Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Economy

Showing Original Post only (View all)
 

Demeter

(85,373 posts)
Fri Apr 18, 2014, 06:08 PM Apr 2014

Weekend Economists Pull the Easter Rabbit Out of the Hat April 18-20, 2014 [View all]

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/416e5YvH1tL._BO2,204,203,200_PIsitb-sticker-v3-big,TopRight,0,-55_SX278_SY278_PIkin4,BottomRight,1,22_AA300_SH20_OU01_.jpg

http://www.amazon.com/CHRISTS-VENTRILOQUISTS-Event-Created-Christianity-ebook/dp/B007Q1H4EG



How Christianity Was Created by Jesus's Enemies

http://www.viewzone.com/ventriloquest.html



RESEARCH METHODOLOGY:

This is the first work to apply to the interpretation of classical documents the methodology which courts of law in a democracy apply when reconstructing a sequence of events on the basis of documentary evidence referring to them. Among the principles employed here, which haven't previously been used by historians, are:

(1) For any alleged historical reconstruction, cite only the best (the most reliable) evidence (and exclude the rest under the best-evidence rule);

(2) Things that a cited document necessarily implies, rather than explicitly asserts, have higher evidentiary value (credibility) than any explicit assertions; and,

(3) Each explicit assertion cited in evidence must be questioned not just as to its accuracy, but also as to its honesty-of-intent. These three principles have never been applied to the documents concerning earliest Christianity. Applying them produces a radically new understanding of how Christianity began.

FINDINGS:

This first-ever legal/forensic exegesis of Paul's letter to the Galatians, and associated legal/forensic analysis of the four canonical Gospels, finds that Christianity started in or around the year 49 CE in Antioch (present-day Antakya, Turkey) as a direct consequence of a personal conflict which had arisen, during the prior 14 years, between Paul and the leader of this (at that time) Jewish sect, which Jesus had begun prior to his crucifixion at around the year 30 by the Romans for sedition.

The sect's leader was not Peter, such as Paul's followers who wrote the Gospels said, but was instead Jesus's brother James. Peter was and remained a follower of James, and he died (as did the rest of the sect) as a member of this Jewish sect, not as a Christian -- not as a member of the group which Paul started on this occasion. Jesus's sect soon itself expired.

What's known today as Christianity started with Paul, and was then developed by his followers, who wrote the canonical Gospels and the rest of the New Testament. The religion of the New Testament actually has nothing to do with the person of the historical Jesus: The NT was written and assembled to fulfill Paul's Roman agenda, not Jesus's Jewish one. This is shown to explain the entire Christian myth.

The conflict between Paul and James has to do with the circumcision-commandment, Genesis 17:14, which is Judaism's signature-commandment, by which a person signs God's contract in blood and becomes eligible to be a member of God's People.

Paul doesn't want to enforce it, because neither anesthesia nor antibiotics yet exist in this ancient era, and so any medical operation is an excruciating horror for these adult men, and frightening also because all operations have a high fatality rate from infections. James knows that if Genesis 17:14 is to be enforced upon Paul's men, then most of them will simply abandon Jesus's sect and will abandon Judaism altogether.

But finally in the year 49 or 50, right after the council in Jerusalem (which Paul refers to in Galatians 2:1-10), James does try to enforce it, and Paul calls James's bluff and refuses to comply. This is the moment when Paul first announces Christianity: the occasion Paul describes approximately four years later in Galatians 2:16-21.

The event that created Christianity is referred to in carefully veiled language in Galatians 2:11-21: James here changes his mind and decides that Genesis 17:14 will have to be enforced after all, and he sends Peter to Paul in Antioch to order him to have all his men circumcised. James also sends a back-up team to check up on Peter (who is very reluctant to do this), and to make sure that Peter does what he is told.

But when the back-up team arrives and sees Peter instead dining with Paul's uncircumcised men, Peter is startled and embarrassed to be seen dining with these non-members, and so he backs away from the table. At this moment, Paul responds to Peter by announcing, for the first time ever, Christianity, which is the doctrine that Paul states in Galatians 2:16-21.

Although Paul says that he's rejecting the circumcision-commandment because he rejects the entire covenant, he is actually rejecting the entire covenant because he rejects the circumcision-commandment. This is the only way Paul can keep his men with him; he simply can't admit to them that they are not Jews. So, from now on, he needs to be very careful about how he words things. Only gradually do his men come to recognize that they aren't Jews. Paul prepares them for this by telling them how horrible strict Jews are, such as he does in Galatians 1:13-14, 1 Thessalonians 2:3-16, and Philippians 3:2-8.

James is now trapped by circumstances: If he publicly announces that Paul's men are no longer members of Jesus's sect, then James will lose the vast majority of his sect's members, since Paul had converted them.

Furthermore, Paul's followers are Gentiles in a Gentile world ruled by Gentile Rome, during the time when Rome is at war against the Jews in Jerusalem. Jerusalem's Jews are a poor and defeated people. James is relying on the financial contributions coming in from Paul's many Gentile congregations, to support the Jesus sect. James therefore needs to remain silent about Paul's coup d'etat.

The "Jesus" who is described in the Gospel-accounts is written later, by Paul's followers, not by James's, and is written so as to add narrative flesh to the bones of Paul's agenda -- the agenda exposed in Galatians and in the other six authentic letters from Paul -- the earliest-written of all Christian documents...


I DO NOT KNOW WHY I AM THE LAST PERSON IN THE WORLD TO LEARN ABOUT THIS SEMINAL WORK...BUT IT IS ASTONISHING! IT EXPLAINS SO MUCH! I'M GOING TO HAVE TO BUY A BOOK!

DO YOU KNOW HOW SELDOM I BUY A BOOK THESE DAYS?
66 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
So far, we haven't lost a bank tonight Demeter Apr 2014 #1
THE BOOK PREVIEW CONTINUES Demeter Apr 2014 #2
I'll have to take a closer look at this. Tansy_Gold Apr 2014 #19
I'll be happy if I don't end up crucified myself Demeter Apr 2014 #20
Supplements to Eric Zuesse's Christ's Ventriloquist by Edward Jones Demeter Apr 2014 #3
I don't think you're the "last person" to have heard of this book Tansy_Gold Apr 2014 #51
First, here is the book’s introductory outline of its argument: Demeter Apr 2014 #4
Vridar (the debunker) is more convincing than Zuesse Tansy_Gold Apr 2014 #47
I think the most convincing evidence is the lack of evidence Demeter Apr 2014 #49
If there were any evidence of a "historical" Jesus Tansy_Gold Apr 2014 #50
Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act--THE RIGHT WING'S NEWEST PANIC Demeter Apr 2014 #5
Nullification, The Bundy Ranch And Right-Wing Lawlessness Demeter Apr 2014 #6
Wingnut Week in Review: None Dare Call It Terrorism Demeter Apr 2014 #7
The first time I ever saw a good use for a drone and a few Hellfire Missiles. Fuddnik Apr 2014 #12
the man's obtuseness and maladroitness astound me. he never learns Demeter Apr 2014 #14
Nebraska Joins States Banning Employers from Asking Job Applicants About Criminal History Demeter Apr 2014 #8
Karl Polanyi Explains It All Robert Kuttner Demeter Apr 2014 #9
If anyone is interested in Polanyi Tansy_Gold Apr 2014 #48
Easter comes pretty late this year Demeter Apr 2014 #10
The BP oilrig blew out on April 20, 2010, four years ago this Sunday... Greg Palast Demeter Apr 2014 #11
I have a problem with this download and windows media player.... Demeter Apr 2014 #13
Youngest Billionaires of 2014 Demeter Apr 2014 #15
Obama Brags About ObamaCare Enrollment As If He Invented The Handout FORBES OP-ED Michael F. Cannon Demeter Apr 2014 #16
Rajaratnam's brother loses bid to dismiss insider trading charges Demeter Apr 2014 #17
How The Clinton White House Played Politics With The Minimum Wage Demeter Apr 2014 #18
Ukraine Hikes Discount Rate from 6.5% to 9.5%, Overnight Rate to 14.5% to Halt Crash of Hryvnia MattSh Apr 2014 #21
You are in Kiev, aren't you, Matt? Demeter Apr 2014 #40
Still here... MattSh Apr 2014 #41
I'd pick you up in the taxi, but Fuddnik Apr 2014 #42
The Annotated History Of The Russian Empire | Zero Hedge MattSh Apr 2014 #22
It's not that Russia is so Strong (although probably more than it's ever been) Demeter Apr 2014 #39
Italy Is Selling Off This Very Creepy 'Haunted' Island In Venice xchrom Apr 2014 #23
SpaceX's Second Attempt To Launch Dragon Spacecraft Was Successful xchrom Apr 2014 #24
America’s Favorite Anarchist Thinks Most US Workers Are Wage Slaves xchrom Apr 2014 #25
Italy PM Renzi cuts taxes for 10 million low earners xchrom Apr 2014 #26
Wall Street Wants to Lend You Money to Fight Climate Change xchrom Apr 2014 #27
Get Rich, Live Longer: The Ultimate Consequence of Income Inequality xchrom Apr 2014 #28
Anglo trial: Pat Whelan and Willie McAteer found guilty xchrom Apr 2014 #29
EU OFFICIAL AGAINST CUTTING RUSSIA GAS TIES xchrom Apr 2014 #30
Labor Shortage Threatens to Bust the Shale Boom xchrom Apr 2014 #31
Energy Needs Curb Eastern EU Hunger for Russian Sanctions xchrom Apr 2014 #32
High-Speed Trader Virtu Said Questioned in N.Y. Inquiry xchrom Apr 2014 #33
Monte Paschi Seeks EU5 Billion to Repay Aid, Build Buffer xchrom Apr 2014 #34
Turkey’s State-Run Ziraat Bank Planning First-Ever Eurobond xchrom Apr 2014 #35
UNEMPLOYMENT RATES FALL IN 21 US STATES LAST MONTH xchrom Apr 2014 #36
PROVIDENCE, RI, SUES FIRMS OVER STOCK TRADES xchrom Apr 2014 #37
BANK OF CYPRUS SELLS BUSINESS IN UKRAINE, ROMANIA xchrom Apr 2014 #38
Something of special interest to Demeter, I do believe... MattSh Apr 2014 #43
It is a worthy goal. THe US has no right or credibility as a superpower left to its name Demeter Apr 2014 #44
Meanwhile, back at the ranch... Demeter Apr 2014 #46
I'm wondering what words of wisdom guide the POTUS Demeter Apr 2014 #45
On the subject at hand, I'm one of those who don't think that Jesus ever actually existed. Fuddnik Apr 2014 #52
That is interesting DemReadingDU Apr 2014 #53
And to you and yours, DRDU! Demeter Apr 2014 #55
Still, the ethical ideas came from SOMEWHERE Demeter Apr 2014 #56
Much of the "ethics" are common sense Tansy_Gold Apr 2014 #61
I had read somewhat about a Rabbi named Hillel Demeter Apr 2014 #64
May have been the first to write them down Tansy_Gold Apr 2014 #66
JIM O'NEILL: The Crisis In Ukraine Is Just A Symptom Of Something Much Worse {IMF funding} xchrom Apr 2014 #54
I think the outing of that woman on the cell phone Nuland Demeter Apr 2014 #57
the IMF and the World Bank are out of control. xchrom Apr 2014 #58
The Truth About Easter and the Secret Worship of the Anunnaki Demeter Apr 2014 #59
Eggs and rabbits Tansy_Gold Apr 2014 #62
Hasenpfeffer (Rabbit Stew) Fuddnik Apr 2014 #63
BNP Banker, His Wife And Nephew Murdered In Belgium DemReadingDU Apr 2014 #60
wow Demeter Apr 2014 #65
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»Weekend Economists Pull t...»Reply #0