Reply #8

In the discussion thread: Israel A Haven for Arabs [View all]

Fri Feb 17, 2012, 05:40 PM

pelsar (11,527 posts)

8. you seem to very busy making posts about the the author of articles...

but not much to about the substance.

so....i guess we can say your more interested in the messenger rather than the message itself?

are the same words/message said from different sources make any message more or less valid?

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

22 replies	Author	Time	Post
Israel A Haven for Arabs [View all]	Liora24	Feb 2012	OP
good luck with this....	mikeysnot	Feb 2012	#1
Well, then, that's the solution!	Owlet	Feb 2012	#2
Or maybe just expand the borders of Israel	DUIC	Feb 2012	#6
well its nice to see the author of the article former Kahanist David Ha'ivri moving up in the world	azurnoir	Feb 2012	#3
Yep, he's just as rightwing as the 1-state BDS nutters Finkelstein just threw under the bus. N/T	shira	Feb 2012	#4
okay but do you agree wth him? n/t	azurnoir	Feb 2012	#5
Hard to argue against his article. His views on 1-state are totally unrealistic...	shira	Feb 2012	#7
okay again but I thought the BDSers were honest too	azurnoir	Feb 2012	#10
you seem to very busy making posts about the the author of articles...	pelsar	Feb 2012	#8
odd I see those kind of posts quite a bit on I/P	azurnoir	Feb 2012	#9
because i just decided to....	pelsar	Feb 2012	#11
I believe that knowledge of the author of an opinion piece helps with understanding the content	azurnoir	Feb 2012	#13
it may help, but does it affect the information within?	pelsar	Feb 2012	#15
it seems your really bothered by my making the bio on the author availible	azurnoir	Feb 2012	#16
i don't care who the author is....	pelsar	Feb 2012	#20
I'm calling bullshit on that, pelsar...	Violet_Crumble	Feb 2012	#18
i think its about time....	pelsar	Feb 2012	#19
Yet it's never been time over a long period of time in the I/P forum...	Violet_Crumble	Feb 2012	#21
nothing special about the "timing"....it was just the long right up about the author...my opinion?	pelsar	Feb 2012	#22
Typical imperialist arguments	TomClash	Feb 2012	#12
Not even remotely as bad as the anti-zionist one state argument...	shira	Feb 2012	#14
And after writing all that . . .	TomClash	Feb 2012	#17

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.