HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Topics » Religion & Spirituality » Religion (Group) » Ancient Confession Found:... » Reply #63
Introducing Discussionist: A new forum by the creators of DU

Response to leveymg (Reply #52)

Wed Oct 9, 2013, 11:54 PM

63. The Way That the Romans Spread Religious Pacificism

was by promoting emperor worship along with Roman gods and holidays. A divine savior was a potential competitor.

Jesus seems to have been regarded as a potential revolutionary as shown by his arrest and method of execution. Since revolution was known to run in families, Domitian had Jesus' grandnephews dragged in to see if they were dangerous. They were dismissed as hapless rubes, which seems to be largely how Christians were perceived except when their refusal to sacrifice to the emperor got them sent to the gladitorial ring, as recounted in sources like Perpetua's diary.

Atwill seems to do what a lot of people do who charge others with not reading the Bible -- fail to read it himself. The Gospels are shot through with angry condemnations, calls for divine judgement, and prophecies of destruction which are utterly alien to anything Josephus or the Romans would have wanted to spread. I can't see Mark 13 fitting into this scenario at all along with a lot of other passages.

Personally, I don't think Jesus was violent during his lifetime, but I do not know if he would have become violent in the event of an uprising -- he might have felt called to lead the revolt and been more like a bar Kosibah figure. Or he might have remained more like his brother James, alternating among benevolence, mysticism, and vicious denunciations.

I really do appreciate Atwill's bringing the kind of political perspective that he does. I believe it is more useful, however, to abandon the invented Jesus portion of the theory along with the Josephus speculation and apply those insights to the realm where it would have taken place -- namely the Jewish political and religious hierarchies who were constantly trying to quell the kind of rebellion that eventually led to national ruin. For example, you could take the approach that the Sermon on the Mount was added later as a pacifistic element by Paul's followers. Many of the sayings in Matthew 4-6 are similar to teachings of people like Hillel the Elder, who was an accomodationist with Rome and a favorite of the upper classes. That line of thinking might be worth developing.

Atwill hasn't really done the homework necessary to propose a different authorship for the Gospels. The complex relationship between the four books has been studied for about a century and a half and is well established. You don't just read a list of place names in Josephus and say the Gospels were all made up by the same author. Even if he is seeing a legitimate influence, there are more likely alternatives such as a 2nd-century date for the Gospels which would allow for an influence by Josephus's writings. That is less sensational but more likely.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 95 replies Author Time Post
cleanhippie Oct 2013 OP
fitman Oct 2013 #1
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #5
fitman Oct 2013 #7
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #11
fitman Oct 2013 #17
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #18
roguevalley Oct 2013 #57
mmonk Oct 2013 #77
Schema Thing Oct 2013 #2
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #6
immoderate Oct 2013 #3
AnotherMcIntosh Oct 2013 #4
russspeakeasy Oct 2013 #9
Champion Jack Oct 2013 #8
Agnosticsherbet Oct 2013 #10
mindwalker_i Oct 2013 #12
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #15
Warren Stupidity Oct 2013 #20
mindwalker_i Oct 2013 #22
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #31
truebluegreen Oct 2013 #56
mindwalker_i Oct 2013 #62
boomer55 Oct 2013 #13
Welibs Oct 2013 #14
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #16
Warren Stupidity Oct 2013 #21
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #23
Warren Stupidity Oct 2013 #24
backscatter712 Oct 2013 #73
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #74
fitman Oct 2013 #19
On the Road Oct 2013 #79
Dorian Gray Oct 2013 #25
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #26
cbayer Oct 2013 #27
Turbineguy Oct 2013 #28
riqster Oct 2013 #29
stopbush Oct 2013 #30
rug Oct 2013 #32
UrbScotty Oct 2013 #33
cbayer Oct 2013 #34
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #36
muriel_volestrangler Oct 2013 #47
cbayer Oct 2013 #48
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #35
rug Oct 2013 #37
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #38
rug Oct 2013 #39
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #43
UTUSN Oct 2013 #78
On the Road Oct 2013 #40
dimbear Oct 2013 #44
On the Road Oct 2013 #55
dimbear Oct 2013 #64
On the Road Oct 2013 #69
dimbear Oct 2013 #75
Pab Sungenis Oct 2013 #76
leveymg Oct 2013 #52
LineLineLineReply The Way That the Romans Spread Religious Pacificism
On the Road Oct 2013 #63
hrmjustin Oct 2013 #41
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #42
dimbear Oct 2013 #45
truebluegreen Oct 2013 #54
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #65
dimbear Oct 2013 #67
Manifestor_of_Light Oct 2013 #46
okasha Oct 2013 #87
Humanist_Activist Oct 2013 #49
AnotherMcIntosh Oct 2013 #58
Humanist_Activist Oct 2013 #68
AnotherMcIntosh Oct 2013 #70
Humanist_Activist Oct 2013 #71
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #50
AnotherMcIntosh Oct 2013 #59
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #60
AnotherMcIntosh Oct 2013 #66
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #72
grantcart Oct 2013 #84
rug Oct 2013 #85
Deep13 Oct 2013 #51
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #61
okasha Oct 2013 #90
eShirl Oct 2013 #53
Deep13 Oct 2013 #93
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #80
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #81
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #82
rug Oct 2013 #83
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #91
dimbear Oct 2013 #92
rug Oct 2013 #94
dimbear Oct 2013 #95
skepticscott Oct 2013 #86
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #88
skepticscott Oct 2013 #89
Please login to view edit histories.