Reply #73

In the discussion thread: How do you rank second amendment rights? [View all]

Response to Hoyt (Reply #71)

Sun Dec 18, 2011, 10:32 PM

PavePusher (15,374 posts)

73. What, on your say-so? Snort. n/t

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

99 replies	Author	Time	Post
How do you rank second amendment rights? [View all]	digonswine	Dec 2011	OP
You're likely referring to my post.	We_Have_A_Problem	Dec 2011	#1
No--I was not referring to your post--	digonswine	Dec 2011	#5
Fair enough....	We_Have_A_Problem	Dec 2011	#7
The idea that you can support your right to marry, etc--	digonswine	Dec 2011	#9
How exactly do you think we gained ours as a nation?	We_Have_A_Problem	Dec 2011	#11
Are you saying that we can exert our will--	digonswine	Dec 2011	#12
Like it or not...yes.	We_Have_A_Problem	Dec 2011	#14
I have not noticed-	digonswine	Dec 2011	#17
Then you're not paying attention.	We_Have_A_Problem	Dec 2011	#18
I am not certain-	digonswine	Dec 2011	#23
Why should public officials have any better protection than the average Citizen?	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#25
Are you saying that the president should NOT have a better security detail than I should?	digonswine	Dec 2011	#30
I'm saying (admittedly a bit hyperbolically) that the pres has a very large and tight security detal	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#32
This post was hidden by jury decision.	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#24
Because right now-and all the lessons of history-	digonswine	Dec 2011	#31
I think it's one of a number of reasons.	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#33
We are no longer fighting the war for independence--	digonswine	Dec 2011	#19
You are only half correct.	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#27
The War of Independence wasn't so much an event	DissedByBush	Dec 2011	#36
I can't say that all rights are equal; I just don't know...	SteveW	Dec 2011	#2
Good post--	digonswine	Dec 2011	#15
You might find the idea of single issue voters nuts..	MicaelS	Dec 2011	#26
This is nuts-	digonswine	Dec 2011	#28
You're right. The Libyans had it all wrong.	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#29
Oh puleeze	fightthegoodfightnow	Dec 2011	#38
Please drop a line to the Taliban, they seem to have missed a memo.	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#41
Don't forget the North Vietnamese either, they didn't know they couldn;t win. ntxt	DonP	Dec 2011	#43
Thanks for Proving My Point	fightthegoodfightnow	Dec 2011	#49
And yet they tie up 150K troops of the best trained, equiped and led military in history.	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#52
You want to overthrow with guns	fightthegoodfightnow	Dec 2011	#53
history lesson	gejohnston	Dec 2011	#56
I refer you back to the last sentance of my post. n/t	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#67
They are leaving in droves to form the Illusionist Party	Starboard Tack	Dec 2011	#77
Thanks for the complement...	SteveW	Dec 2011	#68
I like the positioning of the BOR	MicaelS	Dec 2011	#3
me too.	Tuesday Afternoon	Dec 2011	#4
I do not have a problem with bearing arms--	digonswine	Dec 2011	#20
It's OK, but why is it very important?	Starboard Tack	Dec 2011	#78
define police state	gejohnston	Dec 2011	#79
In France it is a right to own, but illegal to bear.	Starboard Tack	Dec 2011	#96
Lets look at your list a little closer shall we?	We_Have_A_Problem	Dec 2011	#80
Sure. No cameras in this country. Maybe not where you live.	Starboard Tack	Dec 2011	#94
You don't get it do you?	We_Have_A_Problem	Dec 2011	#98
+1000 (n/t)	spin	Dec 2011	#13
I think the BoR should have been prefaced with "In no particular order..." n/t	DissedByBush	Dec 2011	#37
So You Like The BOR Positioning, Do You?	Paladin	Dec 2011	#48
One is stated in the BoR, one is implied	DissedByBush	Dec 2011	#6
It may indeed be pointless-	digonswine	Dec 2011	#8
I have a hard time ranking rights	DissedByBush	Dec 2011	#10
Most important	michreject	Dec 2011	#16
I disagree as I explained here:	TPaine7	Dec 2011	#21
interesting point.	Tuesday Afternoon	Dec 2011	#22
At the end of a continuum of force. nt	rrneck	Dec 2011	#34
I'd rank second amendment rights as being the most important.	Pacafishmate	Dec 2011	#35
How many times have you been shot at in this country?	Hoyt	Dec 2011	#40
I rank second amendment rights right down there with state's rights . . . . . to discriminate.	Hoyt	Dec 2011	#39
When you start picking and choosing Civil Rights...	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#42
I wish you guys would learn the distinction between Civil Rights and Civil Liberties.	Hoyt	Dec 2011	#46
Bill of Rights. Constitutional Right.	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#47
But not a "civil right." So stop trying to hitch your poor pitiful gun plight to that movement.	Hoyt	Dec 2011	#50
So, none of the Bill of Rights is a "civil" Right?	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#54
Sadly, Civil Rights came much later than the Constitution -- not in the "Bill of Rights."	Hoyt	Dec 2011	#71
Sadly, Civil Rights came much later than the Constitution	gejohnston	Dec 2011	#72
What, on your say-so? Snort. n/t	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#73
Civil liberties are one's core rights - they stand above civil rights nt	hack89	Dec 2011	#63
All Civil Rights are equal and mutually supporting.	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#44
You have to stay alive before you can exercise any other right.	ileus	Dec 2011	#45
Gun ownership is not a civil right.	DanTex	Dec 2011	#51
Well Said	fightthegoodfightnow	Dec 2011	#55
individual right	gejohnston	Dec 2011	#57
Nicely Put, DanTex.	Paladin	Dec 2011	#58
Well said.	AlinPA	Dec 2011	#59
You either know better or you should	TPaine7	Dec 2011	#60
Well, 2A was in fact intended to prevent the...	DanTex	Dec 2011	#65
You either know better or you should	TPaine7	Dec 2011	#74
Well, I'm glad you came out and flatly denied that 2A was intended to prevent the...	DanTex	Dec 2011	#75
your argument completely falls apart	gejohnston	Dec 2011	#76
I'll grant that you personally are not prone to hyperbole and extremism on the second amendment.	DanTex	Dec 2011	#97
In order to preserve the well regulated militia, the Second Amendment forbad the government	TPaine7	Dec 2011	#81
Wow, you guys really can't stray even an inch from the gunner talking points, can you!	DanTex	Dec 2011	#89
See post 88. On second thought, your "philosophy" was just too funny to leave alone. Bye now.	TPaine7	Dec 2011	#90
this has what to do with me?	gejohnston	Dec 2011	#91
I'm aware that you have traveled and are familiar with a lot of different...	DanTex	Dec 2011	#93
Thats a hell of an assumption.	We_Have_A_Problem	Dec 2011	#99
Yeah, I've travelled to Europe and Canada and other countires too. Multiple times.	TPaine7	Dec 2011	#95
"Philosophy" or "the most important point to me"	TPaine7	Dec 2011	#88
Ahh, logical ineptitude in all it's glory. Bravo!	DanTex	Dec 2011	#92
"Red Dawn fantasies notwithstanding"	ellisonz	Dec 2011	#83
Condescension and insults	We_Have_A_Problem	Dec 2011	#84
I think it's more an attempt at humor.	ellisonz	Dec 2011	#85
And like your attempt at an argument...	We_Have_A_Problem	Dec 2011	#86
Whatever you say...	ellisonz	Dec 2011	#87
So every right enumerated in the BOR is an individual right except the 2nd?	hack89	Dec 2011	#64
Your analogies suck.	PavePusher	Dec 2011	#66
Your argument hinges on an "obsolete" outlook...	SteveW	Dec 2011	#69
Occupy the Gungeon.	ellisonz	Dec 2011	#82
No enumerated/protected rights should be given more weight over other enumerated/protected rights.	OneTenthofOnePercent	Dec 2011	#61
The scond amendment	41mag	Dec 2011	#62
And Arizona had to follow the hoary, hairy behind of Vermont!	SteveW	Dec 2011	#70

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.