Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ProSense

(116,464 posts)
19. Frankly
Thu Dec 29, 2011, 10:55 AM
Dec 2011

Taibbi's analyses is lacking. He oversensationalizes everything and provides little real insight into what's actually happening. His criticisms haven't changed since Wall Street reform passed.

He goes on and on about Glass-Steagall, but can't seem to understand that without the law in place many of the activities he wants to see prosecuted were no longer illegal. He knows this.

<...>

But the reality is, the brains of investment bankers by nature are not wired for "client-based" thinking. This is the reason why the Glass-Steagall Act, which kept investment banks and commercial banks separate, was originally passed back in 1933: it just defies common sense to have professional gamblers in charge of stewarding commercial bank accounts.

Investment bankers do not see it as their jobs to tend to the dreary business of making sure Ma and Pa Main Street get their $8.03 in savings account interest every month. Nothing about traditional commercial banking – historically, the dullest of businesses, taking customer deposits and making conservative investments with them in search of a percentage point of profit here and there – turns them on.

In fact, investment bankers by nature have huge appetites for risk, and most of them take pride in being able to sleep at night even when their bets are going the wrong way. If you’re not a person who can doze through a two-hour foot massage while your client (which might be your own bank) is losing ten thousand dollars a minute on some exotic trade you’ve cooked up, then you won’t make it on today’s Wall Street.

Nonetheless, thanks to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act passed in 1998 with the help of Bob Rubin, Larry Summers, Bill Clinton, Alan Greenspan, Phil Gramm and a host of other short-sighted politicians, we now have a situation where trillions in federally-insured commercial bank deposits have been wedded at the end of a shotgun to exactly such career investment bankers from places like Salomon Brothers (now part of Citi), Merrill Lynch (Bank of America), Bear Stearns (Chase), and so on.

http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/blogs/taibblog/the-2-billion-ubs-incident-rogue-trader-my-ass-20110915#ixzz1hw3IlEJF


He completely ignores the prosecutions that are happening and spins Wall Street reform, the massive reregulation of the financial sector, as ineffective, using mostly speculative and convoluted arguments and ignoring the fact that the law is still being implemented and is already having an impact.

http://www.stopfraud.gov/news.html

http://www.democraticunderground.com/100282976
I'm not afraid of letting people know. Justice wanted Dec 2011 #1
I don't necessarily "love" Taibbi gratuitous Dec 2011 #2
K&R bahrbearian Dec 2011 #3
ditto roguevalley Dec 2011 #78
Taibbi is a great writer. Bolo Boffin Dec 2011 #4
How is this not a call out thread? sufrommich Dec 2011 #5
Oh my God trumad Dec 2011 #11
"I am heartened though that supporters of Taibbi here at DU annihilate the few sufrommich Dec 2011 #21
It's in reference to DU'ers who think he's a quack. trumad Dec 2011 #27
yes, but with reservations Enrique Dec 2011 #6
Link trumad Dec 2011 #12
"Clark's True Colors" Enrique Dec 2011 #20
That calls to mind one of the most shameful threads on DU2... A-Schwarzenegger Dec 2011 #23
So that means his reporting on the financial industry is wrong? eridani Dec 2011 #72
OK, "love" might be a little much tularetom Dec 2011 #7
Well written Ichingcarpenter Dec 2011 #14
I'm not sure I "love" ANY (current) writer... but I generally respect his work... hlthe2b Dec 2011 #8
Changed Love to Appreciate because you are right---Love is a bit to much. trumad Dec 2011 #15
Checking in! lonestarnot Dec 2011 #9
The man knows his business theaocp Dec 2011 #10
I like Taibbi's columns alcibiades_mystery Dec 2011 #13
he's pretty awesome -- he does his homework. xchrom Dec 2011 #16
Matt is one of the writers on my "must read" list. City Lights Dec 2011 #17
Checking in. Union Scribe Dec 2011 #18
Frankly ProSense Dec 2011 #19
Hey ProSense, I work in the Financial Sector and your last sentence is complete and utter bullshit.. truebrit71 Dec 2011 #24
Thanks, I was about to do a search as I thought I missed them also. sabrina 1 Dec 2011 #56
He wrote some interesting notes about that on his RS blog... truebrit71 Dec 2011 #59
I missed that, thanks, I thought that would be of interest to him as he has been on this sabrina 1 Dec 2011 #67
Actually, ProSense Dec 2011 #62
Speaking of reading comprehension.... truebrit71 Dec 2011 #75
Thank you... as an outsider I haven't seen a single sign of regulation changing things LooseWilly Dec 2011 #80
LOL trumad Dec 2011 #26
Did I somehow miss all those bigshot banksters hifiguy Dec 2011 #28
I have the same issues with Taibbi; over speculation, half truths and out of perspective analysis... uponit7771 Dec 2011 #36
"the massive reregulation of the financial sector," bvar22 Dec 2011 #38
Hmmm? ProSense Dec 2011 #63
You have out done yourself with this one. Ruby the Liberal Dec 2011 #41
Ug, Obama perfect. Ug, critics bad. PurityOfEssence Dec 2011 #51
lol slay Dec 2011 #55
Imagine ProSense Dec 2011 #64
Wow... you nailed not only this thread, but this poster... LooseWilly Dec 2011 #81
The current prosecutions MFrohike Dec 2011 #61
According to "Sixty Minutes" recent piece - prosecutions of the truedelphi Dec 2011 #66
LOL!! Fucking hilarious! Prosense, you're the best!! inna Dec 2011 #91
Matt is tops! hifiguy Dec 2011 #22
Wow, now this place is going after Taibbi? Did he not worship TPTB enough? Huey P. Long Dec 2011 #25
No---it's only one who has a very regular habit trumad Dec 2011 #29
Matt Taibbi, John Nichols, and Naomi Klein totally rock! Zorra Dec 2011 #30
awww, if you can't take the heat... MjolnirTime Dec 2011 #31
No---I can't take douchebag Wall Street apologists. trumad Dec 2011 #35
Count me in. Wind Dancer Dec 2011 #32
KNR! joeybee12 Dec 2011 #33
K&R QC Dec 2011 #34
Checking In NCTraveler Dec 2011 #37
He's one who seems to be allowed to tell the truth Generic Other Dec 2011 #39
Check. Iggo Dec 2011 #40
Giving some thread love. nt Fantastic Anarchist Dec 2011 #42
As someone in the industry, I can say in all honesty Ruby the Liberal Dec 2011 #43
Bingo, plus his pieces on how the SEC systematically destroyed evidence... truebrit71 Dec 2011 #76
K&R (n/t) a2liberal Dec 2011 #44
Matt Taibbi is a most excellent journalist; unfortunately a very rare commodity nowadays. Uncle Joe Dec 2011 #45
I enjoy reading him, but he's been wrong on some "facts" he's presented. And I don't gateley Dec 2011 #46
K & R because sunlight is the best disinfectant.... mike_c Dec 2011 #47
Compared to what? Octafish Dec 2011 #48
K&R MuseRider Dec 2011 #49
He's one of the best and does intense research on all of his work. sabrina 1 Dec 2011 #50
he is smart, he does his research dana_b Dec 2011 #52
Taibbi is one of the few who never disappoints - stays the course - and nails the bastards UpInArms Dec 2011 #53
I love his writing - and his style slay Dec 2011 #54
Matt Rocks! colsohlibgal Dec 2011 #57
96 rec's... boo yeah trumad Dec 2011 #58
K & R Liberal_Dog Dec 2011 #60
I appreciate the fact that Matt Taibbi is a fucking idiot....nt SidDithers Dec 2011 #65
Wow Sid, trumad Dec 2011 #68
Kick trumad Dec 2011 #69
Kick truebrit71 Dec 2011 #77
+ Electric Monk Dec 2011 #85
I stand in awe of the consistent depth, subtlety and complexity of hifiguy Dec 2011 #93
K&R. Taibbi speaks the truth. Maven Dec 2011 #70
K & R !!! WillyT Dec 2011 #71
Kick. Luminous Animal Dec 2011 #73
I forgot to add... and rec! Luminous Animal Dec 2011 #74
Taibbi's a good writer; bit emotional at times - but his heart's in his work. marasinghe Dec 2011 #79
He's a great reporter. UnrepentantLiberal Dec 2011 #82
check limpyhobbler Dec 2011 #83
not only i appreciate, i think he's fuckable! (lol, private joke, inna Dec 2011 #84
I've appreciated everything I've read by him eyewall Dec 2011 #86
in all seriousness, i love Matt to death, and... i appreciate *you*, of all people, inna Dec 2011 #87
he's swell, like rice krispie treats NuttyFluffers Dec 2011 #88
Kick trumad Dec 2011 #89
Matt is a true journalist, something that is lacking in most people fasttense Dec 2011 #90
Checking in for Matt! NorthCarolina Dec 2011 #92
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Check in if you "app...»Reply #19