Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

caseymoz

(5,763 posts)
10. Weren't they suppose to love us?
Thu Apr 19, 2012, 02:32 PM
Apr 2012

After we got rid of that pesky Taliban and rebuilt their nation? The old phrase was, win their hearts and minds? Besides, we already took over Afghanistan, remember? Did we get Japan and Germany on our side during their occupations by doing crap like this? Dehumanization should stop sometime after victory.

Yes, this goes on in every war. Yes, it's a common, psychological effect. So, shouldn't you be surprised, ten years after we "won" that this is still going on, and that you still think our situation is so precarious that this is expedient? It's a sign we've lost. If we're dehumanizing Afghans now, we're never going to accomplish our goals there.

All Afghans feel the insult, including those in Karzi's government. Islam has laws on how to treat the dead. To desecrate these bodies is anti-Muslim. Even if those guys were terrorists and didn't deserve a good burial, their families still need consolation. Funerals are for the living. You won't shed any tears, but apparently you've forgotten that desecration of the dead is considered insulting to any culture.

We didn't see law enforcement posing with John Wayne Gacy's body parts, and it would horribly unsettle people about police in general if they did, and that's within our borders. You simply don't do that when you're trying to bring people to order.

No one asked you to shed any tears in grief, only in defeat.
Remember after September 11th when sheltered Americans wondered why they hate us? Cali_Democrat Apr 2012 #1
Osama hated us because of our military base in The Holy Land xtraxritical Apr 2012 #2
Yes...Osama along with many others found our presence there humiliating Cali_Democrat Apr 2012 #7
You think this behavior is new? leftynyc Apr 2012 #4
Weren't they suppose to love us? caseymoz Apr 2012 #10
Do you remember anyone leftynyc Apr 2012 #11
False dilemma: why does one exclude the other? caseymoz Apr 2012 #16
I thought I had made myself clear leftynyc Apr 2012 #18
Does it occur to you that the person is gone . . . caseymoz Apr 2012 #19
I dunno gratuitous Apr 2012 #20
So they hate us because of how we treat their dead bodies 4th law of robotics Apr 2012 #13
No. They hate us for various things, not just how we treat dead bodies. Cali_Democrat Apr 2012 #15
No they hate for the reasoning (lack of) behind the act. TheMadMonk Apr 2012 #17
What is it about abusing corpses that is so indepat Apr 2012 #3
complete marshall gaines Apr 2012 #8
But...but...but those soldiers are just letting off some steam! Crowman1979 Apr 2012 #5
Rush would say it's just a fraternity prank like Abu Graif. Great moral authority that he is... freshwest Apr 2012 #12
huh marshall gaines Apr 2012 #6
Yeah, "Gee, who coulld have predicted this?" bemildred Apr 2012 #9
They want to blame it on being at war because they'll be back in the USA soon. freshwest Apr 2012 #14
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»US corpse abuse pictures ...»Reply #10