HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Topics » Religion & Spirituality » Religion (Group) » Ancient Confession Found:... » Reply #40

Response to cleanhippie (Original post)

Wed Oct 9, 2013, 03:36 PM

40. If Josephus wanted to invent Christianity,

he was a bit late to the game -- Paul beat him by several decades. The core of Paul's letters is universally considered genuine and placed in the 50s and 60s.

I would be interested in seeing how Atwill lines up the events in Josephus which supposedly prove that the Gospels are derivative. A lot of ancient itineraries are determined by the terrain and limited road structure. Galilee-Samaris-Judea was along one north-south axis. Certainly Titus followed the same roads and stopped at the same places that Jesus did going from Galilee to Jerusalem -- because everybody did. (It would be like saying "What an incredible coincidence -- I stopped at Breezewod, Pennsylvania too!")

Now, the motivations Atwill attributes to the Romans were real. They certainly wanted a pacified population and would not stoop to religious manipulation. They deified their emperors. However, a divine Christ was also a potential competitor to the Emperor. If it came from anwhere in the political power structure, it is likely to have originated in the Jewish vassal state.

If Atwill had wanted to develop that theory, he really should have looked in the direction of Paul. Paul was apparently a member of Herod's clan and had a vested interest in the status quo. You could argue that Paul built the Christian church as a Roman-inspired secret society specifically to provide an alternative to zealot groups that posed a real threat. It is certainly no accident that Paul's church took an unthreatening form, although maybe not as the result of the kind of deliberate machinations he imagines.

Not enough scholars IMO look at Biblical history in terms of general historical and political patterns like this. I appreciate Atwill raising the issue in terms of the New Testament. I just think that government attempts to pacify the population through religious belief are universal and continuous, and that there are more likely ways that this might have influenced early Christianity than the unlikely one Atwill has constructed.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 95 replies Author Time Post
cleanhippie Oct 2013 OP
fitman Oct 2013 #1
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #5
fitman Oct 2013 #7
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #11
fitman Oct 2013 #17
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #18
roguevalley Oct 2013 #57
mmonk Oct 2013 #77
Schema Thing Oct 2013 #2
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #6
immoderate Oct 2013 #3
AnotherMcIntosh Oct 2013 #4
russspeakeasy Oct 2013 #9
Champion Jack Oct 2013 #8
Agnosticsherbet Oct 2013 #10
mindwalker_i Oct 2013 #12
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #15
Warren Stupidity Oct 2013 #20
mindwalker_i Oct 2013 #22
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #31
truebluegreen Oct 2013 #56
mindwalker_i Oct 2013 #62
boomer55 Oct 2013 #13
Welibs Oct 2013 #14
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #16
Warren Stupidity Oct 2013 #21
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #23
Warren Stupidity Oct 2013 #24
backscatter712 Oct 2013 #73
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #74
fitman Oct 2013 #19
On the Road Oct 2013 #79
Dorian Gray Oct 2013 #25
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #26
cbayer Oct 2013 #27
Turbineguy Oct 2013 #28
riqster Oct 2013 #29
stopbush Oct 2013 #30
rug Oct 2013 #32
UrbScotty Oct 2013 #33
cbayer Oct 2013 #34
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #36
muriel_volestrangler Oct 2013 #47
cbayer Oct 2013 #48
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #35
rug Oct 2013 #37
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #38
rug Oct 2013 #39
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #43
UTUSN Oct 2013 #78
LineReply If Josephus wanted to invent Christianity,
On the Road Oct 2013 #40
dimbear Oct 2013 #44
On the Road Oct 2013 #55
dimbear Oct 2013 #64
On the Road Oct 2013 #69
dimbear Oct 2013 #75
Pab Sungenis Oct 2013 #76
leveymg Oct 2013 #52
On the Road Oct 2013 #63
hrmjustin Oct 2013 #41
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #42
dimbear Oct 2013 #45
truebluegreen Oct 2013 #54
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #65
dimbear Oct 2013 #67
Manifestor_of_Light Oct 2013 #46
okasha Oct 2013 #87
Humanist_Activist Oct 2013 #49
AnotherMcIntosh Oct 2013 #58
Humanist_Activist Oct 2013 #68
AnotherMcIntosh Oct 2013 #70
Humanist_Activist Oct 2013 #71
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #50
AnotherMcIntosh Oct 2013 #59
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #60
AnotherMcIntosh Oct 2013 #66
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #72
grantcart Oct 2013 #84
rug Oct 2013 #85
Deep13 Oct 2013 #51
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #61
okasha Oct 2013 #90
eShirl Oct 2013 #53
Deep13 Oct 2013 #93
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #80
cleanhippie Oct 2013 #81
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #82
rug Oct 2013 #83
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #91
dimbear Oct 2013 #92
rug Oct 2013 #94
dimbear Oct 2013 #95
skepticscott Oct 2013 #86
struggle4progress Oct 2013 #88
skepticscott Oct 2013 #89
Please login to view edit histories.