Reply #59

In the discussion thread: Israel sees Palestinian children as 'potential terrorists', panel finds [View all]

Sun Jul 8, 2012, 11:03 AM

shira (18,065 posts)

59. When you adopt the rhetoric of regressive rightwing anti-Israel regimes and advocate....

Last edited Sun Jul 8, 2012, 11:04 AM USA/ET - Edit history (2)

...on behalf of their totalitarian anti-liberal leadership against a progressive democracy like Israel, then it's preposterous to claim you hold to liberal/progressive values. It's silly for you to call out liberals for their alleged "rightwingery".

Heck, you recently all but admitted you're for Palestinian nationalism first and foremost before anything else. Their civil rights are secondary. If they never have civil rights, that's okay too. Now if THAT's not a rightwing nationalist viewpoint, I don't know what is.

Have a nice day, "Alice".

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

65 replies	Author	Time	Post
Israel sees Palestinian children as 'potential terrorists', panel finds [View all]	Scurrilous	Jun 2012	OP
The name of the accusers changes, but Israel continues to break international law.	PDJane	Jun 2012	#1
Maybe it has something to do with the lack of prospects for those children to get on in tbe world.	bemildred	Jun 2012	#2
Not a surprise at all	azurnoir	Jun 2012	#3
I wonder how juvenile offenders are treated in GB	Mosby	Jun 2012	#4
That is surprising...	shaayecanaan	Jun 2012	#5
I can tell you that in the USA juveniles are treated like fresh meat.	bemildred	Jun 2012	#6
especially since the privatization of dentention facilities n/t	azurnoir	Jun 2012	#8
There was an interesting tidbit on QI last night...	shaayecanaan	Jun 2012	#10
Thanks I did not know about how far the prison labor had went	azurnoir	Jun 2012	#11
Richard Millett: Save the children…except when they’re Israeli.	shira	Jun 2012	#7
I'm sorry, I stop reading articles when they do shit like this;	Scootaloo	Jun 2012	#12
The whole report is diversionary and politically loaded. That's the point of bringing up ...	shira	Jun 2012	#13
yep sort of like CNN and Fox News not thinking they had to read	azurnoir	Jun 2012	#14
Oh, okay. Why bother with information, when you can "just know"	Scootaloo	Jun 2012	#16
Yes, I do know that w/o question, and only the deliberately blind would deny it, there's an obvious	shira	Jul 2012	#17
So given the obvious agenda of you and your sources, what makes you the least bit trustworthy?	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#18
My credibility isn't the issue. Did you read both links? Especially the 2nd one (not NGO-M)?	shira	Jul 2012	#19
I read the second	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#20
The NGO's that fed Goldstone the central argument & conclusion of his report....	shira	Jul 2012	#21
I know what your argument is, Shira	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#22
No you don't.	shira	Jul 2012	#23
Yeah, I do; you're not very subtle	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#24
An excellent post	shaayecanaan	Jul 2012	#25
Why does the sourcing of right-wing garbage "stick" here, anyway?	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#30
I ask myself that all the time. Why do people constantly quote from Hamas approved media here?	shira	Jul 2012	#40
Shira, as I cover below...	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#43
You didn't cover anything below.	shira	Jul 2012	#44
I think you're the one not understanding	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#45
There's a difference b/w rightwing sources, liberal ones, and hard left ones....	shira	Jul 2012	#48
Sigh. Here are some true/false questions you can either choose to answer or choose to evade....	shira	Jul 2012	#26
You don't have to be so hostile; just give me a sly come-hither look!	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#29
Why the thin skin when your posts to me are even more hostile? Anyway, I'm stunned w/ yr response...	shira	Jul 2012	#31
Thin skin? I was just saying you're quite the charmer!	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#33
Uhh right, the antisemitic "Lobby" got to Goldstone (the poor victim). And after several posts....	shira	Jul 2012	#34
I'm glad we agree on something, finally	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#35
No, we don't agree. I think it's ridiculous to claim the "Lobby" got a "poor victim" like Goldstone	shira	Jul 2012	#36
"The entire report was invalidated" you say?	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#37
It's dead and buried, in the dustbin of history. No one brings it up anymore...	shira	Jul 2012	#38
Nor have you responded to my question about HRW and their report on Syria, Shira	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#41
What's there to really respond to? Let's say their report on Syria is perfect....	shira	Jul 2012	#42
It's simple, really.	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#46
When the original founder of HRW has a problem with them, something's up...	shira	Jul 2012	#47
Or perhaps Bernstein changed his mind.	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#50
This is great	oberliner	Jul 2012	#51
Not a huge fan of the Henry Rollins Band	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#53
Maybe you should ask yourself why Goldstone and Robert Bernstein turned on Roth and HRW....	shira	Jul 2012	#52
I thought you were done, Shira?	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#54
Just saying Goldstone, Bernstein, and B'tselem call BS on HRW claims. Deal with it as you wish.	shira	Jul 2012	#55
I had thought you were calling it quits, is all	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#56
Can't defend HRW now, can you? Go back to where this all started in post #12...	shira	Jul 2012	#58
What's there to "defend" them against?	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#62
LOL. Even B'tselem directors have a problem with HRW's main allegations vs. Israel...	shira	Jul 2012	#63
LOL.	bemildred	Jul 2012	#32
you may be shocked at this but links to sites such as the Volokh Conspiracy to prove your opinion	azurnoir	Jul 2012	#27
Don't really know what you're on about...	shira	Jul 2012	#39
well 'Alice' I guess the rabbit was talking to you or was it the queen? sounds more like the queen	azurnoir	Jul 2012	#49
By unique...	Scootaloo	Jul 2012	#57
could be n/t	azurnoir	Jul 2012	#61
When you adopt the rhetoric of regressive rightwing anti-Israel regimes and advocate....	shira	Jul 2012	#59
so do Israels 'liberal' civil rights laws apply to the non citizen Palestinians living in the	azurnoir	Jul 2012	#60
No, of course not. But you're not merely for Palestinians having their own state...	shira	Jul 2012	#64
Palestinians civil rights are on hold spin that anyway you'd like it is the truth	azurnoir	Jul 2012	#65
a report on this from B'tselem who interviewed 50 Palestinian kids who had been detained by Israel	azurnoir	Jun 2012	#9
Arrests of Palestinian children– ‘a boy in leg irons’ — is becoming a big story in UK	JohnyCanuck	Jun 2012	#15
WATCH: Palestinian child kicked by Border Police in Hebron	azurnoir	Jul 2012	#28

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.