You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login
Google

Reply #75: I say that to refute the strict constructionist view... [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Topic Forums » Guns Donate to DU
Sleepysage Donating Member (148 posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Fri Nov-12-04 08:27 AM
Response to Reply #73
75. I say that to refute the strict constructionist view...
But as a practical matter, the right has successfully convinced people that "gun control" is code for "ban all guns," which is untrue. Sensible control and regulation of highly dangerous things is something that most people can agree, upon. If we give up on this, the gun lobby will work to eradicate all restrictions.

The better strategy is to recapture the terms and the frame of the debate, by convincing people that gun control is just like the regulation of other dangerous items like cars.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
  -Democrats: Give up on gun control Peak_Oil  Nov-12-04 02:42 AM   #0 
  - no way  Woody Wood   Nov-12-04 02:44 AM   #1 
  - You're one of those so-called "Democrats" whom has...  T Town Jake   Nov-12-04 04:09 AM   #30 
  - damn, and here I thought  iverglas   Nov-12-04 12:26 PM   #134 
     - Magic hats.  FatSlob   Nov-12-04 04:43 PM   #145 
  - so, you believe in authoritarianism?  FatSlob   Nov-12-04 04:45 PM   #146 
     - Gun control is an evil cancer supported by those...  FatSlob   Nov-12-04 04:47 PM   #148 
  - Um...... No.  UdoKier   Nov-12-04 02:45 AM   #2 
  - yes  Woody Wood   Nov-12-04 02:46 AM   #3 
  - How about these reasons  sendero   Nov-12-04 03:39 AM   #22 
  - re: 1) "gun control" costs us many, many votes  YankeeFan   Nov-12-04 05:55 AM   #48 
  - More nonsense from the same crowd...  T Town Jake   Nov-12-04 04:18 AM   #35 
  - nonsense  Cheswick   Nov-12-04 09:47 AM   #107 
     - The Assault Weapons was the stupidest gun control legislation ever  aikoaiko   Nov-12-04 10:05 AM   #114 
        - You want anyone to be able to buy an Uzi? a Howitzer? A Bazooka?  UdoKier   Nov-12-04 08:54 PM   #151 
           - bullshit, you are ignorant on the issue.  FatSlob   Nov-12-04 10:19 PM   #156 
           - You said...  LynnMassGuy   Nov-12-04 10:23 PM   #159 
              - The poster advocated the right to buy ANY weapon.  UdoKier   Nov-12-04 10:32 PM   #162 
                 - I like to collect military style "assault" weapons... are you saying  jtb33   Nov-15-04 10:58 AM   #197 
  - He advocates a gain in freedom.  FatSlob   Nov-12-04 10:10 PM   #155 
  - this issue is an albatross around our necks  Doomsayer13   Nov-12-04 02:47 AM   #4 
  - Look at just exactly what the AWB is about.  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 02:52 AM   #9 
  - I want a full auto short barreled shotgun that I can carry for personal  RapidCreek   Nov-12-04 04:41 AM   #41 
  - Full-Auto ... Shotgun?  REP   Nov-12-04 05:22 AM   #46 
  - Disagree  TX-RAT   Nov-12-04 09:54 AM   #111 
  - Golly someone who actually knows what the fuck they're talking about!  RapidCreek   Nov-13-04 05:57 AM   #170 
  - Look back at what REP said...  Spiffarino   Nov-13-04 03:52 PM   #179 
     - It's not unlikely that it would go through two  RapidCreek   Nov-13-04 08:39 PM   #182 
  - Kinda over the top eh?  RapidCreek   Nov-13-04 05:54 AM   #169 
  - SPAAS-12 and USAS-12  JeebusB   Nov-15-04 02:37 PM   #204 
  - The "AW" ban had nothing to do with short barrels or automatic fire  slackmaster   Nov-12-04 09:47 AM   #106 
  - What the hell does the AW ban have to do with "giving up on gun control"?  RapidCreek   Nov-13-04 06:11 AM   #171 
  - Full Auto shotgun (hahahahaha)  aikoaiko   Nov-12-04 10:12 AM   #119 
  - Is that right? Funny....I had occasion to fire two different models of  RapidCreek   Nov-13-04 05:48 AM   #168 
     - in other words, Gotcha!  NorthernSpy   Nov-13-04 12:30 PM   #177 
     - Well actually quite a few people know about them  RapidCreek   Nov-14-04 04:53 AM   #186 
        - like I said: ya GOT me, already!  NorthernSpy   Nov-14-04 03:08 PM   #188 
           - Actually that was never my intent.  RapidCreek   Nov-14-04 07:35 PM   #190 
     - oh man that's sweet, I sure need one of those. that's probably about the  enfield collector   Nov-13-04 05:11 PM   #181 
  - ummm...  puttothesword   Nov-12-04 11:08 AM   #132 
  - What the hell do you think the National Firearms act of 1934 is?  RapidCreek   Nov-13-04 06:14 AM   #172 
  - what the hell are you talking about?  FatSlob   Nov-12-04 10:21 PM   #157 
  - None of us peasants get to have full auto anything  LynnMassGuy   Nov-12-04 10:28 PM   #161 
  - You are absolutely correct  elderly man   Nov-12-04 08:09 AM   #71 
     - Welcome to DU - Great post  slackmaster   Nov-12-04 09:47 AM   #109 
  - Exactly right. (n/t)  T Town Jake   Nov-12-04 04:05 AM   #28 
  - Why?  LynnMassGuy   Nov-12-04 10:24 PM   #160 
  - The NRA is for responsible gun ownership?  aquart   Nov-12-04 02:47 AM   #5 
  - Sure.  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 03:05 AM   #16 
  - How about responsible CAR ownership?  Firerin   Nov-12-04 04:13 AM   #32 
  - Monopoly on force?  creeksneakers2   Nov-12-04 06:01 AM   #49 
  - My point EXACTLY!  Firerin   Nov-12-04 04:26 PM   #144 
     - I protect myself  creeksneakers2   Nov-12-04 05:36 PM   #150 
        - Hmmm...  jtb33   Nov-15-04 02:36 PM   #203 
  - The Unorganized Militia  Liberty2001   Nov-12-04 07:37 AM   #67 
  - "Why aren't you hot to ban cars and booze?"  iverglas   Nov-15-04 07:56 AM   #194 
  - In Switzerland every home has a GENUINE MILITARY assault rifle.  Silverhair   Nov-12-04 06:22 AM   #54 
  - So wrong I'm not sure where to start...  Jeff in Cincinnati   Nov-12-04 09:16 AM   #91 
     - Incorrect.  Factoid   Nov-12-04 11:49 PM   #165 
  - Responsible Assault Weapon Onwership is self-evident.  aikoaiko   Nov-12-04 10:17 AM   #121 
  - I'm not trying to take anyone's gun away ...  PittLib   Nov-12-04 02:49 AM   #6 
  - Excellent question.  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 03:29 AM   #20 
     - All I know about guns is ...  PittLib   Nov-12-04 03:40 AM   #23 
        - A stray bullet wouldn't be stopped because of the AWB...  formernaderite   Nov-12-04 08:44 AM   #78 
        - do you even know what an assault weapon is?  FatSlob   Nov-12-04 10:23 PM   #158 
  - gang-bangers...  laheina   Nov-12-04 02:50 AM   #7 
  - LA is hicksville?  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 02:59 AM   #12 
  - Gangbangers most certainly do shoot skeet.  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 09:51 PM   #153 
  - Hurm  w13rd0   Nov-12-04 02:52 AM   #8 
  - Ignoramus.  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 03:00 AM   #13 
  - Name calling doesn't get you anywhere...  w13rd0   Nov-12-04 03:37 AM   #21 
     - This is the one single response to my comments.  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 03:56 AM   #26 
        - Wow  w13rd0   Nov-12-04 06:58 AM   #62 
        - You hit the nail on the head  elderly man   Nov-12-04 08:46 AM   #79 
           - That's an incorrect understanding of what was covered in the AWB  Billy Ruffian   Nov-15-04 01:47 PM   #202 
        - You are absolutely correct  elderly man   Nov-12-04 08:26 AM   #74 
        - WE live in fear?  ieoeja   Nov-12-04 09:50 AM   #110 
           - I remember this story ...  Liberty2001   Nov-12-04 12:59 PM   #137 
              - "What was the lesson learned?"  iverglas   Nov-15-04 02:38 AM   #192 
  - I shoot skeet with a submachinegun.  DoNotRefill   Nov-13-04 09:33 PM   #184 
  - The AWB seems to me to be as misleading as the PATRIOT act  killbotfactory   Nov-12-04 02:56 AM   #10 
  - while you might win a few votes in TN and MT  mitchtv   Nov-12-04 03:01 AM   #15 
  - Inflict what?  killbotfactory   Nov-12-04 03:10 AM   #18 
  - inflict what on LA and NYC?  aikoaiko   Nov-12-04 10:24 AM   #122 
  - From a completely pragmatic point of view,  JeebusB   Nov-15-04 03:36 PM   #205 
  - Yes indeed.  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 03:07 AM   #17 
  - Uh, some of us don't live behind a blade of grass.  Harvey Korman   Nov-12-04 02:58 AM   #11 
  - NYC benefitted from a good mayor  LibLover   Nov-12-04 04:43 AM   #42 
  - Highly doubtful.  Harvey Korman   Nov-12-04 04:46 PM   #147 
  - The "benefits" of gun control...  Firerin   Nov-12-04 04:48 AM   #44 
  - that is hilarious.  FatSlob   Nov-12-04 04:48 PM   #149 
  - Not sure why I'm bothering, but . . .  MrModerate   Nov-12-04 03:01 AM   #14 
  - I'm hardly a troll or a provocateur but...  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 03:14 AM   #19 
  - the bottom line is  qazplm   Nov-12-04 03:53 AM   #25 
  - Excellent question, and in intelligent one.  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 04:14 AM   #34 
  - yes! yes!  iverglas   Nov-12-04 12:32 PM   #135 
  - You're Constitutional Law is wrong.  Liberty2001   Nov-12-04 01:10 PM   #138 
  - I agree  elderly man   Nov-12-04 08:58 AM   #83 
  - You should read more...  T Town Jake   Nov-12-04 04:34 AM   #38 
  - No one says you have to have one in your house  JeebusB   Nov-15-04 03:41 PM   #206 
  - It never ceases to amaze me...  sendero   Nov-12-04 03:51 AM   #24 
  - My man.  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 03:58 AM   #27 
  - "It never ceases to amaze me..."  donheld   Nov-12-04 04:06 AM   #29 
  - I agree entirely. (n/t)  T Town Jake   Nov-12-04 04:36 AM   #39 
  - Ditto  elderly man   Nov-12-04 09:06 AM   #88 
  - I don't own guns  Magnulus   Nov-12-04 04:12 AM   #31 
  - Hundred dollar handguns at Wal-Mart?!?  Firerin   Nov-12-04 04:24 AM   #36 
  - "I don't own Guns" Well, that's pretty obvious.  BiggJawn   Nov-12-04 06:30 AM   #55 
  - Street criminals DO NOT like "Saturday Night Specials".  Silverhair   Nov-12-04 06:42 AM   #59 
  - We Already Caved In On This One  AndyTiedye   Nov-12-04 04:13 AM   #33 
  - NRA is not part and parcel of the Republican Party  cattleman22   Nov-12-04 09:02 AM   #85 
  - Howard Dean  elderly man   Nov-12-04 09:16 AM   #92 
  - Exactly right. We did cave. No one noticed because  SmokingJacket   Nov-12-04 09:25 AM   #95 
     - Democrat candidates did not on cave gun control.  aikoaiko   Nov-12-04 10:31 AM   #125 
  - I'm considering getting a gun--  eridani   Nov-12-04 04:32 AM   #37 
  - Sick and tired  Abelman   Nov-12-04 04:40 AM   #40 
  - Re "Sick and Tired"  cattleman22   Nov-12-04 09:04 AM   #87 
     - Link?  ieoeja   Nov-12-04 10:06 AM   #116 
  - That's pretty funny, P_O!  Lexingtonian   Nov-12-04 04:44 AM   #43 
  - Uh huh  NickB79   Nov-12-04 06:39 AM   #57 
  - yup  Lexingtonian   Nov-12-04 10:51 PM   #164 
  - WRONG!!! Welost a voter due to this ONE issue alone in this last election  Mr_Spock   Nov-12-04 06:40 AM   #58 
  - How often do gangbangers go out on the shooting range?  cornermouse   Nov-12-04 05:01 AM   #45 
  - It's a losing issue......  solinvictus   Nov-12-04 05:49 AM   #47 
  - Oh, come on.  GaYellowDawg   Nov-12-04 06:09 AM   #50 
  - Gun Control wasn't a blip on the political radar this time...  Jeff in Cincinnati   Nov-12-04 06:14 AM   #51 
  - Actually, the NRA has at times supported Democratic candidates.  Silverhair   Nov-12-04 06:58 AM   #63 
  - Horse Crap  Jeff in Cincinnati   Nov-12-04 07:53 AM   #69 
     - all the more reason to take away little Grover's meal ticket...  NorthernSpy   Nov-12-04 10:05 PM   #154 
  - RE: NRA and Republican Party  cattleman22   Nov-12-04 09:09 AM   #89 
     - Name one...  Jeff in Cincinnati   Nov-12-04 09:27 AM   #97 
        - Name One? That is very easy  cattleman22   Nov-12-04 09:42 AM   #103 
           - Nope  Jeff in Cincinnati   Nov-12-04 09:47 AM   #108 
           - Did someone mention the Pagan Preacher?  PaganPreacher   Nov-12-04 11:43 AM   #133 
              - oh dear oh dear oh dear  iverglas   Nov-15-04 12:44 PM   #200 
  - One of us is in the wrong party...  Q   Nov-12-04 06:17 AM   #52 
  - Some of us are civil libertarians, and support the entire Bill of Rights!  eallen   Nov-12-04 08:51 AM   #81 
  - RE: taking away guns  cattleman22   Nov-12-04 09:25 AM   #96 
  - Tell you what friend, I'll make this deal with you  MadHound   Nov-12-04 06:18 AM   #53 
  - As the 1990's showed us, gun control is not the way to reduce crime  NickB79   Nov-12-04 06:48 AM   #60 
  - I see you aren't willing to take me up on my offer  MadHound   Nov-12-04 08:50 AM   #80 
     - Where's that neighborhood again?  alwynsw   Nov-12-04 11:03 AM   #131 
        - Get a clue yourself friend  MadHound   Nov-12-04 12:52 PM   #136 
  - If my former father-in-law were still alive ...  ieoeja   Nov-12-04 10:30 AM   #124 
  - You got it, buddy. I'll take it.  Peak_Oil   Nov-12-04 09:42 PM   #152 
  - I agree - this issue unnecessarily alienates a lot of people  Mr_Spock   Nov-12-04 06:36 AM   #56 
  - Or, we could ditch choice or civic freedoms for homosexuals  BlueEyedSon   Nov-12-04 06:49 AM   #61 
  - The 2nd amendment is an individual right  Billy Ruffian   Nov-12-04 09:02 AM   #86 
  - Yeah, sorry but...  Sleepysage   Nov-12-04 07:25 AM   #64 
  - Good luck....  sendero   Nov-12-04 08:22 AM   #73 
  - I say that to refute the strict constructionist view...  Sleepysage   Nov-12-04 08:27 AM   #75 
     - I don't disagree..  sendero   Nov-12-04 08:40 AM   #77 
        - Then we'll have to disagree.  Sleepysage   Nov-12-04 10:02 AM   #113 
  - RE: Militia and Standing army  cattleman22   Nov-12-04 09:31 AM   #98 
     - Actually  Sleepysage   Nov-12-04 10:07 AM   #117 
        - Standing Armies and Militia  cattleman22   Nov-12-04 10:25 AM   #123 
        - If there was to be no permanent military....  DoNotRefill   Nov-13-04 09:37 PM   #185 
  - we need more guns  Sven77   Nov-12-04 07:32 AM   #65 
  - I agree, I never understood this about the Democrats either. nt  Catfight   Nov-12-04 07:33 AM   #66 
  - I agree 100%  agincourt   Nov-12-04 07:40 AM   #68 
  - Show us the figures, please!  Bridget Burke   Nov-12-04 08:07 AM   #70 
  - 2nd amendment interpretation should be as expansive as the 1st.  robcon   Nov-12-04 08:17 AM   #72 
  - I'd like to know why Democrats are asked to compromise on every issue...  Q   Nov-12-04 08:38 AM   #76 
  - I just never  flobee1kenobi   Nov-12-04 09:12 AM   #90 
  - racism...  Jack_DeLeon   Nov-12-04 03:21 PM   #142 
  - Radical fundies....  solinvictus   Nov-13-04 01:05 AM   #167 
  - Proably because we are losing elections like crazy  Fescue4u   Nov-12-04 10:05 AM   #115 
  - I'll think about it. NO.  spanone   Nov-12-04 08:53 AM   #82 
  - I'm still on the gun control fence. Here's why:  EV1Ltimm   Nov-12-04 08:58 AM   #84 
  - If the party goes that way, fine. I'll still vote Democratic, but  SmokingJacket   Nov-12-04 09:19 AM   #93 
  - That's the problem with personal anecdotes.  ieoeja   Nov-12-04 10:52 AM   #129 
  - You don't know the text of the Second Amendment.  CBHagman   Nov-12-04 09:20 AM   #94 
  - The Dems should just say it's NOT a federal issue-let the states deal  geek tragedy   Nov-12-04 09:34 AM   #99 
  - agreed  WorstPresidentEver   Nov-12-04 09:36 AM   #100 
  - BTW, how does one go about getting a gun permit, training..  Glenda   Nov-12-04 09:38 AM   #101 
  - Depends on the state.  ieoeja   Nov-12-04 10:41 AM   #127 
  - I have an even better idea.  lizzy   Nov-12-04 09:38 AM   #102 
  - It's about time  elderly man   Nov-12-04 09:43 AM   #104 
  - interesting rant, i used to oppose guns  m_welby   Nov-12-04 09:46 AM   #105 
  - that will fix it  iverglas   Nov-15-04 11:51 AM   #199 
  - I know of numerous  Iver Johnson   Nov-12-04 09:57 AM   #112 
  - and as i tell all the men and boys in my family  seabeyond   Nov-12-04 10:08 AM   #118 
  - Take a page out the playbook of the militias  StopThePendulum   Nov-12-04 10:15 AM   #120 
  - I would venture to say that you live in a rural area  Politicub   Nov-12-04 10:36 AM   #126 
  - Give that man a prize!  ieoeja   Nov-12-04 11:02 AM   #130 
  - How so?  Jack_DeLeon   Nov-12-04 03:25 PM   #143 
  - Living in most cities suck because its difficult to legally own and carry  aikoaiko   Nov-13-04 10:16 AM   #175 
  - I agree with the poster  OnionPatch   Nov-12-04 10:51 AM   #128 
  - I read very  Buster43   Nov-12-04 01:22 PM   #139 
  - AMEN, BROTHER!!!  Van23   Nov-12-04 01:31 PM   #140 
  - Gun Control is dying...  Jack_DeLeon   Nov-12-04 03:14 PM   #141 
  - Personal Responsibility  El Oso   Nov-12-04 10:33 PM   #163 
     - Bienvenida padre oso  laheina   Nov-12-04 11:56 PM   #166 
     - All guns for all noncriminal, noncrazy adult citizens.  aikoaiko   Nov-13-04 08:19 AM   #173 
        - Ever Have A Family Member Gunned Down?  BearClaws   Nov-13-04 09:53 AM   #174 
           - Sorry to hear about your loss...  aikoaiko   Nov-13-04 10:21 AM   #176 
     - please, everyone, stop this Michael Moore/Canada business  iverglas   Nov-14-04 10:45 PM   #191 
        - Good point about Michael Moore, but remember  aikoaiko   Nov-15-04 01:39 PM   #201 
  - Absolutely! - Support your RKBA  UNIXnutt   Nov-13-04 12:51 PM   #178 
  - I don't think it's necessary to ask people to give up beliefs  Spiffarino   Nov-13-04 03:57 PM   #180 
  - Uh... no.  BTTB   Nov-13-04 08:55 PM   #183 
  - Gun owners need to get serious about keeping guns out of the hands  Jade Fox   Nov-14-04 01:16 PM   #187 
  - Serious gun owners....  aikoaiko   Nov-14-04 05:28 PM   #189 
  - has anybody asked yet?  iverglas   Nov-15-04 04:20 AM   #193 
     - I'm in the NRA  Billy Ruffian   Nov-15-04 07:57 AM   #195 
        - that's all ever so nice  iverglas   Nov-15-04 08:14 AM   #196 
           - Apologies for violating protocol  Billy Ruffian   Nov-15-04 11:24 AM   #198 
 

Home » Discuss » Topic Forums » Guns Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators


Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC