Reply #20: No, he shouldn't have referred them to another pharmacist

[SquireJons]

He should have dispensed what they asked for. If his religious beliefs prevent him from doing his job, then he needs to get another job. If a person is a pacifist, that pretty much disqualifies him from offensive military duty. If a firefighter thinks it's wrong to put out fires, then he can't be a fireman. If a doctor thinks it's ok to let people die who otherwise would have lived... well, hello medical malpractice suit... bye bye medical career. The analogies go on and on forever.

It's pretty simple.