Reply #6

In the discussion thread: Israel Broadens Bombing in Gaza to Civilian Sites [View all]

Response to bupkus (Reply #4)

Sat Nov 17, 2012, 02:52 PM

madrchsod (55,741 posts)

6. many years ago i was banned for three days for saying something simliar

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

121 replies	Author	Time	Post
Israel Broadens Bombing in Gaza to Civilian Sites [View all]	Welcome_hubby	Nov 2012	OP
The cable channels are not really covering this story that well. They just show a few pictures..	hrmjustin	Nov 2012	#1
Amy Goodman interviews Noam Chomsky on Gaza-	crunch60	Nov 2012	#3
Genocide?	oberliner	Nov 2012	#7
Stop U.S., EU support for Israeli genocide	crunch60	Nov 2012	#29
There is no Genocide going on in the Gaza Strip	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#30
You speak with such conviction. Sorry, I trust the views of Chomsky, who has been studying	crunch60	Nov 2012	#32
I could care less what that idiot says about Israel	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#33
And if your wife was Palestinian, what would your position be?	Ash_F	Nov 2012	#34
I am arguing objectivly	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#35
For the record...	Ash_F	Nov 2012	#37
Chomsky is an idiot IMO	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#43
Then you have a different definition of genocide than the legal one. /nt	Ash_F	Nov 2012	#47
I lived under apartheid in So. Africa for two years , the similarities are frightening.	crunch60	Nov 2012	#53
you linked to an antisemitic website	Mosby	Nov 2012	#99
Genocide requires	eyl	Nov 2012	#81
You don't see the correlation?	Ash_F	Nov 2012	#91
Gaza is a concentration camp	RobertEarl	Nov 2012	#38
I really don't care what you are	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#40
Do you believe that the Palestinians likewise have the right to defend themselves?	Orrex	Nov 2012	#41
If they're attacked, yes	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#45
I would be interested to hear whether they think they've been attacked	Orrex	Nov 2012	#50
Simply not true. Israel broke the ceasefire both times.	Puregonzo1188	Nov 2012	#67
Maybe they wouldn't feel the need to defend themselves	arikara	Nov 2012	#86
I agree with that	Ash_F	Nov 2012	#42
Look	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#48
Then at least we have some common ground.	Ash_F	Nov 2012	#51
'If you were Palestinian living in Israel, you would not be allowed to live with your Jewish wife'	King_David	Nov 2012	#96
You can do your own research.	Ash_F	Nov 2012	#98
Well it's bullshit	King_David	Nov 2012	#101
If it was literally anyone else in this thread who questioned it..	Ash_F	Nov 2012	#103
Well what you said was libelous against Israel	King_David	Nov 2012	#105
Gaza is a modern day concentration camp	RobertEarl	Nov 2012	#44
That is so much crap	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#46
Of course they do	RobertEarl	Nov 2012	#49
Actually there were more attacks against Israel when Gaza was more open	oberliner	Nov 2012	#54
More open is the keyword	RobertEarl	Nov 2012	#56
Why are you suprised?	fingrinn	Nov 2012	#64
Feeling the Jewish love?	fingrinn	Nov 2012	#63
Jewish love	King_David	Nov 2012	#72
This message was self-deleted by its author	Scootaloo	Nov 2012	#88
The Three Stooges strike again!	Scootaloo	Nov 2012	#88
Abba Eban	King_David	Nov 2012	#71
So you agree	RobertEarl	Nov 2012	#73
No I do not agree	King_David	Nov 2012	#75
Oh	RobertEarl	Nov 2012	#76
It is against DU rules to compare Jews to Nazis,	King_David	Nov 2012	#77
Not what I did	RobertEarl	Nov 2012	#79
You would be funny if it were not so serious , Really??	King_David	Nov 2012	#80
Again, enough said.	fingrinn	Nov 2012	#62
Chomsky didn't claim that. The poster did.	Puregonzo1188	Nov 2012	#66
Enough said.	fingrinn	Nov 2012	#61
That sounds like it was written by a Nazi, not a Jew.	Raksha	Nov 2012	#104
I want to modify my previous response to your post.	Raksha	Nov 2012	#112
+1	King_David	Nov 2012	#70
Those talking points are tired and no longer	EmeraldCityGrl	Nov 2012	#87
Chomsky is to the "Left" what Rush Limbaugh is to the "Right". nt	AdHocSolver	Nov 2012	#39
Chomsky and Limbaugh names should not be put into the same sentence.	crunch60	Nov 2012	#58
Yes. I recall watching Chomsky physically mocking Parkinson's symptoms	Crunchy Frog	Nov 2012	#92
Here's another brilliant idea. Stop terrorizing Gaza and Hamas will stop rockets like they have done	Puregonzo1188	Nov 2012	#65
Hamas will stop rockets when	King_David	Nov 2012	#74
Your username's King David, like the King David Hotel?	Puregonzo1188	Nov 2012	#106
Think King David was a hotel?	King_David	Nov 2012	#107
Genocide?	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#12
"The genocide that is taking place in Gaza is a unspoken horror. We must stop this assault."	EX500rider	Nov 2012	#52
genocide ?	King_David	Nov 2012	#69
I'm so relieved that no acts of terrorism are being committed during this process.	Orrex	Nov 2012	#2
This post was hidden by jury decision.	bupkus	Nov 2012	#4
That is going way too far	unreadierLizard	Nov 2012	#5
I do not think the Jewish people are exactly oppressed. Some bigots have negative stereotypes,	loudsue	Nov 2012	#9
I	John2	Nov 2012	#10
Hamas is attacking. Israel must respond.	Andy Stanton	Nov 2012	#14
I agree. Hamas is to blame for all this.	rollin74	Nov 2012	#16
I remember how angry Mexico was when Texans started forcibly settling south of the border	Orrex	Nov 2012	#17
Hamas hides behind civilians	Andy Stanton	Nov 2012	#19
There is indeed a double standard here, but it's not what you probably think	Orrex	Nov 2012	#21
Not carte blanche	eyl	Nov 2012	#82
So if a member of Hamas is in a city, Israel can bomb the shit out of that city with impunity?	Orrex	Nov 2012	#94
When has Israel targeted a school bus?	former9thward	Nov 2012	#109
Overall, how many Israelis have been killed or forcibly relocated by Palestinians?	Orrex	Nov 2012	#111
The reason any Palestinian children have been killed is because of the Palestinians.	former9thward	Nov 2012	#116
And the reason that Israealis are killed is because of Israelis	Orrex	Nov 2012	#117
If a group in Mexico started firing in rockets on San Diego what would the U.S. do?	former9thward	Nov 2012	#118
Why do people keep using that ridiculous and invalid analogy?	Orrex	Nov 2012	#119
Your "analogy" is completely devoid of ny similarity to the Gaza-Israel situation.	former9thward	Nov 2012	#120
I'm sure that you believe that, just like you apparently believe you're rational	Orrex	Nov 2012	#121
“May your children die, you dogs”: As Gaza burns, Israelis bay for blood in streets of Tel Aviv	fingrinn	Nov 2012	#68
Please don't make it sound like ALL the Israelis were "baying for blood."	Raksha	Nov 2012	#113
You're joking of course, right?	crunch60	Nov 2012	#31
I've seen DUers (now on Ignore) argue that the deaths of Palestinian	coalition_unwilling	Nov 2012	#60
Thank you. Exactly right. nt	JudyM	Nov 2012	#18
It's Not a Double Standard	Iggy	Nov 2012	#20
That's ridiculous	Orrex	Nov 2012	#22
Hah hahhh!	Iggy	Nov 2012	#23
Yeah what third party would do that?	xtraxritical	Nov 2012	#36
You Actually Don't Know?	Iggy	Nov 2012	#95
I think that applies to both sides actually	Sterling	Nov 2012	#59
I agree	Superbot	Nov 2012	#55
Perhaps they've tried.	Igel	Nov 2012	#26
"assume that the guy involved is powerless and his loss unimportant or he doesn't want to stop it."	Ash_F	Nov 2012	#27
+100000	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#11
And	John2	Nov 2012	#13
I'm relieved it was a 6-0 vote, at least. (nt)	Posteritatis	Nov 2012	#15
Half this board seems to cheer whenever Israelis die or attacked? Links to any of this?	Violet_Crumble	Nov 2012	#24
'Most of Israel's neighbors have peace treaties with Israel'	King_David	Nov 2012	#78
How to you get "most"	eyl	Nov 2012	#83
Yr right. Two out of four isn't most...	Violet_Crumble	Nov 2012	#84
Frequently what Israel's supporters claim is the exact opposite of the truth	cpwm17	Nov 2012	#25
That is such a crock	glacierbay	Nov 2012	#28
You're not doing a great job of proving him wrong, glacierbay	Scootaloo	Nov 2012	#93
pretty much. Israel is the bully with the HUGE military and the backing of the USA against tiny	boilerbabe	Nov 2012	#57
I agree that the "Hitler"	billh58	Nov 2012	#110
many years ago i was banned for three days for saying something simliar	madrchsod	Nov 2012	#6
Wow	oberliner	Nov 2012	#8
'stunning' that it was only 3 days?	King_David	Nov 2012	#97
Both	oberliner	Nov 2012	#102
Deliberate bombing of civilian sites can be considered a war crime	fujiyama	Nov 2012	#85
Why are we always dragged into the discussion just because of spoken word?	Socal31	Nov 2012	#88
Because any Arab nation daring to defend the Palestinians would immediately be	polly7	Nov 2012	#108
Harry Fear's Live link in Gaza	JesterCS	Nov 2012	#100
Yay war crimes.	Fearless	Nov 2012	#114
Palestinian civilian toll climbs in Gaza	dipsydoodle	Nov 2012	#115

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.