Reply #8

In the discussion thread: Israel's Spending on Illegal Settlements Hits Two-Decade High of NIS 1.1 Billion [View all]

Response to holdencaufield (Reply #2)

Tue Aug 7, 2012, 06:11 AM

stockholmer (3,751 posts)

8. because they ARE illegal

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

37 replies	Author	Time	Post
Israel's Spending on Illegal Settlements Hits Two-Decade High of NIS 1.1 Billion [View all]	stockholmer	Aug 2012	OP
Why did you add a dollar sign?	oberliner	Aug 2012	#1
fixed	stockholmer	Aug 2012	#7
Thanks	oberliner	Aug 2012	#10
Why Did You Add...	holdencaufield	Aug 2012	#2
Perhaps for the same reason that Shira changed her headline? .........	kayecy	Aug 2012	#3
So it was done for manipulative propaganda purposes?	oberliner	Aug 2012	#6
Ask Shira.......She refused to explain when I asked her!........n/t	kayecy	Aug 2012	#13
because they ARE illegal	stockholmer	Aug 2012	#8
Legal minds disagree	holdencaufield	Aug 2012	#9
and in your mind what court would have jurisdiction? the ICJ?	azurnoir	Aug 2012	#11
the percentage of 'legal minds' & countries (Israel alone) claiming 'legal' would make even global	stockholmer	Aug 2012	#12
In the absense...	holdencaufield	Aug 2012	#17
"Legal Minds Disagree"	Scootaloo	Aug 2012	#26
well lets straighten this out Israel has spent approx. $275,000,000 on settlements	azurnoir	Aug 2012	#4
Thanks for the correction	oberliner	Aug 2012	#5
Not much point in pursuing the 2-state solution......	kayecy	Aug 2012	#14
It's the only workable solution	oberliner	Aug 2012	#15
It's ONLY workable if, at the VERY least, a permanent settlement expansion moratorium is imposed NOW	Ken Burch	Aug 2012	#16
"WITH the settlements in place, [West Bank] could never be a real state"	holdencaufield	Aug 2012	#18
It wouldn't play out that way	Ken Burch	Aug 2012	#21
"It wouldn't play out that way"	holdencaufield	Aug 2012	#23
But of course the Palestinian should have a RoR!!!	Shaktimaan	Aug 2012	#28
What happened to the Mizrahi was an injustice	Ken Burch	Aug 2012	#31
untrue.	Shaktimaan	Aug 2012	#33
I'm talking about the displacement of the Mizrahi from the other Arab countries, for God's sake	Ken Burch	Aug 2012	#34
I don't agree with all you've written here	oberliner	Aug 2012	#20
What is there to swap?	Ken Burch	Aug 2012	#22
I beg you to look at the Geneva Accords	oberliner	Aug 2012	#24
I looked at the map...but it tells nothing	Ken Burch	Aug 2012	#35
Yes it does	oberliner	Aug 2012	#36
I'll look again later.	Ken Burch	Aug 2012	#37
Hahahaha.	Shaktimaan	Aug 2012	#29
The current Arab democracy movement is still less than two years old	Ken Burch	Aug 2012	#30
you misunderstand.	Shaktimaan	Aug 2012	#32
One side ...	holdencaufield	Aug 2012	#19
Depends on what you mean by "workable"	Scootaloo	Aug 2012	#27
Why not?	Shaktimaan	Aug 2012	#25

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.