You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login
Google

Reply #71: How does letting an innocent man die make us less guilty? [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Topic Forums » Religion/Theology Donate to DU
Deep13 Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Wed Apr-15-09 03:47 PM
Response to Original message
71. How does letting an innocent man die make us less guilty?
When I was a believer, I was very bothered by the question you raise and never resolved it. Frankly, the whole idea of vicarious blood sacricie for the wrong-doing of others is reprehensible.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
  -Jesus died for your sins? Richard D  Apr-14-09 03:02 PM   #0 
  - i didn't ask him to do that for me, i don't/didn't want him to do that for me  Scout   Apr-14-09 03:04 PM   #1 
  - Of course.  Richard D   Apr-14-09 03:05 PM   #2 
  - God  spag68   Apr-14-09 03:47 PM   #10 
  - Its Total BS- Kind, Good People Die Horrible Deaths  we can do it   Apr-14-09 03:05 PM   #3 
  - That's my theory about most celebs, too.  Goblinmonger   Apr-14-09 03:50 PM   #11 
     - No Kidding -also Jimi Hendrix, Freddie Mercury, Heath Ledger.....  we can do it   Apr-14-09 04:22 PM   #14 
        - Yeah, you're with me--Chris Farley, John Belushi, Kurt Cobain.... n/t  Goblinmonger   Apr-14-09 09:07 PM   #25 
  - The point that Jesus loves us more than we love him is exactly the point  CreekDog   Apr-14-09 03:08 PM   #4 
  - Yup. I'm pretty sure he ate too much chocolate.  lumberjack_jeff   Apr-14-09 03:13 PM   #5 
  - I've Been Told By My Fundamentalist Neighbor  AldebTX   Apr-14-09 03:14 PM   #6 
  - What I never got is the whole "sin" system in Christian Theology  Chulanowa   Apr-14-09 03:24 PM   #7 
  - I think it's all allegory  Richard D   Apr-14-09 03:32 PM   #8 
  - Not enough people have read that book.  laconicsax   Apr-14-09 04:39 PM   #16 
  - Haven't read it, but I'm familiar with that take on the story  Chulanowa   Apr-15-09 03:17 PM   #69 
  - "Sin" is literally "missing the mark"  JerseygirlCT   Apr-14-09 09:03 PM   #23 
     - I see the Garden of Eden story as an allegorical explanation for why  Lydia Leftcoast   Apr-15-09 01:01 AM   #42 
     - Thank you, I've not heard it told that way before. That's a beautiful interpretation.  54anickel   Apr-15-09 09:31 AM   #48 
     - Oh, I understand the allegory of the Garden of Eden just fine  Chulanowa   Apr-15-09 03:11 PM   #68 
  - "Jesus died for somebody's sin but not mine"  DBoon   Apr-14-09 03:47 PM   #9 
  - I was taught that Jesus ...  GeorgeGist   Apr-14-09 03:53 PM   #12 
  - The price of sin is death.  Sanctified   Apr-14-09 04:18 PM   #13 
  - Death comes to us all. nt  Deep13   Apr-15-09 03:48 PM   #72 
  - No.  Why Syzygy   Apr-14-09 04:37 PM   #15 
  - Wasn't that all determined after the fact?  laconicsax   Apr-14-09 04:47 PM   #17 
     - Well you are recalling incorrectly.  Sanctified   Apr-14-09 04:52 PM   #18 
     - I did remember that, I was asking a slightly different question.  laconicsax   Apr-14-09 07:56 PM   #20 
        - No.  Igel   Apr-24-09 02:13 PM   #117 
     - The "died for you sins" stuff? Pretty much a later development.  54anickel   Apr-14-09 08:16 PM   #21 
     - Yes! Thank you. nt  JerseygirlCT   Apr-14-09 09:07 PM   #26 
     - I like your point on MARK. We don't know exactly who Mark is,  saltpoint   Apr-14-09 09:16 PM   #28 
     - Yes, of course I should have said the author of Mark - didn't think we were being that scholastic  54anickel   Apr-14-09 09:55 PM   #34 
        - Agree -- the Mark author isn't one for the elaborate flourish.  saltpoint   Apr-14-09 10:00 PM   #35 
     - There's a question that follows that.  laconicsax   Apr-14-09 09:26 PM   #30 
     - There could have been. I would love to know more about the narrative  saltpoint   Apr-14-09 09:42 PM   #32 
     - Opposition by whom? Certainly there was opposition, Peter drew his sword and hacked off the ear of  54anickel   Apr-14-09 10:09 PM   #36 
     - That actually raises a question that I've struggled with many times in church doctrine -  54anickel   Apr-14-09 11:11 PM   #37 
        - The only good answer I've heard offends the hell out of people.  laconicsax   Apr-15-09 12:31 AM   #41 
        - Not offended at all. My understanding is that the Gospels were written for different  54anickel   Apr-15-09 09:15 AM   #47 
        - It certainly would have been  GKirk   Apr-16-09 08:52 PM   #92 
     - The Kingdom of God  Why Syzygy   Apr-14-09 11:16 PM   #38 
        - Only one of those says that he did.  laconicsax   Apr-15-09 01:10 AM   #43 
           - I just included  Why Syzygy   Apr-15-09 01:47 AM   #45 
              - Got it. Thanks.  laconicsax   Apr-15-09 04:47 PM   #74 
     - No. See post #38. nt  Why Syzygy   Apr-14-09 11:16 PM   #39 
        - Thanks. See post #43.  laconicsax   Apr-15-09 01:10 AM   #44 
  - I think Jesus died because he and his followers represented a potential  saltpoint   Apr-14-09 07:53 PM   #19 
  - Oh, absolutely. Though I don't think it was in the least a violent  JerseygirlCT   Apr-14-09 09:06 PM   #24 
     - Madam, you continue to make sense on these boards generally and  saltpoint   Apr-14-09 09:10 PM   #27 
        - Good point!  JerseygirlCT   Apr-14-09 09:19 PM   #29 
  - That's matter the most common way of looking at the resurrection  JerseygirlCT   Apr-14-09 08:58 PM   #22 
  - Yep, but I disagree on the crucifixion, I don't think God caused it or made it happen,  54anickel   Apr-14-09 09:26 PM   #31 
  - So, what's your theory  Why Syzygy   Apr-14-09 11:23 PM   #40 
     - Because the priestly class wanted political power  Meshuga   Apr-15-09 07:00 AM   #46 
     - Do you mind  Why Syzygy   Apr-15-09 10:39 AM   #49 
     - Perhaps you should have PM'd your question directly to JerseygirlCT rather than post it in an open  54anickel   Apr-15-09 10:59 AM   #50 
     - I understand the concept of discussion board.  Why Syzygy   Apr-15-09 11:04 AM   #51 
        - Offended? Not really. Your original wording came off as rather rude and condescending  54anickel   Apr-15-09 11:13 AM   #52 
           - I have a lot of respect for Meshuga  Why Syzygy   Apr-15-09 11:20 AM   #53 
              - I am not a girl  Meshuga   Apr-15-09 11:45 AM   #55 
              - Oh for pity's sake.  Why Syzygy   Apr-15-09 12:21 PM   #57 
                 - I am not an atheist and 54anickel is a Christian  Meshuga   Apr-15-09 12:36 PM   #59 
                    - Two against one.  Why Syzygy   Apr-15-09 12:39 PM   #61 
                       - I don't know 54anickel enough to say she is teaming up with me...  Meshuga   Apr-15-09 01:06 PM   #63 
              - So, am I considered a *gasp* non-Christian in your view? Just curious...regardless of the answer,  54anickel   Apr-15-09 12:20 PM   #56 
                 - What?  Why Syzygy   Apr-15-09 12:26 PM   #58 
                    - I guess it was the closing comment on your post #53.  54anickel   Apr-15-09 12:36 PM   #60 
                       - Right.  Why Syzygy   Apr-15-09 12:41 PM   #62 
                          - Wow. Guess you didn't pay much attention to my conversation with "atheists". Or you'd have noticed  54anickel   Apr-15-09 01:07 PM   #64 
                             - I appreciate your posts and your intrusion  Meshuga   Apr-15-09 01:21 PM   #65 
                                - It is a facinating study, the "evolution" of Christology. I appreciate your insights, though I  54anickel   Apr-15-09 02:03 PM   #66 
                                   - It is Jewish Tradition  Meshuga   Apr-15-09 03:02 PM   #67 
                                      - I must plead ignorance on the names, yet we seem to share interest in similar subject matters of  54anickel   Apr-15-09 05:08 PM   #75 
                                         - Yes, there is a parallel in our interests in regards to our respective religions  Meshuga   Apr-15-09 09:46 PM   #82 
     - You don't want to read my two cents.  Meshuga   Apr-15-09 11:39 AM   #54 
     - It is puzzling how quick Christians are to start a war over nothing.  heidler1   Apr-15-09 03:45 PM   #70 
     - What isn't the least puzzling  Why Syzygy   Apr-15-09 04:01 PM   #73 
     - I want to come back to this question.  Why Syzygy   Apr-15-09 06:49 PM   #77 
        - You have surprised me, Thank you for your generous offer.  heidler1   Apr-16-09 01:33 AM   #84 
           - The offer stands.  Why Syzygy   Apr-16-09 10:36 AM   #88 
              - I replied to your private message.  heidler1   Apr-16-09 12:44 PM   #90 
     - I think that's being sort of rough  JerseygirlCT   Apr-15-09 07:23 PM   #80 
     - how does one person replying block another from replying? nt  Muttocracy   Apr-15-09 09:23 PM   #81 
     - One interpretation I've heard recently of the  JerseygirlCT   Apr-15-09 07:22 PM   #79 
        - That marks the official break.  Meshuga   Apr-17-09 01:46 PM   #101 
     - I'd guess that those were more a function of the culture at the  JerseygirlCT   Apr-15-09 07:20 PM   #78 
  - The anonymous old woman or young man or school teacher or  saltpoint   Apr-14-09 09:51 PM   #33 
  - How does letting an innocent man die make us less guilty?  Deep13   Apr-15-09 03:47 PM   #71 
  - I agree plus this imaginary god is so vengefully that if it turned out to all come true.  heidler1   Apr-15-09 06:08 PM   #76 
  - That was my first-ever doubt as a 7-year-old believer, and the one  iris27   Apr-15-09 10:44 PM   #83 
  - It's interesting. Confronted with ideas like the one  JerseygirlCT   Apr-16-09 09:39 AM   #85 
     - Yes, I had a similar experience. Just found a lot of the church teachings weren't meshing with my  54anickel   Apr-16-09 10:16 AM   #86 
     - If I may play the devil's advocate:  Jokerman   Apr-16-09 10:16 AM   #87 
        - No empirical proof. Just my judgement  JerseygirlCT   Apr-16-09 10:38 AM   #89 
           - "So I'm quite content to believe as I do, and if it turns out I've had it all wrong, then I think my  Evoman   Apr-16-09 08:26 PM   #91 
              - When  Why Syzygy   Apr-16-09 08:57 PM   #93 
              - Again, it's an idea entirely at odds with the idea of a loving God  JerseygirlCT   Apr-17-09 01:12 PM   #96 
              - Unless the authoritarians are right....  Evoman   Apr-17-09 01:18 PM   #99 
              - You are lucky that your  Meshuga   Apr-17-09 01:41 PM   #100 
              - They aren't oval, they are spherical. Canadian scientists use them to calibrate  Evoman   Apr-17-09 02:33 PM   #112 
                 - Yes they are very important to calibrate instruments  Meshuga   Apr-17-09 03:22 PM   #113 
              - I'm rather looking forward to watching them learn the hard lesson  JerseygirlCT   Apr-17-09 01:57 PM   #103 
              - Thomas B. Thayer (snipped)  Why Syzygy   Apr-17-09 01:58 PM   #105 
                 - And yet, look what humankind has done to it over the years  JerseygirlCT   Apr-17-09 02:18 PM   #110 
                    - The driving force.  Why Syzygy   Apr-17-09 02:25 PM   #111 
              - I hope your right....I would hate to spend the rest of eternity with the devil stabbing my ballz  Evoman   Apr-17-09 01:14 PM   #97 
                 - Evo, have you thought about getting some help for that  JerseygirlCT   Apr-17-09 01:58 PM   #104 
                    - Yes, I've gotten help with my preoccupation. It was fun. Now I'm looking for more help.  Evoman   Apr-17-09 02:02 PM   #106 
                       - You're on a roll today, aren't you? nt  JerseygirlCT   Apr-17-09 02:16 PM   #109 
              - Well, we'll be roasting together then, huh?  JerseygirlCT   Apr-17-09 01:08 PM   #95 
                 - Yes, I suppose. I'm wondering if hell has anything like marshmallows.  Evoman   Apr-17-09 01:15 PM   #98 
                    - LOL. You're such a guy. nt  JerseygirlCT   Apr-17-09 01:55 PM   #102 
                       - I can't help it, it's glandular.  Evoman   Apr-17-09 02:03 PM   #107 
                          - LOL! Thanks, I needed that. nt  JerseygirlCT   Apr-17-09 02:15 PM   #108 
  - I don't see the Crucifixion as Jesus dying for our sins to appease an angry God.  deutsey   Apr-17-09 08:46 AM   #94 
  - What The Heck Is Your Problem!!!  ChelseaCenior   Apr-17-09 03:58 PM   #114 
  - One more thing  ChelseaCenior   Apr-17-09 04:00 PM   #115 
  - Guilt and Fear are the prime motivators of Evangelical Christianity  Taverner   Apr-21-09 11:50 AM   #116 
  - Anyway he did not existe, so why they care about my behaviour ?....  Sandrine for you   Apr-24-09 09:55 PM   #118 
 

Home » Discuss » Topic Forums » Religion/Theology Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators


Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC