Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Check in if you "appreciate" Matt Taibbi. [View all]ProSense
(116,464 posts)19. Frankly
Taibbi's analyses is lacking. He oversensationalizes everything and provides little real insight into what's actually happening. His criticisms haven't changed since Wall Street reform passed.
He goes on and on about Glass-Steagall, but can't seem to understand that without the law in place many of the activities he wants to see prosecuted were no longer illegal. He knows this.
<...>
But the reality is, the brains of investment bankers by nature are not wired for "client-based" thinking. This is the reason why the Glass-Steagall Act, which kept investment banks and commercial banks separate, was originally passed back in 1933: it just defies common sense to have professional gamblers in charge of stewarding commercial bank accounts.
Investment bankers do not see it as their jobs to tend to the dreary business of making sure Ma and Pa Main Street get their $8.03 in savings account interest every month. Nothing about traditional commercial banking historically, the dullest of businesses, taking customer deposits and making conservative investments with them in search of a percentage point of profit here and there turns them on.
In fact, investment bankers by nature have huge appetites for risk, and most of them take pride in being able to sleep at night even when their bets are going the wrong way. If youre not a person who can doze through a two-hour foot massage while your client (which might be your own bank) is losing ten thousand dollars a minute on some exotic trade youve cooked up, then you wont make it on todays Wall Street.
Nonetheless, thanks to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act passed in 1998 with the help of Bob Rubin, Larry Summers, Bill Clinton, Alan Greenspan, Phil Gramm and a host of other short-sighted politicians, we now have a situation where trillions in federally-insured commercial bank deposits have been wedded at the end of a shotgun to exactly such career investment bankers from places like Salomon Brothers (now part of Citi), Merrill Lynch (Bank of America), Bear Stearns (Chase), and so on.
http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/blogs/taibblog/the-2-billion-ubs-incident-rogue-trader-my-ass-20110915#ixzz1hw3IlEJF
But the reality is, the brains of investment bankers by nature are not wired for "client-based" thinking. This is the reason why the Glass-Steagall Act, which kept investment banks and commercial banks separate, was originally passed back in 1933: it just defies common sense to have professional gamblers in charge of stewarding commercial bank accounts.
Investment bankers do not see it as their jobs to tend to the dreary business of making sure Ma and Pa Main Street get their $8.03 in savings account interest every month. Nothing about traditional commercial banking historically, the dullest of businesses, taking customer deposits and making conservative investments with them in search of a percentage point of profit here and there turns them on.
In fact, investment bankers by nature have huge appetites for risk, and most of them take pride in being able to sleep at night even when their bets are going the wrong way. If youre not a person who can doze through a two-hour foot massage while your client (which might be your own bank) is losing ten thousand dollars a minute on some exotic trade youve cooked up, then you wont make it on todays Wall Street.
Nonetheless, thanks to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act passed in 1998 with the help of Bob Rubin, Larry Summers, Bill Clinton, Alan Greenspan, Phil Gramm and a host of other short-sighted politicians, we now have a situation where trillions in federally-insured commercial bank deposits have been wedded at the end of a shotgun to exactly such career investment bankers from places like Salomon Brothers (now part of Citi), Merrill Lynch (Bank of America), Bear Stearns (Chase), and so on.
http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/blogs/taibblog/the-2-billion-ubs-incident-rogue-trader-my-ass-20110915#ixzz1hw3IlEJF
He completely ignores the prosecutions that are happening and spins Wall Street reform, the massive reregulation of the financial sector, as ineffective, using mostly speculative and convoluted arguments and ignoring the fact that the law is still being implemented and is already having an impact.
http://www.stopfraud.gov/news.html
http://www.democraticunderground.com/100282976
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
93 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
"I am heartened though that supporters of Taibbi here at DU annihilate the few
sufrommich
Dec 2011
#21
I'm not sure I "love" ANY (current) writer... but I generally respect his work...
hlthe2b
Dec 2011
#8
Hey ProSense, I work in the Financial Sector and your last sentence is complete and utter bullshit..
truebrit71
Dec 2011
#24
I missed that, thanks, I thought that would be of interest to him as he has been on this
sabrina 1
Dec 2011
#67
Thank you... as an outsider I haven't seen a single sign of regulation changing things
LooseWilly
Dec 2011
#80
I have the same issues with Taibbi; over speculation, half truths and out of perspective analysis...
uponit7771
Dec 2011
#36
Wow, now this place is going after Taibbi? Did he not worship TPTB enough?
Huey P. Long
Dec 2011
#25
Matt Taibbi is a most excellent journalist; unfortunately a very rare commodity nowadays.
Uncle Joe
Dec 2011
#45
I enjoy reading him, but he's been wrong on some "facts" he's presented. And I don't
gateley
Dec 2011
#46
Taibbi is one of the few who never disappoints - stays the course - and nails the bastards
UpInArms
Dec 2011
#53
Taibbi's a good writer; bit emotional at times - but his heart's in his work.
marasinghe
Dec 2011
#79