Reply #15

In the discussion thread: Vatican digs in after gay marriage advances [View all]

Sat Nov 10, 2012, 01:33 PM

krispos42 (45,156 posts)

15. And this applies to secular law how?

Their views on marriage stem from religion, which is fundamentally based on unprovable suppositions even if the reasoning that flows from the supposition is logically sound.

And polygamous marriage should be allowed, if we can craft our laws such that nobody in the marriage is unequal.

Something along the lines of Adam and Beth can marry Charlie as a couple, but only if both Adam and Beth agree. Adam and Beth and Charlie as a trio can marry Donna, but only if Adam and Beth and Charlie agree. Charlie can't just fly to Vegas with Donna and get married.

I think it would effectively limit the vast majority of the small segment of the population that wants polygamous marriage to trios and quartets.

It would likely have hellish legal complexities during a divorce, though.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

57 replies	Author	Time	Post
Vatican digs in after gay marriage advances [View all]	Bozita	Nov 2012	OP
That's fine, The Catholic Church doesn't have to marry gay people but..........	W T F	Nov 2012	#1
That's pretty much the size of it	Blasphemer	Nov 2012	#21
Firstly, they shouldn't be able to perform legal marriages.	olegramps	Nov 2012	#42
Agreed	Blasphemer	Nov 2012	#51
They have every right to tell	polmaven	Nov 2012	#2
But to them, the only true religion is Catholicism.	defacto7	Nov 2012	#5
Establishment Clause	DallasNE	Nov 2012	#39
With Enemies Like This We are SURE to Have Marriage Equality	fightthegoodfightnow	Nov 2012	#3
Wait until child mistreatment gets real attention. Oh the humanity!	Gregorian	Nov 2012	#4
50% of American Catholics voted for Obama. That's a much higher percent than among Protestants.	yardwork	Nov 2012	#6
My 86 yr old Catholic father voted twice now for Obama. He has	glinda	Nov 2012	#25
Does a tree falling in the woods make any sound?	Fearless	Nov 2012	#7
Actually, does a tree falling into the church make any sound?	Panasonic	Nov 2012	#46
Perhaps the Catholic Church should look at.....	blue sky at night	Nov 2012	#8
that is preying	Angry Dragon	Nov 2012	#53
You are NEVER getting your empire back.	Dawson Leery	Nov 2012	#9
I hope the DUer who first said this won't mind my repeating it...	FiveGoodMen	Nov 2012	#10
Hey Vatican pervs...	SoapBox	Nov 2012	#17
We have diplomatic relations with the Vatican. Let's not.	byeya	Nov 2012	#11
Is there any wonder why the church is losing the younger generation.	sarcasmo	Nov 2012	#12
well when it comes to the Church	azurnoir	Nov 2012	#13
Never take romance advice from child rapists--or child rapist enablers. nt	valerief	Nov 2012	#14
And this applies to secular law how?	krispos42	Nov 2012	#15
Hey pointy hatted, Gucci shoe, old white guys...	SoapBox	Nov 2012	#16
Then why did God allow the same sexes to like each other - Just to piss off the pope? n/t	socialindependocrat	Nov 2012	#18
The fact of the matter is that many priests are homosexuals. This was revealed in several studies.	olegramps	Nov 2012	#43
Job Ad: Wanted, young males - must be kind, loving, sensative and like working with people	socialindependocrat	Nov 2012	#48
The polygamous statement	Why Syzygy	Nov 2012	#19
1. True, those of us advocating for same-sex marriage equality will let polygamy advocates	MNBrewer	Nov 2012	#20
Even the Bible	Why Syzygy	Nov 2012	#22
Have they admitted they were wrong yet on the whole "sun revolves around the earth" brouhaha?	ruggerson	Nov 2012	#23
Yes, in 1992! but - there's a splinter group that wants to revisit this topic	LiberalElite	Nov 2012	#49
The Only Smart Thing Earl Butz ever said	Wolf Frankula	Nov 2012	#24
FU Pope	Politicalboi	Nov 2012	#26
Hello to the Vatican from Washington state!!!	barnabas63	Nov 2012	#27
Those of us who support equal rights	cloudbase	Nov 2012	#28
Separation of Church and State it IS	Blue4Texas	Nov 2012	#29
They need to openly acknowledge the sexuality of priests	undeterred	Nov 2012	#30
Society must keep them out of the temporal realm.	David__77	Nov 2012	#31
Keep it up Ratzinger!	eringer	Nov 2012	#32
maybe the Catholic church should pay more attention to all of their pedophile priests	olddad56	Nov 2012	#33
Jesus INCLUDED everyone, the prositutes, the beggars, the tax collectors	Dont call me Shirley	Nov 2012	#34
Go fuck yourselves, you bunch of child molestors.	Odin2005	Nov 2012	#35
Their relivance is nonexistent...	and-justice-for-all	Nov 2012	#36
Why do we tolerate another sovereign state meddling in our country?	AtheistCrusader	Nov 2012	#37
For starters, bishops and priests need to register as agents of a foreign country	byeya	Nov 2012	#41
This is one key reason I am no longer a Catholic nor will ever be one again	Nika	Nov 2012	#38
Looks like the rank-and-file Catholics	Mc Mike	Nov 2012	#40
Keep marching toward irrelevance, Vatican.	Sheldon Cooper	Nov 2012	#44
Know thine enemy	libodem	Nov 2012	#45
Hatred is "intrinsically disordered"	toby jo	Nov 2012	#47
"...the lone voice of courage..."	Raster	Nov 2012	#50
Hey I think it is great that a bunch of men that don't marry	Angry Dragon	Nov 2012	#52
I read the subject and worried they were going to send troops	Kennah	Nov 2012	#54
The effects of gay marijuana are fucking unreal. Can't believe the shit I read on DU.	Kennah	Nov 2012	#55
Letter from a Long-Lapsed Catholic	Bragi	Nov 2012	#56
This generation of Vatican officials does not speak for future generations	Democat	Nov 2012	#57

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.