Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Gothmog

(144,920 posts)
53. It depends on the chartering organization
Mon Jan 28, 2013, 07:10 PM
Jan 2013

My troop, pack and explorer unit are chartered by my temple which is a Reformed Jewish congregation. While we are chartered by a Jewish Congregation, we have non-Jewish scouts in the troop and the pack as well as Jewish scouts who are from other temples or synagogues. Many troops are chartered by religious institutions and some troops restrict their membership to members of their organization. LDS units tend to restrict their members to members of the LDS faith in part because these churches use the Boy Scouts as their main male youth program.

I would also point out that there is a split among Jewish units. The Reformed congregations are the ones fighting the current BSA policy while the Orthodox and Conservative congregations have no trouble with the BSA's policy. There have been some heated discussions on this issue among the National Jewish Committee on Scouting with troops chartered by the Reformed Congregation being in the minority.

Anyone can charter a Unit subject to BSA approval. The trouble would be in recruiting sufficient members to be a viable unit.

This is an issue that has prevented us from allowing our boys in scouting AllyCat Jan 2013 #1
We didn't allow our son to join Cub Scouts. We made our own group. Arugula Latte Jan 2013 #19
Interesting. I don't like a group that discriminates against certain people. AllyCat Jan 2013 #22
We just did our own group. Arugula Latte Jan 2013 #38
I don't have children but I have insisted that family members with sons do just as you have done Blasphemer Jan 2013 #76
I would love to see this happen. n/t TDale313 Jan 2013 #2
Oh God. ForgoTheConsequence Jan 2013 #3
Didn't we just go through this... DonViejo Jan 2013 #4
The BSA is getting hammered Xithras Jan 2013 #12
Maybe now that Romney lost, they're less concerned about the LDS. n/t Ian David Jan 2013 #13
Even Mitt Romney said that the BSA should drop the ban Xithras Jan 2013 #32
Yes, but he said that years ago. He's certainly flip-flopped by now. n/t Ian David Jan 2013 #33
Possibly Xithras Jan 2013 #36
They deserved the hammering they got... DonViejo Jan 2013 #25
I agree. This is mostly the national Committee trying .... oldhippie Jan 2013 #74
I absolutely do NOT agree with that. Xithras Jan 2013 #80
Core values of hatred and bigotry? dbackjon Jan 2013 #83
I find it hard to believe that a "former scout" would say that. Xithras Jan 2013 #86
It is far more than a few Texas Bigots dbackjon Jan 2013 #89
The proposal would not leave the decision to the units, but to the chartering organization. Xithras Jan 2013 #90
80% of Scouting units in Arizona dbackjon Jan 2013 #91
There's some debate as to what would happen with the Catholic units. Xithras Jan 2013 #92
Here you go - Catholic and Mormon bigots won't change. No hope for Arizona Scouting. dbackjon Jan 2013 #93
The quote from Sister Walsh is the one I was talking about. Xithras Jan 2013 #94
So if the BSA allows local decision dbackjon Jan 2013 #95
Yes, the local facilities would not be permitted to block them. Xithras Jan 2013 #96
That is interesting to know -thanks dbackjon Jan 2013 #97
Not good enough surrealAmerican Jan 2013 #5
They would just be following President Obama's lead on Gay Rights being a local issue dbackjon Jan 2013 #18
w00t! Taverner Jan 2013 #6
It would be one of those "bout time" Bohunk68 Jan 2013 #7
I'll believe it when I see it. Fearless Jan 2013 #8
But they'll allow local bigotry? SpartanDem Jan 2013 #9
Yet I got hammered here for not being impressed with President Obama dbackjon Jan 2013 #20
And you still haven't done the research I recommended to you DonViejo Jan 2013 #30
I have done my research. Have you really done yours? dbackjon Jan 2013 #45
When someone relies on racist comments... DonViejo Jan 2013 #47
There was nothing racist in my comments dbackjon Jan 2013 #49
It's a crack in the facade. It should be celebrated for that reason alone. randome Jan 2013 #26
"color me unimpressed with this "change"." SoapBox Jan 2013 #42
Many of us involved in scouting have LONG said that this was a simple compromise. Xithras Jan 2013 #10
No, not fine if the local group, part of national organization, discriminates HERVEPA Jan 2013 #11
First off, this would be a first step. Xithras Jan 2013 #17
Thank you Stargazer09 Jan 2013 #28
I am the CRO for my unit Gothmog Jan 2013 #31
No it is not dbackjon Jan 2013 #66
And, remember, the "Friggin Mormon" cult, was in the shadows behind SoapBox Jan 2013 #43
Exactly. And not quite the shadows. Big, big bucks. HERVEPA Jan 2013 #46
Suppose they're the only group in town TrogL Jan 2013 #52
There is no limit to the density of scouting units. Xithras Jan 2013 #57
You haven't been in much of the rural west or south then dbackjon Jan 2013 #67
You're conflating problems. Xithras Jan 2013 #81
And you are excusing bigotry and hatred dbackjon Jan 2013 #82
To paraphraise Voltaire, "Perfection is the enemy of progress". Xithras Jan 2013 #84
If wanting immediate equality for all ends the existence of BSA dbackjon Jan 2013 #85
That's where our opinions split. Xithras Jan 2013 #87
kick! hedgehog Jan 2013 #14
A step forward for progress iandhr Jan 2013 #15
How about atheists? Arugula Latte Jan 2013 #16
Tell them you pray to the FSM Lesmoderesstupides Jan 2013 #24
Ironically, that would work. Xithras Jan 2013 #41
In my book FSM is just as valid as any other god people pray too Lesmoderesstupides Jan 2013 #44
I never got any shit for being an atheist in the Scouts. Codeine Jan 2013 #58
AFAIK most worldwide Scouting has an issue with non-theists. mwooldri Jan 2013 #60
I went through 7 years as an adult leader Gore1FL Jan 2013 #61
I'd never participate in an organization that had an official no gays/no atheists policy, though. Arugula Latte Jan 2013 #70
The US has had backwards laws an policies. Gore1FL Jan 2013 #71
I never liked the rah rah rightwing patriotic bent of the Scouts. Arugula Latte Jan 2013 #72
I didn't experience that right-wing patriotic bent Gore1FL Jan 2013 #77
Excellent. K&R for progress, and may it continue. Brickbat Jan 2013 #21
The Mormons relax BSA rules? longship Jan 2013 #23
"other organizations have threatened to withdraw their financial support if the BSA drops the ban." KamaAina Jan 2013 #27
United Way Gothmog Jan 2013 #34
No, no. He's saying some groups will cease funding if they DROP the ban. KamaAina Jan 2013 #35
They BSA would be better off if the policy is changed Gothmog Jan 2013 #39
Why in the name of the FSM are there troops that are segregated by religion? KamaAina Jan 2013 #48
It depends on the chartering organization Gothmog Jan 2013 #53
This may be the best that we can hope for Gothmog Jan 2013 #29
Discrimination at the Local LEvel is the BEST we could hope for? dbackjon Jan 2013 #68
That leaves atheists as the sole pariah now. no_hypocrisy Jan 2013 #37
My local troop when I was younger openly ignored the ban NYC Liberal Jan 2013 #40
One of the New York Councils has stated that it was ignoring the national policy Gothmog Jan 2013 #54
Okay, as long as they're not ATHEIST Gay members... brooklynite Jan 2013 #50
SMOKE & MIRRORS! William769 Jan 2013 #51
This is where I like the Canadian Scouts Posteritatis Jan 2013 #55
Most if not all of World Scouting Organizations reject the BSA policy Gothmog Jan 2013 #56
It is important for one reason. Gore1FL Jan 2013 #79
I am so happy d_r Jan 2013 #59
This isn't the victory a lot are making it out to be. AngryOldDem Jan 2013 #62
I disagree Gothmog Jan 2013 #63
... but only if they agree to castration? panzerfaust Jan 2013 #64
Too late. Occulus Jan 2013 #65
This Eagle Scout CRK7376 Jan 2013 #69
This Eagle Scout Gore1FL Jan 2013 #78
Not that I have a dog in this fight Le Taz Hot Jan 2013 #73
My son's scout group is headed by a transgendered man marshall Jan 2013 #75
I can't help but laugh at all the right wingers calling up on the radio... davidn3600 Jan 2013 #88
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»NBC News: Boy Scouts Clos...»Reply #53