You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login
Google

Reply #22: What Can Save the Euro? Joseph E. Stiglitz [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
Home » Discuss » Latest Breaking News Donate to DU
Demeter Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Thu Dec-08-11 07:11 AM
Response to Reply #4
22. What Can Save the Euro? Joseph E. Stiglitz
http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/stiglitz146...

Just when it seemed that things couldnt get worse, it appears that they have. Even some of the ostensibly responsible members of the eurozone are facing higher interest rates. Economists on both sides of the Atlantic are now discussing not just whether the euro will survive, but how to ensure that its demise causes the least turmoil possible. It is increasingly evident that Europes political leaders, for all their commitment to the euros survival, do not have a good grasp of what is required to make the single currency work. The prevailing view when the euro was established was that all that was required was fiscal discipline no countrys fiscal deficit or public debt, relative to GDP, should be too large. But Ireland and Spain had budget surpluses and low debt before the crisis, which quickly turned into large deficits and high debt. So now European leaders say that it is the current-account deficits of the eurozones member countries that must be kept in check. In that case, it seems curious that, as the crisis continues, the safe haven for global investors is the United States, which has had an enormous current-account deficit for years. So, how will the European Union distinguish between good current-account deficits a government creates a favorable business climate, generating inflows of foreign direct investment and bad current-account deficits? Preventing bad current-account deficits would require far greater intervention in the private sector than the neoliberal and single-market doctrines that were fashionable at the euros founding would imply.

In Spain, for example, money flowed into the private sector from private banks. Should such irrational exuberance force the government, willy-nilly, to curtail public investment? Does this mean that government must decide which capital flows say into real-estate investment, for example are bad, and so must be taxed or otherwise curbed? To me, this makes sense, but such policies should be anathema to the EUs free-market advocates. The quest for a clear, simple answer recalls the discussions that have followed financial crises around the world. After each crisis, an explanation emerges, which the next crisis shows to be wrong, or at least inadequate. The 1980s Latin American crisis was caused by excessive borrowing; but that could not explain Mexicos 1994 crisis, so it was attributed to under-saving. Then came East Asia, which had high savings rates, so the new explanation was governance. But this, too, made little sense, given that the Scandinavian countries which have the most transparent governance in the world had suffered a crisis a few years earlier.

There is, interestingly, a common thread running through all of these cases, as well as the 2008 crisis: financial sectors behaved badly and failed to assess creditworthiness and manage risk as they were supposed to do. These problems will occur with or without the euro. But the euro has made it more difficult for governments to respond. And the problem is not just that the euro took away two key tools for adjustment the interest rate and the exchange rate and put nothing in their place, or that the European Central Banks mandate is to focus on inflation, whereas todays challenges are unemployment, growth, and financial stability. Without a common fiscal authority, the single market opened the way to tax competition a race to the bottom to attract investment and boost output that could be freely sold throughout the EU. Moreover, free labor mobility means that individuals can choose whether to pay their parents debts: young Irish can simply escape repaying the foolish bank-bailout obligations assumed by their government by leaving the country. Of course, migration is supposed to be good, as it reallocates labor to where its return is highest. But this kind of migration actually undermines productivity.

Migration is, of course, part of the adjustment mechanism that makes America work as a single market with a single currency. Even more important is the federal governments role in helping states that face, say, high unemployment, by allocating additional tax revenue to them the so-called transfer union so loathed by many Germans...But the US is also willing to accept the depopulation of entire states that cannot compete. (Some point out that this means that Americas corporations can buy senators from such states at a lower price.) But are European countries with lagging productivity willing to accept depopulation? Alternatively, are they willing to face the pain of internal devaluation, a process that failed under the gold standard and is failing under the euro?



************************************************************************

Joseph E. Stiglitz is University Professor at Columbia University, a Nobel laureate in economics, and the author of Freefall: Free Markets and the Sinking of the Global Economy.
Printer Friendly | Permalink | Reply | Top
 
  -STOCK MARKET WATCH, Thursday, December 8, 2011 Pale Blue Dot  Dec-08-11 06:05 AM   #0 
  - Today's Reports  Pale Blue Dot   Dec-08-11 06:06 AM   #1 
  - Oil inches to near $102 ahead of EU debt summit  Pale Blue Dot   Dec-08-11 06:07 AM   #2 
  - U.S. Stock Futures Decline as Investors Await ECB Interest-Rate Decision  Pale Blue Dot   Dec-08-11 06:08 AM   #3 
  - Oh, Yeah! A Quarter % Will Fix EVERYTHING!  Demeter   Dec-08-11 06:58 AM   #8 
  - EU "Summit Optimism" (Reuters)  Ghost Dog   Dec-08-11 06:23 AM   #4 
  - ECB cuts rates to record low on recession fears  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 07:01 AM   #11 
  - What Can Save the Euro? Joseph E. Stiglitz  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:11 AM   #22 
     - What can save the Euro? Nothing.  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 08:06 AM   #52 
        - Nor Should It Be Saved, IMO  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:21 AM   #61 
  - here we are -- it's morning again  xchrom   Dec-08-11 06:51 AM   #5 
  - Morning, X  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:00 AM   #10 
     - i knew this was one of your paper days -- and that your weather is  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:05 AM   #17 
        - Two concerts Sunday  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:32 AM   #35 
           - i love it! my partner and i used to go to  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:45 AM   #40 
  - europe: Chancellor Merkel's Difficult Battle in Brussels  xchrom   Dec-08-11 06:55 AM   #6 
  - Iceland's Toxic Legacy Mountains of Debt Temper Hopes despite Recovery  xchrom   Dec-08-11 06:56 AM   #7 
  - ECB Cuts Key Rate to 1%, May Dig Into Toolbox  xchrom   Dec-08-11 06:59 AM   #9 
  - "...said three euro-area officials with knowledge of the deliberations"  Ghost Dog   Dec-08-11 07:02 AM   #13 
  - i always think that's what 'tool box' refers to. nt  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:03 AM   #15 
  - And handing it out cost-free to the banksters, too!  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:04 AM   #16 
  - The FED will probably do the same thing, to cut the rate  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 07:09 AM   #20 
     - SPEAKING OF THE FED: Fed may give loans to IMF to help euro zone  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:13 AM   #23 
     - Kiss that money goodbye  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 07:23 AM   #27 
     - Can rates...  AnneD   Dec-08-11 12:00 PM   #87 
        - Sure they can.  Fuddnik   Dec-08-11 12:39 PM   #90 
  - ECB: Speculators Given Pacifier and Now a Bit Less Sated  Ghost Dog   Dec-08-11 08:23 AM   #64 
  - Hilliary Clinton has said she's hopeful  Ghost Dog   Dec-08-11 07:13 AM   #24 
  - So the 'meat' must be the treaties? Nt  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:27 AM   #29 
  - ECB doused hopes  Ghost Dog   Dec-08-11 03:04 PM   #91 
  - Deutsche Bank, BNP Among Lenders That May Be Cut by S&P Amid Europe Review  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:01 AM   #12 
  - Gazprom Stalls on RWE Talks as Germany Falters  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:07 AM   #19 
  - Jim Willie: The Public Will Not Wake Up Until At Least One Million Private Accounts Are Stolen  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:02 AM   #14 
  - It's so fucked up. eom.  Hotler   Dec-08-11 08:02 AM   #48 
  - Yeh really.  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 08:04 AM   #50 
  - When they wake up, it will be too late to save their money  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 08:02 AM   #49 
  - Interesting thread posted by madfloridian  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 07:07 AM   #18 
  - She see's the next stop for this bus.  Fuddnik   Dec-08-11 08:22 AM   #63 
     - Think of all the time that will free up, though  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:25 AM   #67 
     - I was thinking about that just last night, Fudd.  Tansy_Gold   Dec-08-11 09:23 AM   #82 
     - I recommend we have a contact point.....  AnneD   Dec-08-11 12:08 PM   #89 
        - I'm registerd under an elm tree  Demeter   Dec-08-11 03:40 PM   #92 
           - me too  DemReadingDU   Dec-09-11 05:19 AM   #96 
              - I am registered there too....  AnneD   Dec-09-11 09:21 AM   #97 
  - Wheat Prices Shredded With Near-Record Crop Boosting Reserves: Commodities  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:10 AM   #21 
  - asia: Poll: Investors Predict China Bank Crisis  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:14 AM   #25 
  - Sino-Forest May Go Private, Seek Merger as Martin Tries to Exit Morass  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:17 AM   #26 
  - Nikkei slips from 4-wk high on pre-settlement profit-taking  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:48 AM   #43 
  - China refutes 'land grab' charges in Africa  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:51 AM   #45 
  - PetroChina finds shale gas reserves  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:26 AM   #28 
  - Let the fracking begin! Nt  xchrom   Dec-08-11 07:28 AM   #32 
  - Jon Corzine To Tesify Today Over MF Global Collapse  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 07:28 AM   #30 
  - Is there an insanity defense?  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:33 AM   #36 
  - He's crazy about money?  Fuddnik   Dec-08-11 07:58 AM   #47 
  - "I like money." - Idiocracy (the movie)  Hugin   Dec-08-11 08:12 AM   #57 
     - You've been there?  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:23 AM   #65 
     - My thumbnail impression of DU3.  Hugin   Dec-08-11 08:39 AM   #69 
        - As far as being on a Jury...  Hugin   Dec-08-11 09:18 AM   #79 
     - Yeppers.  Fuddnik   Dec-08-11 08:24 AM   #66 
  - With all the sinister news about MF Global today, I wonder  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 08:22 AM   #62 
     - He's entered a statement into the record  Demeter   Dec-08-11 03:43 PM   #93 
        - Corzine Deflects Blame For MF Global's Fall  Demeter   Dec-08-11 04:34 PM   #94 
  - MAJOR inaccuracy in that  Tansy_Gold   Dec-08-11 11:41 AM   #86 
  - Buffett utility makes solar power move  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:28 AM   #31 
  - ZeroHedge - really, really sinsiter stuff going on with MF Global  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 07:30 AM   #33 
  - That ties in with my post #14  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:36 AM   #37 
  - MF Global and the great Wall St re-hypothecation scandal  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:05 AM   #51 
  - Karl Denninger: MF Global: The SERIOUS Issues Reach Mainstream Media  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 08:12 AM   #56 
  - ZEROHEDGE MONEY QUOTE  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:14 AM   #58 
     - As The Shadow Banking System Imploded In Q2, Bernanke's Choice Has Been Made For Him  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:20 AM   #60 
  - Occupy sets its sights beyond Wall Street  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:30 AM   #34 
  - Hundreds 'occupy' Washington offices demanding stronger social security  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:48 AM   #42 
  - Phil Rockstroh Quotation  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:43 AM   #38 
  - Thought maybe the liquidity lockup was starting yesterday  kickysnana   Dec-08-11 07:44 AM   #39 
  - INGDirect Screwed me on Monday  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:54 AM   #46 
     - Oops  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 08:08 AM   #54 
     - And now that I have a credit union  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:28 AM   #68 
     - It is getting strange.  Fuddnik   Dec-08-11 08:42 AM   #70 
        - Sounds Like it's Time to put the Money in Serta  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:45 AM   #72 
        - That also is a good idea.  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 09:20 AM   #80 
        - That is very odd  DemReadingDU   Dec-08-11 09:17 AM   #77 
           - I can transfer between some accounts, just not that particular account.  Fuddnik   Dec-08-11 09:59 AM   #84 
     - Very interesting.  Hugin   Dec-08-11 08:09 AM   #55 
  - Tony Blair's new 'bank' for super-rich  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:47 AM   #41 
  - RBS - Inside The Bank That Ran Out Of Money VIDEO  Demeter   Dec-08-11 07:51 AM   #44 
  - k&r n/t  Hotler   Dec-08-11 08:06 AM   #53 
  - south asia: Sensex slumps 389 points on growth, euro zone debt concerns  xchrom   Dec-08-11 08:18 AM   #59 
  - ECB unveils new support for banks  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:43 AM   #71 
  - Central Banks Plan for Possible Euro Breakup as Merkel Focuses on Wrong Issues  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:48 AM   #73 
  - Michael Olenick: Bank of America All In Calling Moynihans Bluff to Bankrupt Countrywide  Demeter   Dec-08-11 08:55 AM   #74 
  - HEADLINES AT FINANCIAL TIMES  Demeter   Dec-08-11 09:13 AM   #75 
  - Corzine Rebuffed Internal Warnings on Risks  Demeter   Dec-08-11 09:14 AM   #76 
  - Rutgers University Working Paper : Categorizing the Unemployed by the Impact of the Recession  Demeter   Dec-08-11 09:18 AM   #78 
  - This survey acts like the impact is "over,"  InkAddict   Dec-08-11 06:14 PM   #95 
  - PPT NOT EVEN TRYING!  Demeter   Dec-08-11 09:21 AM   #81 
  - Is Modern Capitalism Sustainable? Kenneth Rogoff  Demeter   Dec-08-11 09:28 AM   #83 
  - Halliburton stock up almost 2% this morning on heavy volume.  Fuddnik   Dec-08-11 10:02 AM   #85 
     - Ojo.  Ghost Dog   Dec-08-11 12:03 PM   #88 
 

Home » Discuss » Latest Breaking News Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators


Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC