HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Topics » Environment & Energy » Environment & Energy (Group) » Stewart Brand: Why Enviro... » Reply #23
Introducing Discussionist: A new forum by the creators of DU

Response to FBaggins (Reply #9)

Mon Feb 11, 2013, 10:39 AM

23. AGREED!!

FBaggins,

I totally agree with you that Brand demolished Jacobsen.

Jacobsen technical errors were numerous and naive.

However, those who are not schooled in science, like kristopher; won't recognize the errors as errors because they don't know any better. They accept anything that Jacobsen says as factual because they don't know enough to know that Jacobsen was wrong.

Any weapons physicist knows that the link between nuclear weapons and nuclear power reactors is tenuous at best. Every nuclear weapons state, including the USA; had nuclear weapons before they had commercial power reactors. In fact, commercial power reactors are really very poor at making weapons grade material. Every nuclear weapons state that uses plutonium made that plutonium NOT with a commercial power reactor, but with special weapons material production reactors, like those at Hanford and Savannah River in the USA; which are specially designed for the purpose.

Jacobsen exhibited an almost childish grasp on the relevant physics.

PamW

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 46 replies Author Time Post
wtmusic Feb 2013 OP
kristopher Feb 2013 #1
FBaggins Feb 2013 #9
LineLineLineReply AGREED!!
PamW Feb 2013 #23
dumbcat Feb 2013 #43
gcomeau Feb 2013 #2
phantom power Feb 2013 #3
wtmusic Feb 2013 #5
dbackjon Feb 2013 #4
kristopher Feb 2013 #6
dbackjon Feb 2013 #7
FBaggins Feb 2013 #12
diane in sf Feb 2013 #20
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #8
wtmusic Feb 2013 #10
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #11
wtmusic Feb 2013 #13
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #17
wtmusic Feb 2013 #19
appal_jack Feb 2013 #21
wtmusic Feb 2013 #27
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #28
joshcryer Feb 2013 #14
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #15
joshcryer Feb 2013 #18
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #22
joshcryer Feb 2013 #24
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #25
joshcryer Feb 2013 #29
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #30
joshcryer Feb 2013 #31
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #32
joshcryer Feb 2013 #33
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #34
wtmusic Feb 2013 #37
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #38
wtmusic Feb 2013 #39
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #40
wtmusic Feb 2013 #41
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #42
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #44
kristopher Feb 2013 #45
GliderGuider Feb 2013 #46
hatrack Feb 2013 #16
HooptieWagon Feb 2013 #26
jpak Feb 2013 #35
wtmusic Feb 2013 #36
Please login to view edit histories.