Reply #43

In the discussion thread: John Edwards' betrayed wife 'tore off bra' [View all]

Response to PotatoChip (Reply #17)

Thu May 3, 2012, 11:43 AM

Hell Hath No Fury (14,254 posts)

43. Makes perfect sense to me.

I kind of like that she did this -- it was a real "fuck you, bastard".

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

78 replies	Author	Time	Post
John Edwards' betrayed wife 'tore off bra' [View all]	Poll_Blind	May 2012	OP
Call me naive, but I don't believe it.	HiPointDem	May 2012	#1
This story came out years ago	Capt. Obvious	May 2012	#4
that doesn't make me believe it any more than i did before. it does make me wonder though,	HiPointDem	May 2012	#9
Im sorry ... But your assertions seem patently ridiculous ...	Trajan	May 2012	#26
It goes to what Elizabeth knew when - it is clear that she was at minimum	karynnj	May 2012	#31
It doesn't make sense because it was not driven by the rational part of Elizabeth Edwards	karynnj	May 2012	#30
why would this witness commit perjury?	Enrique	May 2012	#35
Public and private personas are quite often day and night	RZM	May 2012	#44
Excuse me but Rehnquist was a racist prick. He had	Solomon	May 2012	#46
I didn't say he wasn't	RZM	May 2012	#48
but political wives can and do make scenes. Ever hear of Martha Mitchell?	cali	May 2012	#62
"Grandpa, grandma has a new man living at her house"..	Fumesucker	May 2012	#2
You're right	malaise	May 2012	#6
with malaise.... not gender specific. women are almost at the same percentage as men. nt	seabeyond	May 2012	#20
As a fellow who twice was married to women with whom I later had "incompatible sleeping habits"	TahitiNut	May 2012	#25
Ouch. That just sucks.	TwilightGardener	May 2012	#36
ugh.	laundry_queen	May 2012	#40
I have been betrayed	SemperEadem	May 2012	#3
+1.	HiPointDem	May 2012	#10
I find your assessment of what she did judgmental.	msanthrope	May 2012	#18
ooh, someone can't read	SemperEadem	May 2012	#55
But she DID do the actions you judged so harshly.	msanthrope	May 2012	#67
Some have the patience of Job ....	Trajan	May 2012	#27
Were you suffering from cancer and involved in a presidential campaign at the time?	FedUpWithIt All	May 2012	#34
the issue I'm discussing is betrayal	SemperEadem	May 2012	#56
In real life, which she was dealing with cold, you do not just isolate things like that.	FedUpWithIt All	May 2012	#66
Yeah, but you didn't have to publicly cheerlead your husband	CoffeeCat	May 2012	#42
TOTALLY agree, I'm glad she was able to	Raine	May 2012	#74
"She was entitled to a major, four-alarm, epic meltdown. Look at everything she endured."	Number23	May 2012	#75
we all have different reactions to stress	Whisp	May 2012	#65
chemotherapy impacts people's memories and emotions, even after it is over nt	magical thyme	May 2012	#70
i doubt she did this	madrchsod	May 2012	#5
Ms. Reynolds is under a legal obligation to not keep her mouth shut about her friend.	msanthrope	May 2012	#7
I expect more people to chime in that they don't believe this story	Capt. Obvious	May 2012	#8
Well, denial is a powerful thing. That her personal friends have testified to this	msanthrope	May 2012	#15
whether or not ms edwards ripped off her bra has fuck all to do with whether edwards used	HiPointDem	May 2012	#11
I don't believe Edwards had a mistress	Capt. Obvious	May 2012	#13
How do you explain Rielle Hunter getting pregnant by Edwards during the campain? n/t	cynatnite	May 2012	#16
that doesn't make me believe it any more than i did before	Capt. Obvious	May 2012	#24
Are you related to unionworks?	karynnj	May 2012	#33
Even though Edwards admitted the affair and claimed the child as his? n/t	cynatnite	May 2012	#37
Actually, it does....the prosecution is doing a great job establishing why John Edwards	msanthrope	May 2012	#14
They had already established his motives with previous witnesses. n/t	cynatnite	May 2012	#19
You think the prosecution is going to leave a stone unturned?	msanthrope	May 2012	#22
To me this is just dirty laundry...	cynatnite	May 2012	#38
I agree-	Bluerthanblue	May 2012	#50
I agree, as well.	hamsterjill	May 2012	#53
exactly	SemperEadem	May 2012	#57
the Kenneth Starr playbook of prosecution.	grasswire	May 2012	#77
You're exactly right	customerserviceguy	May 2012	#23
I think your post accurately describes the prosecution strategy.	msanthrope	May 2012	#29
If I were on the jury, I would be disgusted by the prosecution introducing this clearly sensational	sabrina 1	May 2012	#72
The thing that gets me	customerserviceguy	May 2012	#76
Honestly, it does not matter whether this happened or not...	cynatnite	May 2012	#12
Anything to completely finish him off, I guess. Meanwhile....	SammyWinstonJack	May 2012	#28
+1	andlor	May 2012	#58
Odd reaction to be sure, but	PotatoChip	May 2012	#17
Your post describes exactly what I was thinking....she showed him her scars.	msanthrope	May 2012	#21
+1	arthritisR_US	May 2012	#32
Yeah, this is exactly what I was thinking. nt	Poll_Blind	May 2012	#39
Is there any 'correct' way?	laundry_queen	May 2012	#41
Well said n/t	Spazito	May 2012	#49
+1000	Wind Dancer	May 2012	#60
Makes perfect sense to me.	Hell Hath No Fury	May 2012	#43
Sounds like Miranda Richardson in "Damage"	Blue_Tires	May 2012	#45
Sometimes I wonder if we really need this kind of information from the media.	MineralMan	May 2012	#47
That was my first reaction.	Baitball Blogger	May 2012	#52
no, we don't need to know this.	Bluerthanblue	May 2012	#54
I agree, I do not see what this does for the prosecution's case other than disgust decent human	sabrina 1	May 2012	#73
What she must have suffered. It's just unbelievable the additional torment	Baitball Blogger	May 2012	#51
How is this even admissible? and for what purpose, other than to make him look bad?	ChairmanAgnostic	May 2012	#59
I've watched enough tv to know that this is totally not admissible	Capt. Obvious	May 2012	#64
someting doesn't add up.	magical thyme	May 2012	#61
how about the reaction of a wife who had taken her husband's	cali	May 2012	#63
I hadn't seen that	magical thyme	May 2012	#68
She put in writing that she thought the affair had ended	cali	May 2012	#69
oh, I totally understand it	magical thyme	May 2012	#71
John Edwards was a phony even before news of the affair came out ...	slipslidingaway	May 2012	#78

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.