Reply #61

In the discussion thread: It is this simple regarding 9/11...NO ONE has ever came forward and said 'I was part of it!".... [View all]

Response to Logical (Original post)

Thu Mar 22, 2012, 01:47 PM

Shagman (135 posts)

61. a little context

Did anyone ever come forward to "confess" to the Iran-Contra scheme? Do members of organized crime ever spontaneously admit they've broken the law? Any conspiracy on this scale wouldn't have sprung into being overnight, it would be an operation put forward, handled, and kept quiet by people who do that sort of thing every day. Is it a coincidence that GHW Bush was once head of the CIA?

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

118 replies	Author	Time	Post
It is this simple regarding 9/11...NO ONE has ever came forward and said 'I was part of it!".... [View all]	Logical	Dec 2011	OP
logical fallacy n/t	ottobahn	Dec 2011	#1
What logical fallacy?	cpwm17	Dec 2011	#4
the logical fallacy of argumentum e silentio (argument from silence)	stockholmer	Aug 2012	#102
The OP's argument is legitimate.	cpwm17	Aug 2012	#105
Well I see that you're not going to be able to ever respond	cpwm17	Aug 2012	#107
Wow... Stockholmer got canned.	Quantess	Aug 2012	#111
I believe it was for accusing the wrong country in a BS Kennedy assassination theory...	cpwm17	Aug 2012	#112
LOL......that was a very detailed answer. Thanks!	Logical	Dec 2011	#2
Do you think Homeopathy is a scam? n/t	ottobahn	Dec 2011	#3
Yes, most of it. I saw a guy, at a speech, take a whole bottle of "GNC" sleeping pills before the...	Logical	Dec 2011	#5
So if you believe homeopathy is a scam,	ottobahn	Dec 2011	#6
You do not think I can find consumers of Homeopathy who say it is a scam? Seriously?	Logical	Dec 2011	#7
I'm talking people involved with it that would know it was a scam, not	ottobahn	Dec 2011	#8
The difference is that.......	Logical	Dec 2011	#11
But if Homeopathy is a scam, there's got to be scammers involved	ottobahn	Dec 2011	#14
There's no comparison to potential 9-11 conspirators	cpwm17	Dec 2011	#17
If homeopathy is out in the open, seems more easy to out those who would know it's a scam.	ottobahn	Dec 2011	#18
how could anyone PROVE that homeopathy is a scam?	OnTheOtherHand	Dec 2011	#21
Not a scam as in ripping people off. A scam in it does not work.	Logical	Dec 2011	#19
It's not the same thing. Homeopathy can rely on the placebo effect.	chrisa	Jan 2012	#38
I know	BlueMidwest	Mar 2012	#63
That was James Randi n/t	chrisa	Jan 2012	#37
Yes it was!! n-t	Logical	Jan 2012	#39
I don't think there's much doubt that additional people were involved who have not been revealed.	eomer	Dec 2011	#9
So you do not think the whole 9/11 inside job would have taken 100s of people?	Logical	Dec 2011	#10
I'm not sure what you mean by "the whole 9/11 inside job".	eomer	Dec 2011	#12
My point is that someone would come forward at some point. If people.....	Logical	Dec 2011	#13
OK, so there are some specific scenarios that you think would require hundreds.	eomer	Dec 2011	#15
Neither has anyone involved with the 200+ yr old homeopathy 'scam'	ottobahn	Dec 2011	#16
A scam in that it does not work. Maybe a placebo effect but that is it.	Logical	Dec 2011	#20
Why not hire international terrorist	Politicalboi	Mar 2012	#56
This message was self-deleted by its author	wildbilln864	Dec 2011	#22
I was originally brought to this thread by jury	Riftaxe	Dec 2011	#23
A couple of thoughts on "why there is yet no proof".	eomer	Dec 2011	#24
And the fact that	Politicalboi	Mar 2012	#57
the answers would probably depend on the allegations	OnTheOtherHand	Dec 2011	#25
The thing that would prevent that scenario in my mind	Riftaxe	Jan 2012	#31
I haven't seen any good reason to believe CD	OnTheOtherHand	Jan 2012	#32
So squibs 30 stories below	Politicalboi	Mar 2012	#58
Why in the world would someone alert this OP?	Logical	Dec 2011	#26
Not the OP, post #22.	Make7	Dec 2011	#27
yeah, I got called to jury on this post too.	zappaman	Dec 2011	#28
OK, thanks!!	Logical	Dec 2011	#29
so sorry for all the trouble.	wildbilln864	Jan 2012	#30
Also, bin Laden said he did not do it	4dog	Jan 2012	#33
Osama wasn't a big fan of dying	cpwm17	Jan 2012	#34
'OBL wasn't a big fan of dying'	gyroscope	Jan 2012	#40
Nothing that he said denied his actual role in the attack. n/t	Bolo Boffin	Jan 2012	#35
This sounds to me like a denial:	4dog	Jan 2012	#36
Why would anyone ever admit to mass murder?	gyroscope	Jan 2012	#41
The conspiracy people say no one knew the whole plan. So maybe a underling would realize they....	Logical	Jan 2012	#42
Yeah right	gyroscope	Jan 2012	#43
I can find thousands that will say the hijackers did it. You....	Logical	Jan 2012	#44
you left out birthers.	zappaman	Jan 2012	#45
Great point! Fiction is more fun!	Logical	Jan 2012	#46
Keep beating that strawman to death	gyroscope	Jan 2012	#48
Keep living in fantasyland	gyroscope	Jan 2012	#47
LOL......yes, because the world will end in 2012 and JFK is still alive in a hospital wing!!	Logical	Jan 2012	#49
with ELVIS!	BobbyBoring	Feb 2012	#50
Don't forget Tupac n/t	RZM	Feb 2012	#53
"Building 7 colkasped from fires!"	stockholmer	Aug 2012	#101
That's the conclusion of the scientists and engineers that studied the collapse.	cpwm17	Aug 2012	#106
It is obvious 9/11 was not carried out by anyone but the 16 hijackers.	Politicalboi	Mar 2012	#59
There were 19 hijackers	zappaman	Mar 2012	#60
So, You've talked to every person in the world and came to this conclusion?	Ghost in the Machine	Feb 2012	#51
really, that is interesting!	Celebration	Feb 2012	#52
maybe it was the team that did the tight rope walk years ago. Maybe this was a ten year plan. They	earcandle	Feb 2012	#54
Because with this crowd	Politicalboi	Mar 2012	#55
a little context	Shagman	Mar 2012	#61
Duh! Many mobsters have written books! People leaked the Manhattan Project! The...	Logical	Mar 2012	#64
another source	Shagman	Jun 2012	#89
Excellent link, thank you.	dougolat	Sep 2012	#115
aagreed	BlueMidwest	Mar 2012	#62
no one owned up yet	Rosa Luxemburg	Mar 2012	#65
Again. Why would anyone ever admit to being part of a mass murder?	gyroscope	May 2012	#66
You keep asking this paired set of rhetorical questions as if it means anythings or proves something	apocalypsehow	May 2012	#67
You wish	gyroscope	May 2012	#68
I "wish" nothing, for the facts are on my side, not yours. It really is that simple. n/t.	apocalypsehow	May 2012	#70
You have offered no facts	gyroscope	May 2012	#74
Uh-huh. n/t.	apocalypsehow	May 2012	#85
Why not a deathbed confession? nt	hack89	May 2012	#71
You been watching too many Hollywood movies	gyroscope	May 2012	#73
That's funny - massive secret government conspiracies are a staple of Hollywood movies	hack89	May 2012	#77
Who would they confess to?	gyroscope	May 2012	#76
Top 10 deathbed confession	hack89	May 2012	#78
Meaningless speculation	gyroscope	May 2012	#80
Too funny!	zappaman	May 2012	#82
And in your world	gyroscope	May 2012	#83
No, in my world	zappaman	May 2012	#84
You just broke my irony meter	hack89	May 2012	#86
I agree	SoutherDem	May 2012	#69
You watch a lot of movies?	gyroscope	May 2012	#75
Why?	SoutherDem	May 2012	#79
You can speculate about deathbed confessions until the cows come home	gyroscope	May 2012	#81
How many are dead	Why Syzygy	May 2012	#72
But there are plenty of witnesses...	deadinsider	May 2012	#87
And more...	deadinsider	May 2012	#88
No one who's still alive.	Eddie Haskell	Jul 2012	#90
Proof Positive of an Insider coming Forward!...	Indi Guy	Aug 2012	#91
Why would it have taken "100s" or "1000s" to "pull off"?	R.A.R	Aug 2012	#92
Yes, you're right!	Frank_Norris_Lives	Aug 2012	#93
A person could probably find a quote to support, or deny, anything.	R.A.R	Aug 2012	#95
Hmmmmm.....I was thinking....	Frank_Norris_Lives	Aug 2012	#96
"too many things worked in favor of the hijackers for coincidence"	R.A.R	Aug 2012	#109
I can think of these coincidences without digging too far...	Frank_Norris_Lives	Aug 2012	#110
+100000000 It is all about compartmentalisation, For instance, Able Danger, IMHO was patsy control,	stockholmer	Aug 2012	#100
How about if we call it......	Frank_Norris_Lives	Aug 2012	#113
A person who would state that "100s" or "1000s" would be required, hasn't given it much thought.	R.A.R	Aug 2012	#94
OK, then here's your chance to give a plausible explanation on how 9-11 went down.	cpwm17	Aug 2012	#97
Ok! Let me creatively speculate that.....	Frank_Norris_Lives	Aug 2012	#98
You make vague assertions	cpwm17	Aug 2012	#99
Look at the Iran-Contra affair.....	Frank_Norris_Lives	Aug 2012	#103
Still Iran-Contra was exposed	cpwm17	Aug 2012	#104
Still, it was exposed by accident...	Frank_Norris_Lives	Aug 2012	#108
It is this simple regarding 9/11...NO ONE has ever came forward and said 'I was part of it!"....	Indi Guy	Sep 2012	#114
LIHOP...	PopeOxycontinI	Sep 2012	#116
It wouldn't take 100's or 1000's, just PNAC and crew and a death pledge	Politicalboi	Sep 2012	#117
Lance Armstrong makes the case, I think.	BB1	Oct 2012	#118

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.