HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Topics » Religion & Spirituality » Religion (Group) » What's your thoughts on t... » Reply #179
Introducing Discussionist: A new forum by the creators of DU

Response to edhopper (Original post)

Mon Dec 30, 2013, 10:27 AM

179. I Believe Jesus Existed

but pretty much dismiss all of the nativity stories, including the jerry-rigged trip to Judea to bring in the star prophecy.

I pay more attention to the earliest known beliefs of the Ebionites, since that movement descended directly from Jesus' family. Apparently, they did not believe in Jesus' virgin birth, resurrection, or divinity. In the 3rd-4th century, Eusebius joked that they they were referred to as 'the poor' because they had such a 'poor' opinion of Jesus.

All the Christmas stuff we're familiar with, including the manger, wise men, shepards, angels and the rest, was probably written by people much later who were not there. Some people even believe that Paul thought of Jesus more as an eternal heavenly figure rather than a man, and that many gospel stories were written allegorically and never meant to be seen as historical events.

Jesus apparently was from the part of Galilee near Capernaum. However, his brother became a prominent priest in the temple in Jerusalem on the other end of the country. How that happened is not known, but it could be very important for understanding how and where the two of them were born and grew up.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 192 replies Author Time Post
edhopper Dec 2013 OP
elocs Dec 2013 #1
edhopper Dec 2013 #3
riqster Dec 2013 #2
edhopper Dec 2013 #5
riqster Dec 2013 #7
truebluegreen Dec 2013 #9
R. Daneel Olivaw Dec 2013 #4
riqster Dec 2013 #8
cbayer Dec 2013 #15
intaglio Dec 2013 #14
R. Daneel Olivaw Dec 2013 #98
BeyondGeography Dec 2013 #6
OffWithTheirHeads Dec 2013 #10
intaglio Dec 2013 #16
OffWithTheirHeads Dec 2013 #17
msongs Dec 2013 #11
edhopper Dec 2013 #12
cbayer Dec 2013 #13
skepticscott Dec 2013 #19
kwassa Dec 2013 #23
skepticscott Dec 2013 #24
kwassa Dec 2013 #28
skepticscott Dec 2013 #32
kwassa Dec 2013 #34
skepticscott Dec 2013 #36
kwassa Dec 2013 #37
skepticscott Dec 2013 #54
cbayer Dec 2013 #25
kwassa Dec 2013 #29
cbayer Dec 2013 #30
kwassa Dec 2013 #31
840high Dec 2013 #159
trotsky Dec 2013 #40
rug Dec 2013 #41
okasha Dec 2013 #74
edhopper Dec 2013 #42
okasha Dec 2013 #61
edhopper Dec 2013 #64
hrmjustin Dec 2013 #67
edhopper Dec 2013 #69
hrmjustin Dec 2013 #70
hrmjustin Dec 2013 #65
edhopper Dec 2013 #71
hrmjustin Dec 2013 #72
edhopper Dec 2013 #78
skepticscott Dec 2013 #49
hrmjustin Dec 2013 #18
Niceguy1 Dec 2013 #20
rug Dec 2013 #21
pinto Dec 2013 #22
IphengeniaBlumgarten Dec 2013 #26
pinto Dec 2013 #27
okasha Dec 2013 #33
enki23 Dec 2013 #157
okasha Dec 2013 #161
edhopper Dec 2013 #163
enki23 Dec 2013 #166
edhopper Dec 2013 #168
okasha Dec 2013 #169
edhopper Dec 2013 #170
edhopper Dec 2013 #172
Shadowflash Dec 2013 #180
Act_of_Reparation Dec 2013 #182
el_bryanto Dec 2013 #35
spin Dec 2013 #183
goldent Dec 2013 #38
edhopper Dec 2013 #39
goldent Dec 2013 #43
trotsky Dec 2013 #44
edhopper Dec 2013 #45
goldent Dec 2013 #51
okasha Dec 2013 #59
arely staircase Dec 2013 #174
edhopper Dec 2013 #177
arely staircase Dec 2013 #181
edhopper Dec 2013 #184
cbayer Dec 2013 #185
arely staircase Dec 2013 #186
edhopper Dec 2013 #187
arely staircase Dec 2013 #188
edhopper Dec 2013 #189
arely staircase Dec 2013 #190
edhopper Dec 2013 #191
arely staircase Dec 2013 #192
cbayer Dec 2013 #46
edhopper Dec 2013 #47
cbayer Dec 2013 #53
edhopper Dec 2013 #57
cbayer Dec 2013 #58
edhopper Dec 2013 #60
cbayer Dec 2013 #62
trotsky Dec 2013 #66
edhopper Dec 2013 #68
cbayer Dec 2013 #73
edhopper Dec 2013 #75
cbayer Dec 2013 #77
edhopper Dec 2013 #81
cbayer Dec 2013 #82
eomer Dec 2013 #101
cbayer Dec 2013 #102
trotsky Dec 2013 #103
eomer Dec 2013 #104
cbayer Dec 2013 #106
eomer Dec 2013 #108
cbayer Dec 2013 #109
eomer Dec 2013 #110
edhopper Dec 2013 #111
cbayer Dec 2013 #113
trotsky Dec 2013 #114
rug Dec 2013 #115
cbayer Dec 2013 #112
eomer Dec 2013 #116
cbayer Dec 2013 #117
eomer Dec 2013 #118
cbayer Dec 2013 #122
eomer Dec 2013 #123
cbayer Dec 2013 #126
trotsky Dec 2013 #128
Act_of_Reparation Dec 2013 #97
okasha Dec 2013 #63
edhopper Dec 2013 #76
cbayer Dec 2013 #79
edhopper Dec 2013 #83
cbayer Dec 2013 #86
edhopper Dec 2013 #90
cbayer Dec 2013 #92
edhopper Dec 2013 #94
cbayer Dec 2013 #95
edhopper Dec 2013 #96
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #121
cbayer Dec 2013 #124
edhopper Dec 2013 #127
cbayer Dec 2013 #129
edhopper Dec 2013 #151
cbayer Dec 2013 #153
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #134
cbayer Dec 2013 #136
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #137
cbayer Dec 2013 #139
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #140
cbayer Dec 2013 #143
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #144
cbayer Dec 2013 #146
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #148
cbayer Dec 2013 #150
cleanhippie Dec 2013 #165
pinto Dec 2013 #87
edhopper Dec 2013 #89
pinto Dec 2013 #91
edhopper Dec 2013 #93
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #120
cbayer Dec 2013 #125
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #135
cbayer Dec 2013 #138
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #142
cbayer Dec 2013 #145
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #147
cbayer Dec 2013 #149
goldent Dec 2013 #105
cbayer Dec 2013 #107
Warren Stupidity Dec 2013 #141
edhopper Dec 2013 #152
Leontius Dec 2013 #154
okasha Dec 2013 #155
goldent Dec 2013 #156
edhopper Dec 2013 #158
goldent Dec 2013 #162
cleanhippie Dec 2013 #167
hrmjustin Dec 2013 #48
skepticscott Dec 2013 #50
hrmjustin Dec 2013 #52
AtheistCrusader Dec 2013 #119
darkangel218 Dec 2013 #55
hrmjustin Dec 2013 #56
NaturalHigh Dec 2013 #80
edhopper Dec 2013 #84
NaturalHigh Dec 2013 #85
edhopper Dec 2013 #88
NaturalHigh Dec 2013 #99
edhopper Dec 2013 #100
Marblehead Dec 2013 #130
madrchsod Dec 2013 #131
larkrake Dec 2013 #132
cbayer Dec 2013 #133
edhopper Dec 2013 #171
840high Dec 2013 #160
edhopper Dec 2013 #164
arely staircase Dec 2013 #173
edhopper Dec 2013 #175
arely staircase Dec 2013 #176
saltpoint Dec 2013 #178
LineReply I Believe Jesus Existed
On the Road Dec 2013 #179
Please login to view edit histories.