You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login
Google

Reply #25: Abandoning a sinking ship? A plan for leaving the euro [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
Home » Discuss » Latest Breaking News Donate to DU
Demeter Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Fri Dec-02-11 07:13 AM
Response to Reply #5
25. Abandoning a sinking ship? A plan for leaving the euro
Edited on Fri Dec-02-11 07:14 AM by Demeter
http://yanisvaroufakis.eu/2011/11/27/abandoning-a-sinki... /

As regulars of this blog know, I am of the view that the eurozones collapse will be a harbinger of a postmodern 1930s. While virulently opposed to the eurozones creation, in its time of crisis I have been campaigning for saving the euro. Of course, as Alain Parguez wrote aptly here, it is impossible to save someone, or something, that does not want to be saved. In this post, while not going back on my personal commitment to keep trying to save a monetary union bent on self-destruction, I shall relate to you an idea on how a peripheral member-state could try to minimise the (huge) socio-economic costs of an exit from the eurozone forced upon it by the latters steady disintegration...The said plan was put together with Ireland in mind. Its authors are Warren Mosler (an investment manager and creator of the mortgage swap and the current Eurofutures swap contract) and Philip Pilkington, a journalist and writer based in Dublin, Ireland. Their starting point is a (perfectly spot on) diagnosis: austerity programs are an abject failure and yet European officials continue to consider them the only game in town. So, we can only conclude at this stage that, given that European officials know that austerity programs do not work, they are pursuing them for political rather than economic reasons.

For reasons that I have also put forward repeatedly, unless overturned, this political project will, perhaps unintentionally, lead to the eurozones collapse. Should a country like Ireland wait until the bitter end or should it prepare for an exit before the final nail has been hammered into the euros coffin? Mosler and Pilkington argue for an exit. But how can Ireland, or for that matter Portugal or Greece or Italy, exit without the sky falling on our heads? Here is what they propose:
1. Upon announcing that the country is leaving the Eurozone, the government of that country would announce that it would be making payments to government employees etc. exclusively in the new currency. Thus the government would stop using the euro as a means of payment.

2. The government would also announce that it would only accept payments of tax in this new currency. This would ensure that the currency was valuable and, at least for a while, in very short supply.
And that is pretty much it. The government spends to provision itself and thereby injects the new currency into the economy while their new taxation policy ensures that it is sought after by economic agents and, thus, valuable. Government spending is thus the spigot through which the government injects the new currency into the economy and taxation is the drain that ensures citizens seek out the new currency.

The idea here is to take a hands off approach. Should the government of a given country announce an exit from the Eurozone and then freeze bank accounts and force conversion there would be chaos. The citizens of the country would run on the banks and desperately try to hold as many euro cash notes as possible in anticipation that they would be more valuable than the new currency...Under the above plan, however, citizens bank accounts would be left alone. It would be up to them to convert their euros into the new currency at a floating exchange rate set by the market. They would, of course, have to seek out the currency any time they have to pay taxes and so would sell goods and services denominated in the new currency. This monetises the economy in the new currency while at the same time helping to establish the market value of said currency.

My reaction to this plan is simple: It is a blueprint for anyone who thinks that the euro system is past the point of no return. Once that point has been and gone, it is perhaps essential to move into this direction swiftly. However, I do not believe that the eurozone is, presently, past the point of no return. It is still possible to salvage the common currency by means of something akin to our Modest Proposal. It may take more intervention by the ECB than the Modest Proposal envisions (courtesy of the awful delay in implementing a rational plan, continuing instead on the present unsustainable path) but it is still, I think, feasible. The reason why I am adamant that this is not, yet, the time to abandon ship, is the huge human cost of the eurozones breakdown. Consider for example what will happen if we, indeed, adopt the exit plan proposed above.

All contracts by the government to the private sector (abroad and domestically) will be renegotiated in the new currency after the initial depreciation of the latter. In other words, domestic suppliers will face a large haircut instantly. Many of them will declare bankruptcy, with another large lump sum loss of jobs.

The banks will run dry and will not be kept open by the ECB. Which means that the only way Ireland or Greece or whoever adopts this plan can keep its banks open is if they are recapitalised in the new domestic currency by the Central Bank. But this means that bank account deposits will, de facto, be converted from euros to the new currency; thus annulling the beneficial measure of no compulsory conversions of bank holdings into the new currency (see above).

The authors claim that the above ill effects will be lessened by the governments new found monetary independence which will enable it to discontinue austerity programs immediately and adopt counter-cyclical fiscal policy, as Argentina did after its default and discontinuation of the pesos-dollar peg. This may be so but all comparisons with Argentina must be taken with a large pinch of salt. For Argentinas recovery, and associated fiscal policies, was far less due to its renewed independence and much more related to a serendipitous rise in demand for soya beans by China.

While it is true that the weaker currency will boost exports, it will also have a devastating effect: The creation of a two tier nation. One nation that has access to hoarded euros and another that does not. The former will acquire immense socio-economic power over the latter, thus forging a new form of inequality that is bound to operate as a break on development for a long while just like the inequality that sprang up in the post 1970s period did enormous damage to our countries real development (as opposed to GDP growth numbers) in the second postwar phase.

Last, but certainly not least, even if one country exits the eurozone in this manner, the eurozone will unwind within 24 hours. The European System of Central Banks will break instantly down, Italian spreads will hit Greek levels, France will turn instantly into a AA or AB rated country and, before we can wistle the 9th Symphony, germany will have declared the re-constitution of the DM. A massive recession will then hit the countries that will make up the new DM zone (Austria, the Netherlands. possibly Finland, Poland and Slovakia) while the rest of the former eurozone will labour under significant stagflation. The new intra-European currency wars will suppress, in unison with the ongoing recession/stagflation, international and European trade and, therefore, the US will dive into a new Great Recession. The postmodern 1930s that I keep speaking of will be a tragic reality.


In summary, this plan may end up being the only way out of a vessel heading for the rocks. We must keep it in mind given that our European leaders bloodymindedness has put, and keeps, a whole Continent on the rock-bound path. But it is not time yet to adopt it. For it will come at an incredible human cost; a cost that can still be averted (assuming that I am right in saying that the point of no return has not been reached yet). We still have a chance to storm the bridge and change course. Failing that, a plan like that by Mosler and Pilkington may be the equivalent of our lifeboats. We should, however, always keep in mind that our lifeboats will be launched in icy seas and, while stranded on them, many will perish.
Printer Friendly | Permalink | Reply | Top
 
  -STOCK MARKET WATCH, Friday, December 2, 2011 Pale Blue Dot  Dec-02-11 05:57 AM   #0 
  - Today's Reports  Pale Blue Dot   Dec-02-11 05:59 AM   #1 
  - U.S. manufacturing lightly accelerates: ISM  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:45 AM   #14 
  - U.S. unemployment rate falls to 8.6%  DemReadingDU   Dec-02-11 07:41 AM   #35 
     - If you believe the government statistics....  AnneD   Dec-02-11 08:18 AM   #56 
        - Karl Denninger: The Employment Report Is An Intentional FABRICATION  DemReadingDU   Dec-02-11 08:57 AM   #62 
           - ZeroHedge: Key Charts From The NFP Report  DemReadingDU   Dec-02-11 09:10 AM   # 
  - Oil hovers at $100 ahead of key US jobs report  Pale Blue Dot   Dec-02-11 05:59 AM   #2 
  - Natural-gas futures rally after supply report  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:42 AM   #13 
  - U.S. Stock-Index Futures Advance as Investors Await Monthly Payrolls Data  Pale Blue Dot   Dec-02-11 06:00 AM   #3 
  - Good Morning PBD!  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:09 AM   #4 
  - Great question! As a reminder to all, I will stop posting the SMW at the end of the year.  Pale Blue Dot   Dec-02-11 06:27 AM   #9 
  - Euro Zone Falls Short on Fund  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:10 AM   #5 
  - More European financial chicanery  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:13 AM   #6 
  - France and Germany want the stability and growth pact hurdle to move to zero percent by 2016  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:17 AM   #7 
  - Sarkozy and Merkel seek joint solution to debt crisis  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:48 AM   #15 
     - Merkel calls for rapid EU treaty change  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:49 AM   #39 
  - Official Action and Why Italy is Still at the Vortex  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:35 AM   #10 
  - EU bank watchdogs demur on tighter stress test  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:41 AM   #12 
  - The dash for cash Europes troubled banks are running out of money  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:57 AM   #19 
     - We dont believe they are at the stage of buying goldbut perhaps its not far off,  Po_d Mainiac   Dec-02-11 07:29 AM   #31 
        - When the fat lady sings...  AnneD   Dec-02-11 08:23 AM   #59 
  - Central Bank Chief Hints at Stepping Up Euro Support  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:03 AM   #21 
  - The IMF-ECB Plan Fig-Leaf upon Fig-Leaf  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:09 AM   #22 
  - Abandoning a sinking ship? A plan for leaving the euro  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:13 AM   #25 
  - Mosler/Pilkington: Response to Yanis Varoufakis Regarding Our Eurozone Exit Plan  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:20 AM   #27 
     - GERALD CELENTE: Prepare for an Economic 9/11 and Economic Martial Law  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:23 AM   #29 
        - Link?  DemReadingDU   Dec-02-11 07:36 AM   #34 
        - ooPS  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:42 AM   #36 
        - Nature of the Free Markets sir.  Hotler   Dec-02-11 11:09 AM   #67 
           - Maybe  Demeter   Dec-02-11 11:18 AM   #70 
              - I'm with you.  Hotler   Dec-02-11 11:33 AM   #76 
                 - I'm with both of you  DemReadingDU   Dec-02-11 05:52 PM   #82 
  - You are all wrong, printing money can halt Europe's crisis By Ambrose Evans-Pritchard  Demeter   Dec-02-11 08:05 AM   #48 
  - I set the comments on 'best rating'. His readers definitely don't buy that.  Prometheus Bound   Dec-02-11 04:22 PM   #81 
  - Killing the Euro By PAUL KRUGMAN  Demeter   Dec-02-11 08:07 AM   #49 
  - Sweden and the euro: Out and happy  Demeter   Dec-02-11 08:14 AM   #53 
  - Pepper Spray Developer: It Has Become Fashionable to Use Chemicals on People with Opinions  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:21 AM   #8 
  - Einstein, Alfred  Po_d Mainiac   Dec-02-11 07:22 AM   #28 
     - Purpose?  Demeter   Dec-02-11 11:16 AM   #69 
     - I thought his last name was Neuman  Fuddnik   Dec-02-11 12:39 PM   #79 
  - MF Global Accounting Technique Under Review, Schapiro Says  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:40 AM   #11 
  - MF Global accessed client funds for weeks  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:54 AM   #42 
  - it's morning, right?  xchrom   Dec-02-11 06:50 AM   #16 
  - Well, the sky is lightening  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:52 AM   #18 
     - sorry about that..... i've been having 3.ooam wake up pretty regular lately.  xchrom   Dec-02-11 07:02 AM   #20 
  - U.S. banks ask for more time on Volcker rule  Demeter   Dec-02-11 06:51 AM   #17 
  - europe: Germany's Merkel fights for euro  xchrom   Dec-02-11 07:09 AM   #23 
  - Euro zone PPI up less than expected in October  xchrom   Dec-02-11 07:11 AM   #24 
  - Merkel urges euro fiscal union to tackle debt crisis  xchrom   Dec-02-11 07:45 AM   #37 
  - Stock markets rise as Merkel calls for closer union  xchrom   Dec-02-11 07:51 AM   #41 
  - Eurozone crisis: Merkel pledges push for fiscal union - live  xchrom   Dec-02-11 07:59 AM   #44 
  - Unions lose CPI pensions battle in high court  xchrom   Dec-02-11 08:03 AM   #46 
  - Croatia Dreaming of no-strings membership  xchrom   Dec-02-11 08:08 AM   #50 
  - How business is preparing for Eurogeddon  xchrom   Dec-02-11 08:10 AM   #52 
  - asia: Nikkei logs biggest weekly gain in 2 yrs but mood far from upbeat  xchrom   Dec-02-11 07:13 AM   #26 
  - China's Ordos property bust offers warning sign  xchrom   Dec-02-11 08:01 AM   #45 
  - Minister: China wants to invest in US roads, rails  xchrom   Dec-02-11 08:30 AM   #61 
  - PRECIOUS-Gold up, EU plan to fight debt crisis expected  xchrom   Dec-02-11 07:27 AM   #30 
  - south asia: Pranab Mukherjee: India retail reform 'must for growth  xchrom   Dec-02-11 07:31 AM   #32 
  - 'Big-box' protests test India's FDI strategy  xchrom   Dec-02-11 09:20 AM   #65 
     - If our jobs are good enough for you....  Hotler   Dec-02-11 11:19 AM   #71 
        - that is some good Snark  xchrom   Dec-02-11 11:24 AM   #74 
        - HOTLER! Play nice. eom.  Hotler   Dec-02-11 11:36 AM   #77 
  - Are Remotely-Processed Mortgage Assignments Another Smoking Gun?  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:33 AM   #33 
  - Inside the Coakley Foreclosure Fraud Lawsuit  Demeter   Dec-02-11 08:20 AM   #57 
     - Massachusetts Announces First Comprehensive Lawsuit Against Major Banks  Demeter   Dec-02-11 08:23 AM   #58 
  - DOW FUTURES UP 145  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:47 AM   #38 
  - another day of gambling at the casino  DemReadingDU   Dec-02-11 07:50 AM   #40 
  - GM makes buy-back offer to Volt owners  Demeter   Dec-02-11 07:55 AM   #43 
  - Nielsen report: TV ownership declines  Demeter   Dec-02-11 08:04 AM   #47 
  - Our household has several......  AnneD   Dec-02-11 09:11 AM   #64 
     - Ditto  Demeter   Dec-02-11 11:20 AM   #73 
  - British banks could ask taxpayers for more cash  Demeter   Dec-02-11 08:09 AM   #51 
  - Africa rising  xchrom   Dec-02-11 08:14 AM   #54 
  - L.A. Mayor Puts Occupy L.A. Cost Over $1 Million; City Spent More on Michael Jackson Memorial  Demeter   Dec-02-11 08:17 AM   #55 
  - Fracking, Mortgages and Insurance  Demeter   Dec-02-11 08:26 AM   #60 
  - Parents house got its first offer in 13 months for 1/2 assessed value of 2009.  kickysnana   Dec-02-11 09:10 AM   #63 
  - I suspect that may be...  AnneD   Dec-02-11 11:02 AM   #66 
  - The value dropped in half between '09 and '11?  Juneboarder   Dec-02-11 11:11 AM   #68 
  - Much really relies on location....  AnneD   Dec-02-11 11:59 AM   #78 
  - Suburb of St Paul MN  kickysnana   Dec-02-11 02:47 PM   #80 
  - I'd worry about the price paid to purchase, or finance, for comparison  Demeter   Dec-02-11 11:27 AM   #75 
  - Unleashing the Future: Advancing Prosperity Through Debt Forgiveness  Huey P. Long   Dec-02-11 11:19 AM   #72 
 

Home » Discuss » Latest Breaking News Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators


Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC