Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

2016 Postmortem

Showing Original Post only (View all)
 

cali

(114,904 posts)
Fri Feb 12, 2016, 07:40 AM Feb 2016

Celebrated Photographer: Yes, that is Bernie Sanders. Time Magazine is lying [View all]

We're always happy to get an email from Danny Lyon, the great American photographer, credited with inventing what became known as 'the new journalism' back in the 1960s. Lyons photographs of society's outsiders and its dispossessed and downtrodden have become legendary over the years, and he remains to this day a peerless - and fearless - chronicler of human integrity, dignity and resistance.

He sent us a link to a couple of photographs he took of Democrat contender Bernie Sanders back in the early 1960s when the then student activist was talking at a gathering of students holding a sit in in protest at institutional racism againt black students in Chicago. This is what Danny said:

"In 1962 and the spring of 1963 I was the student photographer at the University of Chicago, making pictures for the yearbook, the Alumni Magazine and the student paper, The Maroon. By the summer of 1962 I had taken my camera into the deep South, and become the first photographer for SNCC.

"That winter at the University of Chicago, there was a sit-in inside the administration building protesting discrimination against blacks in university owned housing. I went to it with a CORE activist and friend. The sit in was in a crowded hallway, blocking the entrance to the office of Dr. George Beadle, the chancellor.

"I took the photograph of Bernie Sanders speaking to his fellow CORE members at that sit-in. Bob McNamara, a close friend and CORE activist, is in the very corner next to me in the picture. Across the room from me is another campus photographer named Wexler, who taught me how to develop film.

"I photographed Bernie a second time after he got a haircut, as he appeared next to the noble laureate and chancellor Dr. George Beadle. Time Magazine is now claiming it is not Bernie in the picture but someone else. It is Bernie, and it is proof of his very early dedication to justice for African Americans. The CORE sit-in that Bernie helped lead was the first civil rights sit-in to take place in the North."

<snip>
http://www.phaidon.com/agenda/photography/articles/2016/february/02/when-danny-lyon-met-bernie-sanders/

179 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
FFS can this please finally settle this? Recursion Feb 2016 #1
I agree that it's basically insignificant cali Feb 2016 #4
I totally get that. Recursion Feb 2016 #6
You are right, but cali Feb 2016 #8
And, we are sadly in exact agreement there Recursion Feb 2016 #9
Now I'll add why I think, poor as the odds are, cali Feb 2016 #13
I'm probably going to vote for Sanders in the Democrats Abroad Global Primary for basically Recursion Feb 2016 #14
The only thing that would keep Hillary sammythecat Feb 2016 #121
Sanders/Kucinich would make me almost as happy as a Sanders/Warren ticket. AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #128
I made a big mistake here sammythecat Feb 2016 #132
Geeze, get me all excited... AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #133
I don't know much about him either, except sammythecat Feb 2016 #135
Nobody forceably removed from the stage of a Grateful Dead concert-- geologic Feb 2016 #150
My theory: merrily Feb 2016 #11
And yet that total is what we're starting with in both states Recursion Feb 2016 #12
Nominate someone who turns people out. Also, by that time, the Republicans will have only merrily Feb 2016 #15
That is the exact thing that haunts me. They feel like we did in 2008. Recursion Feb 2016 #17
Read my prior post again, please. I added an edit I think you will like. merrily Feb 2016 #18
Good catch, thanks. I think even Vermin Supreme got 3 Rep. votes. Recursion Feb 2016 #24
Are you serious? merrily Feb 2016 #26
Right: the DNC has refused to kneecap our frontrunner, despite the fact that any consultant Recursion Feb 2016 #28
That is not what I said. merrily Feb 2016 #30
I think it might end up being Rubio cali Feb 2016 #29
It's rare I agree with you four times in one day, but here we are Recursion Feb 2016 #32
That is journalist fantasy. cali Feb 2016 #36
And yet, Bush is making a comeback. I wouldn't rule him out yet either. Live and Learn Feb 2016 #37
I admit, I've ruled him out. cali Feb 2016 #39
Same here Recursion Feb 2016 #42
He's so... cali Feb 2016 #44
Right? (nt) Recursion Feb 2016 #45
I saw a SC Republican focus group yesterday that said no more Bushes basically. Punkingal Feb 2016 #51
I thought so too but now I am not so sure. Stay tuned. nt Live and Learn Feb 2016 #43
It's like the tortus and the hare. Bush being the tortous. Remember he has "Dirty Tricks" Rove rhett o rick Feb 2016 #151
Where Bernie could win over independents and some Republicans from Kasich or Rubio is H-1B visas cascadiance Feb 2016 #56
That's true, but is that a significant number? cali Feb 2016 #67
I think that it should be put to the test by asking about this issue in the debates... cascadiance Feb 2016 #85
They may have thought Vermin Supreme was a ratfscker. merrily Feb 2016 #174
Please, by all means, give Rep. Lewis a call. Hissyspit Feb 2016 #60
Seriously? Recursion Feb 2016 #64
No. Democrats using tactics like he did yesterday is why we lose. Hissyspit Feb 2016 #66
+1 BeanMusical Feb 2016 #170
"This is why we lose" Say WH-HAT? truedelphi Feb 2016 #163
Perhaps because the sus453 Feb 2016 #143
i can tell you why we had lower turn out questionseverything Feb 2016 #144
It isn't just a minimizing of Bernie's civil rights activism, but also of his honesty. femmedem Feb 2016 #89
Good on ya cali ! Ferd Berfel Feb 2016 #140
Thanks, ferd cali Feb 2016 #141
And again...this is a Rovian tactic. Attack the strengths of AikidoSoul Feb 2016 #176
It was a ridiculous meme to begin with but memes when ignored have ways of killing campaigns, eg., Live and Learn Feb 2016 #27
No. It will be brought up from now until the convention. jeff47 Feb 2016 #98
This photo flap only has significance because it adds to the "throw everything and see if it sticks" mikehiggins Feb 2016 #99
This puts paid to the doubters, spinners and liars. Divernan Feb 2016 #2
The depths of this little episode of ratfuckery are truly unfathomable. mhatrw Feb 2016 #149
Holy shit! Did all this info come out today? cui bono Feb 2016 #157
This brings to mind the atrocious swift boating of John Kerry. truedelphi Feb 2016 #161
K&R !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! SamKnause Feb 2016 #3
I bet the MSM will not report this. SamKnause Feb 2016 #5
We'll just have to keep correcting MSM bullshit cali Feb 2016 #7
I just watched the clip again. SamKnause Feb 2016 #10
It's also lazy ass journalism. cali Feb 2016 #23
They are not journalists. SamKnause Feb 2016 #25
But watch.... Bangbangdem Feb 2016 #104
Thank You For Setting The Record Straight cantbeserious Feb 2016 #16
Very happy to do it. Thanks for the kick cali Feb 2016 #20
K n r ReasonableToo Feb 2016 #19
Kicked and recommended! Enthusiast Feb 2016 #21
I must have missed this photo kerfuffle. Erich Bloodaxe BSN Feb 2016 #22
'A concerted effort to try to scrub Bernie's history' Exactly and well said. nt Live and Learn Feb 2016 #33
And when they can't do that, they claim none of it matters anyway, it was decades ago! cui bono Feb 2016 #158
Yep, they are pathetic and nauseating. BeanMusical Feb 2016 #171
Chris Matthews (after last night's debate) brought it up and said it wasn't Bernie KoKo Feb 2016 #61
Great Find. Thank you. K&R nt Live and Learn Feb 2016 #31
Missing all the du Hillary fans who insisted we were lying when cali Feb 2016 #34
Of course, it's Bernie! flpoljunkie Feb 2016 #35
But some in the MSM and hill fans have been saying that it absolutely isn't cali Feb 2016 #46
I'm surprised they haven't tried to photoshop Generic Other Feb 2016 #68
But if you can't prove it is a duck even though it looks, walks and talks like one and has Live and Learn Feb 2016 #53
Also, Cali, did you see this Mother Jones' article? Duppers Feb 2016 #38
Yes, thank you. It does indeed cali Feb 2016 #41
When you compare the two photos and look first at the hands and wrists appalachiablue Feb 2016 #102
Good observations, my friend. Duppers Feb 2016 #120
Isn't that Bruce in the upper right corner? Kensan Feb 2016 #146
Oh man I was going on ears alone. Kalidurga Feb 2016 #156
K&R denbot Feb 2016 #40
It's just an attempt to swift boat of Sanders' civil rights record and it's disgusting. myrna minx Feb 2016 #47
Exactly so. cali Feb 2016 #52
Go ahead Hillary fans, call Lyon a liar. I double dog dare you cali Feb 2016 #48
Thanks for posting. Giving a K & R. Bohunk68 Feb 2016 #50
I'm sorry that John Lewis got involved in this debacle. he's an American hero who is above Doctor_J Feb 2016 #49
Evidence would seem to indicate that he is not, in fact, "above this sort of thing." Funny how, when Gene Debs Feb 2016 #103
I think this should be the focus until May bravenak Feb 2016 #54
I think you don't give a damn how much hilly lies. cali Feb 2016 #57
They all lie. I'm just observant enough to realize it. bravenak Feb 2016 #58
May the Best Liar Win! Iggy Knorr Feb 2016 #65
Some are far more dishonest than others. Your powers of observation cali Feb 2016 #69
And some speak to everybody but us with respect and thats my thing bravenak Feb 2016 #74
Okay cali Feb 2016 #78
+1 Kittycat Feb 2016 #145
History says otherwise. AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #105
Scrub? bravenak Feb 2016 #106
Yes, scrub. AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #108
But do we have to make admiration over him? bravenak Feb 2016 #109
No one said anyone had to be excited tkmorris Feb 2016 #114
Whats a lie? That picture? bravenak Feb 2016 #116
The lie is the attempt to deny Bernie Sanders part of his own history and legacy. AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #126
Well. I guess he understand now why bravenak Feb 2016 #127
We all have to own the consequences of our actions. AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #129
I felt it when he discussed the sanitation strikers. bravenak Feb 2016 #131
I do know it's getting added to a whole lot of confirmation biases for people on all sides AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #134
Thank you, this is so true. bravenak Feb 2016 #136
All true, and I agree. AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #115
In 1964 Hillary was in high school radical noodle Feb 2016 #172
You should read her autobiography. "Living History" AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #177
I did read her biography radical noodle Feb 2016 #178
I did as well. AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #179
Ah yes, rationalization is the key to happiness. Correct? nm rhett o rick Feb 2016 #153
I'm interested to know when Bernie lied. n/t Admiral Loinpresser Feb 2016 #168
Inartful Ratfuckers Iggy Knorr Feb 2016 #55
THIS. Is what Bernie is up against. A once-venerable news-magazine attempting to LIE about him. AzDar Feb 2016 #59
Not just Time. Yesterday Jonathan Capehart cali Feb 2016 #63
Does Capehart have Twitter? TTUBatfan2008 Feb 2016 #80
Yes cali Feb 2016 #110
Yes, Capehart has been all over TV saying it isn't Bernie dreamnightwind Feb 2016 #113
What a find! To have the actual photographer verify the authenticity, then ADD that it was the first FailureToCommunicate Feb 2016 #62
Please contact the Post, Time and Chris Matthews cali Feb 2016 #70
Are these the pictures Tweety was whining about on his show? in_cog_ni_to Feb 2016 #71
Yes. And Capehart and the WaPo and and and cali Feb 2016 #73
Okay. Thanks! I'm going to go enlighten Matthews again. in_cog_ni_to Feb 2016 #77
Looks like Bernie to me (nt) nyabingi Feb 2016 #72
It doesn't matter who it looks like. cali Feb 2016 #75
But now Time will have to call the photographer a liar. valerief Feb 2016 #79
Just so you know Andrea Mitchell just had Capehart on her Noon show KoKo Feb 2016 #123
Proof schmoof. You're ruining the narrative! valerief Feb 2016 #76
And I intend to keep removing those turds. cali Feb 2016 #81
retractions need to be demanded on all fronts nt retrowire Feb 2016 #82
Yep. Pretty vile swiftboating cali Feb 2016 #87
HUGE K & R !!! - THANK YOU !!! WillyT Feb 2016 #83
Worse than the Kerry Swift Boat TTUBatfan2008 Feb 2016 #84
There's a reason capehart keeps lying about Bernie cali Feb 2016 #86
Oh...... SoapBox Feb 2016 #112
Wow, that is interesting dreamnightwind Feb 2016 #117
Actually, he is now a paid staffer in her campaign cali Feb 2016 #118
Damn, that does indeed put some context into Capehart's sliming - eom dreamnightwind Feb 2016 #119
"Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?" nt mhatrw Feb 2016 #138
Time's B.S. repeated on NPR this morning. Eleanors38 Feb 2016 #155
Capehart, eh? MisterP Feb 2016 #160
NT JRLeft Feb 2016 #88
Can you believe that Chris Matthews and Jonathan Capeheart went there on the air???? jillan Feb 2016 #90
Oh.yes, I can believe that hillshills have no problem brazenly lying cali Feb 2016 #92
The constant flow of cheesy, transparent lies, smears, and dirty tricks coming from the Zorra Feb 2016 #91
Lewis supported Hillary against Obama too Geronimoe Feb 2016 #93
He finally switched to Obama after his district voted for him 3-1 cali Feb 2016 #94
And note it took his district's vote to make him switch. jeff47 Feb 2016 #100
Dragged kicking and screaming. frylock Feb 2016 #125
Come on Hillary supporters, where are you? Arazi Feb 2016 #95
Thanks for the kick cali Feb 2016 #111
Actually it's clear zentrum Feb 2016 #96
I have seldom seen two photos of the same individual, taken so many years apart, and yet ... eppur_se_muova Feb 2016 #97
I agree. But I figured that is because I've been familiar cali Feb 2016 #101
He's the real McCoy, and that scares the shit out of some people. AtheistCrusader Feb 2016 #107
Actually, I'M the real Berni McCoy. berni_mccoy Feb 2016 #139
That's too awesome to go unapplauded renate Feb 2016 #169
Good, it is settled and e-mailed to spread around..thanks. Jefferson23 Feb 2016 #122
Thank you. cali Feb 2016 #130
KnR nt 99th_Monkey Feb 2016 #124
K & R! TIME TO PANIC Feb 2016 #137
That is OBVIOUSLY Bernie Sanders in that photo! raging moderate Feb 2016 #142
Another K & R Duppers Feb 2016 #147
How did Time and WaPo both decide this photo was so important DirkGently Feb 2016 #148
Same reason for the anti-Gary Webb editorials in NYT, WaPo, LA Times ON SAME DAY... Eleanors38 Feb 2016 #154
Time mag's claim repeated this A.M. on NPR. Eleanors38 Feb 2016 #152
Rovian politics...why would the photographer lie? EndElectoral Feb 2016 #159
Has Time and WaPo apologized yet? EndElectoral Feb 2016 #162
I think they should apologize Rosa Luxemburg Feb 2016 #175
Electing a President whose genetilia "make history"... MadDAsHell Feb 2016 #164
I thought this was debanked months ago Jack Rabbit Feb 2016 #165
Important story Land Shark Feb 2016 #166
I was overjoyed when Tweetie admitted the whole thing was a lie. Oh, wait. That didn't happen? mikehiggins Feb 2016 #167
Kick and R BeanMusical Feb 2016 #173
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Celebrated Photographer: ...»Reply #0