HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » Politics 2014 (Forum) » Stop calling us wives and...

Thu Feb 14, 2013, 08:43 AM

Stop calling us wives and moms [View all]


A petition calls on President Obama to drop his retro rhetoric about women

BY TRACY CLARK-FLORY


In the wake of President Barack Obama’s State of the Union, a petition is taking him to task for his habit of framing women’s equality as a struggle to protect the rights of “wives, mothers, and daughters.” The campaign was inspired by one line in particular from last night’s speech in which Obama said, “We know our economy is stronger when our wives, mothers, and daughters can live their lives free from discrimination in the workplace and free from the fear of domestic violence.”

A totally righteous argument, right? But the petition, which has 716 signatures at the time of this writing, says that this sort of language is “counterproductive to the women’s equality the President is ostensibly supporting.” It goes on to explain, “Defining women by their relationships to other people is reductive, misogynist, and alienating to women who do not define ourselves exclusively by our relationships to others. Further, by referring to ‘our’ wives et al, the President appears to be talking to The Men of America about Their Women, rather than talking to men AND women.”

Of course, Obama’s larger message, as he went on to say, was that in addition to passing the Violence Against Women Act, Congress should “declare that women should earn a living equal to their efforts, and finally pass the Paycheck Fairness Act this year.” With his “wives, mothers, and daughters” rhetoric, he was largely addressing Congress, which is predominantly male — and Republican men are especially in need of convincing on this. So some might argue that it’s simply a smart strategic move in service of the greater good, even if it’s alienating to women.

But it’s also a refrain Obama has turned to time and again. In fact, at one point in last night’s SOTU he said, “We will draw upon the courage and skills of our sisters and daughters, because women have proven under fire that they are ready for combat.” There was also the “Father Knows Best” paternalism of his argument for restrictions on emergency contraception in 2011. (Not to mention how first lady Michelle Obama presented herself, as Rebecca Traister wrote, “precisely as she needed to in order to be digested by the American people: as a daughter, a sister, a wife, a mother.”) As Melissa McEwan, who started the petition, writes on her blog Shakesville, this makes it sound like Obama is “not speaking to those wives, mothers, daughters, and any women who are none of those things and/or do not define themselves that way” — and that’s not to mention the women who are in Congress.

On the Daily Kos, McKenna Miller — a man, or rather son — makes an excellent comparison to rhetoric about gay rights, “The reason to fight homophobia isn’t because ‘you’ve got a gay friend,’ it’s because it’s simply the right thing to do. The reason why a woman is valuable isn’t because she’s someone’s sister, or daughter, or wife, it’s because of the person she is unto herself.”

http://www.salon.com/2013/02/13/stop_calling_us_wives_and_moms/

Link to the petition:
https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/stop-using-wives-mothers-daughters-rhetorical-frame-defines-women-their-relationships-other-people/3yvcscVK

106 replies, 9277 views

Reply to this thread

Back to top Alert abuse

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 106 replies Author Time Post
Reply Stop calling us wives and moms [View all]
DonViejo Feb 2013 OP
leftynyc Feb 2013 #1
roody Feb 2013 #4
leftynyc Feb 2013 #10
littlemissmartypants Feb 2013 #43
leftynyc Feb 2013 #47
littlemissmartypants Feb 2013 #48
leftynyc Feb 2013 #50
Drahthaardogs Feb 2013 #69
littlemissmartypants Feb 2013 #71
Drahthaardogs Feb 2013 #72
littlemissmartypants Feb 2013 #74
Drahthaardogs Feb 2013 #75
littlemissmartypants Feb 2013 #77
kestrel91316 Feb 2013 #78
littlemissmartypants Feb 2013 #79
undeterred Feb 2013 #93
littlemissmartypants Feb 2013 #94
JustAnotherGen Feb 2013 #103
undeterred Feb 2013 #104
FBaggins Feb 2013 #12
Paladin Feb 2013 #13
RBInMaine Feb 2013 #89
pipoman Feb 2013 #2
SummerSnow Feb 2013 #16
lunatica Feb 2013 #3
bemildred Feb 2013 #5
Heather MC Feb 2013 #6
laureloak Feb 2013 #7
CTyankee Feb 2013 #9
leftynyc Feb 2013 #11
CTyankee Feb 2013 #15
FBaggins Feb 2013 #18
CTyankee Feb 2013 #20
MuseRider Feb 2013 #34
CTyankee Feb 2013 #36
MuseRider Feb 2013 #37
forestpath Feb 2013 #46
magical thyme Feb 2013 #8
MotherPetrie Feb 2013 #14
phleshdef Feb 2013 #19
MotherPetrie Feb 2013 #24
phleshdef Feb 2013 #31
magical thyme Feb 2013 #22
MotherPetrie Feb 2013 #25
MADem Feb 2013 #30
magical thyme Feb 2013 #35
a la izquierda Feb 2013 #67
bettyellen Feb 2013 #81
a la izquierda Feb 2013 #86
LiberalFighter Feb 2013 #17
EastKYLiberal Feb 2013 #21
meow2u3 Feb 2013 #23
MotherPetrie Feb 2013 #26
marybourg Feb 2013 #27
MADem Feb 2013 #33
marybourg Feb 2013 #38
MADem Feb 2013 #39
marybourg Feb 2013 #41
MADem Feb 2013 #42
marybourg Feb 2013 #44
SheilaT Feb 2013 #28
CBGLuthier Feb 2013 #51
SheilaT Feb 2013 #57
MADem Feb 2013 #29
RC Feb 2013 #32
treestar Feb 2013 #40
forestpath Feb 2013 #45
davidpdx Feb 2013 #49
Still Sensible Feb 2013 #52
HappyMe Feb 2013 #53
Dash87 Feb 2013 #54
Le Taz Hot Feb 2013 #55
Blaukraut Feb 2013 #56
CTyankee Feb 2013 #58
phleshdef Feb 2013 #60
CTyankee Feb 2013 #61
CBGLuthier Feb 2013 #63
bunnies Feb 2013 #66
CTyankee Feb 2013 #68
bettyellen Feb 2013 #83
CTyankee Feb 2013 #91
bettyellen Feb 2013 #95
CTyankee Feb 2013 #96
bettyellen Feb 2013 #98
SpartanDem Feb 2013 #59
Blue_Tires Feb 2013 #62
jenmito Feb 2013 #64
bunnies Feb 2013 #65
gollygee Feb 2013 #70
NightOwwl Feb 2013 #73
Swamp Lover Feb 2013 #76
Bluzmann57 Feb 2013 #80
bettyellen Feb 2013 #82
littlemissmartypants Feb 2013 #84
HockeyMom Feb 2013 #85
senseandsensibility Feb 2013 #87
CTyankee Feb 2013 #92
RBInMaine Feb 2013 #88
Drunken Irishman Feb 2013 #90
pink-o Feb 2013 #97
BigDemVoter Feb 2013 #99
aikoaiko Feb 2013 #100
d_b Feb 2013 #101
Ash_F Feb 2013 #102
dionysus Feb 2013 #105
secondwind Feb 2013 #106