| 175. Really? Are you certain he never killed any Deatheaters during |
|
the time Voldemort was in power previously?
|
| -SPOILER THREAD! SPOILER THREAD! |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 09:05 PM |
#0 |
-
I just finished it. |
BlackVelvetElvis |
Jul-16-05 09:15 PM |
#1 |
 -
I was SHOCKED.... |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 09:42 PM |
#3 |
-
Not shocked. |
Spider Jerusalem |
Jul-16-05 10:13 PM |
#6 |
 -
I'm with you that Snape's going to |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 10:20 PM |
#7 |
  -
But what was he begging for? |
Spider Jerusalem |
Jul-16-05 10:37 PM |
#8 |
   -
I think Snape's history. |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 10:44 PM |
#10 |
  -
On reread |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 11:15 AM |
#62 |
 -
I believe that. |
Pithy Cherub |
Jul-17-05 09:39 AM |
#59 |
 -
Last night I wasn't quite there |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 11:14 AM |
#61 |
 -
I agree. |
LWolf |
Jul-17-05 08:19 PM |
#73 |
 -
dupe n/t |
LWolf |
Jul-17-05 08:21 PM |
#74 |
 -
I also hope Snape is redeemed in the end, but I have my doubts. |
Ilsa |
Jul-24-05 07:47 AM |
#225 |
-
I kept thinkin the HBP was Tom Riddle |
malmapus |
Jul-17-05 09:41 PM |
#80 |
-
Not that way, no.... |
politicat |
Jul-16-05 09:34 PM |
#2 |
 -
For sure |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 09:43 PM |
#4 |
-
The short answers? No, no. |
politicat |
Jul-16-05 11:29 PM |
#12 |
-
Definately. |
lildreamer316 |
Jul-16-05 11:37 PM |
#13 |
 -
How did he NOT tear Snape apart??? |
malmapus |
Jul-17-05 09:45 PM |
#81 |
-
The books have been so school focused |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 11:43 PM |
#15 |
 -
How about the reference the Shrub |
SharonRB |
Jul-18-05 11:39 AM |
#96 |
 -
About that first chapter. |
GhostThatWalks |
Jul-19-05 08:38 AM |
#157 |
-
so if the PM is supposed to be John Major, his predecessor ... |
Lisa |
Jul-17-05 07:37 PM |
#71 |
-
I think some of the 7th book needs to be at Hogwarts--as a base |
lulu in NC |
Jul-19-05 09:58 PM |
#191 |
-
My question is why. I hate cliffhangers. |
uppityperson |
Jul-16-05 10:11 PM |
#5 |
-
Did anyone even see |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 10:37 PM |
#9 |
-
mmm; I think I'm on Spyder's side too...just finished it. |
lildreamer316 |
Jul-16-05 11:23 PM |
#11 |
 -
Dumbledore begged Snape to kill him. |
philosophie_en_rose |
Jul-16-05 11:44 PM |
#16 |
-
Interesting take on the argument |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 11:52 PM |
#20 |
-
On the felix potion: |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 12:08 AM |
#24 |
-
Ah, very good! Some think Jesus actually asked Judas to turn |
soothsayer |
Jul-17-05 04:32 AM |
#58 |
-
I personally think that DD knew that Snape was the only |
xmas74 |
Jul-18-05 06:50 PM |
#136 |
-
Yeah, calling him a coward |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 07:26 PM |
#139 |
 -
That's what I thought. |
xmas74 |
Jul-18-05 08:07 PM |
#142 |
-
These speculations are making me feel better about Snape |
Ilsa |
Jul-24-05 08:08 AM |
#226 |
-
X post from re-read thread: My prediction accuracy..... |
politicat |
Jul-16-05 11:41 PM |
#14 |
 -
I agree that this book was very---taut |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 11:46 PM |
#18 |
-
BTW: Thanks, XemaSab. |
politicat |
Jul-16-05 11:45 PM |
#17 |
 -
You're welcome |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 11:48 PM |
#19 |
-
One thing pointed out |
XemaSab |
Jul-16-05 11:55 PM |
#21 |
-
Honestly...kinda. |
Hong Kong Cavalier |
Jul-17-05 12:03 AM |
#22 |
 -
It was necessary, sadly. |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 01:12 AM |
#33 |
-
True, true |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 01:17 AM |
#34 |
-
Sorry to nitpick you but this is funny: |
lildreamer316 |
Jul-19-05 06:48 PM |
#186 |
-
I saw that! |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 10:51 AM |
#201 |
-
According to queeg the non-donor: |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 12:05 AM |
#23 |
 -
Harry only says that it's 24 hours worth. |
philosophie_en_rose |
Jul-17-05 12:09 AM |
#25 |
  -
true |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 12:15 AM |
#26 |
 -
Contradicting the Snape's a goody in disguise..... |
politicat |
Jul-17-05 12:17 AM |
#27 |
-
Agreed |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 12:23 AM |
#28 |
-
Yeah; but |
lildreamer316 |
Jul-17-05 12:29 AM |
#29 |
 -
There's a point |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 12:34 AM |
#30 |
-
Can Occlumency fool a spell? |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 01:05 AM |
#31 |
-
How so? |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 01:07 AM |
#32 |
-
Like a mask, maybe |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 01:19 AM |
#35 |
-
So you're asking |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 01:24 AM |
#37 |
-
Yep |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 01:34 AM |
#39 |
-
Good call |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 01:40 AM |
#40 |
-
What can I say |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 01:44 AM |
#43 |
-
Like she's not already? |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 01:51 AM |
#47 |
-
R.A.B. |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 01:21 AM |
#36 |
 -
That seems to be |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 01:25 AM |
#38 |
  -
Good to see I'm not the only one that jumped out at. |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 01:40 AM |
#41 |
   -
Hee |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 01:43 AM |
#42 |
    -
Hm |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 01:46 AM |
#44 |
   -
Totally |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 01:51 AM |
#48 |
   -
Which would make sense; |
lildreamer316 |
Jul-17-05 03:22 AM |
#56 |
  -
It's interesting to see |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 11:13 PM |
#147 |
  -
Stolen by Mundungus, if you ask me. . . |
brensgrrl |
Jul-19-05 11:06 PM |
#195 |
 -
There's a locket |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 02:02 AM |
#52 |
-
You've found it! |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 02:26 AM |
#54 |
-
night |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 02:29 AM |
#55 |
-
Kreacher was stealing things from the house |
Lavender Brown |
Jul-18-05 12:12 PM |
#101 |
-
Totally |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 12:36 PM |
#104 |
-
From an interview with JKR |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 01:48 AM |
#45 |
 -
Bizarre idea: |
Spider Jerusalem |
Jul-18-05 10:12 PM |
#146 |
-
I don't think |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 11:14 PM |
#148 |
-
Can a human be a Horcrux? |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 01:50 AM |
#46 |
 -
Like, uh, maybe |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 01:52 AM |
#49 |
  -
Possibly |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 01:55 AM |
#50 |
   -
Exactly |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 02:00 AM |
#51 |
  -
that crossed my mind |
dwickham |
Jul-17-05 03:42 AM |
#57 |
 -
I don't think the transfer itself was an accident now |
malmapus |
Jul-18-05 01:27 PM |
#105 |
 -
If LV can use Nagini as as a Horcrux, surely a human would work, too. n/t |
intheflow |
Jul-17-05 05:13 PM |
#68 |
  -
That probably why |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 09:29 PM |
#78 |
 -
i hadn't even thought of that! |
Lisa |
Jul-17-05 07:50 PM |
#72 |
  -
Just thought of another clue re:horcruxes |
lulu in NC |
Jul-19-05 11:01 PM |
#193 |
 -
Interesting thought-- |
brensgrrl |
Jul-21-05 10:42 PM |
#222 |
-
There's a discussion |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 02:08 AM |
#53 |
 -
That was my first impression, actually. |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 11:22 AM |
#63 |
-
This book charmed me, made me cry, made me laugh out loud |
Pithy Cherub |
Jul-17-05 09:56 AM |
#60 |
 -
Tyrants! |
intheflow |
Jul-17-05 06:04 PM |
#70 |
-
I stand by my theory |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 11:25 AM |
#64 |
 -
Ooooo that won't go over well with Aunt Petunia |
malmapus |
Jul-17-05 09:52 PM |
#82 |
-
Probably |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 10:10 PM |
#84 |
-
Major thoughts in the sober light of day: |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 11:47 AM |
#65 |
-
I didn't see it coming but I believe that Dumbledor did. Like the |
loudestchick |
Jul-17-05 04:12 PM |
#66 |
-
Ok, wild theory time: |
XemaSab |
Jul-17-05 04:12 PM |
#67 |
 -
could Harry have a horcrux |
outraged2 |
Jul-17-05 09:04 PM |
#75 |
  -
Could Dumbledore have a Horcrux? |
realFedUp |
Jul-19-05 02:38 PM |
#166 |
 -
You have to kill someone |
XemaSab |
Jul-19-05 03:02 PM |
#167 |
 -
Oh, that's right....nt |
realFedUp |
Jul-19-05 05:49 PM |
#172 |
 -
Really? Are you certain he never killed any Deatheaters during |
ET Awful |
Jul-19-05 06:09 PM |
#175 |
 -
Could they both be eachother's horcruxes? |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 09:18 PM |
#76 |
  -
Interesting thought |
malmapus |
Jul-18-05 08:23 AM |
#87 |
 -
From my understanding in order to make a horcruxes |
malmapus |
Jul-17-05 10:02 PM |
#83 |
  -
That's what I recall |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 10:34 AM |
#90 |
 -
I'm really thinking that Harry is a horcruxes of Voldermort now |
malmapus |
Jul-18-05 10:44 AM |
#94 |
-
Priori incantatem |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 12:06 PM |
#99 |
-
Though I said earlier I didn't think Harry could be a horcruxes, |
lulu in NC |
Jul-18-05 05:01 PM |
#124 |
-
I still think it wasn't on purpose |
TimeChaser |
Jul-18-05 05:07 PM |
#125 |
-
My train of thought is that |
malmapus |
Jul-18-05 05:07 PM |
#126 |
-
But Voldemort didn't do it on purpose. |
Pithy Cherub |
Jul-18-05 05:16 PM |
#127 |
-
I think that's |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 05:46 PM |
#132 |
-
Good point =) |
malmapus |
Jul-18-05 06:48 PM |
#135 |
-
Wow, the Smith/Smith thing went right past me--good catch! n/t |
lulu in NC |
Jul-18-05 07:27 PM |
#140 |
-
I totally saw the Harry/Ginny hook up. |
intheflow |
Jul-17-05 05:55 PM |
#69 |
 -
Lupin/Tonks made my day |
TimeChaser |
Jul-17-05 09:22 PM |
#77 |
-
As far as Luna goes, |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 10:37 AM |
#91 |
-
I think Luna & Neville will be hooking up. |
Rainbowreflect |
Jul-18-05 12:28 PM |
#103 |
-
Sadly |
TimeChaser |
Jul-18-05 03:30 PM |
#118 |
-
Whoa |
malmapus |
Jul-17-05 09:41 PM |
#79 |
-
Just finished it... |
deadparrot |
Jul-18-05 12:45 AM |
#85 |
 -
I'm with you there |
malmapus |
Jul-18-05 08:14 AM |
#86 |
-
Just finished it Sunday night -- |
lulu in NC |
Jul-18-05 09:33 AM |
#88 |
 -
Good ideas.... |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 10:40 AM |
#92 |
-
Loved the book, hated the death - so senseless! What was gained there? |
robbedvoter |
Jul-18-05 09:51 AM |
#89 |
 -
Dumbledore is dead |
Pithy Cherub |
Jul-18-05 11:09 AM |
#95 |
-
From a literary standpoint, DD's death |
intheflow |
Jul-18-05 11:39 AM |
#97 |
 -
Is Harry going to be the new leader of the Order? |
Pithy Cherub |
Jul-18-05 02:20 PM |
#107 |
  -
I'm calling flitwick for assistant head |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 02:35 PM |
#109 |
 -
Can't Lupin be DADA teacher again? And Tonks would have plenty |
lulu in NC |
Jul-18-05 05:38 PM |
#130 |
 -
Not altogether a bad call |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 06:19 PM |
#133 |
  -
I agree the post seems cursed, but is it? But the real Mad Eye would |
lulu in NC |
Jul-18-05 07:24 PM |
#137 |
 -
They said |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 07:29 PM |
#141 |
 -
I forgot that bit! Looks like I read it too fast, and can't do a reread |
lulu in NC |
Jul-18-05 08:26 PM |
#143 |
 -
My SO is traveling this week. |
intheflow |
Jul-18-05 09:51 PM |
#145 |
 -
I'm rereading |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 11:16 PM |
#149 |
 -
Well, Snape sure as hell won't be - JKR said that much! |
robbedvoter |
Jul-19-05 01:01 PM |
#163 |
 -
You don't think Snape's going to be |
XemaSab |
Jul-19-05 01:04 PM |
#164 |
 -
Good point. And wasn't Sirius also killed near the end of the |
lulu in NC |
Jul-18-05 05:45 PM |
#131 |
-
Asked in post 93: |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 11:58 AM |
#98 |
-
What's going to happen |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 10:42 AM |
#93 |
 -
"Will Voldemort be able to use servants that DD died to protect?" |
lulu in NC |
Jul-18-05 05:21 PM |
#128 |
-
What was the spell Snape hit Harry with |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 12:08 PM |
#100 |
 -
Sort of a slap of some kind or other-- |
brensgrrl |
Jul-21-05 10:46 PM |
#223 |
-
Derivation of the word "horcrux"? |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 12:13 PM |
#102 |
 -
According to Merriam-Webster online... |
intheflow |
Jul-18-05 02:34 PM |
#108 |
  -
I was going with |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 02:37 PM |
#110 |
 -
"Storehouse" seems likely, in that a horcrux stores a piece of |
lulu in NC |
Jul-18-05 05:23 PM |
#129 |
-
Ollivander's disappearance |
intheflow |
Jul-18-05 02:18 PM |
#106 |
 -
Fawkes was Dumbledore's patronus, JKR said |
Lavender Brown |
Jul-18-05 03:14 PM |
#111 |
  -
She said |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 03:19 PM |
#112 |
   -
Hmm. |
Lavender Brown |
Jul-18-05 03:22 PM |
#114 |
  -
I think DD's going to live on |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 03:33 PM |
#119 |
  -
One in the headmaster's office |
Lavender Brown |
Jul-18-05 03:38 PM |
#120 |
  -
I don't think the trading cards |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 03:41 PM |
#121 |
  -
His parents are on the cards? |
Lavender Brown |
Jul-18-05 03:44 PM |
#122 |
   -
His parents aren't on the cards |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 04:15 PM |
#123 |
  -
It seems to me that oil paintings have talking mojo. |
intheflow |
Jul-18-05 06:41 PM |
#134 |
  -
true dat |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 07:25 PM |
#138 |
  -
When did JKR say that? |
intheflow |
Jul-18-05 03:20 PM |
#113 |
 -
Yes, I was confused. |
Lavender Brown |
Jul-18-05 03:23 PM |
#115 |
 -
Anagram |
TimeChaser |
Jul-18-05 03:26 PM |
#116 |
-
Well that's not good |
Lavender Brown |
Jul-18-05 03:28 PM |
#117 |
-
Dude, I just finished it! |
Chovexani |
Jul-18-05 09:36 PM |
#144 |
 -
Draco's with Myrtle |
XemaSab |
Jul-18-05 11:23 PM |
#150 |
  -
You know what's hilarious? |
Chovexani |
Jul-19-05 01:27 AM |
#154 |
 -
I've said it before and I'll say it again, |
XemaSab |
Jul-19-05 01:37 AM |
#155 |
 -
Oh dear |
TimeChaser |
Jul-19-05 12:21 AM |
#151 |
  -
I didn't even notice the back cover |
XemaSab |
Jul-19-05 12:25 AM |
#152 |
  -
Ya know |
Chovexani |
Jul-19-05 01:23 AM |
#153 |
 -
Well |
TimeChaser |
Jul-19-05 11:48 AM |
#161 |
 -
You don't think |
XemaSab |
Jul-19-05 12:21 PM |
#162 |
 -
He certainly thinks he is. |
TimeChaser |
Jul-19-05 01:45 PM |
#165 |
 -
I'm pissed JKR killed off DD before the 7th book-- |
lulu in NC |
Jul-19-05 09:17 PM |
#190 |
-
So Harry learns that even the wisest adults can be WRONG |
Nothing Without Hope |
Jul-19-05 01:47 AM |
#156 |
 -
We all have some rereading to do... |
Pithy Cherub |
Jul-19-05 10:07 AM |
#158 |
  -
I agree - this is the coming of age book and also the transitional book |
Nothing Without Hope |
Jul-19-05 10:15 AM |
#159 |
 -
How can Regulus be alive if Harry can order Kreatcher around? |
Coventina |
Jul-20-05 06:33 PM |
#217 |
 -
Excellent call! |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 06:38 PM |
#218 |
 -
But I don't think DD was wrong about Snape. |
mondo joe |
Jul-19-05 06:17 PM |
#177 |
 -
Snape was NOT a bad guy. . . |
brensgrrl |
Jul-19-05 11:05 PM |
#194 |
-
I reread SS and CoS last night |
XemaSab |
Jul-19-05 11:11 AM |
#160 |
 -
Whoa! Great catch! |
intheflow |
Jul-19-05 03:15 PM |
#168 |
-
I wonder if the basilisk was one of the horcruxes. |
intheflow |
Jul-19-05 05:16 PM |
#169 |
 -
I was wondering about |
XemaSab |
Jul-19-05 05:33 PM |
#171 |
-
Being possessed requires a whole spirit. |
intheflow |
Jul-19-05 07:15 PM |
#187 |
-
you have quotes? |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 10:54 AM |
#202 |
-
No, no quotes. |
intheflow |
Jul-20-05 11:41 AM |
#210 |
-
It something we won't know |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 11:45 AM |
#211 |
-
Good interview with JK Owling here: |
XemaSab |
Jul-19-05 05:30 PM |
#170 |
 -
This IS a good interview! |
intheflow |
Jul-19-05 08:19 PM |
#189 |
-
Sorry about my "Owling" slip... |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 10:56 AM |
#203 |
-
Okay, the one thing I haven't seen mentioned (and I haven't read EVERY |
ET Awful |
Jul-19-05 06:05 PM |
#173 |
 -
Dumbledore's not interested |
XemaSab |
Jul-19-05 06:08 PM |
#174 |
-
Yes, but he's given Harry lectures on many things that have fallen |
ET Awful |
Jul-19-05 06:11 PM |
#176 |
-
I'd sooner see Dumbledore |
XemaSab |
Jul-19-05 06:33 PM |
#181 |
-
Ah but could not the pain and remorse of killing be just as effective |
ET Awful |
Jul-19-05 06:36 PM |
#183 |
-
Incredible book... |
spuddonna |
Jul-19-05 06:21 PM |
#178 |
 -
A book that will become a classic |
Pithy Cherub |
Jul-19-05 08:00 PM |
#188 |
-
Actually, yeah... I sort of did. |
LeftPeopleFinishFirst |
Jul-19-05 06:24 PM |
#179 |
 -
Agreed on the identity of the "Prince" |
ET Awful |
Jul-19-05 06:32 PM |
#180 |
-
I thought it was too... |
LeftPeopleFinishFirst |
Jul-19-05 06:34 PM |
#182 |
-
And the memory of him having had the spell that hung him by his ankle |
ET Awful |
Jul-19-05 06:38 PM |
#184 |
-
yeah, really! |
LeftPeopleFinishFirst |
Jul-19-05 06:39 PM |
#185 |
-
Deep-See Fishing for Red Herrings, or |
brensgrrl |
Jul-19-05 10:26 PM |
#192 |
 -
Excellent insights |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 11:30 AM |
#207 |
-
Spoiler Warning---BIGTIME!!!!! |
brensgrrl |
Jul-20-05 10:24 PM |
#219 |
-
Thanks for the repost |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 10:35 PM |
#220 |
-
I have an odd question... |
Hong Kong Cavalier |
Jul-20-05 09:17 AM |
#196 |
 -
Good point. |
ET Awful |
Jul-20-05 09:43 AM |
#197 |
  -
So that begs the question: why was Dumbledore's death so different? |
Hong Kong Cavalier |
Jul-20-05 09:50 AM |
#198 |
 -
I tend to agree. |
ET Awful |
Jul-20-05 09:55 AM |
#199 |
 -
The answer is: |
Twillig |
Jul-20-05 03:29 PM |
#213 |
 -
Good points :) n/t |
ET Awful |
Jul-20-05 04:56 PM |
#215 |
 -
*smacks head on forehead* |
Hong Kong Cavalier |
Jul-20-05 05:42 PM |
#216 |
 -
I've noticed |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 10:59 AM |
#204 |
  -
I think that's depending on what the spell hits: the person or the wand. |
Hong Kong Cavalier |
Jul-20-05 11:34 AM |
#209 |
 -
It doesn't.. . . |
brensgrrl |
Jul-20-05 11:05 PM |
#221 |
-
What I am curious about... |
outraged2 |
Jul-20-05 10:43 AM |
#200 |
 -
In CoS when Hagrid is being hauled off |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 11:11 AM |
#205 |
  -
agreed |
outraged2 |
Jul-20-05 11:18 AM |
#206 |
 -
Its. . . |
brensgrrl |
Jul-21-05 11:03 PM |
#224 |
-
Dunno if I said this already |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 11:32 AM |
#208 |
 -
Hmmm, I don't think so. Voldemort didn't kill her, the basilisk did. |
ET Awful |
Jul-20-05 02:21 PM |
#212 |
-
The basilisk killed her |
XemaSab |
Jul-20-05 04:10 PM |
#214 |
-
I just finished today |
hertopos |
Jul-29-05 09:09 PM |
#227 |