In the discussion thread: Salon: Home-schooled and illiterate - for some kids it means isolation with little education [View all]
Response to Amerigo Vespucci (Original post)
Fri Mar 16, 2012, 08:44 AM
no_hypocrisy (25,711 posts)
2. Consequences of "home schooling".
I've been the legal representative of a mother. All her children were removed three years ago by Child Welfare. One of the allegations is educational neglect. She may lose her parental rights and the kids adopted by the foster parents. We're in trial right now.
Because she kept her three eldest children out of public or private schools. The eldest couldn't go beyond "J" in his ABC's at age 8. Fortunately once the kids were in enrolled in school by social services, they not only caught up in months, but have continued to excel in their grades.
It's debatable how much culpability can be attributed my client as she lived under the thumb of her husband-abuser and was a victim of domestic violence. Whatever her husband said or wanted became the law. The kids watched television (including educational television) most of the time and she read them books. She wanted the kids to go to school and there were options. Although client and her husband withheld vaccinations on "religious grounds", the public school would have accepted the kids and they were poor enough to qualify for financial hardship scholarships at the local Catholic School. The father/husband/abuser just wanted to control the kids. (More likely he didn't want the kids in school to reveal the abuse going on in his house.)
Does my client regret her role in keeping the kids out of school? Sure, she does. The kids have been remediated and she'd put them in school if they are returned.
BTW, my client moved to another state 18 months after the children were removed, to escape her husband and go into hiding from him. She's gone to counseling, therapy for the DV. She's completed school herself and has received two certifications, one advanced, as an EKG technician. She was top of her class gradewise. And she's days away from getting a final divorce judgment from her estranged husband.
I'm not defending her per se as much as explaining what happened.
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
|Amerigo Vespucci||Mar 2012||OP|
|get the red out||Mar 2012||#6|
Consequences of "home schooling".
|Bonhomme Richard||Mar 2012||#4|
|Amerigo Vespucci||Mar 2012||#19|
|Lydia Leftcoast||Mar 2012||#32|
Please login to view edit histories.