Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

hifiguy

(33,688 posts)
1. Hannibal.
Tue Mar 27, 2012, 06:12 PM
Mar 2012

It's not so much that the movie was bad - but it was grossly incomplete. And the ending of the book, which was the only possible resolution of the relationship between Starling and Lecter given everything Thomas Harris had written about these two characters, was discarded in its entirety. It has been said that the proper ending is unfilmable. This is so only if one places, as is the usual practice, commerce above art.

I never had any problem with Julianne Moore as Starling - I thought she was excellent in the role and Hopkins was Hopkins, but the ending just felt tacked on compared to the creepy psychodrama of the book.

Hannibal. hifiguy Mar 2012 #1
Not to mention the complete omission of Verger's sister n/t dogknob Mar 2012 #10
The Choir Boys. Not a great book so much as a great read. The movie was an exercise in mediocrity. ohiosmith Mar 2012 #2
Quite a few.... NRaleighLiberal Mar 2012 #3
I think it's impossible to do a good John Irving book adaptation LynneSin Mar 2012 #4
I loved Cider House rules movie - but just adored the book. NRaleighLiberal Mar 2012 #16
Cider House Rules is one of my favorite movies ever! Logical Mar 2012 #71
I, Robot n/t sarge43 Mar 2012 #5
They pretty much took the name and ran with that one. Neoma Mar 2012 #67
Owen Meany (which became Simon Birch) Taverner Mar 2012 #6
Girl with the Pearl Earing. They could have done that movie so much better. The Other Justice wanted Mar 2012 #7
The Sicilian (Mario Puzo) Cass Mar 2012 #8
DaVinci Code was ruined by being too faithful to the book. Bruce Wayne Mar 2012 #9
Dan Brown is such a mind-bogglingly shitty writer... dogknob Mar 2012 #12
I like his books. Bladian Mar 2012 #14
Hey I read the whole thing... dogknob Mar 2012 #20
Yes, I agree. And casted as Hanks and Tautou....yikes! NRaleighLiberal Mar 2012 #27
Dan Brown wants so bad to be Robert Ludlum...but isn't within a light year. NRaleighLiberal Mar 2012 #17
Agreed! Phentex Mar 2012 #26
Dan Brown is a character in Foucault's Pendulum. Not a compelling one. Chan790 Mar 2012 #28
Is Brown a cretin, a fool, a moron, or a lunatic? myrna minx Mar 2012 #50
Prince of Tides DFW Mar 2012 #11
Eragon, hands down. nt Bladian Mar 2012 #13
The Bible... Tom_Foolery Mar 2012 #15
I liked Jesus Christ Superstar though Dragonbreathp9d Mar 2012 #52
Good point! Tom_Foolery Mar 2012 #82
Ben Hur kicked ass... Blue_Tires Mar 2012 #62
Haha!!! Tom_Foolery Mar 2012 #83
I think that they are finally shooting Ludlum's Matarese Circle (my favorite of his) - casting NRaleighLiberal Mar 2012 #18
Bonfire of the Vanities KamaAina Mar 2012 #19
I thought that Buck Henry did a good job with an impossible book - "Catch 22" underpants Mar 2012 #21
Agreed. geardaddy Mar 2012 #37
Just about all of them, IMO pipi_k Mar 2012 #22
Lawrence Block has taken a beating in Hollywood. dogknob Mar 2012 #23
'The Magus' - on the Canon of the top 100 novels of the 20th century. banned from Kos Mar 2012 #24
Interview with the Vampire /eom IcyPeas Mar 2012 #25
Atlas Shrugged Orrex Mar 2012 #29
Every Heinlein book so far OriginalGeek Mar 2012 #30
Starship Troopers made you wonder... jmowreader Mar 2012 #31
Paul Verhoven has a time machine, and that movie was an allegory on the Iraq War Taverner Mar 2012 #66
I'd love to see a good Stranger or Time Enough for Love Dragonbreathp9d Mar 2012 #53
Lemony Snickett's "A Series of Unfortunate Events" PassingFair Mar 2012 #32
HBO's version of A Bright Shining Lie really sucked. taterguy Mar 2012 #33
Anything by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. mikeSchmuckabee Mar 2012 #34
Mother Night is a great book. geardaddy Mar 2012 #36
Mother Night is great. Canis Mala Mar 2012 #46
I didn't hate Slaughterhouse 5 (the film) mikeSchmuckabee Mar 2012 #78
I've read many Vonnegut books mikeSchmuckabee Mar 2012 #77
Breakfast of Champions geardaddy Mar 2012 #35
Agreed, but that was tough material for film n/t Spike89 Mar 2012 #41
Yeah, it was. geardaddy Mar 2012 #42
The Good German ceile Mar 2012 #38
Dune. arbusto_baboso Mar 2012 #39
Agreed. The Dino D/David Lynch version sucked. RZM Mar 2012 #43
I thought the SCIFI miniseries was great Dragonbreathp9d Mar 2012 #54
Even Cowgirls Get the Blues/The Postman Spike89 Mar 2012 #40
Most Stephen King movies, with the exception of the Frank Darabont ones RZM Mar 2012 #44
I second that.. Doctor Who Mar 2012 #47
Misery and The Green Mile are my exceptions Dragonbreathp9d Mar 2012 #55
I liked a few of them RZM Mar 2012 #57
Oh god the langoliers! Hahahahaha! Dragonbreathp9d Mar 2012 #58
I'm both anticipating and fearful that Ron Howard is making The Dark Tower. Chan790 Mar 2012 #65
Dreamcatcher movie was the worst King book/movie adaptation Broken_Hero Mar 2012 #79
Never saw it, but I've heard really bad things n/t RZM Mar 2012 #80
The Magic Christian n/t Tabasco_Dave Mar 2012 #45
'Contact' by Carl Sagan. Denninmi Mar 2012 #48
Agreed. n/t Bertha Venation Mar 2012 #49
A Princess Of Mars. Iggo Mar 2012 #51
The Half Blood Prince Dragonbreathp9d Mar 2012 #56
I thought the second part of Deathly Hallows was the worst XemaSab Mar 2012 #59
Jaws, The Godfather, Shawshank Redemption! Logical Mar 2012 #69
Haunting of Hill House remake XemaSab Mar 2012 #60
Bonfire of the Vanities lovemydog Mar 2012 #61
That CGI "Beowulf" from a few years back was a major WTF Blue_Tires Mar 2012 #63
I wanna know why they didn't do it in the orignal Anglo-Saxon geardaddy Mar 2012 #86
A Separate Peace-OK book Mendocino Mar 2012 #64
Watership Down Populist_Prole Mar 2012 #68
The film removed... dogknob Mar 2012 #70
Did you ever read Plague Dogs? alphafemale Mar 2012 #73
Yeah. That may have belonged on that "most depressing movies" thread dogknob Mar 2012 #89
The Dark is Rising by Susan Cooper tanyev Mar 2012 #72
How has this thread run three days with no mention of... Bruce Wayne Mar 2012 #74
Looking for Alibrandi RFKHumphreyObama Mar 2012 #75
An honourable mention should go to almost every Roald Dahl book adapted into a movie RFKHumphreyObama Mar 2012 #76
I liked Wes Anderson's version of "The Fantastic Mr. Fox" Burma Jones Mar 2012 #84
Oh, I LOVED Matilda. PassingFair Mar 2012 #85
1984 sakabatou Mar 2012 #81
ANY Terry Pratchett/Neil Gaiman/tom Robbins book cannot translate to film. dixiegrrrrl Mar 2012 #87
Clan of the Cave Bear Marrah_G Mar 2012 #88
The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. Codeine Mar 2012 #90
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Great Books turned into b...»Reply #1