HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » Latest Breaking News (Forum) » Sharp rise in child bowel... » Reply #97
Introducing Discussionist: A new forum by the creators of DU

Response to Godhumor (Reply #95)

Wed Jun 20, 2012, 10:51 AM

97. Sadly, uh, no, it's more nuanced than that AS ADMITTED BY NONCONTROVERSIAL EXPERTS.

Fair and objective reporting doesn't get any better than this.

http://adventuresinautism.blogspot.com/2012/04/dr-walter-zahorodny-believes-vaccines.html

April 3, 2012

Dr. Walter Zahorodny Believes Vaccines Cause Autism. And Geri Dawson???



From a Radio Listener in NYC:
I was listening this AM to WNYC – Kurt Andersen, of all hostile people, did a segment on the ADDM numbers with Walter Zahorodny, assistant professor of pediatrics at the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey in Newark. Zahorodny was the lead researcher on the New Jersey portion of the study.

Kurt Andersen (Seth Mnookin's friend): “I guess we know what they (the causes of autism) aren’t, for instance childhood vaccines. Right?”
Dr. Zahorodny: “Vaccines don’t play a significant role in autism increasing. Some small number of children probably do have autism because of an adverse vaccine reaction, but they don’t make for the overall rise.”
AUDIO at link.

D'oh!

What's that you say Dr. Z? Vaccines don't cause most autism, but they do cause some autism?? You don't say?!


UPDATE:

So is Geri Dawson joining Dr. Zahorodny? Looks that way to me!

Only a year ago, Autism Speaks science director Geri Dawson said we are not allowed to talk about vaccines any more. But now she says this...

Tom Ashbrook interviewed her on NPR:
Ashbrook: "Dr. Dawson, here's a question online from Melrose, has the link between MMR vaccine and autism been completely discredited. I notice that the word 'vaccine' has not even come up so far in this hour. Is that...for some years that had a lot of attention, is that off the table now, Dr. Dawson?"

Dr. Dawson: "There is no evidence that the increase in prevalence that we're seeing in Autism Spectrum Disorder is linked to the MMR vaccine. You know, if vaccines play a role, and there has not been any evidence thus far to show that it has, it would be a very small minority of individuals who have an underlying medical condition where the vaccine may have triggered an onset of symptoms for an already existing condition or vulnerability. So we do not believe that vaccines are an explanation of the increase and we strongly encourage parents to get their children vaccinated."

So again... thrown the softball and didn't take it!

Ashbrook, like Andersen, took the initiative of bringing the vaccine question into the interview, and in both cases it was merely an invitation to declare the vaccine hypothesis DOA. And neither Zahorodny or Dawson took the opportunity to do so!

They BOTH could have said, "Correct." And just moved on. But they didn't!

They both contradicted their interviewers presumptive statements, and said a version of, "Incorrect, vaccines do cause autism in some children, and it is a smaller number of cases than people think, but I don't see that vaccine induced autism could be playing a major factor in the increase."

IMHO... no way in h-e-double hockey sticks that these two didn't know exactly what they were doing. They had every chance to run from vaccine causation and they didn't. They confirmed it. Then they minimized it.

We have just witnessed the very quiet pushing of the envelope. Dr. Geri Dawson and Dr. Walter Zahorodny have just joined you and me and all our friends in taking our position that vaccines cause some cases of autism, just not all the cases of autism. Now we are only separated by the degree in which we believe the vaccine induced autism is a factor in the skyrocketing autism numbers.

Geri said something very interesting... and true...
"You know, if vaccines play a role , and there has not been any evidence thus far to show that it has."

...if by "evidence" of course, she means "scientific research" because there is plenty of data to show that vaccines cause autism, but none that I know of to show how often vaccines cause autism. Remember... we are all still pretending that it doesn't happen at all. So can you imagine the research funding proposal that would read, "It has been established that vaccines are one of the causes of autism, this team endeavors to discover how much of the rise in autism cases are due to vaccine induced autism." HA! Betcha Autism Speaks and CDC would just THROW money at that ask!

Which brings us back to the statement that David Bowman of HRSA issued three years ago:
"The government has never compensated, nor has it ever been ordered to compensate, any case based on a determination that autism was actually caused by vaccines. We have compensated cases in which children exhibited an encephalopathy, or general brain disease. Encephalopathy may be accompanied by a medical progression of an array of symptoms including autistic behavior, autism, or seizures.

Some children who have been compensated for vaccine injuries may have shown signs of autism before the decision to compensate, or may ultimately end up with autism or autistic symptoms, but we do not track cases on this basis."

Not even the government keeps track of their own cases of vaccine induced autism!

So do vaccines cause autism? YES! Now we just need to know how often that happens!

Posted by Ginger Taylor at Tuesday, April 03, 2012


BTW, you should have NOTHING to dispute here from these sources as reported by another of the brilliant parents of a child with autism. And, by the way, Dr. Herbert does not deviate from the CDC vaccination recommendations in her book and has never advocated otherwise. You are committing slander in your overzealous posts.



Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 107 replies Author Time Post
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 OP
DeSwiss Jun 2012 #1
freshwest Jun 2012 #4
DeSwiss Jun 2012 #20
freshwest Jun 2012 #21
wordpix Jun 2012 #30
pnwmom Jun 2012 #2
shcrane71 Jun 2012 #7
pnwmom Jun 2012 #9
shcrane71 Jun 2012 #11
noamnety Jun 2012 #10
shcrane71 Jun 2012 #13
TalkingDog Jun 2012 #14
shcrane71 Jun 2012 #16
noamnety Jun 2012 #17
midnight Jun 2012 #24
Tumbulu Jun 2012 #26
GoCubsGo Jun 2012 #35
wordpix Jun 2012 #33
TalkingDog Jun 2012 #39
Richard D Jun 2012 #37
pnwmom Jun 2012 #66
Richard D Jun 2012 #67
pnwmom Jun 2012 #68
libodem Jun 2012 #65
sense Jun 2012 #3
undeterred Jun 2012 #5
sendero Jun 2012 #36
Eastern Winds Jun 2012 #6
Remmah2 Jun 2012 #31
longship Jun 2012 #8
hedgehog Jun 2012 #56
KoKo Jun 2012 #12
happynewyear Jun 2012 #48
TalkingDog Jun 2012 #15
DeSwiss Jun 2012 #22
hedgehog Jun 2012 #57
BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2012 #18
SalviaBlue Jun 2012 #19
boppers Jun 2012 #23
Bette Noir Jun 2012 #25
sybylla Jun 2012 #32
laundry_queen Jun 2012 #44
Odin2005 Jun 2012 #27
Butterbean Jun 2012 #96
Javaman Jun 2012 #28
DCBob Jun 2012 #29
magical thyme Jun 2012 #34
DCBob Jun 2012 #38
LeftishBrit Jun 2012 #41
laundry_queen Jun 2012 #45
DCBob Jun 2012 #47
Godhumor Jun 2012 #43
DCBob Jun 2012 #46
Godhumor Jun 2012 #50
DCBob Jun 2012 #51
Godhumor Jun 2012 #52
DCBob Jun 2012 #55
Godhumor Jun 2012 #58
DCBob Jun 2012 #59
Godhumor Jun 2012 #60
LeftishBrit Jun 2012 #40
Godhumor Jun 2012 #42
4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #49
Godhumor Jun 2012 #53
4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #54
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #61
LeftyMom Jun 2012 #71
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #76
LeftyMom Jun 2012 #77
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #84
LeftyMom Jun 2012 #90
obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #80
Odin2005 Jun 2012 #104
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #62
Godhumor Jun 2012 #63
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #64
Marrah_G Jun 2012 #69
LeftyMom Jun 2012 #70
Marrah_G Jun 2012 #72
Godhumor Jun 2012 #74
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #78
Godhumor Jun 2012 #82
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #89
Godhumor Jun 2012 #91
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #92
Godhumor Jun 2012 #93
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #94
Godhumor Jun 2012 #95
LineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineNew Reply Sadly, uh, no, it's more nuanced than that AS ADMITTED BY NONCONTROVERSIAL EXPERTS.
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #97
Godhumor Jun 2012 #99
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #101
Godhumor Jun 2012 #102
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #107
obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #79
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #81
Godhumor Jun 2012 #85
obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #88
Godhumor Jun 2012 #86
obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #87
Expertsfromindia Jun 2012 #73
GliderGuider Jun 2012 #75
siligut Jun 2012 #83
FarCenter Jun 2012 #98
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #100
FarCenter Jun 2012 #105
proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #106
siligut Jun 2012 #103
Please login to view edit histories.