HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » Latest Breaking News (Forum) » Pregnant Teen Wins Aborti... » Reply #93

Reply #93

In the discussion thread: Pregnant Teen Wins Abortion Battle [View all]

Response to davidn3600 (Original post)

Tue Feb 19, 2013, 06:45 PM

93. 1) "Roe" made this her choice. There can be no obligation for her to abort.

2) The tattoo/cigarette/pot comparison doesn't work. This is the natural biological outcome of a natural biological function. It's on the parents as long as she's a minor. It's no different than if she got cancer or an inflamed appendix.

3) Speaking of on-the-parents: let this be a lesson; if you don't want to raise grandkids or pay for them, you might want to discuss something more reality based than abstinence. $2.00 probably would have solved this problem.

4) Assuming that what the girl said was true, I get what the parents were trying to do. Make the kid work two jobs and take away perqs to welcome their daughter to the wonderful world of single motherhood. Sorry parents, wrong answer, IMHO. Here is what I would do instead: a) make her give up the name of dad, and sue/negotiate for paternity/child support; b) immediately dual enroll my daughter in Community College and a GED program c) get her into a line of studies that will get her a job with benefits in 2 years or less d) now that we're not kidding ourselves about her being abstinent, get her on birth control. Their object should be to get her to realistic self-sufficiency.

5) There are worse things in life than having a kid young. She could have been injured or killed in a car wreck; OD'd; been raped (hmy understanding is that is not how she became pregnant); attempted suicide; or any one of the thousands of other bad things that happen to young women. Her life will be hard, but she's far from the first woman to have a baby at 16. The parents will be far from the first to have a grand kid from their high school aged daughter. The parents have a choice now: they can throw this whole burden on their daughter, or they can try their hand at being grandparents. Personally, I hope they can heal their family and learn to love their grandkid.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 244 replies Author Time Post
davidn3600 Feb 19 OP
annabanana Feb 19 #1
HockeyMom Feb 19 #2
annabanana Feb 19 #4
Tumbulu Feb 19 #6
TEXASYANKEE Feb 19 #10
HockeyMom Feb 19 #11
Tumbulu Feb 19 #14
HockeyMom Feb 19 #27
Drale Feb 19 #61
demwing Feb 19 #81
HockeyMom Feb 19 #85
uppityperson Feb 19 #90
Exultant Democracy Feb 19 #145
Tumbulu Feb 19 #161
MADem Feb 20 #204
AlbertCat Feb 19 #96
demwing Feb 19 #156
AlbertCat Feb 20 #207
demwing Feb 20 #217
Tumbulu Feb 19 #136
Tumbulu Feb 19 #137
leftyohiolib Feb 19 #151
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #53
avebury Feb 19 #82
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #87
avebury Feb 19 #94
AlbertCat Feb 19 #97
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #105
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #98
Tumbulu Feb 19 #163
elehhhhna Feb 19 #113
Tumbulu Feb 19 #139
avebury Feb 19 #148
Tumbulu Feb 19 #154
avebury Feb 19 #171
Tumbulu Feb 19 #172
MADem Feb 20 #206
Horse with no Name Feb 19 #106
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #109
Horse with no Name Feb 19 #117
McCamy Taylor Feb 19 #122
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #123
obamanut2012 Feb 19 #127
Blue4Texas Feb 19 #129
loudsue Feb 19 #70
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #78
MADem Feb 20 #203
Tumbulu Feb 19 #16
Sekhmets Daughter Feb 19 #35
smirkymonkey Feb 19 #141
Tumbulu Feb 19 #158
Tumbulu Feb 19 #157
freshwest Feb 19 #168
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #185
freshwest Feb 20 #196
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #201
MADem Feb 20 #208
freshwest Feb 20 #210
wisteria Feb 19 #39
Tumbulu Feb 19 #12
leftynyc Feb 19 #17
Tumbulu Feb 19 #23
davidn3600 Feb 19 #28
wisteria Feb 19 #43
Tumbulu Feb 19 #135
wisteria Feb 19 #41
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #51
Marrah_G Feb 19 #74
ScreamingMeemie Feb 20 #225
The Flaming Red Head Feb 22 #243
wisteria Feb 19 #31
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #55
Tumbulu Feb 19 #142
TexasBushwhacker Feb 22 #238
alp227 Feb 19 #80
elehhhhna Feb 19 #118
MADem Feb 20 #211
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #186
alp227 Feb 20 #197
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #199
alp227 Feb 20 #202
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #205
alp227 Feb 20 #209
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #212
riderinthestorm Feb 20 #219
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #221
riderinthestorm Feb 20 #222
MADem Feb 20 #213
The Flaming Red Head Feb 22 #241
booley Feb 19 #3
Jerry442 Feb 19 #45
HockeyMom Feb 19 #57
CaliforniaPeggy Feb 19 #5
wordpix Feb 19 #101
Tumbulu Feb 19 #143
Puzzledtraveller Feb 19 #153
wordpix Feb 20 #183
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #187
wordpix Feb 20 #228
The Flaming Red Head Feb 22 #242
leftyohiolib Feb 19 #159
bhikkhu Feb 19 #160
rox63 Feb 19 #7
kurtzapril4 Feb 19 #46
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #56
Igel Feb 19 #116
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #121
SylviaD Feb 19 #8
iandhr Feb 19 #20
alp227 Feb 19 #84
iandhr Feb 19 #131
Dreamer Tatum Feb 19 #58
azurnoir Feb 19 #9
Dont call me Shirley Feb 19 #25
HockeyMom Feb 19 #30
azurnoir Feb 19 #34
Sekhmets Daughter Feb 19 #40
azurnoir Feb 19 #44
Sekhmets Daughter Feb 19 #52
azurnoir Feb 19 #59
Sekhmets Daughter Feb 19 #65
azurnoir Feb 19 #71
Sekhmets Daughter Feb 19 #72
KatyMan Feb 19 #92
MADem Feb 20 #214
Igel Feb 19 #120
Katashi_itto Feb 19 #13
SaveAmerica Feb 19 #15
azurnoir Feb 19 #22
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #188
azurnoir Feb 20 #195
JDPriestly Feb 19 #18
HockeyMom Feb 19 #32
JDPriestly Feb 20 #177
snooper2 Feb 19 #48
happyslug Feb 19 #162
JDPriestly Feb 20 #178
happyslug Feb 20 #223
riderinthestorm Feb 20 #224
happyslug Feb 21 #231
riderinthestorm Feb 21 #232
happyslug Feb 21 #233
happyslug Feb 21 #234
riderinthestorm Feb 21 #236
happyslug Feb 21 #237
iandhr Feb 19 #19
alp227 Feb 19 #88
Igel Feb 19 #124
iandhr Feb 19 #133
alp227 Feb 20 #200
Crunchy Frog Feb 20 #175
alp227 Feb 20 #198
Xithras Feb 19 #21
azurnoir Feb 19 #24
NaturalHigh Feb 19 #134
bluestateguy Feb 19 #26
VA_Jill Feb 19 #38
wisteria Feb 19 #47
rachel1 Feb 19 #29
wisteria Feb 19 #36
wordpix Feb 19 #107
wisteria Feb 19 #33
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #49
wisteria Feb 19 #60
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #63
azurnoir Feb 19 #62
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #66
notadmblnd Feb 19 #91
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #100
notadmblnd Feb 19 #103
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #114
Yo_Mama Feb 19 #130
VA_Jill Feb 19 #37
Jerry442 Feb 19 #50
wisteria Feb 19 #54
DaveJ Feb 19 #64
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #67
jeff47 Feb 19 #69
riderinthestorm Feb 19 #76
jeff47 Feb 19 #146
riderinthestorm Feb 20 #218
bluestateguy Feb 19 #42
DollarBillHines Feb 19 #73
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #192
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #190
HockeyMom Feb 19 #68
uppityperson Feb 19 #75
HockeyMom Feb 19 #83
uppityperson Feb 19 #89
Horse with no Name Feb 19 #119
uppityperson Feb 19 #77
tammywammy Feb 20 #229
marybourg Feb 19 #79
MADem Feb 20 #215
happyslug Feb 21 #235
Ilsa Feb 19 #86
LineReply 1) "Roe" made this her choice. There can be no obligation for her to abort.
OmahaBlueDog Feb 19 #93
krispos42 Feb 19 #95
wordpix Feb 19 #99
Blue_Tires Feb 19 #102
McCamy Taylor Feb 19 #115
MADem Feb 20 #216
UnseenUndergrad Feb 20 #230
Horse with no Name Feb 19 #104
wordpix Feb 19 #111
NaturalHigh Feb 19 #138
wordpix Feb 20 #184
NaturalHigh Feb 20 #226
AzDar Feb 19 #108
smirkymonkey Feb 19 #144
Tumbulu Feb 19 #165
Pool Hall Ace Feb 19 #110
treestar Feb 19 #112
McCamy Taylor Feb 19 #125
Tumbulu Feb 19 #166
judesedit Feb 19 #126
christx30 Feb 22 #244
mountain grammy Feb 19 #128
Tumbulu Feb 19 #167
obama2terms Feb 19 #132
NaturalHigh Feb 19 #140
CC Feb 19 #147
NaturalHigh Feb 19 #150
Manifestor_of_Light Feb 20 #174
Pterodactyl Feb 19 #149
Tumbulu Feb 19 #170
Pterodactyl Feb 19 #173
Ken Burch Feb 19 #152
Puzzledtraveller Feb 19 #155
etherealtruth Feb 20 #180
EastKYLiberal Feb 20 #182
La Lioness Priyanka Feb 20 #189
happyslug Feb 19 #164
muriel_volestrangler Feb 20 #194
Nine Feb 20 #227
Nine Feb 19 #169
secondwind Feb 20 #176
TexasBushwhacker Feb 22 #239
Notafraidtoo Feb 20 #179
avebury Feb 20 #181
Jennicut Feb 22 #240
pink-o Feb 20 #191
Nine Feb 20 #193
riderinthestorm Feb 20 #220
Please login to view edit histories.