Reply #1: Is that really fair to his prospective/current students?

[Atman]

How do they effectively rate a professor if we artifically skew the results.

We shouldn't "DU" everything you know. Don't bastardize Ratemyprof just to thump Bush. There is no need. Bush is hanging himself, and this professor sounds like he'd likely get a good rating for real. If we hose it it opens up an easy door for any detractors to claim he isn't really liked by students, just the crazy lefites on DU.