You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login
Google

Reply #40: She's not a credible argument? [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (Through 2005) Donate to DU
RapidCreek Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Sun Nov-09-03 06:17 PM
Response to Reply #6
40. She's not a credible argument?
Edited on Sun Nov-09-03 06:23 PM by RapidCreek
This is the first time we have heard her argument, for christs fucking sakes. What facts go against what she is saying? Facts...give them to me. One by one.

1) Iraqi doctors said they saw no evidence that she was raped. That's a fact.

2)Ms. Lynch says she doesn't remember being raped. that's a fact.

3)It is claimed by a right wing neocon author that Ms. Lynch's US military medical records indicate she was raped.That is a fact.

4)These records do NOT say she was raped. The same military which told lies about her rescue also compiled her medical records, which by the way are confidential and not viewable by anyone but her without her permission. That is a fact.

5)The taping of her 'rescue' was a PR film produced by the military. The same military who lied about her brave fight and dangerous rescue. A fight she does remember, she did not participate in. That is a fact.

6)Those on DU who castigated Ms. Lynch were lead to believe that she backed up the militarys nonsensical account of her capture and rescue. She now has come forward and stated that this account is untrue. That is a fact.

7)The media initially led us to believe that she gladly accepted her 'hero' status when it now becomes clear, she does not. That is a fact.

What of the above is not credible?

RC

Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
  -Sickening FRuitcakes turn on American hero Jessica Lynch... johnfunk  Nov-09-03 03:46 PM   #0 
  - Ha  htuttle   Nov-09-03 03:49 PM   #1 
  - They're just being consistent  Jack Rabbit   Nov-09-03 03:55 PM   #5 
     - they are being perfectly reasonable and rational to lie about it  WhoCountsTheVotes   Nov-09-03 04:02 PM   #8 
     - And I think that's where a lot of criticism from our side came into play..  liberal_veteran   Nov-09-03 05:00 PM   #25 
     - Your point is taken  Jack Rabbit   Nov-09-03 08:56 PM   #78 
     - Bush doesn't need a Monica Lewinsky to suck HIS cock!!  RapidCreek   Nov-09-03 05:59 PM   #39 
        - Wouldn't that be a bit difficult for them to do....  liberal_veteran   Nov-09-03 07:11 PM   #50 
     - It's not just the moronic freepers, Charles Kruthhammer sounded like  loudnclear   Nov-09-03 07:22 PM   #53 
     - A couple of months ago Mr Krauthammer quipped that "We liberals  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 08:33 PM   #71 
        - Well, he had that partly right  Jack Rabbit   Nov-09-03 08:45 PM   #76 
     - They're consistently UnAmerican. They hate our country and military.  MIMStigator   Nov-09-03 07:37 PM   #55 
  - Freepazoids only "support the troops" as long as the troops support BushJr  AntiCoup2k   Nov-09-03 03:51 PM   #2 
  - You've GOT to be kidding  sandnsea   Nov-09-03 03:52 PM   #3 
  - I agree...  MessiahRp   Nov-09-03 03:56 PM   #6 
  - She's not a credible argument?  RapidCreek   Nov-09-03 06:17 PM   #40 
     - Sounds like you got it right and I agree!  0007   Nov-09-03 08:34 PM   #72 
  - Yeah, we're all of one mind here at DU  chascarrillo   Nov-09-03 03:58 PM   #7 
     - Yeah, kind of like Free Republic eh?  Selwynn   Nov-09-03 04:38 PM   #20 
     - The vast majority...  sandnsea   Nov-09-03 04:40 PM   #23 
        - We were lead to believe by the military  RapidCreek   Nov-09-03 06:43 PM   #46 
        - Not true. On the few occaisions where she was bashed most  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 07:59 PM   #62 
  - This guy is aredneck supreme  Eroshan   Nov-09-03 03:54 PM   #4 
  - heh heh  ProudGerman   Nov-09-03 04:23 PM   #14 
  - It does happen to male POW's  RapidCreek   Nov-09-03 06:44 PM   #47 
  - They hate us for our freedoms  tom_paine   Nov-09-03 04:08 PM   #9 
  - do you think  Eroshan   Nov-09-03 04:11 PM   #10 
     - Nope, I think the Busheviks have already worked most of the bugs out  tom_paine   Nov-09-03 04:24 PM   #15 
  - They spout the Bush party line. Disagreeing is treason.  faygokid   Nov-09-03 04:11 PM   #11 
  - Son of a BITCH  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 04:18 PM   #12 
  - Bull everyone didn't say something bad about Lynch  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 06:21 PM   #41 
  - The only real thing I can say negative about Lynch...  liberal_veteran   Nov-09-03 04:20 PM   #13 
  - You should live outside Fort Bragg!  OldSoldier   Nov-10-03 07:41 AM   #104 
  - They get pissed when REALITY shows up to  Clark Can WIN   Nov-09-03 04:27 PM   #16 
  - "But all we want is the truth!"  elperromagico   Nov-09-03 04:28 PM   #17 
  - You gotta love this answer  Kamika   Nov-09-03 04:30 PM   #18 
  - Saw the EXACT same thing here...  Selwynn   Nov-09-03 04:39 PM   #21 
     - How many times did you see it here?  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 05:04 PM   #26 
     - 2 times  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 06:24 PM   #43 
     - Well, let's ask Skinner  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 07:01 PM   #49 
        - so now it is fifty posts instead of 50 people  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 07:15 PM   #52 
           - Oh wow, are you stretching  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 07:40 PM   #56 
              - I never saw anything about the rape other than people saying  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 07:54 PM   #61 
                 - No, really  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 08:32 PM   #70 
                    - My views are different, but that isn't saying anything bad about Lynch  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 08:35 PM   #73 
     - I'm staying on my moral high horse ...  Isome   Nov-09-03 08:27 PM   #69 
     - lol show me ONE time someone said that  Kamika   Nov-09-03 05:30 PM   #30 
     - You're joking right?  Selwynn   Nov-09-03 05:35 PM   #33 
        - Thats not what I reacted too  Kamika   Nov-09-03 05:48 PM   #38 
        - Well Selwyn...I didn't call her a greedy money whore  RapidCreek   Nov-09-03 06:54 PM   #48 
     - You couldn't be more right  jumptheshadow   Nov-09-03 05:46 PM   #37 
     - I didn't see a pigpile nearly as big on Lynch here.  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 06:22 PM   #42 
     - Where did you see it?  RapidCreek   Nov-09-03 07:44 PM   #58 
        - Who needs a link? Just go to post #36.  mgdecombe   Nov-09-03 08:56 PM   #80 
           - That is not the exact same thing  RapidCreek   Nov-09-03 09:02 PM   #81 
              - Did she sign a movie deal?  mgdecombe   Nov-09-03 09:24 PM   #83 
                 - Yep you're right she walked away from the movie deal.  RapidCreek   Nov-09-03 09:47 PM   #89 
                    - We'll just have to agree to disagree on the book part. I'd like to know  mgdecombe   Nov-09-03 10:10 PM   #93 
  - Yeah well, no one was calling her "America Hero" around here...  Selwynn   Nov-09-03 04:37 PM   #19 
  - What would like people to do?  liberal_veteran   Nov-09-03 04:47 PM   #24 
  - Deleted message  Name removed   Nov-09-03 05:07 PM   #27 
  - Can you really blame people?  liberal_veteran   Nov-09-03 05:14 PM   #29 
  - Yes I can blame people  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 05:34 PM   #32 
     - but you can't blame everyone  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 08:01 PM   #63 
        - Yeah, and there are many on FreeRepublic  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 08:12 PM   #65 
           - What interests do you have in defending freak repuklic?  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 08:14 PM   #66 
              - Huh?  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 08:20 PM   #67 
                 - You are saying we're the same it ain't true  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 08:24 PM   #68 
                    - Two points  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 08:42 PM   #75 
                       - Name a specific DUer who blithely made such a switch?  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 09:06 PM   #82 
                          - What do you think this is?  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 09:26 PM   #84 
                             - aha, you can't name one, unless you are insinuating John Funk  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 09:29 PM   #86 
                                - Deleted message  Name removed   Nov-09-03 09:53 PM   #90 
                                   - The individual I was referring to got tombstoned  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 10:28 PM   #97 
                                      - Admit what?  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 10:35 PM   #99 
  - No, I didnt say anything bad about Lynch  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 06:26 PM   #45 
  - No, just not be hypocritical about it. :)  Selwynn   Nov-09-03 05:31 PM   #31 
  - I never said anything bad about the poor girl  Clark Can WIN   Nov-09-03 05:38 PM   #35 
  - Deleted message  Name removed   Nov-09-03 07:33 PM   #54 
     - Since I never bashed Lynch....  liberal_veteran   Nov-09-03 07:41 PM   #57 
        - I thought you were speaking for  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 07:50 PM   #59 
           - No I was merely saying that we had to take human nature into account...  liberal_veteran   Nov-09-03 07:53 PM   #60 
              - What aspect of human nature is that?  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 08:06 PM   #64 
  - Bull. 90% of the people here were nice to Lynch and defended her  Classical_Liberal   Nov-09-03 06:25 PM   #44 
  - I'll go along with that statement...  0007   Nov-09-03 08:53 PM   #77 
  - 2 interesting things I gathered here about the freeps  T Bone   Nov-09-03 09:33 PM   #87 
  - The only thing I said about Lynch that would be considered bashing  cat_girl25   Nov-09-03 09:33 PM   #88 
  - One who allows a lie to persist,  RapidCreek   Nov-09-03 07:14 PM   #51 
  - F@cking Reich-wingers.  Zynx   Nov-09-03 04:40 PM   #22 
  - I have never been against her.  Tandalayo_Scheisskopf   Nov-09-03 05:14 PM   #28 
  - She served with honor -- AND she spoke out about being exploited.  johnfunk   Nov-09-03 05:36 PM   #34 
     - I'd respect her more  Skittles   Nov-09-03 05:43 PM   #36 
        - I was wondering when you'd show up. nt  mgdecombe   Nov-09-03 08:36 PM   #74 
        - It would have made it more creditable...  0007   Nov-09-03 08:56 PM   #79 
  - 'America-hating lefties are twisting her words'  Cat Atomic   Nov-09-03 09:28 PM   #85 
  - I don't think...  grasswire   Nov-09-03 09:56 PM   #91 
  - Oh brother. Thanks fer nuttin'  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 10:10 PM   #92 
     - all in good time....  mgdecombe   Nov-09-03 10:14 PM   #95 
  - They told us to "support our troops"...  LoZoccolo   Nov-09-03 10:11 PM   #94 
  - Maybe we should send her some flowers or something.  LoZoccolo   Nov-09-03 10:23 PM   #96 
  - I wouldn't  jfxgillis   Nov-09-03 10:48 PM   #100 
     - A donation to the Lori Peistewa foundation through her publisher  mgdecombe   Nov-09-03 10:53 PM   #102 
  - Never doubt that these people are disgusting assholes  ComerPerro   Nov-09-03 10:29 PM   #98 
  - Send this to Malloy, Randhi, and the Wall St Journal OpEd.  Bleachers7   Nov-09-03 10:52 PM   #101 
  - Jessica Lynch gets turned on by fruitcakes?  liberal_veteran   Nov-09-03 11:02 PM   #103 
 

Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (Through 2005) Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators


Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC