Ask Auntie Pinko
March 9, 2006
By Auntie Pinko
I like political debate, and I love reading political books
and watching shows on the same topic. However we don't have nearly
as much of it in Australia as you guys do in the U.S. I follow U.S.
politics quite closely, like a lot of people from around the world,
and this site is one of my favorites. I have read books by Jon Stewart
and Al Franken and really enjoyed both of them, but as a result
of geographic distance from the U.S., I really don't know which
authors I should be looking out for! I know to steer clear of nutters
like Sean Hannity and Ann Coulter, but beyond that I'm really in
Could you perhaps let me know who the best liberal authors
(or podcast casters) are so that I can try and track them down?
Good on you! I wish more Americans would take the initiative to
read and examine the political life of Australia (and other countries,
of course!). We tend to be pretty self-absorbed, unfortunately.
It's easily interpreted as arrogance, and there is doubtless plenty
of that here, but I think it's mostly laziness.
Now, Auntie can't help you with podcasts, since I've been limited
by dialup modem speeds and have never really broached the resources
of podcast culture. I suggest you post that question in Democratic
Underground's "General Discussion: Politics" forum, and you'll probably
get more references than you can manage! But at least it will give
you a starting place.
As far as books, though, you've come to the right place, sort
of. I'm an avid reader and my bookshelves are stuffed full of books
that relate to politics in one fashion or another. I'd like to make
it clear up front, especially to the fans of any author I omit to
mention, that I can't possibly offer a comprehensive list, and I'm
positive that I'll leave at least half-a-dozen really great writers/books
unmentioned and regret it later. But I'm not as young as I used
to be, and my mental "hard disk" data retrieval system isn't as
fast or thorough as I'd like it to be.
First, I should clarify a bit about my reading habits so you have
some context for my recommendations. My "political" reading falls
into three rough (and overlapping) categories: Commentary, advocacy,
and analysis/history/biography. Here's how I think of each category:
Commentary ranges from pure partisan diatribes through
humor to semi- (and sometimes pseudo-) scholarly or journalistic
explication of current and recent past political events, trends,
and sometimes individuals. The bias of the author is usually pretty
clear, and I tend to judge this kind of book or article on how entertainingly
and well it is written, how honest the author is about her/his bias,
and how well s/he has done the homework that lends substance and
context to the author's views.
In this category, anything by Molly Ivins wins hands-down, since
I think she's outstanding on all of those criteria. I've also enjoyed
books by Mark Crispin Miller, Bill Moyers, Joe Conason, Jim Hightower,
and others. A quick search of a major online book retailer's database
will give you titles, and following the "other recommended" links
will lead you to similar books and authors, too.
Special mention must also go to two U.S. Senators who have published
enormously thoughtful and moving commentaries: Senator Paul Wellstone's
The Conscience of a Liberal, and Senator Robert Byrd's Losing
America: Confronting a Reckless and Arrogant Presidency. Both
are well worth reading and will give you insight into some of the
U.S. Senate's most profound moral leadership in the late 20th Century.
Advocacy is a related genre of books that presents the
author's views, experiences, scholarship, and/or recommendations
on contemporary issues (rather than people, leaders, government
entities, etc.) in the political sphere. Again, the authors are
generally willing to acknowledge their own viewpoints and/or biases,
and the books often focus on how those views were changed or enhanced
through their exploration of the issues. Some of the outstanding
authors here include Jonathan Kozol, Barbara Ehrenreich, Lisbeth
Schorr, and William Julius Wilson.
Analysis/history/biography includes books that relate to
current geopolitical issues through the context of historical developments,
the biographies (and autobiographies) of pivotal individuals, or
the detailed analysis of a specific event. Authors of these works
do not always feel it necessary to state particular biases, although
some do. But a good writer generally makes his or her perspective
clear through how they analyze and comment. You can also tell a
lot by looking at bibliographies and lists of citations. Sometimes
authors of these books attempt to present as many perspectives as
possible and establish a "balanced" viewpoint, sometimes they are
writing clearly from the basis of their own ideological stand.
In this area you can look at Howard Zinn's A People's History
of the United States, Madeline Albright's recent autobiography,
Intelligence Wars: American Secret History from Hitler to Al-Qaeda
by Thomas Powers, and almost anything by David Halberstam. Very
special mention must go to Barbara Tuchman's The March of Folly:
From Troy to Vietnam, a book that does more to expose the dark
side of American policymaking than just about anything I've ever
read. Although it was published in the wake of Vietnam, it's disappointingly
clear that little has changed at the highest levels of American
policymaking since it was published.
At the moment, I'm reading and enjoying Seymour Hersh's Chain
of Command: The Road from 9/11 to Abu Ghraib, a book that occupies
the middle ground between all three of these categories, and American
Fascism: The Rise of the Christian Right by Chris Hedges, a
commentary laced with plenty of historical and philosophical analysis
by an excellent writer.
I hope this gives you something to go on, Warren, and thanks for
asking Auntie Pinko!
View Auntie's Archive
Do you have a question for Auntie Pinko?
Do political discusions discombobulate you? Are you a liberal at
a loss for words when those darned dittoheads babble their talking
points at you? Or a conservative, who just can't understand those
pesky liberals and their silliness? Auntie Pinko has an answer for
Just send e-mail to: email@example.com,
and make sure it says "A question for Auntie Pinko" in
the subject line. Please include your name and hometown.