Mon Jan 21, 2013, 09:12 PM

Beyonce or Whitney Houston? [View all]

Until today, I considered Houston singing the national anthem at the Super Bowl 1991 the best. Today's Beyonce's may just nudged Houston.

60 replies, 2676 views

Reply to this thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

60 replies	Author	Time	Post
Beyonce or Whitney Houston? [View all]	question everything	Jan 2013	OP
whitney by 1000	robinlynne	Jan 2013	#1
Absolutely Whitney.... +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++	hlthe2b	Jan 2013	#2
Indeed! Whitney's performance still gives me chills	panAmerican	Jan 2013	#4
Have to go with Whitney	Jeff In Milwaukee	Jan 2013	#34
Beyonce was exceptional ... but Whitney was legendary.	11 Bravo	Jan 2013	#42
Whitney's was a studio version...	TTUBatfan2008	Jan 2013	#3
Beyonce lip-synched it, too.	NewJeffCT	Jan 2013	#37
Is this why she threw away something from her ear?	question everything	Jan 2013	#43
Maybe it distracted her lip synching?	NewJeffCT	Jan 2013	#46
Yeah, saw that reported today...	TTUBatfan2008	Jan 2013	#50
Beyonce	blue_heron	Jan 2013	#5
I liked Beyonce's version better.	MADem	Jan 2013	#6
whitney-her voice was amazing	MichiganVote	Jan 2013	#7
Got to go with Whitney.	okwmember	Jan 2013	#8
I'm pretty sure Beyonce	leftynyc	Jan 2013	#19
gotta go with Whitney	sad-cafe	Jan 2013	#9
Beyonce	frazzled	Jan 2013	#10
Neither	LuvLoogie	Jan 2013	#11
ok...that was amazing.	Evergreen Emerald	Jan 2013	#24
Very impressive	question everything	Jan 2013	#44
Thank you. His best was on 9/11/11 at Soldier Field. Check it out.	LuvLoogie	Jan 2013	#55
Yes! An actual singer, not a manufactured pop star	Pool Hall Ace	Jan 2013	#56
Whitney Houston	KT2000	Jan 2013	#12
Whitney hands down nt	Samantha	Jan 2013	#13
Whitney for sure!	kittykitty	Jan 2013	#14
I could go with	John2	Jan 2013	#15
Whitney, hands down......	MzShellG	Jan 2013	#16
whitney at the super bowl by a long stretch	tnvoter	Jan 2013	#17
By a hair - Whitney	leftynyc	Jan 2013	#18
Bouncey's yodeling typically grates my nerves, but she did a fine job today.	Liberal_Stalwart71	Jan 2013	#20
All I know is they're both stunningly beautiful and awesomely talented	cherish44	Jan 2013	#21
Both were great performances. Period..	Filibuster Harry	Jan 2013	#22
Whitney.	kjackson227	Jan 2013	#23
I don't want to minimize how great both versions are	Evergreen Emerald	Jan 2013	#25
Whitney all day!!!	Mdterp01	Jan 2013	#26
This message was self-deleted by its author	Sekhmets Daughter	Jan 2013	#27
Neither	Shadowflash	Jan 2013	#28
Stunning! Thank you for posting this	question everything	Jan 2013	#29
Absolutely my pleasure!	Shadowflash	Jan 2013	#30
Whitney	SugarShack	Jan 2013	#31
Beyonce's version was closer to the original version - she was amazing	Justice	Jan 2013	#32
Whitney. Hands down. (nt)	bigwillq	Jan 2013	#33
Whitney Whitney Whitney!	tiffany_willis	Jan 2013	#35
But....	tiffany_willis	Jan 2013	#36
A generous sentiment	question everything	Jan 2013	#49
Whitney's voice, everything else Beyonce. nt	geek tragedy	Jan 2013	#38
Neither. Ladies and Gentlemen, I give you Mr. Marvin Gaye:	RedSpartan	Jan 2013	#39
Interesting. Different	question everything	Jan 2013	#47
Thanks for sharing!	goclark	Jan 2013	#58
Beyonce is a truly nice person, she is...	Little Star	Jan 2013	#40
Count me among the "neither" votes...	markpkessinger	Jan 2013	#41
I think that Linda Ronstadt version	question everything	Jan 2013	#51
Whitney -	ohheckyeah	Jan 2013	#45
Neither - don't yell it, don't howl it ... you don't get points for decibel level.	Myrina	Jan 2013	#48
Marvin Gaye, hands down.	graham4anything	Jan 2013	#52
Loved it!	Evergreen Emerald	Jan 2013	#53
Never heard this version. Absolutely beautiful.	Pool Hall Ace	Jan 2013	#57
Stevie Ray, 1985, Astrodome	DollarBillHines	Jan 2013	#54
Jimi Hendrix, ladies and gentlemen.	MuttLikeMe	Jan 2013	#59
Whitney and its not even close!	Bob Sacamano	Jan 2013	#60