Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

saras

(6,670 posts)
61. There's no dignity in "work" or "jobs". Sisyphus has a job, doing work.
Wed Apr 18, 2012, 08:49 PM
Apr 2012

There's dignity in accomplishing things of worth to people. Some jobs offer much more leeway at this than others. Some, like working on an assembly line making land mines, may not have ANY value in this way, but merely be of economic value to someone - I'll pay you all to help me beat up my neighbor's kids.

But if you worked for the post office for forty years, you don't deserve praise because you went to work every day and did a job. You and I both know that someone can do both those things, and nothing else but waste resources. You deserve praise because you made 5,000 people happier today, and kept 1000 more out of trouble, and helped keep 400 local businesses in operation. And you did THAT for forty years. Damn right that deserves dignity.

There's equal dignity in accomplishing things of worth to people via routes other than paid employment. Anyone who assists in any way in raising children, from making a playground safer to writing books to inspecting utilities to actually being a mother, father, or child care worker. Anyone who makes the lives of others around them easier or more rewarding. Volunteers. Off-the-grid workers. Good Samaritans.

But no one anywhere is going to tell me, or anyone else I know, that we need to have a BOSS in order to have DIGNITY. In fact, I'd argue that in many cases they're mutually exclusive.

I would amend this slightly el_bryanto Apr 2012 #1
Hanging a picture doesn't count as swinging a hammer tk2kewl Apr 2012 #5
a lot of workers can't do those things Enrique Apr 2012 #7
that's fine... tk2kewl Apr 2012 #14
those things you added is what I was thinking of Enrique Apr 2012 #21
Hmmmm. Well I guess there's a few questions here el_bryanto Apr 2012 #25
For a moment of digression... tk2kewl Apr 2012 #30
ah yes... takers v. givers tk2kewl Apr 2012 #32
LOL maddiemom Apr 2012 #47
Wow liberalmike27 Apr 2012 #42
no one let r.money finish his statement the whole statement leftyohiolib Apr 2012 #2
and it's really not just the work Enrique Apr 2012 #3
you are right my friend tk2kewl Apr 2012 #9
A cowed worker pscot Apr 2012 #31
The wealthy fuckwads who spew this shit hifiguy Apr 2012 #4
George Carlin was right. Initech Apr 2012 #11
Stewie Griffin got it right hifiguy Apr 2012 #13
99 to 1 tk2kewl Apr 2012 #16
Maybe he is attacking trust fund babies. dkf Apr 2012 #6
Come on, he's "indolent and unproductive" because of his parents. sinkingfeeling Apr 2012 #8
How about pulled items in a warehouse, hedgehog Apr 2012 #10
yep tk2kewl Apr 2012 #20
There are three things you don't want to watch being made - law, sausage and software TrogL Apr 2012 #12
awww come on... tk2kewl Apr 2012 #15
You've obviously never been in an Agile scrum TrogL Apr 2012 #24
been at it for quite a while tk2kewl Apr 2012 #26
A couple of my favorite descriptions of Agile tk2kewl Apr 2012 #27
"...Doesn't just mean doing more work with fewer people" abelenkpe Apr 2012 #28
yep... that one fits perfectly with this thread tk2kewl Apr 2012 #29
+1000 nt abelenkpe Apr 2012 #18
That's being very disrespectful. Baitball Blogger Apr 2012 #17
Not if you're dressed for it pscot Apr 2012 #33
Silly. Only corporate raiding counts as dignified work ecstatic Apr 2012 #19
Post removed Post removed Apr 2012 #22
Romney is a bum on the plush abelenkpe Apr 2012 #23
Well said Fry Pan Jack. tk2kewl Apr 2012 #34
I put myself through college Mz Pip Apr 2012 #35
but those rich kids need to be smart enough to keep the proles down and their bank accounts secret tk2kewl Apr 2012 #36
Add to that how many double or even triple shifts they had to pull as well. n/t Cleita Apr 2012 #37
or 2nd or 3rd job... tk2kewl Apr 2012 #48
How would he lsewpershad Apr 2012 #38
Hey, Ann says she and Mittens lived "on the edge!" Bake Apr 2012 #39
I know what "a donkey on the edge!" looks like, but what is an elephant on the edge? tk2kewl Apr 2012 #40
I think of the movie "Clockwork Orange" when I hear that expression. . . DinahMoeHum Apr 2012 #41
If work is so dignified why did they ship our jobs overseas? McCamy Taylor Apr 2012 #43
They never do low level office work ether. Tabasco_Dave Apr 2012 #44
Most work... Johnny Noshoes Apr 2012 #45
yeah, try being a roofer in over one hundred degree heat newspeak Apr 2012 #52
Hey I totally agree. Johnny Noshoes Apr 2012 #60
These so called "job creators" guitar man Apr 2012 #46
what is dignity anymore... ? handmade34 Apr 2012 #49
nice collection tk2kewl Apr 2012 #51
Even simpler... Javaman Apr 2012 #50
How many of these jokers Glaisne Apr 2012 #53
the list go on... tk2kewl Apr 2012 #54
I did industrial temp work when I was an unemployed Ph.D. Lydia Leftcoast Apr 2012 #55
I attended but did not matriculate from a small naval architecture school... tk2kewl Apr 2012 #56
To them - "dignity of work" is code for "let's bring back slavery". Initech Apr 2012 #57
slavery IS unregulated capitalism taken to it's logical end tk2kewl Apr 2012 #58
I'm ready to bring on the revolution at this point. Initech Apr 2012 #59
There's no dignity in "work" or "jobs". Sisyphus has a job, doing work. saras Apr 2012 #61
Well said! valerief Apr 2012 #62
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»If I hear one more rich f...»Reply #61