Israel/Palestine

shira

(30,109 posts)

26. Violet, what kind of peace do you envision the PA and Arab nations agreeing to...

Fri May 18, 2012, 12:21 PM

May 2012

...with Israel? You say you're for the end of the conflict. What does that mean?

Does that mean there should be no negotiations, Israel should agree to the Saudi Initiative, and trust that its neighbors will call off the dogs?

What kind of peace do you envision if Israel were to end the occupation tomorrow? What would Israel have to negotiate with after that? RoR would still be an issue.

What does this 2 state peace deal look like in your opinion? Israel agreed to peace with Egypt and now that the MB is taking over, that seems to be falling apart. Is that your notion of peace b/w Israel and Hamas, for example? Peace on paper, not in reality?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

45 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

EU Castigates Israel Over Settlements, Palestinians [View all] Purveyor May 2012 OP

LOL. When has the EU ever castigated both Hamas and the PA for the following incitement.... shira May 2012 #1

well I am glad you have shared that with us azurnoir May 2012 #10

You don't think that stuff is really, really bad and jeopardizes 2 states more... shira May 2012 #11

you believe that Palestinians are genocidal towards Jews yet claim to support a 2 state solution? azurnoir May 2012 #12

You didn't answer my question in the last post. Please do... shira May 2012 #13

oh so now a 2 state solution when you feel 'teh Palestinians' are ready eh? lol azurnoir May 2012 #14

I get it now. You're for 2 states (if it becomes 1 that's fine) but not really for peace, right? shira May 2012 #15

again shira if an attack came from the West Bank what would be the result? azurnoir May 2012 #16

Depends on the role of the PA (or Hamas if they take over). Are those in control of Palestine... shira May 2012 #17

What was Israel's reward... holdencaufield May 2012 #18

well look it up and let us know now okay? n/t azurnoir May 2012 #20

You want Israel to get rewarded for finally complying with international law? Violet_Crumble May 2012 #22

80% of 300,000 is 50,000? azurnoir May 2012 #19

What question was I talking about that you deflected from? The one in #11.... shira May 2012 #35

so let's be clear here you believe the Palestinians to be genocidal towards Jews yes or no? n/t azurnoir May 2012 #38

Trying real hard, aren't you? Those videos show the PA and Hamas doing their very best.... shira May 2012 #39

the answer is no and as has been pointed out to you apparently you do not understand what genocide azurnoir May 2012 #40

So the content in those videos in no way points to Hamas or the PA inciting towards genocide? shira May 2012 #41

No they are not and although you claim not to believe that the Palestinian people are genocidal azurnoir May 2012 #42

Post removed Post removed May 2012 #43

That post said that Hamas was genocidal, not the Palestinian population... Violet_Crumble May 2012 #29

Hamas is genocidal... shira May 2012 #30

They're not, and only someone completely ignorant of what genocide is would claim so... Violet_Crumble May 2012 #31

The entire post concerned azurnoir May 2012 #32

Anyone taking bets... holdencaufield May 2012 #2

Only people with absolutely no life and no intelligence, I'd say.. Violet_Crumble May 2012 #3

"Only people with absolutely no life and no intelligence, I'd say.." holdencaufield May 2012 #4

The EU willingly participates in the delegitimization of Israel... shira May 2012 #5

Don't go getting tears all over yr pillow! Violet_Crumble May 2012 #6

You're not reading my posts holdencaufield May 2012 #7

Don't you worry. I read yr posts... Violet_Crumble May 2012 #8

Pot meet kettle... shira May 2012 #9

I see yr still deliberately ignoring what people say their own views are... Violet_Crumble May 2012 #21

"...you deliberately pretend to misunderstand what I say my own views are... " holdencaufield May 2012 #23

Nope, you didn't say anything about negotiations on a level playing field... Violet_Crumble May 2012 #24

Violet, what kind of peace do you envision the PA and Arab nations agreeing to... shira May 2012 #26

Why ask 'questions' when you ignore what people say in reply? Violet_Crumble May 2012 #28

IOW, you're too embarrassed and/or ashamed to answer those questions honestly. shira May 2012 #33

Yeah, that's it. It's yr superior debating style that does it every time! Violet_Crumble May 2012 #44

I see you're still obfuscating... shira May 2012 #25

Not all all. Yr continuing to try to tell everyone what my views are... Violet_Crumble May 2012 #27

Oh, it's obvious. When pressed, you never answer direct questions. shira May 2012 #34

Nope. I don't answer yr 'questions' and you know why... Violet_Crumble May 2012 #45

Post removed Post removed May 2012 #36

Or the EU can do some soul-searching in their own backyard? jimmie May 2012 #37