Reply #25: are you a doctor? How do you know where these people were socked?

[npincus]

You are awfully sure of yourself. In my estimation, the 'wounds' she is exhibiting look fake-- just my opinion. I don't have your certitude. No, I have never had a black eye myself, but have had bruises and injuries throughout my life, including those to the eye, and as a female, have experience with eye shadow and charcoal eye pencil. Her black eyes look like make up to me. She did not submit herself to an exam, so we'll never know.

here is the opinion of a doctor who supports McCain, who thinks her black eyes are "suspect".

http://www.freedomslighthouse.com/2008/10/mccain-staffe...

he never offered a description of her attacker other than he was 'supposedly' an Obama supporter. Was he white, black, latino??
This is outrageous and demands further scrutiny. Also suspect are the blackeyes. Although real, the contusions are not reminiscent of a frontal punch as there are no abrasions/contusions above the eye socket (men have big, large knuckles) and the area around the eye socket is sensitive soft tissues. This woman is committing fraud via Munchhausen By Proxy and should be jailed for submitting a false police report/complaint. And the only reason WHY she would refuse to seek medical treatment is that she knows her story would not hold up under a physicians examination.