Reply #58

In the discussion thread: Oral Arguments in Illinois Carry Case (Shepard v. Madigan) [View all]

Sun Jun 10, 2012, 11:30 PM

58. It hasn't come into play lately, but it's quite apparent.

Last edited Sun Jun 10, 2012, 11:52 PM USA/ET - Edit history (1)

It would be unconstitutional for any civil or military authority to require me to host soldiers in my home in peacetime. I have the right to refuse them, and if they commandeer my house anyway, I can file a valid lawsuit alleging violation of my 3A right.

Now, you said "Let's analyze the relevance to modern American life of the 3A too." It's not "too" unless you give me an example of when I could sue over violation of my 2A right.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

84 replies	Author	Time	Post
Oral Arguments in Illinois Carry Case (Shepard v. Madigan) [View all]	TPaine7	Jun 2012	OP
Guns and ammo in the hands of the public is a menace.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#1
Good luck with that.	TheWraith	Jun 2012	#2
The science is that bullets kill and maim.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#3
True, but for anyone keeping score at home this is the 2nd 'Ban Them All'	petronius	Jun 2012	#7
Indeed the trolls are busy today.	ProgressiveProfessor	Jun 2012	#29
Alert and send it to a jury	shadowrider	Jun 2012	#37
Since Heller/McDonald, criminalizing them is going to require a Constitutional amendment	Glaug-Eldare	Jun 2012	#4
Nah it just needs a different composition of SCOTUS.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#5
Do you think Obama will appoint justices that disagree with his stated position? n/t	TPaine7	Jun 2012	#6
He evolves.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#9
I have evolved. I once opposed the RKBA as did Obama.	TPaine7	Jun 2012	#11
Did you suffer some lack of oxygen to your brain?	Loudly	Jun 2012	#14
So, is it your position that our president, who took the same path, also devolved?!	TPaine7	Jun 2012	#19
If he said it to secure the lunatic vote, I'll cut him the slack he needs.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#20
Chicago is a gun free paradise (or it was before MacDonald). How would Obama	TPaine7	Jun 2012	#22
Chicago borders on Indiana.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#44
Your usual answer Shares.	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#45
You asked why Chicago suffered from gun crime despite the ban.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#47
Chicago suffers from gun crime	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#49
Can blacks marry whites? Can men marry men? Can women marry women?	Loudly	Jun 2012	#51
Times do change	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#52
The gun worshipping state I grew up in	gejohnston	Jun 2012	#54
Hmmmm... "from sea to shining sea." Now where have I heard that before?	TPaine7	Jun 2012	#56
He's bound and determined to get Prohibition 3.0 going.	friendly_iconoclast	Jun 2012	#64
Shares, you're recycling your own post from two years ago:	friendly_iconoclast	Jun 2012	#63
I do hope that you mean to ban ALL GUNS...no military, no police. NO GUNS FOR ANYONE AT ALL	Tuesday Afternoon	Jun 2012	#79
do you know this for a fact?	gejohnston	Jun 2012	#46
Spare me. They sell to Hoosiers who bring them over.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#48
Pot	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#50
there is only one poster feigning obtuseness and it is not you. n/t	Tuesday Afternoon	Jun 2012	#80
That is also a federal crime.	gejohnston	Jun 2012	#53
And your evidence of that is ... where?	DonP	Jun 2012	#84
Ahhhhhh	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#26
Chicago banned handguns up until McDonald v Chicago	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#30
So when you changed from sharesunited, was it evolution, devolution or metamorphosis?	friendly_iconoclast	Jun 2012	#40
Now you're being a true Progressive...	ileus	Jun 2012	#66
Obama has evolved on this issue, just like many here and wants to leave the issue alone.	ProgressiveProfessor	Jun 2012	#42
And in McDonald, Stevens cited the absurd Cruikshank decision as his rationale	Glaug-Eldare	Jun 2012	#8
The 2A has been deliberately misinterpreted.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#10
That is true.	TPaine7	Jun 2012	#13
Access to guns and ammo is the problem.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#15
Well it seems the courts, the people, and the legislators	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#31
so that would mean	armueller2001	Jun 2012	#38
This message was self-deleted by its author	Clames	Jun 2012	#16
What do you believe the 2nd Amendment protects, in that case?	Glaug-Eldare	Jun 2012	#21
Sure. Let's analyze the relevance to modern American life of the 3A too.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#43
The Third Amendment is very important.	TPaine7	Jun 2012	#55
The 2A enabled slavery and the American Civil War.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#57
The 2A enabled slavery and the American Civil War?	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#59
I get the feeling we'd argue quite bitterly on that subject.	Glaug-Eldare	Jun 2012	#61
huh?	gejohnston	Jun 2012	#62
Ri-i-i-i-i-ght..... n/t	PavePusher	Jun 2012	#70
2A and the Civil War: a classic Shares meme.	Straw Man	Jun 2012	#81
It hasn't come into play lately, but it's quite apparent.	Glaug-Eldare	Jun 2012	#58
Oh look, Shares is back.	Clames	Jun 2012	#12
Laugh at loss and grief and suffering.	Loudly	Jun 2012	#17
Just laughing at you.	Clames	Jun 2012	#18
For those that post a personal attack on	safeinOhio	Jun 2012	#24
Oh yeah	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#27
Pot kettles black again.	Clames	Jun 2012	#32
I could be wrong	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#33
I am sometimes guilty of	safeinOhio	Jun 2012	#34
Wrong again.	Clames	Jun 2012	#65
Right.	safeinOhio	Jun 2012	#67
Back atcha buddy	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#68
I only make personal comments about a DU	safeinOhio	Jun 2012	#69
If textual analysis has any validity at all, DUer Loudly is in fact, former DUer sharesunited.	friendly_iconoclast	Jun 2012	#71
Once again, wrong.	Clames	Jun 2012	#72
So now you are making fun of my race?	safeinOhio	Jun 2012	#73
Huh? n/t	Glaug-Eldare	Jun 2012	#74
Don't bother	safeinOhio	Jun 2012	#75
bad thing about homophones	gejohnston	Jun 2012	#76
Try this from WIKI. It is NOT a racial slur.	oneshooter	Jun 2012	#77
Fine with me.	Clames	Jun 2012	#78
You are kidding, right?	hack89	Jun 2012	#82
You've got to be kidding us right?	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#83
I was wondering why I hadn't seen that posted for a while.	ileus	Jun 2012	#36
welcome to du. enjoy your stay. have a nice day.	Tuesday Afternoon	Jun 2012	#23
So tell us	SGMRTDARMY	Jun 2012	#25
Not to worry, many of us will strenuously oppose your position	ProgressiveProfessor	Jun 2012	#28
So what about all the people who saved their lives or the lived of loved ones with guns and ammo?	Atypical Liberal	Jun 2012	#39
Let's hope this removes power from the 1% and restores it to the 99%	ileus	Jun 2012	#35
A short synopsis would have been nice.	Logical	Jun 2012	#41
I agree. (n/t)	spin	Jun 2012	#60

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.