You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login

Reply #60: The Canadian ‘good banks’ myth [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Editorials & Other Articles Donate to DU
Demeter Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Sat Jun-05-10 10:24 AM
Response to Reply #52
60. The Canadian ‘good banks’ myth /

The sorry spectacle of Conservative cabinet ministers flying around the world defending banks from a tax to cover their next, inevitable, meltdown is bad enough. What is perhaps worse is that it is being largely justified by the perpetuation of the myth that Canada did not have to bail out its banks.


We are, according to the IMF, actually the third worst of the G7 countries, behind the US and Britain, in terms of financial stabilization costs.

First, we put up $70 billion to buy up iffy mortgages from the big five banks, through the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation, taking them off the banks’ balance sheets. That is almost the exact equivalent the US bailout – it spent ten times as much, $700 billion, and its economy is about 10 times as large.

Secondly, the Harper government established a fund of $200 billion to backstop the banks – money they could borrow if they needed it. The government had to borrow billions – mostly from the banks! – to do it. It’s euphemistically called the Emergency Financing Framework – implying that our impeccable banks might actually face an emergency. It is effectively a line of low-interest credit and while it has not all been accessed, it’s there to be used. Could it help explain why credit has not dried up here as much as it has in the US?

Third, the government now insures 100% of virtually all mortgages through CMHC eliminating risk for the banks – and opening the door to the ridiculous flood of housing loans we have seen over the past few years. The result: housing has become unaffordable for tens of thousands of Canadians and new rental housing has dried up.

Why all this extraordinary effort?

If Canadian banks are such paragons of conservative virtue and prudent behaviour why did the federal government have to relieve them of mortgages that, presumably, were all carefully vetted and the borrowers scrutinized?

And why is Mr Flaherty not making any connection between the growing housing bubble (which he now reluctantly acknowledges) and the banks which lend virtually all the money (backed by CMHC) that is growing that bubble?

One of the reasons that Canadians (and international commentators, other finance ministers and global financial institutions) buy this Canadian banking fairy tale is the way the government accounts for the money borrowed to support the banks.

As Bruce Campbell of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives explained in 2009:

“These measures are considered ‘non-budgetary’ or ‘off book.’ They do not show up as expenditures, which increase the federal deficit and debt. Rather, they appear on the books of CMHC and the Bank of Canada. But they have increased the government’s borrowing from $13.6 billion in 2007-08 to $89.5 billion in 2008-09, or double the fiscal deficit now projected for 2009.”

Not only has the Harper government felt it necessary to prop up Canadian banks it was this same government which created financial system risk in the first place. In 2007 the Harper government allowed US competition into Canada which prompted the CMHC to dramatically change its rules in order to compete: it dropped the down payment requirement to zero per cent and extended the amortization period to 40 years. In August 2008 Flaherty moderated those rules in response to the US mortgage meltdown. CMHC then “securitized” an increasing number of its loans into bond-like investments (if you have a typical Canadian mutual fund, you’ve got some.)

At the end of 2007 there were $138 billion in securitized pools outstanding and guaranteed by CMHC –17.8 per cent of all outstanding mortgages. By June 30, 2009, that figure was $290 billion and by the end of 2010 it was $500 billion.

In an effort to prop up the real estate market in 2008 (when affordability nose-dived), the Harper government directed the CMHC to approve as many high-risk borrowers as possible to keep credit flowing. CMHC described these risky loans as “high ratio homeowner units approved to address less-served markets and/or to serve specific government priorities.” The approval rate for these risky loans went from 33 per cent in 2007 to 42 per cent in 2008. By mid-2007, average equity as a share of home value was down to six per cent — from 48 per cent in 2003. At the peak of the U.S. housing bubble, just before it burst, house prices were five times the average American income; in Canada in late 2009 that ratio was 7.4:1 — almost 50 per cent higher.

While it was CMHC that insured these loans it was still the banks that put up the money. And they knew they were effectively sub-prime. How do we know? Because they avoided direct risk like the plague - in the two years from the beginning of 2007 to January 2009, the banks themselves took on virtually no new risk. According to CMHC numbers Canadian banks increased their total mortgage credit outstanding by only 0.01 per cent. But they were happy to put Canadian taxpayers at risk by lending to high-risk borrowers knowing their money was protected by CMHC.

Conservative? Prudent? Responsible? In a pig’s eye.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
  -That Was a Weekend That Was! June 4-6, 2010 Demeter  Jun-04-10 06:53 PM   #0 
  - First Rec!  Tansy_Gold   Jun-04-10 06:54 PM   #1 
  - Congrats! Tansy, I KNOW You could do a LOT Better in the Oval Office  Demeter   Jun-04-10 06:59 PM   #3 
  - I second that!  Roland99   Jun-04-10 07:27 PM   #8 
     - Third!  ozymandius   Jun-04-10 07:44 PM   #14 
  - Perfect Theme Song  Demeter   Jun-04-10 09:02 PM   #35 
  - Three Banks Down and the Night Is Young!  Demeter   Jun-04-10 06:58 PM   #2 
  - On A Personal Note  Demeter   Jun-04-10 07:06 PM   #4 
  - Wheeeee!  DemReadingDU   Jun-04-10 08:32 PM   #32 
  - WHILE LAST WEEK: Four more Ga. banks get consent orders  Demeter   Jun-04-10 09:08 PM   #38 
  - Greece to Sell Assets to Help Pay Down Deficit  Demeter   Jun-04-10 07:17 PM   #5 
  - Ancient Greek Tragedy  Demeter   Jun-04-10 07:36 PM   #11 
  - Deleted message  Name removed   Jun-04-10 07:19 PM   #6 
  - A Scandal Is Coming. Eventually.  Demeter   Jun-04-10 07:24 PM   #7 
  - AND VOILA! GOP wants Justice probe of White House dealmaking  Demeter   Jun-05-10 02:47 PM   #94 
  - How to Blame Obama for the Gulf Spill  Demeter   Jun-04-10 07:27 PM   #9 
  - Oliphant's View  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:28 PM   #31 
  - Yes, Obama Is 'Engaged' – in a Colossal Crime By Glen Ford  Demeter   Jun-04-10 09:06 PM   #37 
  - Spain's Dropout Generation  Demeter   Jun-04-10 07:32 PM   #10 
  - Salgado’s ‘Nightmares’ Over as Spain Tackles Banks, Labor Rules  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:15 PM   #25 
  - THE OIL BIDNESS  Demeter   Jun-04-10 07:43 PM   #12 
  - US House votes quadrupling of per-barrel oil tax  Demeter   Jun-04-10 07:49 PM   #15 
  - The cost effects of the tax will depend on which oil transaction is taxed.  ozymandius   Jun-04-10 08:01 PM   #16 
  - BP's Credit Rating Buckles  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:23 PM   #29 
  - FUgly Day  ozymandius   Jun-04-10 07:43 PM   #13 
  - Dogbert's "Timely" Advice  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:02 PM   #17 
  - I have seen that happen.  ozymandius   Jun-04-10 08:07 PM   #20 
  - THE BANKSTERS  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:05 PM   #18 
  - JP Morgan fined £33.3m for client funds error  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:06 PM   #19 
  - Because there is no Eighth Amendment in Britain - the judge should get creative.  ozymandius   Jun-04-10 08:11 PM   #23 
  - Fed Chief Urges Banks to Do More for Small Business  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:08 PM   #21 
  - G-20 Central Banks Delay Exit on Euro Debt Woes (Update1)  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:09 PM   #22 
  - U.S. to Push Europe on Stress Tests  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:13 PM   #24 
  - spew  Po_d Mainiac   Jun-04-10 09:38 PM   #42 
  - ECB's Weber, Draghi Urge Quick End to Bond Purchases (Update1)  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:16 PM   #26 
  - S.E.C. Is Said to Seek to Bar Wall St. Financier  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:17 PM   #27 
  - Would Washington Let J.P. Morgan, Citi, BofA or Wells Fargo Fail?  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:19 PM   #28 
  - Wall Street's War By Matt Taibbi  Demeter   Jun-04-10 09:18 PM   #40 
  - Try this link >>>>  Roland99   Jun-05-10 08:43 AM   #46 
  - Marc Faber: "The Banks Are Gone" Video  Demeter   Jun-06-10 06:50 AM   #111 
  - Summer of Full Flights and High Fares  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:26 PM   #30 
  - Europe is Headed For a Mini-depression By Mike Whitney  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:35 PM   #33 
  - Merkel's Savage Blitz through Euroland By Mike Whitney  Demeter   Jun-06-10 10:10 AM   #116 
  - Real People v. Corporate “People”: The Fight Is On  Demeter   Jun-04-10 08:37 PM   #34 
  - A Plague Upon The World: The USA is a "Failed State" By Dr. Paul Craig Roberts  Demeter   Jun-04-10 09:11 PM   #39 
  - Let the Rioting Begin! I'm Off to Bed.  Demeter   Jun-04-10 09:03 PM   #36 
  - .  JTFrog   Jun-04-10 09:24 PM   #41 
  - Deleted message  Name removed   Jun-04-10 09:41 PM   #43 
  - Thanks to the moderators who saw reason.  ozymandius   Jun-05-10 07:59 AM   #44 
  - +1  Roland99   Jun-05-10 08:38 AM   #45 
  - Sorry I missed the excitement.  Hugin   Jun-05-10 09:05 AM   #47 
  - +2  Dr.Phool   Jun-05-10 09:09 AM   #48 
  - Amen. Well said.  Lochloosa   Jun-05-10 09:37 AM   #49 
  - Well, see, that's where you made your fundamental mistake  Tansy_Gold   Jun-05-10 09:46 AM   #50 
     - Thanks Tansy  Lochloosa   Jun-05-10 09:50 AM   #51 
  - I'm Impressed, Ozy!  Demeter   Jun-05-10 02:29 PM   #90 
     - You're welcome, Demeter.  ozymandius   Jun-06-10 06:16 AM   #104 
        - A Conspiracy, Eh?  Demeter   Jun-06-10 06:25 AM   #106 
        - Thanks, Ozy, for letting us know  Tansy_Gold   Jun-06-10 01:11 PM   #120 
  - Deleted message  Name removed   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #52 
  - Before We Were So Rudely Interrupted...  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #53 
  - Three American cities on the brink of broke  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #54 
  - Debt-induced stress continues for many Americans  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #68 
  - American Denial: Living in a Can’t-Do Nation By Tom Engelhardt  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #69 
  - Jefferson County, AL -- Matt Taibi revisited  Tansy_Gold   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #82 
  - The World Teeters on the Brink of a New Age of Rage By Simon Schama  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #55 
  - Europe faces summer of intermittent unrest  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #58 
  - Eurozone unemployment rate rises  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #66 
  - French protest retirement age plan  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #73 
  - Spain approves austerity measures  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #74 
  - Hungary's debt "crisis"  Turbineguy   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #56 
  - "The Center Cannot Hold: Rekindling the Radical Imagination" By Noam Chomsky  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #57 
  - Thanks for the new thread!  DemReadingDU   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #59 
  - The Canadian ‘good banks’ myth  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #60 
  - When Rivers Flow Upstream: International Capital Movements in the Era of Globalization  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #61 
  - Dollar Primed for Collapse by End June: Charts By: Daryl Guppy | CNBC Contributor  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #62 
  - Is the U.S. Government Planning War to Quell the Tide of Economic Unrest? By Gary D. Barnett  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #63 
  - Hi Demeter! Thanks for reposting  ixion   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #64 
  - I Am the Very Model of a Stubborn Pollack  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #65 
     - WTF happened?  Dr.Phool   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #83 
     - All I can tell you is this  Tansy_Gold   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #84 
        - See my post #104 for additional information. n/t  ozymandius   Jun-06-10 06:21 AM   #105 
     - I have no doubt.  ixion   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #85 
  - BP hit by avalanche of compensation claims over US oil spill  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #67 
  - Weekend Economists was locked?  Lochloosa   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #70 
  - It's Right Here  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #71 
  - Interesting reading. The truth hurts.  Lochloosa   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #77 
     - The truth hurts, but it also sets us free  Tansy_Gold   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #80 
  - not anymore  ozymandius   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #86 
     - That'll learn 'em! Now they got TWO of us to deal with! ;-)  Tansy_Gold   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #88 
        - EEEK! A MOUSE!!!  Demeter   Jun-05-10 02:34 PM   #91 
           - (And a Disney one at that!) ;-)  Tansy_Gold   Jun-05-10 03:15 PM   #95 
  - US money supply plunges at 1930s pace as Obama eyes fresh stimulus  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #72 
  - Banks Trim Debt, Obscuring Risks  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #75 
  - The Cult of Subprime Central Bankers By Dean Baker  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #76 
  - The American Century Is So Over  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #78 
  - Well, I'm Off to a Funeral (Memorial Service)  Demeter   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #79 
  - Give 'em hell, Demeter!  hamerfan   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #81 
  - Encore.  jotsy   Jun-05-10 10:24 AM   #87 
  - K&R! K&R!  bread_and_roses   Jun-05-10 10:56 AM   #89 
  - Many Blessings on your holy day!  Demeter   Jun-05-10 02:38 PM   #92 
  - Growing ranks of long-term jobless face tough odds  Demeter   Jun-05-10 02:44 PM   #93 
  - Did you know that today is Saturday?  Demeter   Jun-05-10 06:20 PM   #96 
  - Like, back to the future  DemReadingDU   Jun-05-10 07:23 PM   #97 
     - Can't take Credit for that  Demeter   Jun-05-10 07:34 PM   #98 
        - As someone, I can't remember who, used to say. . . .  Tansy_Gold   Jun-05-10 07:51 PM   #99 
  - Cobra payment aid appears likely to end  Demeter   Jun-06-10 02:48 AM   #100 
  - What a night!  Demeter   Jun-06-10 02:51 AM   #101 
  - You must be exhausted.  ozymandius   Jun-06-10 06:48 AM   #109 
     - At least it stopped raining for a bit  Demeter   Jun-06-10 06:57 AM   #113 
  - Notable Quote  Demeter   Jun-06-10 02:56 AM   #102 
  - "You forgot The Philippines!"  ozymandius   Jun-06-10 06:55 AM   #112 
  - Kick and Rec.  Dr.Phool   Jun-06-10 05:28 AM   #103 
  - The Death of Party by David Glenn Cox  ozymandius   Jun-06-10 06:34 AM   #107 
  - Food stamp fraud fight heats up in Michigan  Demeter   Jun-06-10 06:46 AM   #108 
  - Are You Unemployed Because You Are Lazy? By Dave Johnson  Demeter   Jun-06-10 06:49 AM   #110 
  - "The Time We Have Is Growing Short"  ozymandius   Jun-06-10 09:21 AM   #114 
  - fascinating read. this is another WE to bookmark (n't)  bread_and_roses   Jun-06-10 06:02 PM   #122 
  - Corporations Profit from Permanent War By Bill Quigley  Demeter   Jun-06-10 10:03 AM   #115 
  - The Greeks Get It By Chris Hedges  Demeter   Jun-06-10 10:16 AM   #117 
  - That's a really good article  bread_and_roses   Jun-06-10 05:55 PM   #121 
  - STOLEN FROM CAPT. JACK: Judge James L. Shumate Orders Halt to Bank of America Foreclosures in Utah  Demeter   Jun-06-10 11:40 AM   #118 
  - Grayson's Smart Calculus Makes War Cost Real for Taxpayers By John Nichols  Demeter   Jun-06-10 11:44 AM   #119 
  - I'm wrapping it up here--but feel free to go on  Demeter   Jun-06-10 06:06 PM   #123 
     - This was a WEE to remember.  ozymandius   Jun-06-10 07:29 PM   #124 
        - .  Tansy_Gold   Jun-06-10 10:23 PM   #125 

Home » Discuss » Editorials & Other Articles Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators

Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC