furman
(363 posts)
Send PM |
Profile |
Ignore
|
Thu Dec-21-06 12:01 PM
Response to Reply #88 |
| 92. So Benny Morris says that population transfer may be justified in certain situtations |
|
Why don't you guys jump down Morris's throat for saying this?
Most of the posters here seem to find the idea of population transfer abhorrent under any circumstances.
|
| -The Green Line is the border |
bemildred |
Dec-15-06 09:59 AM |
#0 |
 -
Israel has a border? But if the border is the Green line...why does the |
Tom Joad |
Dec-15-06 10:03 AM |
#1 |
  -
The Green Line is not an official border |
furman |
Dec-15-06 11:03 AM |
#2 |
| -
why shouldn't Palestinians be allowed to live anywhere they want? |
Tom Joad |
Dec-15-06 12:20 PM |
#3 |
| -
I can't answer for the Arab countries who don't want them |
furman |
Dec-15-06 02:45 PM |
#4 |
| -
Yeah , like the immigration quotas implemented by the US at the dawn of the 20th century , quotas .. |
UndertheOcean |
Dec-15-06 03:18 PM |
#5 |
| -
How can you get it so wrong |
nicoll |
Dec-16-06 10:02 AM |
#7 |
| -
Funny that in your post you don't mention |
Phx_Dem |
Dec-16-06 11:16 AM |
#10 |
| -
The Mandate, Sir, Lapsed In '47 |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 12:48 PM |
#14 |
| -
Professor Stone disagrees with your assessment |
Phx_Dem |
Dec-16-06 03:27 PM |
#30 |
| -
You Will Note The Date Of This Material Is 2003, Sir |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 04:41 PM |
#32 |
| -
Perhaps I am looking at the wrong advisory opinion. |
msmcghee |
Dec-16-06 05:45 PM |
#35 |
| -
You Will Fnd It Contained In The Opinion, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 06:05 PM |
#36 |
| -
Legal opinions are just that. |
msmcghee |
Dec-17-06 09:46 AM |
#45 |
| -
A Legal Opinion By A Court With Jurisdiction, Ma'am, Is The State Of The Law On The Matter |
The Magistrate |
Dec-17-06 11:21 AM |
#49 |
| -
It is my opinion that such pronouncements as in your last post . . |
msmcghee |
Dec-17-06 11:44 AM |
#51 |
| -
It Is Always A Pleasure To Be Seen As A Naif, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-17-06 01:02 PM |
#53 |
| -
If you noticed, I prefaced my whole post with . . |
msmcghee |
Dec-17-06 03:05 PM |
#56 |
| -
Let Me Assure You No Offense Was Taken, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-17-06 03:30 PM |
#58 |
| -
I'm always pleased to find agreement with you. |
msmcghee |
Dec-17-06 04:02 PM |
#59 |
| -
One Small Point, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-19-06 12:27 AM |
#68 |
| -
Problem is that that wasn't whatthe ruling said |
eyl |
Dec-19-06 12:41 AM |
#69 |
| -
That Is Not Quite What The Ruling Says, Sir |
The Magistrate |
Dec-20-06 08:22 PM |
#77 |
| -
Umm.... |
dmesg |
Dec-20-06 12:21 PM |
#73 |
| -
I think that to understand my reasoning here . . |
msmcghee |
Dec-20-06 01:20 PM |
#74 |
| -
You May Forgive Me, Ma'am, Since You Have Invoked Some Earlier Comments Of Mine |
The Magistrate |
Dec-20-06 08:48 PM |
#78 |
| -
Please don't apologize for jumping into . . |
msmcghee |
Dec-20-06 10:54 PM |
#79 |
| -
It Is True Enough, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-21-06 12:50 AM |
#82 |
| -
Thanks for the great post.. |
msmcghee |
Dec-22-06 03:44 PM |
#95 |
| -
You Have Set Me a Pretty Task, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-23-06 01:03 AM |
#97 |
| -
It does seem we may be getting closer to . . |
msmcghee |
Dec-23-06 11:24 AM |
#98 |
| -
Your next concern is my use of the phrase . . |
msmcghee |
Dec-23-06 06:08 PM |
#99 |
| -
Regarding your final paragraph . . |
msmcghee |
Dec-23-06 06:55 PM |
#100 |
| -
I have thought about that last paragraph overnight and . . |
msmcghee |
Dec-24-06 02:45 PM |
#101 |
| -
Catholics don't have a Right of Return for Vatican City. |
Ken Burch |
Dec-17-06 09:56 AM |
#46 |
| -
It Might As Well Be, Mr. Furman |
The Magistrate |
Dec-15-06 04:21 PM |
#6 |
| -
amusing at best... |
pelsar |
Dec-16-06 10:59 AM |
#8 |
| -
What is the end game that is so clear to you? |
breakaleg |
Dec-16-06 11:02 AM |
#9 |
| -
the end game ... |
pelsar |
Dec-16-06 01:53 PM |
#16 |
| -
Which settlements to you believe they will get to keep? And why? |
breakaleg |
Dec-16-06 01:59 PM |
#17 |
| -
cities are hard to move... |
pelsar |
Dec-16-06 02:04 PM |
#19 |
| -
But if they were temporary, then Israel must have considered that when |
breakaleg |
Dec-16-06 02:09 PM |
#20 |
| -
consequences for one actions... |
pelsar |
Dec-16-06 02:15 PM |
#21 |
| -
Looking at maps of the West Bank |
breakaleg |
Dec-16-06 02:20 PM |
#24 |
| -
There Are Some Settlements, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 02:22 PM |
#25 |
| -
What if it makes it so difficult to swallow for the Palestinians that they won't? |
breakaleg |
Dec-16-06 02:24 PM |
#26 |
| -
they already have.....their leadership (PA) |
pelsar |
Dec-16-06 02:30 PM |
#28 |
| -
In That Case, Ma'am, They May Continue The Futile Course They Are On Now |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 02:40 PM |
#29 |
| -
You are right, of course. |
breakaleg |
Dec-16-06 03:42 PM |
#31 |
| -
In Things Like This, Ma'am, Raw Power Matters |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 04:45 PM |
#33 |
| -
Ok. If that's their position, then I'd rather they wouldn't sugar coat it, or |
breakaleg |
Dec-16-06 05:11 PM |
#34 |
| -
It Is My View, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 06:06 PM |
#37 |
| -
Yes, raw power does matter.. |
newyorican |
Dec-17-06 09:31 PM |
#61 |
| -
why the palestenains have to 'compromise"... |
pelsar |
Dec-16-06 11:48 PM |
#38 |
| -
How ironic. |
breakaleg |
Dec-17-06 01:11 AM |
#39 |
| -
welcome to the world.... |
pelsar |
Dec-17-06 02:23 AM |
#40 |
| -
Doubtless We Share The View, Mr. Pelsar, Amusement Is Where One Finds It |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 12:18 PM |
#12 |
| -
my argument with the intl law... |
pelsar |
Dec-16-06 01:59 PM |
#18 |
| -
A Good Lawyer, Sir, Can Indeed Argue Anything |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 02:16 PM |
#22 |
| -
Saying that means nothing. |
msmcghee |
Dec-17-06 10:02 AM |
#47 |
| -
It Means Both Nothing And Everything, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-17-06 11:29 AM |
#50 |
| -
To be frank, |
eyl |
Dec-17-06 12:46 PM |
#52 |
| -
To Address Just One Item, Sir |
The Magistrate |
Dec-17-06 01:22 PM |
#54 |
| -
Given that |
eyl |
Dec-18-06 03:19 AM |
#62 |
| -
Cheerleaders? You mean those folk who claim Israeli settlements are legal? n/t |
Violet_Crumble |
Dec-17-06 03:14 AM |
#41 |
| -
my definition of cheerleaders... |
pelsar |
Dec-17-06 06:02 AM |
#43 |
| -
So there's no cheerleaders on the Israeli side? |
Violet_Crumble |
Dec-17-06 06:26 AM |
#44 |
| -
my definition... |
pelsar |
Dec-17-06 11:02 AM |
#48 |
| -
That last sentence makes my head spin. |
msmcghee |
Dec-16-06 11:30 AM |
#11 |
| -
Over The Years, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 12:40 PM |
#13 |
| -
here is one recent poll with a extensive breakdown of Palestinian opinion |
Douglas Carpenter |
Dec-16-06 01:11 PM |
#15 |
| -
Thanks for the informative reply. |
msmcghee |
Dec-16-06 02:18 PM |
#23 |
| -
Thank You For The Kind Words, Ma'am |
The Magistrate |
Dec-16-06 02:29 PM |
#27 |
| -
About those pious noises... |
Violet_Crumble |
Dec-17-06 04:35 AM |
#42 |
| -
The same reason Palestinians can't live anywhere they want |
dmesg |
Dec-19-06 01:35 PM |
#70 |
| -
Responses |
furman |
Dec-19-06 02:35 PM |
#71 |
| -
You just repeated a myth... |
Violet_Crumble |
Dec-20-06 01:23 PM |
#75 |
| -
Only a small number of Arabs were expelled or terrorized, the rest fled voluntarily |
furman |
Dec-20-06 03:25 PM |
#76 |
| -
I'm sorry, I apologize for being rude. but that is pure nonsense |
Douglas Carpenter |
Dec-21-06 12:23 AM |
#80 |
| -
Thanks for posting that, Douglas... |
Violet_Crumble |
Dec-21-06 12:32 AM |
#81 |
| -
"For the record" by Benny Morris, The Guardian, January 14, 2004 |
furman |
Dec-21-06 09:46 AM |
#84 |
| -
Ben-Gurion was a "transferist" and Benny Morris doesn't think he went far enough |
Douglas Carpenter |
Dec-21-06 10:52 AM |
#88 |
| -
So Benny Morris says that population transfer may be justified in certain situtations |
furman |
Dec-21-06 12:01 PM |
#92 |
| -
Most people here do find population transfer abhorrent... |
Violet_Crumble |
Dec-21-06 01:11 PM |
#93 |
| -
I find it abhorrent as well n/t |
furman |
Dec-22-06 01:04 PM |
#94 |
| -
Thanks for clarifying that n/t |
Violet_Crumble |
Dec-22-06 03:49 PM |
#96 |
| -
Mr. Barak certainly NEVER made the Palestinians any generous offer |
Douglas Carpenter |
Dec-21-06 11:04 AM |
#89 |
| -
As I have responded before, this is revisionist history |
furman |
Dec-21-06 11:26 AM |
#90 |
| -
I will take the written record of the European Union notes as |
Douglas Carpenter |
Dec-21-06 11:33 AM |
#91 |
| -
So where did the Palestinian Arab-Israelis come from? |
Phx_Dem |
Dec-21-06 09:51 AM |
#85 |
| -
a minority did indeed stay in Israel and remained under military |
Douglas Carpenter |
Dec-21-06 10:32 AM |
#87 |
| -
No, that's not correct. |
Englander |
Dec-21-06 03:55 AM |
#83 |
| -
The comparison between Israel |
cali |
Dec-21-06 10:11 AM |
#86 |
| -
Sharon's Wall was a great success, to my surprise |
IndianaGreen |
Dec-17-06 02:21 PM |
#55 |
| -
I don't see the point |
cali |
Dec-17-06 03:18 PM |
#57 |
| -
Me too. |
bemildred |
Dec-17-06 05:11 PM |
#60 |
| -
Just as a point of information |
eyl |
Dec-18-06 03:22 AM |
#63 |
| -
no rockets from the westbank.. |
pelsar |
Dec-18-06 08:21 AM |
#64 |
| -
I have to ask: why would you believe anything he says? |
bemildred |
Dec-18-06 09:32 AM |
#67 |
| -
zakarwi... |
pelsar |
Dec-19-06 03:15 PM |
#72 |
| -
I know, but they might. The barrier will do nothing to stop rockets. |
bemildred |
Dec-18-06 08:23 AM |
#65 |
| -
quite true |
eyl |
Dec-18-06 08:31 AM |
#66 |
Printer-friendly format
Email this thread to a friend
Bookmark this thread