Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
32. You MUST read this even if a more nuanced explanation is ultimately more accurate (eg post #26).
Sun Apr 8, 2012, 07:53 PM
Apr 2012
http://adventuresinautism.blogspot.com/2012/04/dr-walter-zahorodny-believes-vaccines.html

Posted by Ginger Taylor at Tuesday, April 03, 2012

Dr. Walter Zahorodny Believes Vaccines Cause Autism. And Geri Dawson???


From a Radio Listener in NYC:
I was listening this AM to WNYC – Kurt Andersen, of all hostile people, did a segment on the ADDM numbers with Walter Zahorodny, assistant professor of pediatrics at the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey in Newark. Zahorodny was the lead researcher on the New Jersey portion of the study.

Kurt Andersen (Seth Mnookin's friend): “I guess we know what they (the causes of autism) aren’t, for instance childhood vaccines. Right?”

Dr. Zahorodny: “Vaccines don’t play a significant role in autism increasing. Some small number of children probably do have autism because of an adverse vaccine reaction, but they don’t make for the overall rise.”

D'oh!

What's that you say Dr. Z? Vaccines don't cause most autism, but they do cause some autism?? You don't say?!

When the brainwashed "science media" can't even get those involved in the research to hold the "vaccines do not cause autism" line any more... we can be assured that the Hungry Lie is falling apart in earnest and the end of the vaccine age is near.

If anyone can confirm or has audio, would love to hear it.

UPDATE:

Confirmation. Starts at 13:20: AUDIO AT LINK.

It is CRAZY how blase he is about this. Like he is reporting a light rain moving in from the west in the late afternoon. Drops a bomb and strolls on by.

Worth listening to the whole interview as it counters many of the media talking points.

His thoughts are that:
•NJ high rate is because they have a better reporting system and they looked at both educational and medical records, where other states only looked at medical records, so other states are likely as high as NJ
•The increase is real
•The NJ 2002 rate and this number is a real increase because the reporting system was designed to measure that exactly
•Fluctuations due to 1994 DSM4 changes would have been settled in the first years and would not impact rates now
•Most cases they found were serious autism, not a load of high functioning cases that would have been mised before
•DSM5 will "muddy the waters" on autism tracking

UPDATE:

So is Geri Dawson joining Dr. Zahorodny? Looks that way to me!

Only a year ago, Autism Speaks science director Geri Dawson said we are not allowed to talk about vaccines any more. But now she says this...

Tom Ashbrook interviewed her on NPR:
Ashbrook: "Dr. Dawson, here's a question online from Melrose, has the link between MMR vaccine and autism been completely discredited. I notice that the word 'vaccine' has not even come up so far in this hour. Is that...for some years that had a lot of attention, is that off the table now, Dr. Dawson?"

Dr. Dawson: "There is no evidence that the increase in prevalence that we're seeing in Autism Spectrum Disorder is linked to the MMR vaccine. You know, if vaccines play a role, and there has not been any evidence thus far to show that it has, it would be a very small minority of individuals who have an underlying medical condition where the vaccine may have triggered an onset of symptoms for an already existing condition or vulnerability. So we do not believe that vaccines are an explanation of the increase and we strongly encourage parents to get their children vaccinated."

So again... thrown the softball and didn't take it!

Ashbrook, like Andersen, took the initiative of bringing the vaccine question into the interview, and in both cases it was merely an invitation to declare the vaccine hypothesis DOA. And neither Zahorodny or Dawson took the opportunity to do so!

They BOTH could have said, "Correct." And just moved on. But they didn't!

They both contradicted their interviewers presumptive statements, and said a version of, "Incorrect, vaccines do cause autism in some children, and it is a smaller number of cases than people think, but I don't see that vaccine induced autism could be playing a major factor in the increase."

IMHO... no way in h-e-double hockey sticks that these two didn't know exactly what they were doing. They had every chance to run from vaccine causation and they didn't. They confirmed it. Then they minimized it.

We have just witnessed the very quiet pushing of the envelope. Dr. Geri Dawson and Dr. Walter Zahorodny have just joined you and me and all our friends in taking our position that vaccines cause some cases of autism, just not all the cases of autism. Now we are only separated by the degree in which we believe the vaccine induced autism is a factor in the skyrocketing autism numbers.

Geri said something very interesting... and true...
"You know, if vaccines play a role [in rising autism prevalence], and there has not been any evidence thus far to show that it has."

...if by "evidence" of course, she means "scientific research" because there is plenty of data to show that vaccines cause autism, but none that I know of to show how often vaccines cause autism. Remember... we are all still pretending that it doesn't happen at all. So can you imagine the research funding proposal that would read, "It has been established that vaccines are one of the causes of autism, this team endeavors to discover how much of the rise in autism cases are due to vaccine induced autism." HA! Betcha Autism Speaks and CDC would just THROW money at that ask!

Which brings us back to the statement that David Bowman of HRSA issued three years ago:
"The government has never compensated, nor has it ever been ordered to compensate, any case based on a determination that autism was actually caused by vaccines. We have compensated cases in which children exhibited an encephalopathy, or general brain disease. Encephalopathy may be accompanied by a medical progression of an array of symptoms including autistic behavior, autism, or seizures.

Some children who have been compensated for vaccine injuries may have shown signs of autism before the decision to compensate, or may ultimately end up with autism or autistic symptoms, but we do not track cases on this basis."

Not even the government keeps track of their own cases of vaccine induced autism!

So do vaccines cause autism? YES! Now we just need to know how often that happens!
I have worked with kids on the autism spectrum HockeyMom Mar 2012 #1
The ratio is about 4 to 1 KamaAina Mar 2012 #3
BiPolar also seems to dominate among girls HockeyMom Mar 2012 #14
It's now being considered that ADHD is a possible sign of later onset of bipolar. I know GreenPartyVoter Mar 2012 #20
Now that you mention it HockeyMom Mar 2012 #21
Maybe. My mom was on hormone replacement therapy when she was GreenPartyVoter Mar 2012 #22
I've met a lot of guys who are bi-polar. Neoma Apr 2012 #37
I have one of each, Throckmorton Mar 2012 #7
There is an interesting book called "The Imprinted Gene" that... Odin2005 Mar 2012 #15
Thanks, Odin. BlueIris May 2012 #60
Cue someone blaming vaccines in three... two... TheWraith Mar 2012 #2
One boy's family blamed it on the vaccines HockeyMom Mar 2012 #5
So how does the family try and explain it? sakabatou Mar 2012 #9
Probably the same way laundry_queen Apr 2012 #46
three... More likely an extreme shortage of the pro-hormone Cholecalciferol Bearware Apr 2012 #26
Until the source is known nothing should be taken off the table. harun Apr 2012 #34
In that case, I declare that autism is caused by unicorn shit. TheWraith Apr 2012 #36
Stay tuned. proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #39
A bit of logic miss there.. X_Digger Mar 2012 #4
+1 sakabatou Mar 2012 #6
I recall a resent study of late middle age people Throckmorton Mar 2012 #10
Funny you should mention that zipplewrath Mar 2012 #11
*nod* Or a study (were it possible).. X_Digger Mar 2012 #13
While that is definitely true, HockeyMom Mar 2012 #17
You were expecting accurate journalism? TheWraith Mar 2012 #23
I live in hope. X_Digger Mar 2012 #24
For years I was diagnosed as having an anxiety disorder sakabatou Mar 2012 #8
See, I TOLD people that it is about more people getting diagnosed. Odin2005 Mar 2012 #12
I agree with you on the anti-vax folks. AverageJoe90 Apr 2012 #44
Higher rates in Utah? Didn't someone just post an apology letter from a grandparent midnight Mar 2012 #16
I know two families with Autism Marrah_G Mar 2012 #18
In the old days, the low-functioning autistic kids would have simply been labeled Lydia Leftcoast Mar 2012 #19
OFFICIAL DATA: the autism rate for boys born in NJ in 2000 is 1 in 29 reports Mark Blaxill (@ 4:09). proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #25
"Living in Utah... baby boy will have a 1 in 32 chance of being autistic, the highest risk in US." proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #27
ENVIRONMENTAL QUESTIONS: Occupy EPA Action, 3/30/12,"If the EPA were occupied with sound science..." proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #28
Of mice & children: does this happen in infants & should it comprise a contraindication, like fever? proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #29
I'm sorry, but 1 in 32!?!? AverageJoe90 Apr 2012 #45
Wrong, sorry. The stats are from ADDM, a project of the CDC and its parent agency, DHHS. proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #48
This message was self-deleted by its author AverageJoe90 Apr 2012 #54
I'm terribly sorry, but........ AverageJoe90 Apr 2012 #55
Runs 1 to 2 in my house. Throckmorton Apr 2012 #30
Consider $$$ as factor in increase of this diagnosis panzerfaust Apr 2012 #31
You MUST read this even if a more nuanced explanation is ultimately more accurate (eg post #26). proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #32
HHS Press Release naming new public members of Interagency Autism Coordinating Committee: proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #33
Ouch, PUSHBACK. The devastating grievances detailed here warrant attention. proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #35
Post removed Post removed Apr 2012 #38
Harvard Health Publications: The Autism Revolution by Martha Herbert, MD, PhD, with Karen Weintraub. proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #40
Previous links. proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #41
I know very little about autism, but saw this at Alternet today, polly7 Apr 2012 #42
More on Brick Township, NJ reported by Mark Blaxill here: proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #49
More on NJ Senator Lautenberg's Safe Chemicals Act here. proverbialwisdom Apr 2012 #50
My view is the EXACT opposite. AverageJoe90 Apr 2012 #43
A lot of Autistic people were misdiagnosed or undiagnosed until... Odin2005 Apr 2012 #47
It's kind of ironic, but....... AverageJoe90 Apr 2012 #56
I have aspergers raps Apr 2012 #51
Welcome to DU! gkhouston Apr 2012 #52
Welcome! Odin2005 Apr 2012 #53
As an ADD guy who was misdiagnosed as supposedly being Aspie........ AverageJoe90 Apr 2012 #57
Physicians for Social Responsibility: Impending Vote on Safe Chemicals Act! proverbialwisdom May 2012 #58
Could school funding have anything to do with it? jmowreader May 2012 #59
"Not 1 newborn American baby has been tested without finding 100's of chemicals in umbilical cord." proverbialwisdom May 2012 #61
Age of Autism = Bullshit. Odin2005 May 2012 #62
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Autism in US more common ...»Reply #32