You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login

Reply #32: Galbraith and Vietnam [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (01/01/06 through 01/22/2007) Donate to DU
Octafish Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Sat May-13-06 10:09 PM
Response to Reply #11
32. Galbraith and Vietnam
Edited on Sat May-13-06 10:12 PM by Octafish
He was a giant in statescraft, economics and ethics. The recent passing of John Kenneth Galbraith also marks one fewer witness to what was the Time before the War Party.

Galbraith and Vietnam

The Nation, March 14, 2005 issue

In the fall of 1961, unknown to the American public, John F. Kennedy was weighing a crucial decision about Vietnam not unlike that which George W. Bush faced about Iraq in early 2002--whether to go to war. It was the height of the cold war, when Communism was the "terrorist threat," and Ho Chi Minh the era's Saddam Hussein to many in Washington. But the new President was a liberal Massachusetts Democrat (and a decorated war veteran), not a conservative Sunbelt Republican who claimed God's hand guided his foreign policy. JFK's tough-minded instincts about war were thus very different. Contrary to what many have come to believe about the Vietnam War's origins, new research shows that Kennedy wanted no war in Asia and had clear criteria for conditions under which he'd send Americans abroad to fight and die for their country--criteria quite relevant today.

But thanks also in part to recently declassified records, we now know that Kennedy's top aides--whatever his own views--were offering him counsel not all that different from what Bush was told forty years later. Early that November, his personal military adviser, Gen. Maxwell Taylor, and his deputy National Security Adviser, Walt Rostow, were on their way back from Saigon with a draft of the "Taylor report," their bold plan to "save" Vietnam, beginning with the commitment of at least 8,000 US troops--a down payment, they hoped, on thousands more to follow. But they knew JFK had no interest in their idea because six months earlier in a top-secret meeting, he had forcefully vetoed his aides' proposed dispatch of 60,000 troops to neighboring Laos--and they were worried about how to maneuver his assent.

Harvard economist John Kenneth Galbraith, then Ambassador to India, got wind of their plan--and rushed to block their efforts. He was not an expert on Vietnam, but India chaired the International Control Commission, which had been set up following French withdrawal from Indochina to oversee a shaky peace accord meant to stabilize the region, and so from State Department cables he knew about the Taylor mission--and thus had a clear sense of what was at stake. For Galbraith, a trusted adviser with unique back-channel access to the President, a potential US war in Vietnam represented more than a disastrous misadventure in foreign policy--it risked derailing the New Frontier's domestic plans for Keynesian-led full employment, and for massive new spending on education, the environment and what would become the War on Poverty. Worse, he feared, it might ultimately tear not only the Democratic Party but the nation apart--and usher in a new conservative era in American politics.

Early that November, just as Taylor and his team arrived back in Washington, Galbraith arrived from New Delhi for the state visit of Prime Minister Nehru. Hoping to gain a quick upper hand over Taylor and his mission, he arranged a private luncheon for Kennedy and Nehru at the Newport estate of Jacqueline Kennedy's mother and stepfather. No one from the State Department--to Secretary of State Dean Rusk's great consternation--was invited, save Galbraith. Ten days earlier, Galbraith, in one of his back-channel messages, had shared with Kennedy his growing concerns about Vietnam. From India, he'd played a role in defusing the Laos situation that spring, but over the summer, the Berlin crisis had sent a sharp chill through relations with the Soviets, with the risks of nuclear confrontation for a time all too real. About this, Galbraith now told the President:

Although at times I have been rather troubled by Berlin, I have always had the feeling that it would be worked out. I have continued to worry far, far more about South Viet Nam. This is more complex, far less controllable, far more varied in the factors involved, far more susceptible to misunderstanding. And to make matters worse, I have no real confidence in the sophistication and political judgment of our people there.

This was advice Kennedy was hearing from no one else in his Administration, but clearly welcomed.


How different was Kennedy's approach to the problems of Vietnam and southeast Asia. His successors had no problem pulling the trigger, bringing in the ground troups to fight, and getting the nation into a war without knowing how or when to get out. Sounds familiar.

PS: Thank your for the kind words, happydreams. Your friendship means the world to me.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
  -Know your BFEE: Lies are the Currency of their Realm Octafish  May-12-06 02:46 PM   #0 
  - kick  annces8   May-12-06 03:15 PM   #1 
  - Nice work  90-percent   May-12-06 03:17 PM   #2 
  - Harriman helped Bush get his button and the whole Skull and Bones thing.  Octafish   May-12-06 11:40 PM   #14 
  - Congressman Richard NIXON claimed to have employed Jack RUBY  Octafish   May-12-06 11:29 PM   #13 
  - K&R. Bookmarked, as always.  Turn CO Blue   May-12-06 03:45 PM   #3 
  - The BFEE got rich and powerful by backing the right org.  Octafish   May-12-06 11:53 PM   #15 
  - Lets let Jack in on the conversation  Greeby   May-12-06 04:01 PM   #4 
  - Thank you for the JFK audio. I'd heard about his reaction...  Octafish   May-13-06 12:12 AM   #17 
     - Not so very long ago. 1992-2000.  WinkyDink   May-15-06 09:13 AM   #42 
        - Most of what we know concerning JFK and Vietnam came after 1992...  Octafish   May-15-06 09:34 AM   #45 
  - Operation 40  DrDebug   May-12-06 04:14 PM   #5 
  - Hughes. Nixon. Maheu. Roselli. Operation 40.  Octafish   May-13-06 01:35 PM   #22 
     - The interesting thing about Tosh is that he is on the internet  DrDebug   May-13-06 03:22 PM   #29 
        - What's Tosh Plumlee say regarding Poppy Bush 'n' Dealey Plaza?  Octafish   May-13-06 09:58 PM   #31 
           - Bush was in Dallas of course. Where was Nixon?  DrDebug   May-14-06 04:32 AM   #35 
              - Five  Octafish   May-15-06 01:38 PM   #46 
  - Thankyou, old friend..... and check out this post  blm   May-12-06 04:19 PM   #6 
  - NAZIs connect to Dallas through members of the BFEE  Octafish   May-13-06 01:52 PM   #23 
  - That's MY vision of history  SupplyConcerns   May-12-06 04:45 PM   #7 
  - Octafish has posted about that many times before. This is just another  blm   May-12-06 04:47 PM   #8 
  - The more you uncover  Karenina   May-13-06 05:27 AM   #18 
  - It's a layered discussion. E. Howard Hunt  DrDebug   May-12-06 05:02 PM   #9 
  - You're spot-on. Here's a bit more on our 'Secret History'...  Octafish   May-13-06 02:15 PM   #24 
     - Bless You Octafish  Sydnie   May-13-06 02:39 PM   #27 
  - PRESCOTT BUSH FINANCED  Karenina   May-12-06 05:44 PM   #10 
  - It bugs me, see? It's the CIA's worst-kept secret, see?  Octafish   May-13-06 02:29 PM   #26 
  - BWHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!  Karenina   May-13-06 07:48 PM   #30 
  - That they have little sense worth offending, imo.  blm   May-13-06 03:07 PM   #28 
  - K&R! Keep it coming my friend. nt  happydreams   May-12-06 07:03 PM   #11 
  - Galbraith and Vietnam  Octafish   May-13-06 10:09 PM   #32 
  - Excellent post, Octafish ~ and fascinating to read Nixon's own words  Catrina   May-12-06 11:22 PM   #12 
  - The "Bay of Pigs Thing" means Dallas was LIHOP  Octafish   May-13-06 10:53 PM   #34 
     - There is a lot to absorb ~ and it's both really disturbing and fascinating  Catrina   May-14-06 10:36 PM   #36 
  - Kick  Cleita   May-13-06 12:11 AM   #16 
  - The second biggest lie (after the Warren Commission)...  Octafish   May-14-06 11:35 PM   #37 
  - For lies are the  H2O Man   May-13-06 05:51 AM   #19 
  - Orwell saw that future fascistii would shorten the vocab, so to speak...  Octafish   May-14-06 11:43 PM   #38 
  - "And the truth shall set you free". Kick  oasis   May-13-06 10:24 AM   #20 
  - Abraham Bolden, the 1st National Security Whistleblower, Protected JFK...  Octafish   May-14-06 11:59 PM   #39 
  - Nothing like a little light reading on a Saturday morning.  bleever   May-13-06 01:05 PM   #21 
  - Kennedy, the Vietnam War, and Intelligence Failures  Octafish   May-15-06 09:02 AM   #41 
  - Keep it up and running, kick to ensure it does not get hidden.  AuntPatsy   May-13-06 02:16 PM   #25 
  - Your wish is my command  Karenina   May-15-06 05:16 AM   #40 
     - Papers reveal JFK efforts on Vietnam  Octafish   May-15-06 09:15 AM   #43 
  - Kick! eom  TheGoldenRule   May-13-06 10:17 PM   #33 
  - John Kenneth Galbraith spelled it out for us...  Octafish   May-15-06 09:24 AM   #44 
     - No, Thank You for all your research and information, Octafish!  TheGoldenRule   May-15-06 01:54 PM   #47 
  - Bush, United Fruits Co, Chiquita, Guatemala coup  rman   May-16-06 12:27 PM   #48 
  - E Howard Hunt and United Fruit overthrew Guatemala.  Octafish   May-17-06 12:36 PM   #49 
  - kick!  G_j   May-17-06 12:44 PM   #50 
     - G_j be in da Haus!!!  Karenina   May-17-06 01:46 PM   #51 

Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (01/01/06 through 01/22/2007) Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators

Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC