Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Fumesucker

(45,851 posts)
15. It's comforting to us to blame the parents..
Fri May 4, 2012, 07:22 PM
May 2012

We tell ourselves I could *never* do that, we cannot let ourselves imagine doing such a thing to our own child.

If you could forget your wallet or your cell phone you could forget your child, our wetware is remarkably buggy in a lot of ways.

I read an article several years ago that basically said in virtually every case it's a disruption of the normal routine of the parent(s) that leads to this.

http://www.salon.com/2009/03/09/fatal_distraction/

The subhead of Gene Weingarten’s heartbreaking article in yesterday’s Washington Post asks an inflammatory question — “Forgetting a child in the back seat of a hot, parked car is a horrifying, inexcusable mistake. But is it a crime?” — but it’s a bit of a red herring. Weingarten makes it clear from the outset that his answer is no — and that, in any case, no punishment could match the life sentence of guilt that parents who have done so were handed the moment they realized what happened. Seeking to demonstrate how even the most conscientious parents can have a tragic lapse of memory, Weingarten not only interviewed 13 people who have endured the horror of killing their own children in a “perfect storm” of distraction and absent-mindedness, but also a memory expert, David Diamond, who explains why it could happen to any of us: “Memory is a machine, and it is not flawless. Our conscious mind prioritizes things by importance, but on a cellular level, our memory does not. If you’re capable of forgetting your cellphone, you are potentially capable of forgetting your child.”

As unbelievable as that statement may sound, Weingarten makes a strong case for its truth. In every instance he covers, the parents responsible were dealing with unusual interruptions in their morning routine, got distracted and believed they’d already dropped their children off at daycare or with the baby sitter — when in reality, they’d skipped that step and left the children in their parked cars as they went to work. Says Diamond, “The important factors that keep showing up involve a combination of stress, emotion, lack of sleep and change in routine, where the basal ganglia is trying to do what it’s supposed to do, and the conscious mind is too weakened to resist. What happens is that the memory circuits in a vulnerable hippocampus literally get overwritten, like with a computer program. Unless the memory circuit is rebooted — such as if the child cries … it can entirely disappear.” Weingarten makes it chillingly clear how the lack of that “reboot” can lead to parents sincerely believing their kids are safe in their daily routines while they’re actually dying. “Several people … have driven from their workplace to the day-care center to pick up the child they’d thought they’d dropped off, never noticing the corpse in the back seat. Then there is the Chattanooga, Tenn., business executive who must live with this: His motion-detector car alarm went off, three separate times, out there in the broiling sun. But when he looked out, he couldn’t see anyone tampering with the car. So he remotely deactivated the alarm and went calmly back to work.”

“I was that guy, before. I’d read the stories, and I’d go, ‘What were those parents thinking?’” says Mikey Terry, whose 6-month-old daughter, Mika, died of hyperthermia after he left her in a car while he went to work driving a truck, only to realize what he’d done when he was 40 long miles away. For those of us who haven’t experienced such a tragedy, perhaps the most disturbing element of Weingarten’s article is how he indicts us for our knee-jerk judgments of these parents, our insistence that we would never be so careless. He quotes psychologist Ed Hickling, who’s studied the effects of fatal car accidents on the surviving drivers: “We want to believe that the world is understandable and controllable and unthreatening, that if we follow the rules, we’ll be okay. So, when this kind of thing happens to other people, we need to put them in a different category from us. We don’t want to resemble them, and the fact that we might is too terrifying to deal with. So, they have to be monsters.” Weingarten follows that up with an example of one of the comments on a Charlottesville News Web site article about Lyn Balfour, who left her son, Bryce, to perish in her car: “If she had too many things on her mind then she should have kept her legs closed and not had any kids. They should lock her in a car during a hot day and see what happens.”

I still don't get how you can forget your baby in the car or your dog or parakeet cali May 2012 #1
I don't get it either. proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #3
It's comforting to us to blame the parents.. Fumesucker May 2012 #15
These threads are always so damn ugly. trotsky May 2012 #19
Just so ridiculous. Do people who post shit like that on forums EVER do any kind of Iris May 2012 #83
This sounds like what happened with me... cynatnite May 2012 #22
It is so brave of you to post this. Iris May 2012 #94
I have twice driven past daycare on my way to work, with two of my boys in the back seat. Skinner May 2012 #121
I did it--I posted about it in post #131. nt msanthrope May 2012 #133
When my kids were little, my dad used to tell me proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #134
Things happen Worried senior May 2012 #139
It's very important that you've posted this here. sibelian May 2012 #170
The parent is to blame 4th law of robotics May 2012 #23
How can you punish them worse than the punishment they will live for the rest of their lives with? Fumesucker May 2012 #26
I never said she should go to jail 4th law of robotics May 2012 #27
It could never happen to you, right? Fumesucker May 2012 #29
Well, yeah 4th law of robotics May 2012 #32
Because it is that simple...you just forget... cynatnite May 2012 #39
Interesting how the article predicts so accurately some people's reactions.. Fumesucker May 2012 #41
I can accurately predict how most people will respond to a variety of stories 4th law of robotics May 2012 #45
So you think it could never happen to you.. Fumesucker May 2012 #50
You keep saying that "so you think it could never happen to you" 4th law of robotics May 2012 #51
As I said in my first post, you have a psychological need to see these parents as different from you Fumesucker May 2012 #54
I see a lot of people as different from me 4th law of robotics May 2012 #90
A deliberate act is not the same thing as an error, a mistake.. Fumesucker May 2012 #102
" I can easily envision a scenario . . . " 4th law of robotics May 2012 #135
You do not have complete control over your memory unless Susan Calvin really was your designer.. Fumesucker May 2012 #152
In many areas, whether or not liberalhistorian May 2012 #110
As far as our memory is concerned it is no different than forgetting your wallet.. Fumesucker May 2012 #40
One would think a child would be more significant 4th law of robotics May 2012 #44
No one is saying a child is equivilant to a wallet... cynatnite May 2012 #49
Here's someone it happened to talking about the experience.. Fumesucker May 2012 #52
Denial. Iris May 2012 #84
Trust me...she knows... cynatnite May 2012 #30
indeed... n/t ProdigalJunkMail May 2012 #37
Tell that to the baby tabasco May 2012 #24
None of us are perfect.. Fumesucker May 2012 #28
Perfect is a long fucking way tabasco May 2012 #34
In other words it you think it could never happen to you.. Fumesucker May 2012 #38
I'm impressed with your calm and persistent responses here. yardwork May 2012 #104
I forgot my daughter... cynatnite May 2012 #35
Which posters are laughing at this??? obamanut2012 May 2012 #56
Nobody is laughing. yardwork May 2012 #103
Every single one of these parents thought they could NEVER do this obamanut2012 May 2012 #55
Comparing childen to cell phones is idiotic. Odin2005 May 2012 #65
Tell it to the cognitive science researchers.. Fumesucker May 2012 #66
A culpable person defends himself! tabasco May 2012 #72
Our conscious mind uses our memory as a tool but it doesn't control it completely. Fumesucker May 2012 #77
Well if it didn't convince you the first time, mythology May 2012 #120
The sparing use of emoticons showed the poster was a really serious person. Fumesucker May 2012 #158
Thanks for posting that, Fumesucker. I immediately thought of Gene Weingarten's articles. CBHagman May 2012 #79
I hadn't seen that before. Fumesucker May 2012 #81
I do. I am a parent. I can imagine this happening. It never happened to me, but it could happen. yardwork May 2012 #100
I'm also a parent. I never, no matter how harried I was cali May 2012 #141
i get it. i had the baby almost exclusively. it was as natural as anything for me seabeyond May 2012 #181
Poor thing. :( dkf May 2012 #2
It almost happened to me... cynatnite May 2012 #4
I'm a space cadet. proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #8
Both my husband and I were working full time and attending college... cynatnite May 2012 #13
And who hasn't done something on autopilot before? Iris May 2012 #92
I can tell that you are still so horrified by what happened Number23 May 2012 #73
" I can't explain how I could have forgotten my baby girl" i think probably if honest seabeyond May 2012 #182
BRING CAR SEATS BACK TO THE FRONT SEAT! This never happened till they are forced to be in Lionessa May 2012 #5
Front seats are more dangerous... cynatnite May 2012 #6
Airbags can be turned off. Car seats designed for front seat safety. Lionessa May 2012 #31
Even without airbags ... surrealAmerican May 2012 #58
it is still possible to compare deaths via each mode and select the optimum route. JVS May 2012 #113
How about putting the diaper bag or something the child needs in the front seat? proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #9
That is a very good idea. Jamastiene May 2012 #20
Excellent counter idea. That would work. Let's spread it around, clearly it's needed since Lionessa May 2012 #25
Another possibility for new cars - have an alarm go off if too much weight in the child seat spot MH1 May 2012 #67
Perfect idea for this issue, but still it is really hard to do the Lionessa May 2012 #97
I took off one shoe. It reminded me when I put it on that I needed to remember something. Luminous Animal May 2012 #87
That's a good idea laundry_queen May 2012 #157
Then they get killed by the airbag. LeftyMom May 2012 #33
Airbags can be turned off these days. Didn't you know? Lionessa May 2012 #36
Generally only vehicles with no back seat have that feature. LeftyMom May 2012 #48
My daughter's 4 door Honda has a switch, not a permanent disable of the bag. Lionessa May 2012 #53
That's unusual. Most cars don't, and the LATCH anchors are generally only in back. LeftyMom May 2012 #57
My point is to re-design rather than continue with BS reasons to keep them in the back, fix it. Lionessa May 2012 #59
The back seat is still safer because it's the farthest point from the point of impact. LeftyMom May 2012 #63
It isn't safer when it makes the driver less safe in his/her actions trying to tend Lionessa May 2012 #101
The data on the matter don't reflect your view. LeftyMom May 2012 #107
My Prius automatically disables the front airbag if a certain weight range is in the front seat. MH1 May 2012 #69
A lot of cars do that. proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #71
That's too big for an infant seat, LeftyMom May 2012 #75
Mine go off automatically proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #76
I'm praying for this family... dhood8083 May 2012 #7
+1 obamanut2012 May 2012 #18
a tragedy riverwalker May 2012 #10
sad. Liberal_in_LA May 2012 #11
omg how tragic. Whisp May 2012 #12
This happens every year, and is just so sad obamanut2012 May 2012 #14
This message was self-deleted by its author LASlibinSC May 2012 #16
Sadly it does happen LASlibinSC May 2012 #17
Such a sad thing. I worry about my Riley18 May 2012 #21
that is really a fantastic idea! renate May 2012 #42
I've read articles where they recommend leaving your cellphone in the car seat 4th law of robotics May 2012 #46
As a society I think we need to warn more people away from parenting instead of idealizing it. LeftyMom May 2012 #43
Actually, I think we need to be more supportive of parents... cynatnite May 2012 #47
You and LeftyMom are BOTH right obamanut2012 May 2012 #60
And let's not forget a case where the entire family forgot the child. CBHagman May 2012 #88
So, only the superhuman should procreate? Iris May 2012 #85
Clearly only the superhuman are capable of not killing their kids through neglect 4th law of robotics May 2012 #89
Have you read any of the posts here that are outside your filter bubble? Iris May 2012 #91
Yeah there really haven't been any legitimate studies posted 4th law of robotics May 2012 #93
Have you ever experienced doing something on autopilot? Iris May 2012 #96
You and I must define "horrible parent" differently 4th law of robotics May 2012 #137
You are still convinced it could never happen to you.. Fumesucker May 2012 #165
Pure conjecture 4th law of robotics May 2012 #174
It is either perfection or luck.. Fumesucker May 2012 #175
"You might as well say that you'll never get hit by lightning." 4th law of robotics May 2012 #176
Where did I say it's sheer chance that parents don't murder their kids? Fumesucker May 2012 #179
You keep making the comparison to things like brakes going out or lightning 4th law of robotics May 2012 #184
It is a chance event, that's what you fail to understand.. Fumesucker May 2012 #185
Yes. Only Superman can keep track of where his kid is. LeftyMom May 2012 #106
Pretty simplistic answer to a very complex problem. Iris May 2012 #109
It's really not that complicated. LeftyMom May 2012 #111
You know, clearly it is b/c no one can predict what every day of the next 18-20 years will be like Iris May 2012 #112
+1 4th law of robotics May 2012 #138
Absolutely! Marengo May 2012 #126
How do you know if you can cope with the stresses before you have a child? uppityperson May 2012 #154
Summer season. I was actually hoping this year we'd get by without any of these terrible stories riderinthestorm May 2012 #61
A good friend of ours ran over his friend's kid proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #70
I know. Gawd, I know. If my 14 yr old hadn't shouted loud enough, that would've been me. riderinthestorm May 2012 #74
I've noticed PSA's about this phenomenon this year. Iris May 2012 #86
Some people are too fucking stupid to be parents. Odin2005 May 2012 #62
You think that is all there is to it? cynatnite May 2012 #68
Read this Pulitzer prize winning article if you want to understand how it could happen. undeterred May 2012 #64
Thank you for posting this Number23 May 2012 #78
Reading it really does give you an explanation. undeterred May 2012 #118
Thankyou for this article. Vanje May 2012 #80
Similar to the time before sensors when people backed over their children in driveways Iris May 2012 #82
It was really quite hot here yesterday, and I thought, phylny May 2012 #95
That's actually an excellent solution. Iris May 2012 #98
There had ben talk of weight sensor alarms in car seats to prevent this. FedUpWithIt All May 2012 #99
Excellent post. Iris May 2012 #108
Public awareness and education are the keys to preventing this kind of tragedy DesertRat May 2012 #105
There is no justifying this shit SixString May 2012 #114
BINGO!! B Calm May 2012 #115
Yup, exactly the same thing obamanut2012 May 2012 #123
Here's someone it *almost* happened to, his child was saved by a quirk of fate.. Fumesucker May 2012 #116
You either don't want to understand this or can't obamanut2012 May 2012 #122
I understand it perfectly. SixString May 2012 #125
You are confusing "excuse" and "justifying" with "explaining" uppityperson May 2012 #155
Well, SixString May 2012 #160
Read this to understand how it happens. undeterred May 2012 #143
It appears you decided to ignore the article. sibelian May 2012 #171
For the people judging this woman Dorian Gray May 2012 #117
Yep. Union Scribe May 2012 #166
How hard would it be to program the car... B2G May 2012 #119
That's an excellent idea obamanut2012 May 2012 #124
The seatbelt is latched to the car seat. proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #130
Hmm...true. Perhaps a weight sensor in the carseats B2G May 2012 #142
Sounds good to me. proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #145
The more I think about it... B2G May 2012 #144
I just put the diaper bag in the front seat proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #146
To the people in this thread who are pointing the finger: Skinner May 2012 #127
This article really opened my eyes. Several have linked it in this thread: proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #132
Maybe this thread can help remind people to take that extra second to glance at the back seat... cynatnite May 2012 #147
retro-active darwinism... OneTenthofOnePercent May 2012 #128
That is really a distasteful post obamanut2012 May 2012 #153
Don't blame Charles Darwin for your personal, distasteful viewpoints. nt msanthrope May 2012 #169
I don't think that's terribly insightful. sibelian May 2012 #172
We expect working parents to show up for work and focus exclusively hedgehog May 2012 #129
I left my kid in the car. And I DEFY any poster on this board who would DARE blame me. msanthrope May 2012 #131
You left your kid in the car for 5 minutes Rex May 2012 #149
Forgetting your child does not = forgetting your child? uppityperson May 2012 #156
Oh I agree it is the same, but the results are different. Rex May 2012 #161
But do you understand how easily I could have been walking into work, or into something else msanthrope May 2012 #168
Yes yes I do understand. Rex May 2012 #183
How long ago did this happen? Number23 May 2012 #162
9 years ago. I still get a tremor thinking about it. The people who don't 'get' this msanthrope May 2012 #167
Absolutely. Minds can be made to fail by stress. sibelian May 2012 #173
Someone needs to invent a motion detector/alarm inside automobiles, after being turned off. tawadi May 2012 #136
Sometimes good people make mistakes that have tragic consequences varelse May 2012 #140
Yes, the mother is experiencing things I shudder to Rex May 2012 #150
This. n/t lumberjack_jeff May 2012 #178
How do you forget another lifeform a few feet away from you? Rex May 2012 #148
It happens 25 times every year in this country proud2BlibKansan May 2012 #151
Easy to see how this could happen. gulliver May 2012 #159
I have forgotten many things in my car. Beacool May 2012 #163
Often it seems they skip going to child care and leave the kid in the back when they park at work.. Fumesucker May 2012 #164
I'm not standing in judgment. Beacool May 2012 #180
This is a horrible, just horrible tragedy... tallahasseedem May 2012 #177
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Baby died after mom left ...»Reply #15