drifting further afield into utter nonsense.  Spider Jerusalem   Aug-28-06 11:44 AM   #40 
                       - A couple of questions  Boojatta   Aug-28-06 03:12 PM   #42 
                          - No.  Spider Jerusalem   Aug-29-06 06:05 AM   #45 
              - Some Czechified ethnic Germans were already expelled from Czechoslovakia  Boojatta   Aug-28-06 03:31 PM   #43 
  - My mother passed last week  Retired AF Dem   Aug-27-06 09:16 AM   #25 
  - Yes. It Makes Absolutely Zero Sense.  OPERATIONMINDCRIME   Aug-27-06 01:17 PM   #34 
  - whatever is necessary to destroy the inter-generational overclass  welshTerrier2   Aug-27-06 01:26 PM   #35 
  - Racist bullcrap with no redeeming value  slackmaster   Aug-28-06 10:21 AM   #38 
  - Let's suppose that the doctrine has no redeeming value.  Boojatta   Aug-28-06 11:17 AM   #39 
     - Yes, there is no redeeming value in the discussion  slackmaster   Aug-28-06 12:25 PM   #41 
  - Yes. It's ridiculous.  cigsandcoffee   Aug-28-06 03:32 PM   #44 
  - Why?  JHB   Aug-29-06 06:08 AM   #46 
  - I have no problem at all with inheritance...  Tyler Durden   Aug-29-06 06:22 AM   #47 
  - Ridiculous. And non-American Indians can just "sell" their property to  MJDuncan1982   Aug-29-06 08:10 AM   #48 
  - Funny the Indian had no concept of owning the land until white man came  Toots   Aug-29-06 08:16 AM   #49 

Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (01/01/06 through 01/22/2007) Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators

Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC