Reply #7

In the discussion thread: Lincoln Was An Atheist [View all]

Response to Thats my opinion (Reply #4)

Wed May 2, 2012, 12:45 PM

laconicsax (14,860 posts)

7. Holy crap! I didn't realize you were THAT old!

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

38 replies	Author	Time	Post
Lincoln Was An Atheist [View all]	rug	May 2012	OP
and, apparently, a vampire hunter. n/t	Goblinmonger	May 2012	#1
and GAY!	AlbertCat	May 2012	#19
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!	Joseph8th	May 2012	#25
In all truth maybe he was m,aybe he wasn't.	dmallind	May 2012	#2
Great post. Lincoln also had no electricity or elevators for his cars.	Lint Head	May 2012	#3
Lincoln was a bona fide member of the church I served.	Thats my opinion	May 2012	#4
Sounds like a Mormon posthumous baptism.	trotsky	May 2012	#5
Lighten up!	Thats my opinion	May 2012	#8
That you do not see the arrogance and presumption in this...	trotsky	May 2012	#9
Yup. nt	Joseph8th	May 2012	#26
He may have been a fit, but he probably would (may) not have joined your congregation.	cleanhippie	May 2012	#30
I do not think	Goblinmonger	May 2012	#6
Holy crap! I didn't realize you were THAT old!	laconicsax	May 2012	#7
Whoa. The first Republican president was Lincoln. The Republican Party didn't even	dimbear	May 2012	#10
His law partner, Herndon, claimed that Abe was an atheist.	PassingFair	May 2012	#11
Abraham Lincoln attended the New York Ave. Presbyterian Church in DC	kwassa	May 2012	#12
And clearly, if one attends a church, they MUST be a Christian and not an atheist.	trotsky	May 2012	#13
Oh, SNAP!	Goblinmonger	May 2012	#14
Uh, didn't you claim to be a history teacher?	kwassa	May 2012	#18
Nope. Wrong discipline.	Goblinmonger	May 2012	#21
and when have I done that, Mr. Logic?	kwassa	May 2012	#22
By your anecdote that you sat in Lincoln's pew at a church he attended.	Goblinmonger	May 2012	#31
No, I offered additional proof which you have ignored.	kwassa	May 2012	#32
One of the problems with religion is ...	Joseph8th	May 2012	#27
On the fun chart of logical errors,. I counted 8 on this one alone. nt	Thats my opinion	May 2012	#15
Congrats, tell kwassa!	trotsky	May 2012	#16
Who said Hitler was an atheist? Not me. And since you know little about Lincoln ..	kwassa	May 2012	#17
You have maintained that Hitler was NOT a Christian.	trotsky	May 2012	#20
In my opinion, Hitler was not a Christian. That is still my opinion.	kwassa	May 2012	#23
So what is your definition of a Christian? (nt)	eqfan592	May 2012	#24
The Real Christians argument again? Really?	Joseph8th	May 2012	#28
Please post in a state of sobriety.	kwassa	May 2012	#33
There are also quotes from people with personal knowledge of Hitler, who claim he was a Christian.	trotsky	May 2012	#29
A logical trap? Not your strong suit.	kwassa	May 2012	#34
You don't even know when you invoke logical fallacy. I don't think you're the one	darkstar3	May 2012	#37
I see you've dropped any attempt to defend your failed logic.	trotsky	May 2012	#38
are there really any true Christians??	Angry Dragon	May 2012	#35
Nope. I've asked that question countless times here,	darkstar3	May 2012	#36

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.