HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Jill Stein got to keep ov... » Reply #66

Response to pnwmom (Original post)

Sat Jan 28, 2017, 10:32 AM

66. There is a danger

 

in comparing 3rd party vote totals with margin of victory/defeat and declaring the former to be the cause of the latter.

When the margins of defeat/victory are as small as they were in the last election (particularly in Michigan and Wisconsin), and much more so when they are as small as they were in the GE-determinative outcome in in Florida in 2000 (less than 1000), any factor which suppressed Democratic turnout in an amount greater than these (small) margins is an INDEPENDENT (i.e., would have changed the outcome even if everything else would have stayed the same) cause of our defeat and accordingly is EQUALLY RESPONSIBLE for that defeat.

I mention this because it has become almost as de rigueur among a certain faction of the Democratic Party to "blame the left" for the outcome in 2016 as it was in 2000, when, in both instances, actions by the "middle" of the party deprived our candidate of the support of identifiable voters in a number sufficient to overcome these (small) margins.

Prior to the 2000 election, Florida used ChoicePoint to purge thousands and thousands of mostly black convicted felons from Florida voter rolls, even though their voting rights had been automatically restored upon their release from prison and/or when their parole ended under the laws of the states where they were convicted. I was among a number of attorneys who were contacted by these men to try to get them back on the rolls before the election. Because they were poor, because they were powerless, and because they were, after all, felons, it became clear that this effort was going to require both financial help and mainstream support from the national party. They were turned away. We were told by told by party officials that there was no way that, after the "Willie Horton" ads in 1988, the Democratic Party was going to make it possible for Republicans to make a black convicted felon the image of the party. Even the most cautious estimates place the number of Democratic votes lost in Florida close to 10,000.

A similar thing happened this election. CrossCheck (which is ChoicePoint on steroids) purged thousands upon thousands of convicted felons from the voter rolls in key states. Aside from one or two passing comments about the handful of "non-Willie Horton" voters who got swept up in this deliberate assault on the voting rights of a group of primarily young black men (who had already been targeted by the war on drugs) the party kept silent. In fact, when Governor Terry McAuliffe (D.Va.) took the extraordinary step of using his pardon power to restore the voting rights of convicted felons in Virginia, the national party kept him at arms length even as he was being eviscerated by the right.

People who regularly claim we should support moderate party leadership because "the left cost us the last election" should remember that the same "comparison of lost voters v. margin of victory/defeat" analysis which is being used to place the "blame" for the last election (and the election of 2000) on the left could easily be used to shift that blame back on moderates.

That being said, there are still MORE than enough reasons to despise Stein voters. The Green Party is, and always has been, a complete fraud. People who fall for their BS are either painfully na´ve or painfully lacking in the very concern for their fellow citizens of the world whom they claim to care so much about. Socialism and social justice SHOULD be inextricably intertwined (Quick example, how, other than socialism, does the $60 trillion of wealth stolen from people of color during the 400 years of North American slavery and the 150+ years of institutional racism that has followed ever get returned to the people who created it?). Unfortunately, in "the Greens'" deceitful and/or feeble hands, socialism has become nothing but a tool to achieve further benefits for an already-privileged class.

I completely agree that "the Greens" are not our friends. I agree that the millions they collected for recount efforts were not donated to help their overall cause and should be distributed to folks fighting Trump. AND I add that they are traitors to the cause of socialism who think that alliance to Russia and beasts like Putin somehow substitutes for standing with the oppressed. It's just that they aren't the reason we lost any more than was our failure to stand up for the most oppressed individuals among the most oppressed demographic group in our party.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 140 replies Author Time Post
pnwmom Jan 28 OP
larry budwell Jan 28 #1
HassleCat Jan 28 #2
pnwmom Jan 28 #3
Demsrule86 Jan 30 #131
FarPoint Jan 28 #58
democratisphere Jan 28 #4
Maru Kitteh Jan 28 #5
SunSeeker Jan 28 #6
Chevy Jan 28 #7
pnwmom Jan 28 #11
yardwork Jan 28 #34
DFW Jan 30 #127
PotatoChip Jan 30 #130
betsuni Jan 28 #10
JI7 Jan 28 #17
AlexSFCA Jan 28 #8
pnwmom Jan 28 #9
Hekate Jan 28 #13
AlexSFCA Jan 28 #111
Hekate Jan 28 #12
pnwmom Jan 28 #14
diva77 Jan 28 #15
brush Jan 28 #16
Cha Jan 28 #18
pnwmom Jan 28 #19
Docreed2003 Jan 28 #59
Blue_true Jan 28 #109
diva77 Jan 29 #115
pnwmom Jan 29 #116
jmg257 Jan 28 #32
mythology Jan 28 #60
hunter Jan 28 #96
Hekate Jan 28 #114
HoneyBadger Jan 28 #20
pnwmom Jan 28 #23
scipan Jan 28 #100
pnwmom Jan 28 #106
scipan Jan 28 #107
pnwmom Jan 28 #108
EL34x4 Jan 28 #21
oberliner Jan 28 #25
KittyWampus Jan 28 #77
uncle ray Jan 28 #22
pnwmom Jan 28 #26
NCTraveler Jan 28 #30
uponit7771 Jan 28 #36
oberliner Jan 28 #24
atreides1 Jan 28 #27
Starry Messenger Jan 28 #28
NCTraveler Jan 28 #29
pnwmom Jan 28 #31
NCTraveler Jan 28 #33
pnwmom Jan 28 #37
NCTraveler Jan 28 #39
Glamrock Jan 28 #35
pnwmom Jan 28 #38
Glamrock Jan 28 #41
pnwmom Jan 28 #42
Glamrock Jan 28 #48
KittyWampus Jan 28 #75
NCTraveler Jan 28 #40
pnwmom Jan 28 #43
NCTraveler Jan 28 #46
Glamrock Jan 28 #45
NCTraveler Jan 28 #47
Glamrock Jan 28 #49
NCTraveler Jan 28 #67
truebluegreen Jan 28 #44
orwell Jan 28 #52
Glamrock Jan 28 #54
LisaL Jan 28 #64
truebluegreen Jan 28 #65
sweetloukillbot Jan 28 #91
MrPurple Jan 28 #104
CajunBlazer Jan 30 #123
oberliner Jan 28 #53
truebluegreen Jan 28 #61
LisaL Jan 28 #63
truebluegreen Jan 28 #69
LisaL Jan 28 #76
truebluegreen Jan 28 #94
LisaL Jan 28 #62
QC Jan 28 #74
pnwmom Jan 28 #83
Post removed Jan 30 #128
pnwmom Jan 30 #139
truebluegreen Jan 30 #137
pnwmom Jan 30 #140
Blue_true Jan 28 #110
truebluegreen Jan 30 #129
SticksnStones Jan 28 #50
ismnotwasm Jan 28 #51
Hokie Jan 28 #55
LisaL Jan 28 #68
La Lioness Priyanka Jan 28 #56
catbyte Jan 28 #57
LineReply There is a danger
Uponthegears Jan 28 #66
truebluegreen Jan 28 #70
pnwmom Jan 28 #73
truebluegreen Jan 30 #132
pnwmom Jan 30 #134
truebluegreen Jan 30 #135
pnwmom Jan 30 #136
beachbum bob Jan 28 #71
KittyWampus Jan 28 #72
LisaL Jan 28 #79
pnwmom Jan 28 #81
Tatiana Jan 28 #78
LisaL Jan 28 #80
Tatiana Jan 28 #87
LisaL Jan 28 #90
pnwmom Jan 28 #82
Qanisqineq Jan 28 #84
pnwmom Jan 28 #85
BlancheSplanchnik Jan 28 #86
Cha Jan 29 #120
lapucelle Jan 28 #88
NWCorona Jan 28 #93
nycbos Jan 28 #89
NWCorona Jan 28 #92
Gothmog Jan 28 #95
BainsBane Jan 28 #97
Barack_America Jan 28 #98
BainsBane Jan 28 #99
liquid diamond Jan 28 #101
braddy Jan 28 #102
JI7 Jan 29 #117
braddy Jan 29 #121
Equinox Moon Jan 28 #103
Blue_true Jan 28 #112
Equinox Moon Jan 28 #113
CajunBlazer Jan 30 #124
Cha Jan 29 #119
Equinox Moon Jan 29 #122
bettyellen Jan 30 #138
pbmus Jan 28 #105
JI7 Jan 29 #118
pnwmom Jan 30 #126
Blue_Tires Jan 30 #125
FreeStateDemocrat Jan 30 #133
Please login to view edit histories.