You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login

Reply #10: Corzine’s Know-Nothing MF Global Defense [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
Home » Discuss » Editorials & Other Articles Donate to DU
Demeter Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Sat Dec-10-11 05:56 AM
Response to Reply #7
10. Corzine’s Know-Nothing MF Global Defense

Jon Corzine’s evasive testimony before the Senate Agriculture Committee was scripted so as to lay foundations for his defense against customer and possibly shareholder suits and reduce the already very low odds of an indictment. Although I’ll touch on other interesting elements shortly, the key item from his presentation was one that the New York Times’ Dealbook noted:

“I never intended to break any rules,” said Mr. Corzine, dressed in a dark suit but without his trademark sweater vest. “I know I had no intention to ever authorize the transfer of segregated moneys. I know what my intentions were.” Mr. Corzine has not been accused of any wrongdoing….

Still, over three hours of testimony, Mr. Corzine danced carefully around questions touching on the scandal of the missing funds, using phrases like “never intended” and “not to my knowledge.”

To prove fraud, you need to prove intent. So Corzine’s insistence that he didn’t intend for customer accounts to be raided would seem to get him off the hook, unless documents or the testimony from multiple employees establishes otherwise. His justification amounts to blaming any misdeeds on the fog of war: “Yes, I told staffers to be aggressive, but I never meant for them to bayonet old women and babies.” In other words, if anything bad was done deliberately, it was all a really big miscommunication:

He did not rule out possible wrongdoing at MF Global. In theory, an employee may have misused customer cash after misinterpreting the chief executive’s words, he said.

Now as regular readers know, CEOs morphing suddenly from Masters of the Universe to empty 42 longs who are clueless as far as operational details are concerned was supposed to go the way of the dodo bird with Sarbanes Oxley. Sarbanes Oxley requires key corporate executives, typically at least the CEO and CFO, to certify the adequacy of internal controls. For a financial firm, that has to include risk controls, which were the big point of failure in the crisis and with MF Global. And the beauty of Sarbox is the criminal provisions track the civil, so if a prosecutor were to prevail in a civil suit and thought it had enough dirt to pass the “reasonable doubt” threshold, it could file the related criminal suit. Knowing violations of Sarbanes Oxley certifications are subject to up to five years in jail; willful violations, up to twenty years. To my knowledge, only one executive has faced charges under Sarbox: HealthSouth’s Robert Scrushy. He won that case, but as someone who followed it off and on in the Birmingham press, it is not a stretch to argue that Scrushy had a position in the Birmingham area that would make him more difficult to prosecute than most CEOs. And it it also pretty typical for it to take a while to perfect cases when using new legal arguments, so losing an early case or two is often part of the learning process. So a “know nothing” argument would not only be useless in defending against Sarbox charges, it might actually be damaging (“How can you say you know nothing about operations yet sign that certification?”). Note that for financial statements, the usual approach is to shed liability by relying on auditors. But there are no comparable players in the risk modeling/control world. The banks are typically on the bleeding edge in some areas, which often include very profitable new strategies, which works against third party validation.

There were some other oddities in the Corzine testimony. Remarkably, he insists the firm got to be less risky on his watch because its gearing fell from over 37 to one to 30 to one. Immediately after that, however, he describes the repo to maturity trades in some detail, and points out, as others have, that they were treated as off balance sheet for accounting purposes. Since these trades were clearly NOT off balance sheet from an economic standpoint, any discussion of the firm’s true economic risk should include the repo to maturity transactions. It would clearly lead to a higher level of leverage than Corzine presented in his testimony, and likely higher than under the predecessor regime...Finally, it appears that Corzine, thanks to the advice of the Boston Consulting Group, was in the process of trying to become the next Bear or Lehman: a subscale full service investment bank, presumably with a strength in commodities...The Bear/Lehman movies ended badly for a simple reason: if you are going to compete directly with the big boys, you need roughly 90% of their infrastructure. The business has large minimum scale requirements: back office, computers, broad product mix to serve corporate and institutional clients, presence in major geographies, you might be able to get away with not being in certain secondary locations. Yet you only have 60% to 75% of their volume. That gives you inferior economics, which in turn puts you at a disadvantage in attracting and retaining the dreaded “talent.” Sadly, many producers do have leverage, in the sense that they can take their franchise to another full service firm. If the heads of business units leave and take their top two subordinates with them, the hole is very difficult to plug short term and will have a detrimental impact on related operations...So what do firms in those positions do? They take on outside risks in the hopes of producing higher returns than the industry leaders, so as to make them more attractive to industry professionals and to help them over time reduce the scale gap with the leaders. But the network effects (primarily, information advantages) of being a top player are so large that even superior risk taking acumen (or just dumb luck) are almost certain to be insufficient to overcome the advantages of the very top firms.

So in other words, MF Global blowing up by taking too much risk was not an accident...

Printer Friendly | Permalink | Reply | Top
  -Weekend Economists Go for the Gold December 9-11, 2011 Demeter  Dec-09-11 10:15 PM   #0 
  - ANOTHER WEEKEND WITHOUT A BANK FAILURE  Demeter   Dec-09-11 10:26 PM   #1 
  - Piketty, Saez and Stantcheva: Taxing the 1% – Why the Top Tax Rate Could be Over 80%  Demeter   Dec-09-11 10:36 PM   #2 
  - Finally, Higher Taxes for the 1% — Is Occupy Behind Governors' Moves to Make the Wealthy Pay Their S  Demeter   Dec-10-11 12:34 PM   #76 
  - More fun to come...see you tomorrow!  Demeter   Dec-09-11 10:37 PM   #3 
  - 5th rec  some guy   Dec-10-11 12:15 AM   #4 
  - Life is risky  Demeter   Dec-10-11 05:34 AM   #6 
  - Down to the wire now in Europe.  girl gone mad   Dec-10-11 12:20 AM   #5 
  - Depression and war  DemReadingDU   Dec-10-11 06:35 AM   #17 
  - The MFGlobal Subthread  Demeter   Dec-10-11 05:37 AM   #7 
  - CFTC Issues A Clear Statement: MF Global Customers Have Priority In This Bankruptcy  Demeter   Dec-10-11 05:44 AM   #8 
  - Testimony: U.S. House of Reps, Committee on Agriculture, Washington, DC by Commissioner Jill E. Somm  Demeter   Dec-10-11 05:47 AM   #9 
  - Trades Are Linked to Missing MF Global Funds  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:47 AM   #39 
  - That would be good news  DemReadingDU   Dec-10-11 07:54 AM   #45 
  - Corzine’s Know-Nothing MF Global Defense  Demeter   Dec-10-11 05:56 AM   #10 
  - On Corzine - MFG in the fog of war BRUCE KRASTING  Demeter   Dec-10-11 06:05 AM   #11 
     - Incarcerate Corzine By Eric Fry  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:13 AM   #26 
  - Suppose MFG had been a Chinese firm that disappeared client money?  MannyGoldstein   Dec-10-11 07:26 AM   #32 
     - Don't the Chinese commit suicide? n/t  DemReadingDU   Dec-10-11 07:56 AM   #46 
        - With assistance from the authorities  Demeter   Dec-10-11 08:31 AM   #58 
        - That's the Japanese  Tansy_Gold   Dec-10-11 08:33 AM   #60 
  - Americans Got Much Poorer Last Quarter By CATHERINE RAMPELL  Demeter   Dec-10-11 06:08 AM   #12 
  - All the G.O.P.’s Gekkos By PAUL KRUGMAN  Demeter   Dec-10-11 06:13 AM   #13 
  - Santorum: We Don’t Need Food Stamps Because Obesity Rates Are So High  Demeter   Dec-10-11 06:16 AM   #14 
  - oops  Demeter   Dec-10-11 06:18 AM   #15 
  - LOL, I read the subject as obesity in rats  DemReadingDU   Dec-10-11 06:39 AM   #18 
  - Land of the Free, Home of the Hungry  Demeter   Dec-10-11 08:08 AM   #49 
  - The EU, ECB, Eurozone Roundup  Demeter   Dec-10-11 06:19 AM   #16 
  - The only real solution to the European debt crisis is credit writedowns  Demeter   Dec-10-11 06:48 AM   #20 
  - Market rout as ECB dashes bond hopes  Demeter   Dec-10-11 06:53 AM   #21 
     - Engineering the Eurozone Collapse - F. William Engdahl on GRTV  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:27 AM   #33 
  - EU Leaders Drop Demands for Investor Write-Offs  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:30 AM   #34 
  - Latest Plan for Europe Fails to Wow Investors  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:36 AM   #35 
     - Eurocrisis Solutions For Whom?  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:42 AM   #37 
  - European CEOs Move Cash to Germany In Case of Euro Breakup  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:57 AM   #47 
  - The Euro: That Procrustean Bed... By Adrian Salbuchi  Demeter   Dec-10-11 08:48 AM   #64 
  - morning to one and all  xchrom   Dec-10-11 06:46 AM   #19 
  - Wally Philosophy  Demeter   Dec-10-11 06:56 AM   #22 
  - VS CORPORATE PHILOSOPHY  Demeter   Dec-11-11 07:52 AM   #95 
  - Got my R in - I am totally out of the loop otherwise - meanwhile, here in NY...  bread_and_roses   Dec-10-11 07:02 AM   #23 
  - Hope you get a break  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:19 AM   #28 
  - TY on tow/toe  bread_and_roses   Dec-10-11 07:26 AM   #31 
  - hi  some guy   Dec-11-11 12:16 AM   #86 
  - A delightful distraction  Tansy_Gold   Dec-10-11 07:02 AM   #24 
  - Those are so cool!  DemReadingDU   Dec-10-11 07:04 AM   #25 
  - Somebody's got way too much free time  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:24 AM   #30 
  - I love this stuff and enjoy passing it on  Tansy_Gold   Dec-10-11 08:25 AM   #55 
     - You almost make me want to pierce my ears  Demeter   Dec-10-11 08:30 AM   #57 
     - I've reached an age where I do it for me, not for what I think  Tansy_Gold   Dec-10-11 08:38 AM   #63 
     - Patterns on Etsy  DemReadingDU   Dec-10-11 09:25 AM   #67 
  - Vampire calamari.  Fuddnik   Dec-10-11 07:15 AM   #27 
  - Any Way I Can Get It!  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:21 AM   #29 
  - DU3 - Thoughts on what is going to happen with the SMW and WEE  DemReadingDU   Dec-10-11 07:50 AM   #41 
  - now i want calamari. nt  xchrom   Dec-10-11 07:42 AM   #36 
     - I'd settle for breakfast  Demeter   Dec-10-11 08:12 AM   #51 
        - i looked at the clock last night -- it was dark and i was getting sleepy --  xchrom   Dec-10-11 08:29 AM   #56 
           - I'm okay--it was the other players  Demeter   Dec-10-11 08:32 AM   #59 
              - that's good. nt  xchrom   Dec-10-11 08:37 AM   #62 
  - Analysis - Sarkozy, Draghi winners in EU rift  xchrom   Dec-10-11 07:43 AM   #38 
  - They are captains on a sinking ship  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:54 AM   #44 
     - I've been reading - you've been posting - tons of articles  xchrom   Dec-10-11 08:04 AM   #48 
        - I think they are all still trying to screw each other  Demeter   Dec-10-11 08:10 AM   #50 
           - wow -- that hadn't occured to me -- and i think you might very well on to something.  xchrom   Dec-10-11 08:17 AM   #52 
  - The Occupation Continues to Diversify  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:50 AM   #40 
  - JP Morgan Chase Mic Checked at Princeton Recruiting  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:52 AM   #42 
  - Goldman Sachs Anti-Recruitment Session at Princeton University  Demeter   Dec-10-11 07:53 AM   #43 
  - Your Money or Your Life: Humanity Nears a Deadline to Decide Which it Will Surrender  Demeter   Dec-10-11 08:18 AM   #53 
  - "Your money or your life"  Demeter   Dec-10-11 08:24 AM   #54 
  - needs a link  some guy   Dec-10-11 01:56 PM   #78 
     - Thanks!  Demeter   Dec-10-11 05:31 PM   #82 
  - An Idiot’s Overview Of Why Western Capitalism Is Crashing By Alan Hart  Demeter   Dec-10-11 08:37 AM   #61 
  - I didn't like this piece at all.  some guy   Dec-10-11 02:27 PM   #79 
     - Well, If you consider that one worker can only do so much  Demeter   Dec-10-11 05:34 PM   #83 
        - one investor.  some guy   Dec-10-11 09:39 PM   #85 
           - I'm with you, some guy  Tansy_Gold   Dec-11-11 11:28 AM   #104 
              - That's why and how you'll get my vote for President.  some guy   Dec-11-11 01:22 PM   #109 
  - "Dog whistle": economics’ code words  Demeter   Dec-10-11 09:01 AM   #65 
  - I REALLY need some breakfast  Demeter   Dec-10-11 09:07 AM   #66 
  - have a good breakfast! -- i might go get some biscuits and gravy.  xchrom   Dec-10-11 09:27 AM   #68 
  - I just had a breakfast that would make Ronald McDonald proud.  Fuddnik   Dec-10-11 10:56 AM   #72 
  - European Council Unity dearly bought  xchrom   Dec-10-11 09:29 AM   #69 
  - Max Keiser-Crazy David Cameron SUICIDAL with knife in a Euro gunfight!!!!!  Demeter   Dec-10-11 11:34 AM   #73 
     - tee-hee -- fingers crossed! nt  xchrom   Dec-10-11 11:42 AM   #74 
     - Oh, that was good.  Prometheus Bound   Dec-10-11 03:59 PM   #80 
  - I feel so fucking lost these days. eom.  Hotler   Dec-10-11 10:18 AM   #70 
  - We all found each other  Demeter   Dec-10-11 12:32 PM   #75 
  - I'm lost, I can't find anything/anyone in DU3  DemReadingDU   Dec-11-11 06:49 AM   #87 
  - I can't either! ARGH!  Tansy_Gold   Dec-11-11 08:51 AM   #98 
  - Thank you. n/t  Hotler   Dec-11-11 09:34 AM   #99 
  - Take heart, dear friend  Tansy_Gold   Dec-10-11 01:41 PM   #77 
  - Me too  DemReadingDU   Dec-10-11 04:30 PM   #81 
     - Some who were made to feel unwelcome in the shade  Tansy_Gold   Dec-10-11 09:16 PM   #84 
  - India inches closer to crisis as rupee retreats  xchrom   Dec-10-11 10:20 AM   #71 
  - I Said No to My Student Loan: One Borrower's Decision to Stop Paying  Demeter   Dec-11-11 07:16 AM   #88 
  - How the Occupy Movement Helped Americans Move Beyond Denial and Depression to Action  Demeter   Dec-11-11 07:18 AM   #89 
  - Using Debt to Crush Democracy: How Financiers Are Waging Warfare Against Nations  Demeter   Dec-11-11 07:21 AM   #90 
  - 10 Fun Facts About the Top 1 Percent  Demeter   Dec-11-11 07:43 AM   #91 
  - 6 Members of Walton Family Have More Money Than 30% of Americans  Demeter   Dec-11-11 07:47 AM   #93 
     - Obama: jobless rate may fall to 8% by election  Demeter   Dec-11-11 07:49 AM   #94 
  - Michael Moore: 5 Ways for OWS to Keep Sticking it to Capitalist Crooks as Winter Comes  Demeter   Dec-11-11 07:46 AM   #92 
  - How Goldman Sachs and Other Companies Exploit Port Truck Drivers  Demeter   Dec-11-11 07:58 AM   #96 
  - Negative Equity: How Many Loans are Underwater in Your State?  Demeter   Dec-11-11 08:01 AM   #97 
  - If I lose track of you guys in DU3......  Hotler   Dec-11-11 09:48 AM   #100 
  - Editorials & Other Articles is going to be were in DU3 ? n/t  Hotler   Dec-11-11 09:50 AM   #101 
  - I reckon that would be the "Good Reads (Forum)"  Ghost Dog   Dec-11-11 10:39 AM   #102 
  - SMW just got locked out of Late Breaking  InkAddict   Dec-11-11 11:07 AM   #103 
  - I saw that. :grrrrr:  Tansy_Gold   Dec-11-11 11:33 AM   #105 
     - I don't like the idea of "host". It's just a way for..  Hotler   Dec-11-11 12:42 PM   #108 
  - I am going to move the Subject of this thread over to the DU3 E&E - Economy Group.  Hugin   Dec-11-11 11:52 AM   #106 
     - Thanks!  DemReadingDU   Dec-11-11 12:13 PM   #107 
        - Just walking through the graveyard here.  Fuddnik   Dec-11-11 03:58 PM   #110 
           - Think  Ghost Dog   Dec-11-11 04:30 PM   #111 
              - Well done. Thank you. eom.  Hotler   Dec-11-11 05:09 PM   #112 

Home » Discuss » Editorials & Other Articles Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators

Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC