Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

jimmy the one

(2,708 posts)
40. have a cup of swiss myth
Wed May 8, 2013, 09:03 AM
May 2013

marblefalls: In both Israel and Switzerland anyone who serves in the armed forces.. also serves in the reserves after active duty and takes their personal weapons including assault weapons home.. I bet they are more armed than we in firepower per capita.

While on home guard duty, swiss soldiers are issued an assault rifle which they can keep after completing service, but ammo for the assault rifle is now kept in swiss armories not in the soldiers home (after service dunno). Swiss cannot carry concealed firearms without a valid reason, like a US 'may issue' state, & gunlicense required.
(BTW, dan did provide a link for his 'spread sheet', unedited, check again & apologize).

You say 'you bet' swiss & israel & canada are more armed than US? couldn't be more wrong, you are off by 2 or 3 orders of magnitude (in total, closer with rates).
Israel .. less than a million legal guns, maybe less than 100,000.
Switz: ~8 million people.. ~3 million guns .. ~1 gun per 3 people
USA: ~310 million people.. ~300 million guns.. near one gun per person.
In other words, the US has about 300 million more guns than Switz & Israel combined.

a good read for you, marblefalls: .. they don’t have high levels of gun ownership. The gun ownership in Israel and Switzerland has decreased. For instance, in Israel, they’re very limited in who is able to own a gun. There are only a few tens of thousands of legal guns in Israel, and the only people allowed to own them legally live in the settlements, do business in the settlements, or are in professions at risk of violence.
Both countries require you to have a reason to have a gun. There isn’t this idea that you have a right to a gun. You need a reason. And then you need to go back to the permitting authority every 6 months or so to assure them the reason is still valid.
The second thing is that there’s this widespread misunderstanding that Israel and Switzerland promote gun ownership. They don’t. Ten years ago, when Israel had the outbreak of violence, there was an expansion of gun ownership, but only to people above a certain rank in the military. There was no sense that having ordinary citizens [carry guns] would make anything safer.
In Israel, it used to be that all soldiers would take the guns home with them. Now {since 2006} they have to leave them on base.. there’s been a 60% decrease in suicide on weekends among IDS soldiers.
..Israel rejects 40% of its applications for a gun, the highest rate of rejection of any country in the world. And even when you get approved, you say that “all guns must have an Interior Ministry permit and identifying mark for tracing.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2012/12/14/mythbusting-israel-and-switzerland-are-not-gun-toting-utopias/


That's good. I hope it continues to fall. nt ZombieHorde May 2013 #1
We're still in the stratosphere when compared to most other countries. Squinch May 2013 #2
No doubt. Three countries I can think of are as or more armed than the US .... marble falls May 2013 #3
Israel, Switzerland, and Canada are not as armed as we are. DanTex May 2013 #5
In both Israel and Switzerland anyone who serves in the armed forces..... marble falls May 2013 #10
Yes, but we have more guns per capita. DanTex May 2013 #16
Also funny how billh58 May 2013 #24
Why are gun suicides your big concern? Are you concerned with non-gun suicides as well? What Squinch May 2013 #6
It shows what a low priority we have for mental health, I am concerned about suicide by cop... marble falls May 2013 #11
Concerned as in you would like to see fewer guns in circulation so as to reduce suicides? Squinch May 2013 #13
Another NRA billh58 May 2013 #18
These are inconveniant facts, but they don't negate the need in lite of all the gun mayhem... marble falls May 2013 #23
No they are not billh58 May 2013 #25
Another example of billh58 May 2013 #28
I wouldn't get too excited yet rightsideout May 2013 #4
There are less shootings, period. Violence, according to the FBI has gone down. marble falls May 2013 #12
The number of shootings has increased in the last decade. DanTex May 2013 #17
FBI says otherwise: marble falls May 2013 #19
Sigh. Again, violent crime and shootings are not the same thing. DanTex May 2013 #20
see marble falls May 2013 #21
So you are saying that the CDC stats are false. Am I understanding you correctly? DanTex May 2013 #22
So you are saying the FBI is making it up. Am I understanding you correctly? marble falls May 2013 #26
For the third time, "violent crime" and "shootings" are not the same thing. DanTex May 2013 #27
NRA apologists billh58 May 2013 #30
Facts you don't like? Try these: marble falls May 2013 #38
Tell Uncle Wayne billh58 May 2013 #43
The CDC says otherwise rightsideout May 2013 #31
You do know you keep linking to this story which requires a subscription to see? pipoman May 2013 #37
Let's bring it to zero mwrguy May 2013 #7
Then how come gun nuts want everyone to be armed to the teeth? TheCowsCameHome May 2013 #8
Um.... because they're gun nuts? Because like the article says, the public percieves... marble falls May 2013 #14
Holy Shit! The NRA had better get right on this. Turbineguy May 2013 #9
Nice try billh58 May 2013 #15
Rubbish. And has been proven so repeatedly. Robb May 2013 #29
Exactly rightsideout May 2013 #32
Over the last decade or so there is a definite plateau. n/t ellisonz May 2013 #34
Gun porn in the gun control group Kingofalldems May 2013 #33
There's some fine education going on upthread. ellisonz May 2013 #36
So if the general argument is correct, gun control clearly works! ellisonz May 2013 #35
While at the same time AR-15's and SK-47's and banana clips were made legal. marble falls May 2013 #39
Jared Lee Loughner, Adam Lanza, and James Holmes all used weapons or clips... ellisonz May 2013 #53
have a cup of swiss myth jimmy the one May 2013 #40
Try this: marble falls May 2013 #41
the bigger picture jimmy the one May 2013 #42
From CBS, LA Times, USA Today .... got more if you need it...... marble falls May 2013 #44
Are you going to address woundings Robb May 2013 #45
Gun violence includes woundings. I haven't repeated anything. All links are origional.... marble falls May 2013 #46
So should we just do what the NRA tells us? Kingofalldems May 2013 #49
but gun ownership has declined those years jimmy the one May 2013 #47
Right. From 50% ownership in the 1950's to 37% currently. But population.... marble falls May 2013 #48
1950 = wrong census jimmy the one May 2013 #50
bullshit. Suicide IS gun violence. bowens43 May 2013 #51
Suicide by gun is most definately violence. marble falls May 2013 #52
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control Reform Activism»Rate Of U.S. Gun Violence...»Reply #40