Reply #6: world bankers bearing gifts

[xchrom]

http://www.economist.com/blogs/banyan/2011/04/assistance_timor-leste

RONALD REAGAN is supposed once to have said that the scariest words in the English language were “I’m from the government, and I’m here to help.” But what if you are the government? In that case, perhaps, the scariest words are “I’m from the World Bank, and I’m here to help.”

That certainly seems to have been the experience of Timor-Leste, a much-put-upon country that spent more than 200 years under Portuguese rule, then 24 under Indonesia’s and a final two under the United Nations, before eventually winning independence in 2002. Nowadays the young republic finds a number of reasons for cheer. But if the World Bank’s own review is to be believed, it deserves little credit for Timor-Leste’s progress.

When Indonesia was at last forced to give in to overwhelming demands for the independence of its then-province of East Timor, the bank moved in quickly to offer assistance. It has been assisting every since. A report from the bank’s Independent Evaluation Group, to be published next month, details the success of that assistance. Or rather, its lack of success.

Of the outcomes of the bank’s 12 self-defined strategic and operational goals, five are rated “unsatisfactory”, four “moderately unsatisfactory”, two “moderately satisfactory” and only one “highly satisfactory”. That last was, admittedly, to bring transparency and probity to the management of oil and gas revenues—no mean feat for a poor country in that particular industry. But the failures were legion.