Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Jefferson23

(30,099 posts)
20. This is tantamount to an apportionment position, very sad but not surprising.
Thu Dec 6, 2012, 04:38 PM
Dec 2012

Good luck with this approach if the Israeli government is ever brought to the Hague.

Gawd, they're almost as bad as the Americans. geek tragedy Dec 2012 #1
"youd better stop it or one day you might get a slap on the wrist... bunnies Dec 2012 #2
wow, that sounds bad. Mosby Dec 2012 #3
Building on someone elses land TexasProgresive Dec 2012 #4
It's disputed land. Not someone else's. In fact, E1 was to be Israeli territory.... shira Dec 2012 #5
why can you only talk about the past is the future that scarey or disturbing to you? azurnoir Dec 2012 #6
Just saying E1 would be Israeli territory in any reasonable peace deal.... shira Dec 2012 #7
reasonable for who? you? rightist Israeli's? azurnoir Dec 2012 #8
To Bill and Hillary Clinton, and Arafat. From Rabin to Peres to Olmert in 2008. shira Dec 2012 #9
again with the past Hill and Bill are no longer POTUS and First Lady azurnoir Dec 2012 #10
It's a consensus issue in Israel. Both Left and Right agree.... shira Dec 2012 #12
Well, then, you are a per se, de facto supporter of apartheid in the Holy Land. geek tragedy Dec 2012 #15
Shira doesn't believe political rights are civil rights Scootaloo Dec 2012 #19
Scoot...I never wrote any such thing. It appears the best you've got.... shira Dec 2012 #28
Clearly you did write it, Shira Scootaloo Dec 2012 #47
Don't put words in my mouth. If you have questions about my positions, ask. shira Dec 2012 #48
You're the one who used those words, Shira. Scootaloo Dec 2012 #53
Huh? shira Dec 2012 #24
E1 under Israeli accord was never part of the Geneva Accord. geek tragedy Dec 2012 #34
No there is no consensus globally or otherwise azurnoir Dec 2012 #22
It's a consensus issue in Israel in which both Left and Right agree. n/t shira Dec 2012 #25
No it is not -not anymore at least if iindeed it ever was azurnoir Dec 2012 #27
Yes, it is. Here's Larry Derfner just 2 days ago... shira Dec 2012 #29
well yes in Israel and sadly yes we know the Israeli public prefers azurnoir Dec 2012 #30
Carter and Chomsky endorsed a deal that gave Israel control.... shira Dec 2012 #31
you posted it I did not even though I read that piece days ago azurnoir Dec 2012 #33
Really now? Carter and Chomsky endorsed a deal that gave Israel control over E1 territory? Jefferson23 Dec 2012 #83
You are correct--the problem isn't Netanyahu, it's Israel itself. nt geek tragedy Dec 2012 #35
No, it's not Israel. It's Shira. Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #63
Oh, if only it were so isolated n/t Scootaloo Dec 2012 #87
We know your views on Israel King_David Dec 2012 #90
No, the Left doesn't agree. Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #61
See #29 above. Except for the extreme fringe, it's a consensus. n/t shira Dec 2012 #62
Nice back peddle ... Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #72
Do you consider liberal zionists in Israel to be Left? Or just the extreme fringe? n/t shira Dec 2012 #75
I'm sorry, but I don't acknowledge your question. Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #78
On E1 and Maale Adumim, the Left and Right in Israel agree.... shira Dec 2012 #96
Six people who think the Palestinians should get fucked agree; "Fuck the Palestinians" Scootaloo Dec 2012 #17
I thought you said that you supported the Geneva accord shaayecanaan Dec 2012 #42
I do. You don't. In fact, none of your comrades here support... shira Dec 2012 #50
Ma'al Adumim goes all the way to Jericho. Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #58
If you go by the Clinton Parameters ... Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #57
If Arafat made the concessions, why did he reject it? shira Dec 2012 #59
You didn't hear of Taba? Nevermind ... Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #77
I thought you were against settlements, Shira? Scootaloo Dec 2012 #18
I'm for reasonable land swaps in a future 2 state deal. shira Dec 2012 #26
Let's see: Israel annexes land by force, now - then offers a nuclear waste dump later. delrem Dec 2012 #44
Palestinians could have had their own state way back in 1947 shira Dec 2012 #46
Whoever you're trying to convince, and whatever of, delrem Dec 2012 #49
So why have they rejected one offer after another since 1947? shira Dec 2012 #51
In your own head. Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #56
Extremists says Jews have no right to any part of the territories... shira Dec 2012 #60
I held no position ... Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #73
My original response was to another DU'er who says... shira Dec 2012 #74
Zionists can also be Christian ... Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #79
And antisemites equate "Israel" and "Jew" Scootaloo Dec 2012 #88
Yes, they do. They're not even hiding it anymore.... shira Dec 2012 #95
Not a surprising response, all considered. n/t Jefferson23 Dec 2012 #11
You've gotta admit.... shira Dec 2012 #13
+1 Mosby Dec 2012 #16
This is tantamount to an apportionment position, very sad but not surprising. Jefferson23 Dec 2012 #20
why is that ProIsrael people always equate all Arabs/Muslims to Palestinians? azurnoir Dec 2012 #23
Its simple ForgoTheConsequence Dec 2012 #52
+100 Scootaloo Dec 2012 #54
Oh yeah. Racist zionists in the US are fake progressives. shira Dec 2012 #68
Yes, they are. I'm glad you're catching on. Scootaloo Dec 2012 #89
Fascinating generalization. shira Dec 2012 #94
I don't know. Why is that? Did it happen here recently? n/t shira Dec 2012 #69
Oh, no, look over here! Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #64
That "look over there" is obviously in reverse. shira Dec 2012 #66
You're prolific ... Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #71
I was agreeing to Mosby's comment. shira Dec 2012 #76
I hope we can be progressive together in another thread! Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #80
Shira does not post outside of I/P. Ever Scootaloo Dec 2012 #91
what's your street address? frylock Dec 2012 #32
that's not a good argument Mosby Dec 2012 #36
your questions are rather nonsensical azurnoir Dec 2012 #37
Sure, Jews should be free to pay taxes to a Palestinian state, rely on the Palestinian geek tragedy Dec 2012 #38
I agree Mosby Dec 2012 #39
Well, you can see issues arising with armed settlers out there. geek tragedy Dec 2012 #40
so what Mosby Dec 2012 #41
Because those settlers tend to be really violent people who hate Arabs. nt geek tragedy Dec 2012 #43
Stupid Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #55
The whole world has always been against Israel oberliner Dec 2012 #14
If the whole world was always against Israel, how did the UN manage to create it? nt geek tragedy Dec 2012 #21
textbook insanity nt delrem Dec 2012 #45
I've respected your posts. Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #65
They can't all be winners oberliner Dec 2012 #67
I agree ... Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #70
This particular OP is about Israel feeling like the world is against them oberliner Dec 2012 #81
That's more than a fair concern. Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2012 #82
excuse me..but israel does not have such power to end the conflict pelsar Dec 2012 #84
Egypt is in full control of the Muslim Brotherhood? Really? Raksha Dec 2012 #85
a revision is necessary..thanks pelsar Dec 2012 #86
Interesting thing you just said, Pelsar... Scootaloo Dec 2012 #92
I/P conflict Lesson number 1 pelsar Dec 2012 #93
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Israel/Palestine»'This Time, Israel Has De...»Reply #20